Intrauterine Adhesions Combined with Robert's Uterus : A Case Report and Literature Review

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-620125/v1

Abstract

Background: Robert's uterus, a rare congenital abnormality of Mullerian duct development, has oblique septum and non-communicating asymmetric hemi-cavity. Key clinical characterization of the congenital disorder is presence of hematometra and severe dysmenorrhea, some patients experience acute abdominal pain in association with menstruation. Due to the difficulty of preoperative diagnosis and high rate of misdiagnosis, Preoperative assessment matters the choice of emergency surgery and avoid a second surgery. No systematic literature review in detail has been reported previously.

Case presentation: We reported a rare case of Robert’s uterus with severe abdominal pain during menstruation, in which the patient initially underwent emergency laparoscopic right ovarian cystectomy, right salpingectomy, and pelvic adhesiolysis on suspicion of ovarian teratoma torsion. However, dysmenorrhea still existed or even aggravated after the operation, hysteroscopic surgery was performed three month later, which revealed two asymmetric uterine cavities, hematometra was located in the right-side blind cavity, and thus diagnosed as Robert’s uterus and severe uterine adhesion, which, to our knowledge, has not been reported previously. Hysteroscopic incision of the septum and intrauterine adhesion were performed. Subsequently, Two-year follow-up showed no obvious dysmenorrhea recurrence.

Conclusion: Robert's uterus is uncommon but can mimic other common and acute abdominal disease. Advance imaging technologies, such as three-dimensional ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging combined with hysteroscopy and laparoscopy are less invasive for diagnosis and treatment of Robert’s uterus. Septal resection is main surgical procedure, combining laparoscopy and hysteroscopy is conducive and less invasive treatment. 


Background

Robert's uterus is a rare Mullerian abnormality with an asymmetric septum, which was first reported by Robert in 1970. To date, more than 20 cases of Robert's uterus have been reported in previous literature. It is characterized by non-communicating intrauterine cavity and unilateral haematometra in blind uterine cavity attributing to the oblique septum. Progressively significant dysmenorrhea and severe abdominal pain are the main manifestation. We reported and analyzed in detail the clinical features and mechanisms of a case of Robert's uterus with severe abdominal pain. The patient underwent surgical treatment twice and was also complicated with severe adhesions, which was not mentioned in the literature so far. Hence, we simultaneously performed a systematic literature review for purposing of improving preoperative diagnosis and avoiding inappropriate operation performance.

Case Presentation

The patient, a 24-year-old married woman, suffered from reduced menstruation and lower abdominal pain around menstrual period since the age of 22, especially before and on the first day of menstruation. The frequency of pain increased afterward, from once every three months to once a month, from spontaneous remission without the assist of medications to drug assistant. Two months ago, the patient presented to the emergency department of local hospital due to severe abdominal pain, accompanied by nausea and vomiting. Ultrasonography revealed that intrauterine fluid measured 13×20 ×10 mm,cystic mass localized at right parametrium space measured 32×23 ×20 mm, isoechoic and hyperechoic cyst on the right ovary measured 55×60×57 mm. Emergency laparoscopic surgery was performed for suspicion of ovarian teratoma torsion, which has been recorded severe pelvic adhesions, normal size of the uterus, right hematosalpinx, as well as cystic mass of the right ovary without torsion. Laparoscopic right ovarian cystectomy, right salpingectomy, and pelvic adhesiolysis were performed. The pathological diagnosis was ovarian mature cystic teratoma and right fallopian tube endometriosis. However, the patient presented to our center for the unrelieved abdominal pain after the operation. The left endometrium thickness was 4 mm, and the right uterine cavity fluid measured 42×19 mm. The size of anechoic area in the right uterine horn was 23×15 mm, which seemed to communicate with the right uterine cavity (Fig. 1a). Three-dimensional ultrasound (3D-US) confirmed the presence of oblique septum and fluid in the blind uterine cavity (Fig. 1b). Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) showed a septum in the uterus divided the endometrial cavity into two cavities of unequal in size, and haematometra was mainly in the right smaller cavity, mimicking the unicornuate uterus with the communicating rudimentary horn (Fig. 2). Physical examination and laboratory blood examination were normal. Hysteroscopic surgery with ultrasound guided was performed, which revealed a small narrow uterine cavity with one horn communicated with cervical canal and biased to the left side. The fundus and left wall of the uterine cavity had severe adhesion with a thin endometrium, and the left fallopian ostium was invisible. A fibrous oblique diaphragm presented on the right-side uterine cavity with a slight bulge. The right corn and fallopian ostium were invisible (Fig. 3a). After gently separating the weak part of the diaphragm along the bulge using a needle eletrode, the dark brown hematocele liquid spilled out, and the oblique septal tissue was gradually removed by band electrodes along the opening. Then, the right-side uterine cavity and the right corn were exposed, separating intrauterine adhensions with needle electrode recover uterus normal morphology. A Foley catheter inflated with 3 ml saline was placed in the uterine cavity for 7 days to prevent intrauterine adhesion recurrence. The patient was discharged 2 days after the surgery. Estrogen and progesterone sequential treatment were given for the prevention of recurrence. Four weeks after the operation, the repeat hysteroscopy showed a normal appearing cavity and endometrium (Fig. 3b). The patients were followed up for two-year after the operation, intractable dysmenorrhea disappeared.

