DOI: https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-675299/v1
Background: To investigate the drug resistance and clinical characteristics of hospitalized children with drug-resistant Mycoplasma pneumoniae pneumonia (MRMP).
Methods: Sixty patients with MPP admitted to the Second Pediatric Respiratory Ward of Shengjing Hospital, Affiliated to China Medical University from November 2016 to February 2017 were enrolled in the study.
Results: Of these 53/60 (88.3%) patients had Mycoplasma pneumoniae nucleic acid identified by throat swab. 23S rRNA V region gene sequencing was performed, 47/49 (95.9%) had mutation sites, including 46 cases of A2063G, one case of A2064G, two cases of no mutation, and a final drug resistance rate of 95.9%. The summary characteristics of the 47 cases of drug-resistant MPP were based on 22 male and 25 female patients. The onset age was 6.9 ± 2.5 years and the total fever duration was 9.8 ± 3.7 days. The leukocyte count during the acute phase was (8,300 ± 4,200) cells/mm3, C-reactive Protein (CRP) was 18.2 (8.2–32.5) mg/L, neutrophil/lymphocyte ratio (NLR) was 2.1 (1.5–3.3), There was no significant difference between the acute phase and the convalescent phase for leukocyte count, P = 0.336. The NLR and CRP levels were significantly higher during the acute phase compared to the recovery period (P < 0.05). The level of lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) increased in 65.7% of patients, with a median of 248.5 (200.0–299.7) U/L. D-dimer levels were elevated in 59.4% of patients, with a median of 301.0 (188.5–545.0) mg/L. A total of 23/47 (48.9%) patients were diagnosed with severe MPP. The incidence of extra-pulmonary complications was 38.2%.
Conclusions: In summary, MRMP patients had a fever of long duration, higher inflammatory index, higher LDH and D-dimer levels, and an increased incidence of extra-pulmonary complications.
Mycoplasma pneumoniae (MP) is the smallest prokaryote that can survive independently. It causes upper and lower respiratory tract infections, mostly in children and young people (Waites KB, 2009). A worldwide MP pandemic occurs every 3–7 years. Pneumonia caused by MP (MPP) is a common community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) in children, accounting for approximately 40% of CAP in children greater than 5 years of age (Rogozinski Le, 2017). Since MP does not contain a cell wall, it is naturally resistant to beta lactam antibiotics, which affect cell wall synthesis. Macrolides, tetracyclines, and fluoroquinolones are effective drugs against mycoplasma (Bradley JS, 2011). Since tetracycline drugs such as minocycline and doxycycline are only used in children greater than 8 years of age and since quinolones should be used with caution in children less than 18 years of age, macrolides are the first choice for MP infection in children.
However, recent MP resistance to macrolides has become a serious clinical problem. The rate of macrolide-resistant MP (MRMP) is as high as 87.7% (Guo DX, 2019). However, the clinical characteristics of drug-resistant MPP are rarely reported in China. In this study the drug resistance and clinical characteristics are summarized for 60 MPP children hospitalized in the Second Pediatric Respiratory Ward of Shengjing Hospital, Affiliated to China Medical University from 2016 to 2017.
1.1 General information.
1.1.1 Clinical data were assessed for 60 cases of MPP from the Second Pediatric Respiratory Ward of Shengjing Hospital, Affiliated to China Medical University from November 2016 to February 2017, which included 27 males and 33 females.
1.1.2 Inclusion criteria: (1) met the diagnostic criteria for MPP, had clinical symptoms such as fever, cough or wheezing, imaging showed infiltration shadow or large consolidation shadow in the lung, positive MP nucleic acid in pharyngeal swab and antibody titer for MP during the acute stage was greater than 1:160, or serum antibody titer increased or decreased at least four times or more when the acute state was compared to the recovery period, (2) age < 18 year, and (3) study inclusion approved by the ethics committee.
1.1.3 The diagnostic criteria for severe MPP were the latest domestic diagnostic criteria for severe CAP in children (Respiratory Group, 2013) including a diagnosis of MPP as well as: (1) poor general condition, (2) food refusal or dehydration, (3) disturbance of consciousness, (4) significant increase in respiratory rate (judgment criteria: RR of infants ≥ 70 times / min, RR of older children ≥ 30 times / min), (5) cyanosis, (6) dyspnea (groaning, flapping of nasal alar, three concave sign), (7) lung infiltration range: multi lobe involvement or 2 / 3 of a lung lobe, (8) pleural effusion, (9) pulse oxygen saturation ≤ 92%, and (10) extra-pulmonary complications.
