DON-induced apoptosis has been confirmed in various cell types including gastrointestinal tract and intestinal epithelial cells. However, there has been no data available on the effects of DON in nerve cells, especially related to DON-induced apoptosis through the mitochondrial signaling pathway. Here we used PHNCs to evaluate this question (schematic, Fig. 8).
DON is known to be toxic to many cell types, with its significant cytotoxicity mediated primarily through induction of apoptosis [15]. The inference of apoptotic chromatin deviates with treatment of DON has been observed by fluorescence microscopy in lung fibroblasts, human proximal tubule cells, and human colon cancer cells [16, 17]. Our experimental results are consistent with these observations. We demonstrated that PHNC viability decreased with increasing concentrations of DON, and that DON-treated cells showed typical ultrastructural changes consistent with apoptosis including nuclear shrinkage and dense fluorescence. These findings collectively propose that DON induces cell death in PHNCs via mitochondrial apoptosis pathway.
DON can damage cell membranes, inhibit cell activity, and promote LDH release, which lead to apoptosis and cell death in PC12 cells [18]. Different concentrations of DON will cause injury to cells in varying degrees. Many studies have shown that DON can inhibit cell proliferation in a dose-dependent manner [19, 20]. Even low concentrations of DON may cause apoptosis, with increasing rates of apoptosis as DON concentrations increase. At higher concentrations DON mostly caused cell death and also may cause a little apoptosis [21]. We confirmed using flow cytometry that apoptosis occurs in a DON dose-dependent fashion in PHNCs; we observed a higher rate of apoptosis in cells cured with 1000 ng/mL of DON compared to 2000 ng/mL DON, but higher cell death at 2000 ng/mL DON compared to 1000 ng/mL DON. These results are consistent with earlier observations. Overall, the above results revealed that DON can persuade apoptosis of PHNCs, suggesting that further research focusing on the mitochondrial apoptotic pathway is warranted.
Caspase–8 is known to play a crucial role in intervening Fas-persuaded apoptosis [22, 23]. In this paradigm, Fas ligand- or agonistic antibody-mediated cross-linkage of the Fas receptor that leads to assembly of the death inducing signal complex (DISC), of which the adaptor FADD/MORT–1 and caspase–8 form a part [24].Association of this complex leads to initiation of caspase–8, which pledges the classic apoptotic cascade including activation of caspase–3, –6, and –7, and ultimately mitochondrial damage [25]. During apoptosis which are activated by Fas, a subcategory of caspase family associates is triggered. Among them is caspase–8, which activates additional downstream caspases and directs the cell toward apoptosis. In light of its central role in apoptosis, we chose an inhibitor of caspase–8 to demonstrate the role of the mitochondrial apoptosis pathway in DON-associated toxicity.
Mitochondria are one of the most important cellular organelles for cellular energy production and survival, and the mitochondrial pathway is the utmost vital intracellular apoptosis signaling cascade. The mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP) results from the uneven distribution of protons and ions across the mitochondrial membrane. Recently researchers have also shown that variations in MMP and mitochondrial permeability play a significant role in the process of apoptosis, and it is thought that alterations in MMP occur in the earliest stages of apoptosis. Once mitochondria are injured, the MMP is markedly decreased, leading to severe impairment of mitochondrial function and eventually irreversible apoptosis. In recent years, studies have shown that mitochondria are involved in almost all cell apoptosis [26]. In this study, we labeled mitochondria of apoptotic cells with JC–1 and measured fluorescence using flow cytometry to quantify changes in MMP. We found that MMP of PHNCs decreased significantly after 24 h exposure to concentrations of DON in ascending order. MMP was significantly increased in PHNCs cured with 1000 ng/mL DON + FMK compared to 1000 ng/mL alone (P < 0.01), suggesting that caspase–8 inhibition can prevent dissipation of the MMP. Altogether, these data confirmed that mitochondria are involved in DON-mediated cell apoptosis.
For the first time B-cell lymphoma/leukemia–2 (Bcl–2) was known in a study of B-cell lymphoma, and overexpression of Bcl–2 protein can inhibit apoptosis and prolong cell life. Bcl–2 was the first protein to be recognized as an inhibitor of apoptosis. Bcl–2 protein is contained on the endoplasmic reticulum, mitochondrial membrane, and the nuclear envelope, through a region in its C-terminus [27–29].
Bcl–2 has been shown to be the most important protein that inhibits tumor cell apoptosis. There are more than 25 members of Bcl–2 family have been identified. Studies propose that that Bcl–2 may act on signaling molecules and mitochondrial and nuclear pore complexes such as CYCS and apoptosis inducing factor AIF, and control cell signaling to prolong cell survival [30]. The Bcl–2/Apaf–1/caspase–9 complex is directly combined with Apaf–1 to inhibit the activation of caspase–9 by caspase–3. Bcl–2 may also regulate caspase on the mitochondrial membrane and reduce its activity, but it does not affect the activation of caspase–9 by CYCS and Apaf–1 [31]. Bcl–2 protein can inhibit apoptosis by binding to Bid, Bim, or Bad, and Bcl–2/Bax ratio concludes whether a cell will live after receiving apoptotic signals [32].
