Data from 146 HIV infected patients with seizure were analyzed; their sociodemographic and medical characteristics are shown in Fig. 1 and Table 1.
Majority of the patients (80.8%) were from Addis Ababa. Most patients (93.8 %) were admitted to general medical ward and 6.2% were admitted to intensive care unit (ICU). The mean hospital stay (±SD) was 23.3±15.9 days (range, 1-76 days). The diagnosis of HIV-infection was made before current hospital admission in 31.5 % and after current admission in 68.5%. Duration since the diagnosis of HIV-infection ranged from 7 days to 5 years (median 6months).
The clinical presentation of patients is shown in Table 2. The initial presenting symptom was neurological in 131(95.8%) patients and 21(14.4%) patients presented with seizure as initial manifestation. The mean duration of initial symptom before presentation was 44.2 days (median = 21, range 1 day to 18.3 months). Almost all patients (98.6%) had stage 4 HIV infection at presentation. Duration of first seizure at presentation varies from 30 minutes to a year (mean 22 days, median 5 days). All patients had more than two episodes of seizure. In 84(57.5%) patients, seizure started before current hospital admission while in 62(42.5%) patients the first seizure occurred after current admission. In patients with seizure onset before hospital admission, the duration of seizure was ≤ 1 day in 18% , ≤ 1week in 64%, ≤ 2 weeks in 80%, ≤ 1 month in 88% and ≤ 3 months in 95% of the patients. The clinical seizure types were generalized tonic-clonic seizure (GTCS) in 101(69.2%), focal motor with secondary generalization (FMWSG) in 29(19.9%) and simple focal motor in 16(11%) patients. The causes of seizure in relation to outcome status are shown in Table 3. Status epilepticus was present in 26(17.8%) patients. The duration of status epilepticus at presentation ranged from 2hours to 7 days (mean= 31.1 hours, median =24hours). The status epilepticus started before admission in 24 patients and after admission in 2 patients. It was generalized convulsive type of status epilepticus in 24(92.3%) patients and epilepsia partialis continua in 2 patients. The causes of status epilepticus were infectious in 25(96%) of patients and metabolic in 1 patient (hyperkalemia and uremic encephalopathy). Identified infectious causes include cerebral toxoplasmosis (n= 16), tuberculous meningitis (n=4), cryptococcal meningitis(n=2), PML (n=2) and HIV encephalopathy(n=1). Complications of status epilepticus were present in 13(50%) patients (aspiration pneumonia n=12, acute renal failure n=1).
Table 1. Clinical profile of HIV-infected patients with seizure by outcome status, n=146
|
|
Total(n=146)
|
Dead(n=77)
|
Alive(n=69)
|
Sex
|
Male
|
81(55.5%)
|
42(51.9%)
|
39(48.1%)
|
Female
|
65(44.5%)
|
35(53.8%)
|
30(46.2%)
|
Age
|
Mean[SD]
|
34[8.4]
|
33.78[8.6]
|
34.3[8.3]
|
|
Median
|
33
|
32
|
34
|
|
Range
|
51
|
41
|
45
|
Seizure type
|
Simple focal
|
16(11%)
|
11(68.8%)
|
5(31.3%)
|
FWSG
|
29(19.9%)
|
12(41.4%)
|
17(58.6%)
|
Prim gener
|
101(69.2%)
|
54(53.5%)
|
47(46.5%)
|
Status epilepticus
|
Yes
|
26(17.8%)
|
12(46.2%)
|
14(53.8%)
|
No
|
120(82.2%)
|
65(54.2%)
|
55(45.8%)
|
Level of consciousness at initial evaluation
|
Alert
|
35(24%)
|
9(25.7%)
|
26(74.3%)
|
Confused/stuporous
|
61(41.8%)
|
35(57.4%)
|
26(42.6%)
|
comatose
|
50(34.2%)
|
33(66%)
|
17(34%)
|
GCS at initial evaluation
|
≥13
|
13(8.9%)
|
5(38.5%)
|
8(61.5%)
|
9-12
|
26(17.8%)
|
16(61.5%)
|
10(38.5%)
|
≤ 8
|
48(32.9%)
|
33(68.8%)
|
15(31.3%)
|
Unknown
|
59(40.4%)
|
23(39%)
|
36(61%)
|
FWSG, focal with secondary generalization; prim gener , primarily generalized; GCS, Glasgow coma scale;
Table 2. Clinical presentation of 146 patients with HIV infection and seizure presented to Tikur Anbessa Specialize Hospital.