1.1.4 Exclusion criteria: (1) basic metabolic disorders, low immune function, or major chronic consumptive diseases and other basic diseases, (2) patients with previous recurrent wheezing or chronic cough were diagnosed as asthma, (3) premature infants, or (4) incomplete data.
1.2 Observation index.
Medical history collection included, (gender, age, duration of fever on admission, total heat duration, and complications), imaging examination, laboratory indicators (white blood cell count, serum C-reactive protein (CRP), neutrophil to lymphocyte ratio (NLR), lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), D-dimer, pathogenic indexes (nucleic acid detection, drug resistance gene detection, antibody titer), and treatment.
1.3 Laboratory testing.
Clinical specimens testing positive for MP were shipped to the Laboratory and tested by real-time PCR using a Universal Genomic DNA Kit (Beijing Kangwei Century Biotech Co., Ltd., China) for detection of MP as well as all point mutations in the 23S rRNA gene known to be associated with macrolide resistance. This analysis was based on the different melting points for the mutated nucleotide base pairs compared with those of wild type (Waites KB, 2017). Sanger sequencing using the same primers as for PCR was performed to confirm MP detection and the point mutations. Results were compared to MP M129 (GenBank accession no. X68422).
1.4 Statistical analysis.
Statistical analysis was performed using IBM SPSS software, version 16.0(SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA)for Windows. Continuous data were compared using Students’t test. Differences in categorical variables were assessed with Yates’ corrected Chi-square (χ) or Fisher’s exact test as appropriate. To compare the laboratory data between the acute stage and convalescence, Student’s T-test, Mann-Whitney U test, Chi-square test, and Fisher’s exact test were used, as appropriate. P values less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant.
2.1 Basic data: 60 patients with MPP were assessed (27 males and 33 females), of which 53/60 (88.3%) patients had Mycoplasma pneumoniae nucleic acid identified by throat swab. Forty-seven patients had macrolide resistant MPP (22 males and 25 females) and two patients had no mutation as judged by 23S rRNA V region gene sequencing. Of the 47 patients, the onset age was 6.9 ± 2.5 years, with total fever duration 9.8 ± 3.7 days, and cough relief time 13.1 ± 3.9 days. During the acute phase, leukocyte count was (8,300 ± 4,200) cells/mm3, CRP was 18.2 (8.2–32.5) mg/L, and neutrophil/lymphocyte ratio was 2.1 (1.5–3.3). LDH increased in 65.7% of the patients, with a median of 248.5 (200.0–299.7) U/L, D-dimer levels increased in 59.4% of patients with a median of 301.0 (188.5–545.0) mg/L, 30/47 (63.8%) had lung consolidation, 13/47 (27.6%) had double lung involvement, and 23/47 (48.9%) were diagnosed as severe MPP. The total incidence of extra-pulmonary complications was 38.2%. Among those, 8/47 (17%) were complicated with pleural effusion, 8/47 (17%) had central nervous system involvement, and 2/47 (4.2%) had functional liver damage. Treatment: 13/47 (27.6%) patients were treated with glucocorticoid, 5/47 (10.6%) were treated with human serum immunoglobulin, and 7/47 (14.9%) were treated with fiber-optic bronchoscopy. See Table 1.
Table 1. Characteristics of hospitalized patients with MRMP.
Index |
MRMP(n=47) |
Age, years |
6.9±2.5 |
Gender(Male/Female) |
22/25 |
Duration of fever at admission, days |
7.4±3.2 |
Total duration of fever, days |
9.8±3.7 |
Cough relief time, days |
13.1±3.9 |
Leukocyte (cells/mm3 ) |
8,300±4,200 |
NLR |
2.1(1.5-3.3) |
CRP(mg/L) |
18.2(8.2-32.5) |
*LDH(U/L) |
248.5(200.0-299.7) |
**D-Dimer(UG/L) |
301.0(188.5-545.0) |
Radiographic findings |
|
Bilateral infiltration, n(%) |
13(27.6) |
Lobar Consolidation, n(%) |
30(63.8) |
Total complication, n(%) |
|
Pleural effusion, n(%) |
8(17.0) |
Central nervous system involvement, n(%) |
8(17.0) |
Liver function impairment, n(%) |
2(4.2) |
Other interventions |
|
Glucocorticoid, n(%) |
13(27.6) |
Immunoglobulin, n(%) |
5(10.6) |
Fibrobronchoscopy, n(%) |
7(14.9) |
Combined use of cephalosporins |
|
n=0(%) |
1(2.1) |
n=1(%) |
26(55.3) |
N=2(%) |
16(34.0) |
n≥3(%) |
4(8.5) |
Data are presented as number (percentage), median (25th–75th percentile), mean ± SD.
