There is a sex disparity in patients with papillary thyroid cancer. Men with thyroid cancer are more likely to have advanced disease and tumors with aggressive histological subtypes[7, 11]. This study examined the association between sex and the risk of ENE in PTC patients. Through multivariate analysis five variables were found to be associated with ENE, including male sex, ETE, older age, more positive nodes, and bilateral multifocality. Our results indicated male sex had a higher risk of ENE.
Lymph node metastasis is common in PTC patients. And some metastatic nodes may show ENE. Patients with ENE may have worse prognosis[15]. ENE is an independent variable associated with poor overall survival[4] and disease-specific survival[16]. The presence of ENE also increases the risk of recurrence[3, 17, 18, 4, 19]. ENE has a significant association with local recurrent disease[20, 21]. The presence of ENE in low volume LN metastasis indicates an intermediate risk of recurrence[2]. ENE is also associated with a lower probability of achieving an excellent response to initial therapy[20, 5].
Some clinical and pathological factors have been found to be associated with ENE in PTC. Kim et al[19] found that ETE, central and lateral neck involvement, lymph node ratio, and 3 positive nodes or more could predict ENE. Roh et al[4] found that sex, ETE, N1 classification, and number of positive nodes were all significant factors associated with occurrence of ENE. Other studies have demonstrated that large tumor size[22] and lymph node size[23] increase the risk of ENE for metastatic PTC.
Similar to previously reported studies[4, 22], in our study cohort men were associated with higher risk of ENE both in univariate and in multivariate analyses. Our results indicated male sex was an independent prognostic factor of ENE. Because ETE was also a risk factor of ENE, we further investigated the association between sex and ENE in patients with early-stage PTC. Multivariate analyses revealed that men were still independently associated with ENE in T1-2 PTC patients. In contrast, Kim et al[19] observed that male was a significant risk factor of ENE in univariate analyses, but not in the multivariate analyses after analyzing 1693 PTC patients. That might be due to the differences in population characteristics. In Kim et al’s study, the median age was older (median age, 55 years), and up to 64.2% patients had ETE.
Our study has some limitations. First, this is a retrospective study using data from a single tertiary institution. The results need to be externally validated using data from other centers. Second, 67.7% of the patients in our series had papillary thyroid microcarcinoma, This might be due to increased use of thyroid cancer screening. Third, there was no follow-up data in our series. Though men were independently associated with ENE, the impacts of sex on survival and recurrence in PTC were not analyzed in our cohort study. However, these were out of scope of our study.
In summary, our analyses demonstrate that male sex, as well as older age, more positive nodes, ETE, and bilateral multifocality, is independently associated with ENE. Male sex has a higher risk of ENE in PTC. The potential mechanism needs to be further investigated.