Symptom /sign
|
Frequency (n)
|
Percentage (%)
|
Headache
|
111
|
76
|
Change in mentation
|
111
|
76
|
Fever
|
96
|
65.8
|
Focal deficit
|
All types
|
75
|
51.4
|
Hemiparesis/plegia
|
44
|
30.1
|
MCN* deficit
|
9
|
6.2
|
Paraparesis/plegia
|
3
|
2
|
Monoparesis/plegia
|
3
|
2
|
Quadriparesis/plegia
|
2
|
1.4
|
Triparesis/plegia
|
1
|
0.7
|
Meningeal irritation sign
|
55
|
37.7
|
Papilledema
|
17
|
11.6
|
hemiballismus
|
2
|
1.4
|
*MCN , multiple cranial nerve deficit
Table 3. The causes of seizure by outcome in 146 HIV infected patients.
Cause of seizure
|
Total (146)
|
Dead (n=77, 52.7%)
|
Alive (n=69,47.3%)
|
Cerebral toxoplasmosis
|
67
|
29(43.3%)
|
38(56.7%)
|
Tuberculous meningitis
|
52
|
34(65.4%)
|
18(34.6%)
|
Cryptococcal meningitis
|
20
|
13(65%)
|
7(35%)
|
PML
|
7
|
3(42.9%)
|
4(57.1%)
|
neurosyphilis
|
4
|
2(50%)
|
2(50%)
|
Bacterial meningitis
|
3
|
1(33.3%)
|
2(66.7%)
|
stroke
|
3
|
2(66.7%)
|
1(33.3%)
|
Uremic encephalopathy
|
2
|
2(100%)
|
0
|
Unknown(except HIV infection)
|
2
|
0
|
2(100%)
|
others*
|
3
|
2(66.7%)
|
1(33.3%)
|
* Others: HIV encephalopathy/dementia =1, neurocysticercosis n=1, primary CNS lymphoma n=1
Note that more than one possible cause of seizure was possible in some patients.
Table 4. Risk factor for case-fatality: logistic regression analysis
Factor
|
n
|
%
|
Unadjusted OR(95% CI)
|
Adjusted OR(95% CI)
|
Age(year)
|
≥40
|
20
|
54.1
|
1.00
|
1.00
|
<40
|
57
|
52.3
|
0.932(0.441-1.968)
|
0.67o(0.274-1.641)
|
Sex
|
Female
|
35
|
53.8
|
1.00
|
1.00
|
Male
|
42
|
51.9
|
0.923(0.480-1.775)
|
0.922(0.429-1.983)
|
Address
|
Outside Addis Ababa
|
10
|
35.7
|
1.00
|
1.00
|
Addis Ababa
|
67
|
56.8
|
2.365(1.006-5.558)
|
3.428(1.240-9.479)
|
Admitted to
|
Intensive care unit
|
3
|
33.3
|
1.00
|
1.00
|
Ward
|
74
|
54
|
2.349(0.564-9.778)
|
2.818(0.506-15.686)
|
Seizure started
|
Before admission
|
37
|
44
|
1.00
|
1.00
|
After admission
|
40
|
64.5
|
2.310(1.175-4.538)
|
2.017(0.889-4.575)
|
Status epilepticus
|
No
|
65
|
54.2
|
1.00
|
1.00
|
Yes
|
12
|
46.2
|
0.725(0.310-1.698)
|
0.526(0.156-1.781)
|
Change in mentation at initial evaluation
|
No
|
9
|
25.7
|
1.00
|
1.00
|
Yes
|
68
|
61.3
|
4.568(1.955-10.675)
|
3.981(1.475-10.749)
|
Comatose at initial evaluation
|
No
|
44
|
45.8
|
1.00
|
1.00
|
Yes
|
33
|
66
|
2.294(1.128-4.664)
|
2.035(0.828-5.005)
|
CD4 count
|
≥ 200
|
32
|
58.2
|
1.00
|
1.00
|
< 200
|
45
|
49.5
|
0.703(0.358-1.381)
|
0.730(0.313-1.703)
|
Antiretroviral therapy
|
No
|
48
|
57
|
1.00
|
1.00
|
yes
|
29
|
46.8
|
0.659(0.341-1.275)
|
0.632(0.268-1.493)
|
Altered mental status was found in 111(76%) of patients and 50(34.2%) patients presented with coma. Glasgow coma scale (GCS) was documented in 87(59.6%) patients and 48(55.2%) had ≤ 8, 26(29.9%) had 9 to 12 and 13(14.9%) had ≥ 13.