Discussion And Conclusions

Robert’s uterus is a rare congenital abnormality, a uterine septum asymmetrically separates the uterine cavity from the bottom of the uterus, half of which is a disconnected blind cavity [1]. Gupta et al. suggested that right side are common for the ahead advancement of left Mullerian duct [2]. However, blind cavity is more commonly left-side in the review. Musset et al [3] have summarized its characteristics include: (1) primary dysmenorrhea; (2) no significant difference of the uterus by laparoscopy and the unicorn uterine cavity found by hysterography; (3) no deformity of the urinary system. Most patients complained of dysmenorrhea, periodic abdominal pain, abnormal menstruation, abortion, or infertility. Twenty-two cases were conducted in our systematic reviewed literature (Table 1), 20/22 cases (81.82%) underwent dysmenorrhea [2, 419], 3/22 cases (13.64%) abortion [4, 7, 20], one case endured infertility [14]. It is noted that intractable dysmenorrhea seems to associate with haematometra for the identical existence. Gupta, N proposed that endometriosis may associate with menstrual blood reflux [2]. With hormonal stimulation, menstrual blood induced by the shedding of endometrium could be retrograde into the abdominal cavity through the ipsilateral fallopian tube during menstruation, thus the early dysmenorrhea was periodic but not obvious in initial. Then, with the right fallopian tube gradually thickened, blocked and blood accumulated, dysmenorrhea gradually aggravated due to the formation of a closed cavity, which may associate with inflammation or endometriosis. In our reported case, after the resection of the right fallopian tube, the blind cavity was completely disconnected from the outside world. As a result, increased pressure was associated with the retention of menstrual blood in the closed right-sided uterine cavity, which induced aggravated abdominal pain.

Table 1

Review of Robert’s uterus cases reports.

Authors

(year)

Case

Age

(years)

Dysmenorrhea

Other complaints

Haematometra

Other complication

Deenadayal.

2021

five

28.2(M)

Yes(5/5)

Recurrent abortion(1/5)

Yes(4/4)

Adenomyosis(2/4), Endometrioma(2/4)

Zhang J.

2021

one

24

Yes

-

Yes

Hematosalpinx, Endometriosis

Liu Y.

2021

one

45

No

abnormal menstruation

No

Blind hemicavity Pregnancy, Adenomyosis

Liu Y.

2020

one

16

Yes

Acute abdominal pain

Yes

Ipsilateral renal agenesis, Hematosalpinx

Yang QM.

2019

one

23

Yes

Abortion

Yes

Blind cavity pregnancy,

Ipsilateral renal agenesis,

Adenomyosis

Shah N.