*The normal range of LDH is 103–227 U / L, * * the normal range of D-dimer is 0–52 UG / L.
2.2 MP detection: during the acute stage the positivity rate for throat swab MP nucleic acid was 53/60(88.3%), 35/60 cases (58.3%) had mycoplasma antibody titers > 1:160 during the acute stage, during the recovery stage the antibody titer for MP in 60 cases was higher than 1:160 or four times higher than during the acute stage.
2.3 Detection of macrolide resistant sites: four of 53 pharyngeal swabs failed to detect 23S rRNA V mutation, mutation sites were found in the remaining 47/49, the macrolide-resistance rate was 95.9% including 46 cases of the A2063G mutation, one case of the A2064G mutation, and two cases of no detected mutation.
2.4 NLR and CRP: during the acute phase the number of leukocytes was higher than normal in 30% of patients with no significant difference between the acute and convalescent stages (P = 0.336), levels of NLR and CRP during the acute phase were significantly higher than those during the convalescent stage (P < 0.05). See Table 2.
Table 2. Comparison of Leukocyte, NLR, and CRP between acute phase and convalescent stage in hospitalized patients with MRMP.
|
acute phase |
convalescence stage |
*P-value |
Leukocyte (cells/mm3 ) |
8,300±4,200 |
7,200±2,200 |
0.336 |
NLR |
2.1(1.5-3.3) |
1.1(0.8-1.7) |
0.000 |
CRP(mg/L) |
18.2(8.2-32.5) |
3.1(3.1-3.4) |
0.000 |
Data are presented as median (25th–75th percentile), mean ± SD.
*There was no significant difference in Leukocytes between the acute phase and convalescent stage, P = 0.336, the levels of NLR and CRP during the acute phase were significantly higher than those during the convalescent stage, P < 0.05.
Okazaki, a Japanese scholar, first discovered MRMP in 2000. The antibiotic resistance was found to be related to a point mutation in the 23S rRNA gene (Okazaki N, 2001). Since then, investigation of MRMP has intensified. Zhao Fei et al. (Zhao F, 2013, Zhao F, 2019, Zhao F, 2019) monitored MRMP in six Chinese cities from 2008 to 2018 and found the macrolide-resistance rate to be as high as 65%–98%. The MRMP rate in Japan was 81.6% in 2008 and 43.6% in 2015. Examples of resistance rates are, 80% in Korea in 2015, 13.2% in the United States in 2013, 8.3% in France in 2011, and 3.1% (Takaaki Tanaka,2017, Lee, E, 2017, Zheng X, 2015, Pereyre S, 2013, Dumke R, 2015) in Germany in 2011-2012. Overall, the macrolide-resistance rate in Asian countries is much higher than that in European and American countries. Analysis of the clinical data for MPP children hospitalized in the Second Pediatric Respiratory Ward of Shengjing Hospital, Affiliated to China Medical University from November 2016 to February 2017 found the resistance rate of MP to be as high as 95.9%. Only one case had the A2064G mutation, with the remainder the classic mutation site, A2063G. These data demonstrate the prevalence of MRMP in hospitalized Chinese children.
For the 47 hospitalized children with MRMP pneumonia, the average fever duration was more than 9 days, which is longer than that of non-macrolide-resistant MPP. Fever was approximately 8.0 ± 6.0 days (n = 12) (Eun Lee,Korean J Pediatr 2017) and 6.0 ± 3.5 days (n = 96) (Kim YJ,J Korean Med Sci 2017) for non-macrolide-resistant MPP. These observations demonstrate MRMP pneumonia to have longer fever duration, which is consistent with this study. The incidence of leukocytosis was approximately 30%, which is consistent with previous reports (Stevens, D. 1978, Medjo B, 2014). Those reports found approximately 27.6% of cases to involve bilateral lungs, which was higher than the 20% of cases in a previous report (Ferwerda, A, 2001). Extra-pulmonary complications were as high as 38.3%, which was higher than the 17% reported previously (Yang TI, 2019). Herein, CRP and NLR during the acute phase were significantly higher than those in the recovery stage. CRP is an acute phase protein secreted by the liver in response to a variety of inflammatory cytokines. NLR can accurately predict the severity of and prognosis for CAP, as well as assist in risk determination for severe pneumonia patients with complications (Che-Morales JL, 2019). Increases in CRP and NLR reflect aggravation of the inflammatory response, suggesting a more serious disease. Approximately half of the cases within the macrolide-resistant group had severe pneumonia. For more than half of the cases, LDH and D-dimer levels were higher than the normal value, suggesting that MRMP likely involves not just the lungs but also other organs. Myocardial, liver, pancreas, and other injuries result in elevated LDH. Hypoxia and endotoxin stimulate inflammatory cells to release a variety of inflammatory mediators that result in vascular endothelial cell damage and coagulation events that significantly increase plasma D-dimer (Yuan SJ, 2017). D-dimer levels can be used as one of the critical markers for monitoring inflammation and severe infection (Wu HB, 2017). Chen Yu (Chen Yu, 2018) found that LDH was higher in patients with MRMP compared with patients with non-drug resistant MPP. Ryou Kawamata concluded that the higher the LDH, the more severe the MPP (Kawamata R, 2015). These results suggest that LDH and D-dimer levels are high in more than half of the cases with MRMP pneumonia cases, indicating that the pneumonia caused by MRMP is more serious clinically.
