Additional File 1: PRISMA-P Checklist (file extension .docx)
Below is a summary of the items addressed in the proposed protocol according to Shamseer et al. (36).
Section and topic
|
Item No
|
Item Addressed
|
Checklist item
|
ADMINISTRATIVE INFORMATION
|
|
Title:
|
|
|
|
Identification
|
1a
|
Yes
|
Identify the report as a protocol of a systematic review
|
Update
|
1b
|
Not applicable
|
If the protocol is for an update of a previous systematic review, identify as such
|
Registration
|
2
|
Yes
|
If registered, provide the name of the registry (such as PROSPERO) and registration number
|
Authors:
|
|
|
|
Contact
|
3a
|
Yes
|
Provide name, institutional affiliation, e-mail address of all protocol authors; provide physical mailing address of corresponding author
|
Contributions
|
3b
|
Yes
|
Describe contributions of protocol authors and identify the guarantor of the review
|
Amendments
|
4
|
Not applicable
|
If the protocol represents an amendment of a previously completed or published protocol, identify as such and list changes; otherwise, state plan for documenting important protocol amendments
|
Support:
|
|
|
|
Sources
|
5a
|
Yes
|
Indicate sources of financial or other support for the review
|
Sponsor
|
5b
|
Yes
|
Provide name for the review funder and/or sponsor
|
Role of sponsor or funder
|
5c
|
Yes
|
Describe roles of funder(s), sponsor(s), and/or institution(s), if any, in developing the protocol
|
INTRODUCTION
|
|
Rationale
|
6
|
Yes
|
Describe the rationale for the review in the context of what is already known
|
Objectives
|
7
|
Yes
|
Provide an explicit statement of the question(s) the review will address with reference to participants, interventions, comparators, and outcomes (PICO)
|
METHODS
|
|
Eligibility criteria
|
8
|
Yes
|
Specify the study characteristics (such as PICO, study design, setting, time frame) and report characteristics (such as years considered, language, publication status) to be used as criteria for eligibility for the review
|
Information sources
|
9
|
Yes
|
Describe all intended information sources (such as electronic databases, contact with study authors, trial registers or other grey literature sources) with planned dates of coverage
|
Search strategy
|
10
|
Yes
|
Present draft of search strategy to be used for at least one electronic database, including planned limits, such that it could be repeated
|
Study records:
|
|
|
|
Data management
|
11a
|
Yes
|
Describe the mechanism(s) that will be used to manage records and data throughout the review
|
Selection process
|
11b
|
Yes
|
State the process that will be used for selecting studies (such as two independent reviewers) through each phase of the review (that is, screening, eligibility and inclusion in meta-analysis)
|
Data collection process
|
11c
|
Yes
|
Describe planned method of extracting data from reports (such as piloting forms, done independently, in duplicate), any processes for obtaining and confirming data from investigators
|
Data items
|
12
|
Yes
|
List and define all variables for which data will be sought (such as PICO items, funding sources), any pre-planned data assumptions and simplifications
|
Outcomes and prioritization
|
13
|
Yes
|
List and define all outcomes for which data will be sought, including prioritization of main and additional outcomes, with rationale
|
Risk of bias in individual studies
|
14
|
Yes
|
Describe anticipated methods for assessing risk of bias of individual studies, including whether this will be done at the outcome or study level, or both; state how this information will be used in data synthesis
|
Data synthesis
|
15a
|
Not applicable
|
Describe criteria under which study data will be quantitatively synthesised
|
15b
|
Not applicable
|
If data are appropriate for quantitative synthesis, describe planned summary measures, methods of handling data and methods of combining data from studies, including any planned exploration of consistency (such as I2, Kendall’s τ)
|
15c
|
Not applicable
|
Describe any proposed additional analyses (such as sensitivity or subgroup analyses, meta-regression)
|
15d
|
Yes
|
If quantitative synthesis is not appropriate, describe the type of summary planned
|
Meta-bias(es)
|
16
|
Yes
|
Specify any planned assessment of meta-bias(es) (such as publication bias across studies, selective reporting within studies)
|
Confidence in cumulative evidence
|
17
|
Yes
|
Describe how the strength of the body of evidence will be assessed (such as GRADE)
|
Additional File 2: Master List of Synonyms for Key Concepts in the Search Strategy (file extension .docx)
Keyword searching will include search terms from the two key concepts in the PIC-derived review question: patient-centred measurement and implementation. This list contains all generated synonyms, plurals, and alternate spellings.