2019

1

16

Yes

-

Yes

-

Kiyak H.

2018

one

15

Yes

-

Yes

-

Biler A.

2017

one

29

Yes

mild abdominal pain,

abnormal menstruation

Yes

-

Mittal P.

2017

one

15

Yes

-

Yes

Haematosalpinx, Endometriosis

John SK.

2017

one

16

Yes

Acute abdominal pain

Yes

-

Ludwin A.

2016

one

22

Yes

-

Yes

-

Di Spiezio Sardo A.

2015

one

30

Yes

infertility

Yes

Uterine myomas, A pseudocystic lesion

Li J.

2015

one

26

Yes

-

Yes

Ovarian endometriotic cyst, Endometriosis

MaddukuriSB.2014

one

16

Yes

-

Yes

Haematosalpinx

Vural M.

2011

one

24

Yes

-

Yes

-

Capito C.

2009

one

15

Yes

Acute abdominal pain

Yes

-

Gupta N.

2007

one

19

Yes

Acute abdominal pain

Yes

Ovarian endometriotic cyst, Endometriosis

Singhal S.

2002

one

20

No

Abortion

No

Blind cavity pregnancy

To the best of our knowledge, Intrauterine adhesions are first involved in Robert's uterus which have been verified by the laparoscopy, although no intrauterine operation history such as induced abortion, which may be related to obstruction of menstrual blood outflow and inflammation, although there is no evidence of endometritis. In our opinion, early diagnosis and hysteroscopic surgery may reduce incidence of these complication. Ultrasound, MRI, hysteroscopy, and laparoscopy have been performed for Robert’ uterus diagnosis. The septum with asymmetric cavities is easily discernible, hematometra and hematosalpinx are easy to identify by the noninvasive imaging modalities, such as 3D-US and MRI, Which are considered the reliable modality to examine the morphology of the uterus [14, 21]. In addition, we strongly recommended a detailed inspection of urinary system considering that two cases of ipsilateral renal agenesis were reported. Ludwin et al. described three types of Robert’s uterus according to the amount of bleeding in the blind cavity: no hematocele, small and large [19]. However, the detection rate of uterine malformation by ultrasound is also significantly affected by the diagnostic level of the examiner. In the literature, 5/22 cases (22.73%) endured re-operation or the third time surgery before diagnosis and management [2, 4, 5, 6, 12]. It is still a challenge for clinicians, especially the differentiation of serious dysmenorrhea of Robert's uterus and other acute abdominal diseases. we recommend that if the intraoperative finding is inconsistent to clinical manifestation of severe abdominal pain, uterine inspection is needed. Trauma would be relatively less if taking adequate evaluation and determining the preoperative diagnosis.

Surgical treatment is recommended as soon as it is highly suspected. Surgical option may determine by the factors of age and fertility desire of patient. The prime targets are drainage of hematometra and prevention of its recurrence through septal resection [11]. Laparoscopic septum resection and metroplasty seems to be considerable for the minimal invasion, especially for the adolescent girl. In twenty-one cases of Robert's uterus involved surgery (Table 2), 13/21 cases (61.90%) were performed septal resection by laparoscopy, hysteroscopy or laparotomy. 11/21 cases (52.38%) of endometriosis have been documented in patients performed laparoscopy or hysteroscopy [7, 8, 10, 11, 13, 14]. There is prevalence in laparoscopy-guided hysteroscopic metroplasty recently for the advantage of security and less invasion, one case underwent hysterectomy due to no fertility requirement. Hysteroscopic surgery performed by experienced surgeons is essential for the complicated environment in uterus. At present, the main surgical methods reported in the literature are hysteroscopy or hysteroscopy combined with laparoscopic surgery [8, 10, 11]. Laparoscopy can deal with hematosalpinx, pelvic adhesions, and endometriosis, which cannot be evaluated by auxiliary examination. Some of the Robert's uterus have normal external uterine contour [12], making it difficult to identify in the laparoscopic surgery. Successful pregnancy and the cesarean section of healthy babies after ultrasound-monitored laparoscopy combined with hysteroscopy in patients with Robert's uterus have been reported [15]. If our patient has fertility requirements in the future, salpingography can be done first to determine whether the left fallopian tube is unobstructed, and then decide on natural pregnancy or assisted reproductive treatment. Monitoring the situation of pregnancy and appropriate intervention to achieve better pregnancy outcomes if required.