The duration of fever induced by MRMP is longer than that induced by non- macrolide-resistant MP (Suzuki S, 2006, Zhou YL, 2014, Yao HS, 2016, Yang TI, 2019). Further, fever duration is longer after administration of macrolides, hospitalization time is longer, and extra-pulmonary complications are more serious. MRMP infections are more common in immune suppressed individuals and in cancer patients. The predominant clinical difference between MRMP and non- macrolide-resistant MP is the duration of fever, with no significant difference in lung imaging, laboratory measures, or extra-pulmonary complications (Deng H, 2018, Wu HM, 2013, KB Waites, 2019). According to Jae Hong Choi, MRMP involves the lobes of the lungs without other clinical or laboratory signs of infection (Choi JH, 2019). AE Yoon et al. (Yoon IA, 2017) showed that the duration of fever was related to the severity of lung imaging, but not to drug resistance. These inconsistent reports may be due to differences in sample size or treatment methods.
In this study, the macrolide-resistance rate of MPP inpatients was as high as 95.9%, which was significantly higher than the concomitant rate of 65.4% for outpatients (Zhao F, 2019). We infer that MRMP infection is more likely to cause refractory/severe MPP that results in a higher treatment failure rate for outpatients, such that the macrolide-resistance rate for hospitalized patients is significantly increased. The results of this study identify the total fever duration of drug-resistant MPP patients is 9 days, which is significantly longer than the 5–6 days for patients infected with non-macrolide-resistant MP (Medjo B, 2014). These patients were treated with glucocorticoid (n = 13) and immunoglobulin (n = 5) to shorten the course of fever. Approximately half of macrolide-resistant MPP develops into severe MP. The rate of extra-pulmonary complications is high, with lungs seriously affected as judged by imaging. Therefore, MRMP is more likely to develop into a severe case. We also found severe MPP cases in patients with non-macrolide-resistant MP. Severe MPP is not only related to the macrolide-resistance of the pathogen but also to bacterial load, bacterial virulence, and the immune status of the patient. Future investigations need to consider the influence of these other factors on severe MPP outcomes.
Limitations of this study: This study summarizes the drug resistance and case characteristics of hospitalized patients, but does not include analysis of outpatients with mycoplasma pneumonia. This short term study was performed at a single center and only assessed drug resistant MPP in the Pediatric Department of Shengjing Hospital in the winter of 2016. Further, there were few non-drug resistant cases in this study and comparisons between groups is therefore limited. The results of this study need to be confirmed with a larger sample size and a more in-depth study.
Conclusions: The majority of MPP patients were found to be infected with macrolide-resistant MP (95.9%). The children with MRMP pneumonia were mainly school-aged with a mean age of 6.9 years. Average total fever duration was more than 9 days. Leukocyte count during the acute phase was slightly increased in approximately 30% of cases. CRP and NLR during the acute phase were significantly higher than during the recovery period. LDH and D-dimer levels were increased in more than half of the patients with MRMP. The overall incidence of extra-pulmonary complications was 38.2%. Therefore, MRMP patients exhibited longer fever duration, higher inflammatory index, higher levels of LDH and D-dimer, increased incidence of extra-pulmonary complications, and were likely to develop severe pneumonia. MP resistance requires strict attention, with appropriate administration of antibiotics, and early identification of severe cases. Early glucocorticoid intervention can prevent and/or reduce complications and improve prognosis.
MPP- Mycoplasma pneumoniae pneumonia
CRP- C-reactive Protein
NLR- neutrophil/lymphocyte ratio
LDH- lactate dehydrogenase
MRMP- macrolide-resistant Mycoplasma pneumoniae pneumonia
Conflict of Interest Statement: The authors declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship or publication of this article.
Acknowledgement:We thank International Science Editing for editing this manuscript. (http://www.internationalscienceediting.com )