Patient-Centred Measurement
"family caregiver* assess*" OR
"family caregiver* index*" OR
"family caregiver* indicator*” OR
"family caregiver* instrument*" OR
"family caregiver* inventor*" OR
"family caregiver* measur*" OR
"family caregiver* outcome*" OR
"family caregiver* questionnaire*" OR
"family caregiver* scale*" OR
"family caregiver* screen*" OR
"family caregiver* survey*" OR
"family experience assess*" OR
"family experience index*" OR
"family experience indicator*” OR
"family experience instrument*" OR
"family experience inventor*" OR
"family experience measur*" OR
"family experience outcome*" OR
"family experience questionnaire*" OR
"family experience scale*" OR
"family experience screen*" OR
"family experience survey*" OR
“family outcome assess*" OR
"family outcome index*" OR
"family outcome indicator*” OR
"family outcome instrument*" OR
"family outcome inventor*" OR
"family outcome measur*" OR
"family outcome questionnaire*" OR
"family outcome scale*" OR
"family outcome screen*" OR
“family outcome survey*” OR
"family-reported experience questionnaire*" OR
"family-reported outcome measur*" OR
"family satisfaction assess*" OR
"family satisfaction index*" OR
"family satisfaction indicator*” OR
"family satisfaction instrument*" OR
"family satisfaction inventor*" OR
"family satisfaction measur*" OR
"family satisfaction outcome*" OR
"family satisfaction questionnaire*" OR
"family satisfaction scale*" OR
“family satisfaction survey*” OR
"Health care outcome* assess*" OR
"Health care outcome* index*" OR
"Health care outcome* indicator*” OR
"Health care outcome *instrument*" OR
"Health care outcome* inventor*" OR
"Health care outcome* measur*" OR
"Health care outcome* questionnaire*" OR
"Health care outcome* scale*" OR
"Health care outcome* screen*" OR
"Healthcare outcome* survey*" OR
"Healthcare outcome* assess*" OR
"Healthcare outcome* index*" OR
"Healthcare outcome* indicator*” OR
"Healthcare outcome* instrument*" OR
"Healthcare outcome* inventor*" OR
"Healthcare outcome* measur*" OR
"Healthcare outcome* questionnaire*" OR
"Healthcare outcome* scale*" OR
"Healthcare outcome* screen*" OR
"Healthcare outcome* survey*" OR
"Health outcome assess*" OR
"Health outcome index*" OR
"Health outcome indicator*” OR
"Health outcome instrument*" OR
"Health outcome inventor*" OR
"Health outcome measur*" OR
"Health outcome questionnaire*" OR
"Health outcome scale*" OR
"Health outcome screen*" OR
"Health outcome survey*" OR
"health status assess*" OR
"Health status index*" OR
"Health status indicator*” OR
"health status instrument*" OR
"Health status inventor*" OR
"Health status measur*" OR
"Health status outcome*" OR
"Health status questionnaire*" OR
"Health status scale*" OR
"Health status screen*" OR
"Health status survey*" OR
“Patient-centred experience” OR
"Patient-centered experience" OR
“Patient-centred outcome*" OR
"Patient-centered outcome*" OR
“Patient experience assess*" OR
"Patient experience index*" OR
“Patient experience indicator*” OR
"Patient experience instrument*" OR
"Patient experience measur*" OR
"Patient experience outcome*" OR
"Patient experience questionnaire*" OR
"Patient experience screen*" OR
"Patient experience scale*" OR
"Patient experience survey*" OR
“Patient outcome* assess*" OR
"Patient outcome* index*" OR
“Patient outcome* indicator*” OR
"Patient outcome* instrument*" OR
"Patient outcome* inventor*" OR
"Patient outcome* measur*" OR
"Patient outcome* questionnaire*" OR
"Patient outcome* screen*" OR
"Patient outcome* scale*" OR
"Patient outcome* survey*" OR
“Patient-orientated assess*" OR
"Patient-orientated index*" OR
“Patient-orientated indicator*” OR
"Patient-orientated instrument*" OR
"Patient-orientated measur*" OR
"Patient-orientated questionnaire*" OR
"Patient-orientated scale*" OR
"Patient-orientated survey*" OR
“Patient-oriented assess*"
"Patient-oriented index*"
“Patient-oriented indicator*”
"Patient-oriented instrument*"
"Patient-oriented inventor*"
"Patient-oriented measure*"
"Patient-oriented questionnaire*"
"Patient-oriented scale*"
"Patient-oriented screen*"
"Patient-oriented survey*"
"patient-reported experience*" OR
"patient-reported outcome*" OR
“patient-reported satisfaction*” OR
"patient satisfaction assess*" OR
"patient satisfaction index*" OR
"patient satisfaction indicator*” OR
"patient satisfaction instrument*" OR
"patient satisfaction inventor*" OR