Bid is a pro-apoptotic factor and its product, tBid, has the ability to induce CYCS leakage from mitochondria [33–35], without dissipation of the mitochondrial inner membrane potential. Bid does not possess activity under normal physiological conditions. With the initiation of apoptosis, caspase–8 is activated first, and then the Bid enzyme is cleaved into dual number of fragments, namely a C-terminal fragment and an N-terminal fragment of 15 kD. C-fragments are transferred from the cytoplasm to mitochondria and induce release of CYCS from mitochondria, while N- fragments remain in the cytoplasm and cannot induce the release of CYCS. In our study, bcl–2 expression declined with higher concentration of DON, with expression reaching a lowest at 1000 ng/mL. However, changes in bax expression showed an opposite trend, as found by earlier observations [36, 37]. With increasing of DON concentration, bid expression also increased, and at 1000 ng/mL it reached a maximum level. We suspect that the increase in expression of bid at the transcriptional level reflectsincreased levels of active Bid. Variations in expression of bcl–2, bax and bid in PHNCs preserved with 1000 ng/mL DON + FMK were contrary to those cured with 1000 ng/mL DON alone. Our data support the conclusion that bcl–2, bax, and bid act a decisive role in apoptosis in DON-treated cells.
A water-soluble mitochondrial inner membrane protein called Cytochrome C that plays a fundamental role in the transportation of electron in the respiratory chain. CYCS released from the mitochondria into the cytoplasm after stimulation by an apoptotic signal, further increasing caspase–3 and caspase–9 activation [38]. We found that mitochondrial CYCS abundance decreased as DON concentration increased, with the greatest effect observed at at 1000 ng/mL DON. Nevertheless, mitochondrial levels of CYCS in PHNCs treated with 1000 ng/mL DON + FMK were higher than in cells cured with 1000 ng/mL DON alone. These data propose that CYCS is unconstrained into the cytoplasm from mitochondria when DON-triggered apoptosis occurred, and that caspase–8 inhibition via FMK could prevent the release of CYCS from the mitochondria.
AIF is an active protein of induced apoptosis, located between the mitochondrial double membranes. AIF is free from the mitochondria into the cytoplasm after stimulation by an apoptosis signal, enters nucleus where it facilitates DNA cleavage, which may further contribute to apoptosis [39]. In our previous study [18], we found that AIF was released into the cytoplasm from the mitochondria in cells treated with DON, and that this release was prohibited by FMK-mediated inhibition of caspase–8.
Caspases are a family of cysteine proteases that can specifically shear peptide bonds that follow aspartic acid residues, and have the capacity for autocatalysis and mutual activation [40]. Caspase proteases play a vital role in signal transduction during cell apoptosis, and cleaved caspases hydrolyze important proteins involved in cell regulation, cell signal transduction, and DNA restoration [41]. Caspase–3 is located downstream of the initial triggers of cell apoptosis; cleaved caspase–3 acts directly on the nucleus and mediates apoptosis. Apoptosis signal in the cell could induce the formation of a PT (permeability transition) channel and endorse the discharge of CYCS from the mitochondria. CYCS, Apaf–1, ATP, or ADP and caspase–9 zymogen form an apoptosis-promoting complex, from which caspase–9 is released and activated [42]. Triggered caspase–9 cleaves downstream caspase–3 zymogen, leading to its activation, while caspase–3 degrades substrates lead to rupture of the nuclear fiber lamina and compaction of nuclear chromatin, resulting in cell apoptosis [43]. In the present experiment, DON treatment significantly augmented the expression of cleaved-caspase–9 and cleaved-caspase–3 in PHNCs, and decreased the relative expression of caspase–9 and caspase–3 compared to untreated (control) cells. The abundance of cleaved-caspase–9 and cleaved-caspase–3 in PHNCs cured with 1000 ng/mL DON + FMK was lesser than that in cells canned with 1000 ng/mL DON. The expression of caspase–9 and caspase–3 in cells treated with 1000 ng/mL DON + FMK showed the opposite trends. These results indicated that CYCS, AIF, caspase–9, and caspase–3 contribute in DON-triggered apoptosis in PHNCs.
The tumor suppressor gene P53, a transcription factor central to regulation of apoptosis, possesses two functions: to repair cell damage or to induce cell apoptosis. P53 could combine with DNA and checked if DNA was damaged. After DNA damage was founded by P53, it would stimulate the expression of CIP (CDK-interacting protein), preventing cell division and allowing for DNA repair to occur. When DNA damage was higher than P53 repair, then the expression of P53 could promote cell apoptosis [44, 45]. P53 could affect cell apoptosis through inhibiting the Bcl–2 expression level and endorsing Bax and Bak expression [46].In our study, the transcription activities of P53 were enhanced with the increasing DON concentration, which confirmed the effect of P53 in cell apoptosis.
In summary, the present study indicates that DON can induce apoptosis of PHNCs via triggering of mitochondrial signal transduction pathway. Our study found that DON treatment led to induction of the pro-apoptotic genes Bax and Bid, while Bcl–2 expression was repressed. DON treatment also led to cleavage (activation) of the apoptosis-related proteins caspase–3 and caspase–9. These effects were diminished by inhibition of caspase–8. Together, these data propose that mitochondrial apoptosis might be a principal mechanism through which DON persuades neurotoxicity, and provide important insights for future studies on mechanisms of DON neurotoxicity.