Table 2

Review of Robert’s uterus cases reports.

Authors

(year)

Side

Main surgical Treatment

Number of operations

Deenadayal.

2021

Left

(5/5)

Laparoscopic endometrectomy of the blind cavity (1/5), Hysteroscopic septal resection under laparoscopic control (1/5), Laparoscopic excision of the blind cavity (1/5), Hysterectomy with unilaeral salpingo- oophorectomy (1/5), No treatment (1/5)

one(3/4),

three(1/4)

Zhang J.

2021

Right

Hysteroscopic septal resection and laparoscopic oophorectomy

one

Liu Y.

2021

Right

Hysterectomy and right salpingectomy

two

Liu Y.

2020

Right

Hysteroscopic septal resection and Laparoscopic right salpingectomy

two

Yang QM.

2019

Right

Hysteroscopic septal resection and Laparoscopy guidance

one

Shah N.

2019

Left

Hysteroscopic septal resection and Laparoscopy guidance

one

Kiyak H.

2018

Right

Laparoscopic septal resection

one

Biler A.

2017

Right

Hysteroscopic septal resection and Laparoscopy guidance

one

Mittal P.

2017

Left

Laparotomy excision of the blind cavity

one

John SK.

2017

Right

Laparotomy septal resection

three

Ludwin A.

2016

Left

Hysteroscopic septal resection.

one

Di Spiezio Sardo A.

2015

Left

Hysteroscopic septal resection and Laparoscopy guidance

one

Li J.

2015

Left

Laparotomy septal resection and laparoscopic oophorocystectomy

one

MaddukuriSB.2014

Left

Laparotomy septal resection

one

Vural M.

2011

Left

Laparotomy endometrectomy of the blind cavity

one

Capito C.

2009

-

Laparotomy endometrectomy of the blind cavity

one

Gupta N.

2007

Right

Laparotomy septal resection

two

Singhal S.

2002

Right

Laparotomy

one

Robert's uterus is rare but can mimic other common acute abdominal disease. Adequate evaluation in each case is crucial for diagnosis and management.

Abbreviations

3D-US

Three-dimensional ultrasound;

MRI

Magnetic resonance imaging.

Declarations

Ethics approval and consent to participate

We have obtained informed approvement from ethics institutional from Institutional Review Board, First Hospital, Jilin University.

Consent for publication

The details/images/videos will be freely available on the internet and may be seen by the general public. The consent form is provided.

Availability of data and materials

The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.

Funding

This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 81701436).

Authors' contributions

Meiling Yu: conceived the case report, participated in the surgery, drafted and edited the manuscript.

KeXin Gao: reviewed the literature and drafted the manuscript.

Zhang Han: participated in the literature review and edited the manuscript. 

Jihong Zhu: participated in the surgery and literature review. 

All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Acknowledgements

Not applicable.