"patient satisfaction measur*" OR
"patient satisfaction outcome*" OR
"patient satisfaction questionnaire*" OR
"patient satisfaction scale*" OR
"patient satisfaction screen*" OR
“patient satisfaction survey*” OR
“People-centred assess*" OR
"People-centred index*" OR
"People-centred instrument*" OR
"People-centred measur*" OR
"People-centred outcome*" OR
"People-centred screen*" OR
"People-centred scale*" OR
"People-centred survey*" OR
“patient-centred healthcare outcomes” OR
“patient-centred health care outcomes” OR
“patient-centered healthcare outcomes” OR
“patient-centered health care outcomes” OR
“People-centered assess*" OR
"People-centered index*" OR
“People-centered indicator*” OR
"People-centered instrument*" OR
"People-centered measur*" OR
"People-centered outcome*" OR
"People-centered screen*" OR
"Person-centered outcome*" OR
"Person-centred outcome*" OR
"person-reported outcome*" OR
"person-reported experience*" OR
"PREM" OR
“PREMs” OR
"PROM" OR
"PROMs" OR
"PROMIS"
Implementation
"Attitudes of health personnel" OR
Barrier* n4 implement* OR
challeng* n4 implement* OR
"Clinical application*" OR
"clinical decision making" OR
"Clinical decision support*" OR
"clinical educat*” OR
"clinical support*” OR
"clinician attitude*” OR
"clinician perception*” OR
"clinician view*” OR
"computer application*" OR
"electronic application*" OR
Enabler* OR
Experience* OR
facilitat* n4 implement* OR
“health personnel attitude” OR
"Implementation science" OR
Implement* OR
integrat* OR
Interpret* OR
"Knowledge translat*" OR
"online application*" OR
"Practice guid*" OR
"Practise guid*" OR
"Practic* application*" OR
"practice educat*” OR
"practice support" OR
"Professional practice" OR
"Professional development" OR
"program evaluat*” OR
"provider attitude*” OR
"provider perception*” OR
"provider view*” OR
"quality improve*" OR
"smartphone application*" OR
"stakeholder engagement” OR
"Training project” OR
"Training program” OR
"training clinician*” OR
"web* application*"
Additional File 3: Example of Search Strategy in Bibliographic Database (file extension .docx)
Draft of search strategy to be for CINAHL database with year and language limits.
Database name: CINAHL Complete
Date searched: 2019-12-10
Limiters: Human
Language: English
Type of document: peer reviewed, academic journals
Date range: January 1, 2010 to December 31, 2020
Implementation
|
AND
|
PCM
|
"Attitudes of health personnel" OR Barrier* n4 implement* OR challeng* n4 implement* OR "Clinical application*" OR "clinical decision making" OR "Clinical decision support*" OR "clinical educat*" OR "clinical support*" OR "clinician attitude*" OR "clinician perception*" OR "clinician view*" OR "computer application*" OR "electronic application*" OR Enabler* OR Experience* OR facilitat* n4 implement* OR "health personnel attitude" OR "Implementation science" OR Implement* OR integrat* OR Interpret* OR "Knowledge translat*" OR "online application*" OR "Practice guid*" OR "Practic* application*" OR "practice educat*" OR "practice support" OR "Practise guid*" OR "Professional practice" OR "Professional development" OR "program evaluat*" OR "provider attitude*" OR "provider perception*" OR "provider view*" OR "quality improve*" OR "smartphone application*" OR "stakeholder engagement" OR "Training project" OR "Training program" OR "training clinician*" OR "web* application*"
|
|
"family caregiver* assess*" OR "family caregiver* index*" OR "family caregiver* indicator*" OR "family caregiver* instrument*" OR "family caregiver* inventor*" OR "family caregiver* measur*" OR "family caregiver* outcome*" OR "family caregiver* questionnaire*" OR "family caregiver* scale*" OR "family caregiver* screen*" OR "family caregiver* survey*" OR "family experience assess*" OR "family experience index*" OR "family experience indicator*" OR "family experience instrument*" OR "family experience inventor*" OR "family experience measur*" OR "family experience outcome*" OR "family experience questionnaire*" OR "family experience scale*" OR "family experience screen*" OR "family experience survey*" OR "family outcome assess*" OR "family outcome index*" OR "family outcome indicator*" OR "family outcome instrument*" OR "family outcome inventor*" OR "family outcome measur*" OR "family outcome questionnaire*" OR "family outcome scale*" OR "family outcome screen*" OR "family outcome