CD4 count per mm3 was obtained in 96(65.8%) patients and the mean was 77±85 (median = 52, range 1 to 550). Lumbar puncture was done in 87(59.6%) patients. The mean and median CSF cell count per mm3 was 177.26 and 1.5, respectively (range 0 to 2500). CSF VDRL test was performed in 72 patients and 4 were reactive. India ink was done in 75 patients and 20 (26.7%) were positive.
Brain imaging with CT-scan was performed for 76(50.1%) patients and 3 patients were additionally evaluated with brain MRI. Brain imaging showed mass lesion in 43(56.6%), normal findings in 19(25%), multiple white matter hypodense lesions in 7(9.2%), meningeal enhancement (n=4), brain atrophy (n=2) and hydrocephalus (n=1).
Hematologic findings were: leucopenia in 46(31.5%), anemia in 81(55.5%) and thrombocytopenia in 54(37%) patients. Erythrocyte sedimentation rate was obtained in 99(67.8%) patients and in 96(97%) patients it was 35 mm per hour or more (mean= 92.32, median= 94). One patient underwent electroencephalography (EEG) and it was normal. Serum antiepileptic medication level was determined in one patient and it showed low phenytoin level.
Comorbidities identified were : oral thrush(n=25), herpes zoster(n=21),hypertension(n=6), bleeding diathesis(5),drug induced hepatitis (n=5),hypokalemia(n=4), pneumonia(n=4),chronic diarrhea (n=4), diabetes mellitus (n=4), congestive heart failure (n=4),deep venous thrombosis(n= 3) , pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (n=2)and bed sore(n=4).
Antiepileptic drugs (AED) were given to 135(92.5%) after hospital admission and 11(7.5%) patients were on antiepileptic medications at admission. The AED used were: phenytoin in 137(93.8 %) , Phenobarbital (n=15), carbamazepine(n=5), and valproate(n=3). Of the 69 patients who were discharged alive, 56(81.2%) were continued on the AED and in 13(18.8%) patients these were discontinued. Antiretroviral therapy (ART) was started before hospital admission in 24(16.4%) and after admission in 38(26%) patients. No ART was given to 84(57.5%) patients. The duration of ART before admission ranges from 1 to 30 months (mean= 6.09, median=3). Prophylactic cotrimoxazole was started in 65(44.5%) patients (before admission= 10, after admission= 55).
Treatment out comes at hospital discharge were: 77(52.7%) patients died, 60(41.1%) improved, 7(4.8%) deteriorated without death and 2 remained in the same clinical condition. In most patients, the immediate cause of death was attributed to the underlying disorder and seizure was not documented as an immediate cause of death.