References

  1. Robert H. [Asymmetrical bifidities with unilateral menstrual retention (apropos of l2 cases)]. Chirurgie. 1970;96(11):796–9.
  2. Gupta N, Mittal S, Dadhwal V, Misra R. A unique congenital mullerian anomaly: Robert's uterus. Arch Gynecol Obstet. 2007;276(6):641–3.
  3. Musset R, Poitout P. A further case of asymetrically divided uterus. Role of the isthmus in the initiation of menstruation. Journal de gynécologie, obstétrique et biologie de la reproduction, 1974. 3(7): 1117.
  4. Deenadayal M, Günther V, Alkatout I, Freytag D, Deenadayal-Mettler A, Deenadayal Tolani A, Sinha R, Mettler L. Critical Role of 3D ultrasound in the diagnosis and management of Robert's uterus: a single-centre case series and a review. Facts Views Vis Obgyn. 2021;13(1):41–9.
  5. Zhang J, Zhou W, Tang Y, Tan S, Qiao L. Robert's uterus with delayed diagnosis and potential consequences: a case report. J Int Med Res. 2021;49(3):300060521999531.
  6. Liu Y, Yang Y, Duan J, Liu L, Zhang W, Wang Y. Favorable pregnancy outcome for a patient with Robert's uterus, bicornuate uterus, and ipsilateral renal agenesis. Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 2020;151(2):302–3.
  7. Yang QM, Li H, He SH, Chen D, Chen L. Pregnancy in a blind hemi-cavity of Robert's uterus with ipsilateral renal agenesis: a case report and literature review. J Int Med Res. 2019;47(7):3427–34.
  8. Shah N, Changede P. Hysteroscopic Management of Robert's Uterus. J Obstet Gynaecol India. 2020;70(1):86–8.
  9. Kiyak H, Karacan T, Wetherilt LS, Seckin KD, Ozyurek ES. Laparoscopic Blinded Endometrial Cavity Resection for Robert's Uterus. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2018;25(2):340.
  10. Biler A, Akdemir A, Peker N, Sendag F. A Rare Uterine Malformation: Asymmetric Septate Uterus. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2018;25(1):28–9.
  11. Mittal P, Gupta R, Mittal A, Taneja A, Sekhon PS, Gupta S. Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) Depiction of Robert's Uterus: A Rare Mullerian Duct Anomaly Presenting with Cyclical Pain in Young Menstruating Woman. Pol J Radiol. 2017;82:134–6.
  12. John SK, Prabhu PS, Virmani S, Kumar V, Thotan SP. Misdiagnosed Roberts Uterus Leading to Surgical Misadventures. J Pediatr Adolesc Gynecol. 2017;30(4):508–10.
  13. Ludwin A, Ludwin I, Martins WP. Robert's uterus: modern imaging techniques and ultrasound-guided hysteroscopic treatment without laparoscopy or laparotomy. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2016;48(4):526–9.
  14. Di Spiezio Sardo A, Giampaolino P, Scognamiglio M, Varelli C, Nazzaro G, Mansueto G, Nappi C, Grimbizis GF. An Exceptional Case of Complete Septate Uterus With Unilateral Cervical Aplasia (Class U2bC3V0/ESHRE/ESGE Classification) and Isolated Mullerian Remnants: Combined Hysteroscopic and Laparoscopic Treatment. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2016;23(1):16–7.
  15. Li J, Yu W, Wang M, Feng LM. Hysteroscopic treatment of Robert's uterus with laparoscopy. J Obstet Gynaecol Res. 2015;41(9):1491–4.
  16. Maddukuri SB, Karegowda LH, Prakashini K, Kantipudi S. Robert's uterus: a rare congenital mullerian duct anomaly causing haematometra. BMJ Case Rep, 2014:10:16.
  17. Vural M, Yildiz S, Cece H, Camuzcuoglu H. Favourable pregnancy outcome after endometrectomy for a Robert's uterus. J Obstet Gynaecol. 2011;31(7):668–9.
  18. Capito C, Sarnacki S. Menstrual Retention In a Robert's Uterus. J Pediatr Adolesc Gynecol. 2009;22(5):e104-6.
  19. Ludwin A, Ludwin I, Bhagavath B, Lindheim SR. Pre-, intra-, and postoperative management of Robert's uterus. Fertil Steril. 2018;110(4):778–9.
  20. Singhal S, Agarwal U, Sharma D, Sirohiwal D. Pregnancy in asymmetric blind hemicavity of Robert's uterus–a previously unreported phenomenon. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol. 2003;107(1):93–5.
  21. Ludwin A, Martins WP, Ludwin I. Uterine cavity imaging, volume estimation and quantification of degree of deformity using automatic volume calculation: description of technique. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2017;50(1):138–40.