survey*" OR "family-reported experience questionnaire*" OR "family-reported outcome measur*" OR "family satisfaction assess*" OR "family satisfaction index*" OR "family satisfaction indicator*" OR "family satisfaction instrument*" OR "family satisfaction inventor*" OR "family satisfaction measur*" OR "family satisfaction outcome*" OR "family satisfaction questionnaire*" OR "family satisfaction scale*" OR "family satisfaction survey*" OR "Health care outcome* assess*" OR "Health care outcome* index*" OR "Health care outcome* indicator*" OR "Health care outcome *instrument*" OR "Health care outcome* inventor*" OR "Health care outcome* measur*" OR "Health care outcome* questionnaire*" OR "Health care outcome* scale*" OR "Health care outcome* screen*" OR "Healthcare outcome* survey*" OR "Healthcare outcome* assess*" OR "Healthcare outcome* index*" OR "Healthcare outcome* indicator*" OR "Healthcare outcome* instrument*" OR "Healthcare outcome* inventor*" OR "Healthcare outcome* measur*" OR "Healthcare outcome* questionnaire*" OR "Healthcare outcome* scale*" OR "Healthcare outcome* screen*" OR "Healthcare outcome* survey*" OR "Health outcome assess*" OR "Health outcome index*" OR "Health outcome indicator*" OR "Health outcome instrument*" OR "Health outcome inventor*" OR "Health outcome measur*" OR "Health outcome questionnaire*" OR "Health outcome scale*" OR "Health outcome screen*" OR "Health outcome survey*" OR "health status assess*" OR "Health status index*" OR "Health status indicator*" OR "health status instrument*" OR "Health status inventor*" OR "Health status measur*" OR "Health status outcome*" OR "Health status questionnaire*" OR "Health status scale*" OR "Health status screen*" OR "Health status survey*" OR "Patient-centred experience" OR "Patient-centered experience" OR "Patient-centred outcome*" OR "Patient-centered outcome*" OR "Patient experience assess*" OR "Patient experience index*" OR "Patient experience indicator*" OR "Patient experience instrument*" OR "Patient experience measur*" OR "Patient experience outcome*" OR "Patient experience questionnaire*" OR "Patient experience screen*" OR "Patient experience scale*" OR "Patient experience survey*" OR "Patient outcome* assess*" OR "Patient outcome* index*" OR "Patient outcome* indicator*" OR "Patient outcome* instrument*" OR "Patient outcome* inventor*" OR "Patient outcome* measur*" OR "Patient outcome* questionnaire*" OR "Patient outcome* screen*" OR "Patient outcome* scale*" OR "Patient outcome* survey*" OR "Patient-orientated assess*" OR "Patient-orientated index*" OR "Patient-orientated indicator*" OR "Patient-orientated instrument*" OR "Patient-orientated measur*" OR "Patient-orientated questionnaire*" OR "Patient-orientated scale*" OR "Patient-orientated survey*" OR "Patient-oriented assess*" OR "Patient-oriented index*" OR "Patient-oriented indicator*" OR "Patient-oriented instrument*" OR "Patient-oriented inventor*" OR "Patient-oriented measure*" OR "Patient-oriented questionnaire*" OR "Patient-oriented scale*" OR "Patient-oriented screen*" OR "Patient-oriented survey*" OR "patient-reported experience*" OR "patient-reported outcome*" OR "patient-reported satisfaction*" OR "patient satisfaction assess*" OR "patient satisfaction index*" OR "patient satisfaction indicator*" OR "patient satisfaction instrument*" OR "patient satisfaction inventor*" OR "patient satisfaction measur*" OR "patient satisfaction outcome*" OR "patient satisfaction questionnaire*" OR "patient satisfaction scale*" OR "patient satisfaction screen*" OR "patient satisfaction survey*" OR "People-centred assess*" OR "People-centred index*" OR "People-centred instrument*" OR "People-centred measur*" OR "People-centred outcome*" OR "People-centred screen*" OR "People-centred scale*" OR "People-centred survey*" OR "patient-centred healthcare outcomes" OR "patient-centred health care outcomes" OR "patient-centered healthcare outcomes" OR "patient-centered health care outcomes" OR "People-centered assess*" OR "People-centered index*" OR "People-centered indicator*" OR "People-centered instrument*" OR "People-centered measur*" OR "People-centered outcome*" OR "People-centered screen*" OR "Person-centered outcome*" OR "Person-centred outcome*" OR "person-reported outcome*" OR "person-reported experience*" OR "PREM" OR "PREMs" OR "PROM" OR "PROMs" OR "PROMIS"
|