This study had two purposes: (1) to determine the reliability of static measurements of foot posture and (2) to clarify the effect of foot arch deformity on motor function in the elderly.
Acceptable inter-rater reliability for the two indices were determined by direct measurement. Intra-rater reliability for the TFL measurement was determined by digital imaging. Inter-rater reliability of ICC was 0.98 for FL and 0.70 for DH. Intra-rater reliability for TFL measured from the digital images was ICC 0.92, and for foot arch ratio was ICC 0.96. The ICC values for the two raters would be classified as “almost perfect” for intra-rater and “substantial” for inter-rater reliability based on Landis and Koch’s classification [29].
The foot measurements in our study were found to be smaller than those previously reported [15, 16]. In our study, the AHR of the mean value for men was 0.332 and 0.329 for the right and left feet, respectively, and the mean value for women was 0.330 and 0.323 for the right and left feet, respectively.
The AHR values reported here are lower than those previously reported by McPoil et al. [16], where the mean AHR values were 0.345 and 0.341 for the right and left feet, respectively based on measurements in 850 participants. Similarly, Zifchock et al [30] reported mean AHR values of 0.340 and 0.336 for 68 male and 77 female participants, respectively.
McPoil et al. reported that the average FL, TFL, and DH in the right foot of men were 27.0 cm, 19.8 cm, and 6.85 cm, respectively. Those for the men in this study were 24.0 cm, 18.8 cm, and 6.16 cm, respectively. Additionally, the average value in the study by McPoil et al. was lower, and the average value for women was similar. The mean foot measurements in this study may be smaller than those previously reported because of bony structure differences based on race and age. Song et al. reported that Asians have flexible feet that are prone to pronation at the subtalar joint [31] and that foot measurements in the Japanese population tend to have a smaller AHR than those in Western countries.
Moreover, we examined the proportions of the three groups based on the arch height. The proportion in this study were as follows: normal foot was 79.2% for men and 77.7% for women; low-arched foot was 9.4% for men and 9.6% for women, and high-Arched foot was 12.7% for men and 12.7% for women.
The rate of foot arch deformation was 60% for normal arch, 20% for flat foot, and 20% for high-arched foot in previous studies [32]. However, flat foot had a 2.4% incidence in adults [33], and high arches occurred with an incidence of 8 to 15% on both feet [34, 35]. Thus, the proportion of low-arched foot and high-arched foot is not constant. However, a foot deformity of approximately 10% in this study is consistent with the findings in other studies.
This cross-sectional study mainly aimed to clarify the effect of foot arch deformity on physical characteristics and muscle strength, and locomotive function in the elderly.
On comparing the foot arches among the three groups in the community-dwelling elderly, the physical characteristics showed a significant difference in BMI, with the HAG having the highest BMI. Locomotive examination showed a significant difference in walking speed, with the HAG being the slowest. The bone structure of a high-arched foot may influence the decreased walking speed in the HAG.
Regarding the association between foot and balance functions in the elderly, Menz et al. reported that foot flexibility, plantar sensation, and plantar flexor strength are important and independent predictors of stable performance [4]. Tanaka et al. revealed that toe muscle function is particularly important for maintaining balance in the elderly and that elderly people place greater pressure on their toes than younger people to maintain their standing position to obtain sensory information [36]. However, in this study, there were no significant differences in the SMI, grip strength, and foot intrinsic muscle strength, which are the muscle strength indicators.
A high-arched foot is more rigid than the normal foot, reducing the range of motion and lessening shock absorption [12, 32]. Several researchers have reported that the center of gravity pressure shifts laterally during walking because of the effect of a high-arched foot [37, 38]. Additionally, Hösl et al. showed that there was no significant difference in gait propulsion between the normal foot and the asymptomatic flatfoot [39].
A high BMI reportedly increases the center of gravity displacement to maintain posture balance [40], and it is significantly associated with decreased walking speed in the elderly [41]. LaRoche showed that older women who are obese have low plantar flexor stiffness, which may limit propulsive forces during walking and require greater muscle activation for active force generation [42].
In contrast, the foot arch reportedly decreases as the BMI increases [43, 44]. Therefore, the BMI affects the structural changes of the MLA of the foot and may be involved in the foot arch height. However, foot deformity is more likely to occur at any age, and when the BMI is higher. However, it is unclear whether BMI is related to deformation. Longitudinal studies are needed to confirm whether obesity increases the incidence of having a high-arched foot.
There are some limitations to consider in the interpretation of these findings. The first limitation is that the inter-rater reliability of the measured values was lower for DH in the foot measurements than in the previous report using a measurement device. Moreover, the measurement of the foot was performed in the standing position, and the load was not adjusted.
The second limitation is that we did not consider pain evaluation, which is a factor related to the decrease in the walking speed of the elderly. High-arched deformity is a common finding in patients with foot pain [45], and the possibility that pain affects walking speed cannot be ruled out. Although this study did not show a difference in muscle strength among the three groups, Muchna et al. found that foot problems, especially foot pain and peripheral neuropathy, became more prominent as the frailty level worsened [10]. Further, they were not associated with decreased walking speed and stride length. We have described the effects of the high-arched foot and BMI on the factors that impaired gait in the elderly, although it is necessary to measure and examine the effect of foot pain and peripheral neuropathy.