Growth and natamycin production kinetics
To investigate the growth and natamycin production kinetics of S. natalensis HW-2 treated with and without the fungal elicitor, the fungal elicitor was added into the broth after fermentation for 24 h, and the production of natamycin and dry cell weight (DCW) were measured. Figure 1a showed that the logarithmic period and the stability period of S. natalensis HW-2 were 36-72 h and 72-108 h, respectively. Figure 1b showed that the biosynthesis of natamycin started at 24 h, and the maximum natamycin yield was 1.25 g/L at 120 h in the control and 1.88 g/L at 120 h in the experiment group. The yield was increased by 50.4%. According to the growth and antibiotic production kinetics, the checked points to the transcriptome of S.natalensis HW-2 were chosen in this study.
Transcriptome analysis of S. natalensis HW-2
For a global analysis of fungal elicitor-induced genes, S. natalensis HW-2 was cultured for 24 h and the fungal elicitor was added into the fermentation broth. Then, the strain was grown up to the mid-exponential growth phase (40 h) and early period of stationary phase (80 h) (see figure 1). The mycelium was collected. Total RNA in control groups and experimental groups were isolated and the transcriptome was studied. S. natalensis ATCC 27448 genes were publically available and used as reference genes. The change of all genes was represented in a volcano plot (Figure 2). Two groups were divided into 40 h and 80 h. These genes with a fold change ≥2 and p<0.05 were considered as differential expression genes (DEGs). Sequence reads were submitted to GenBank GEO database under accession number GSE112559, with a link at http://www.ncbi. nlm.nih.gov/geo/ query/acc.cgi?acc= GSE112559.
In response to fungal elicitor, the transcriptome of S.natalensis HW-2 showed that the transcripts of 7578 genes were detected and 1265 genes had significantly changed at 40 h (Figure 2a). Among them, 949 DEGs were up-regulated and 316 DEGs were down-regulated. As we can be seen from Figure 2b, 7500 genes were detected. Among them, 2196 genes had significantly changed at 80 h, in which 1940 DEGs were up-regulated and 256 DEGs were down-regulated (Table S2). The results illustrated that the fungal elicitor had significant effects on the transcriptional level of S.natalensis HW-2 at 40 h and 80 h. The transcriptome data showed greater change at the second time point than that at the first time point. Some of up-regulated and down-regulated DEGs were shown in Table 1. It can be seen that the transcriptional levels of family transcription factors, such as MarR, TetR, LyseE, GntR, MerR and LacI, were greatly up-regulated. The transcriptional levels of the some enzymes related to the degradation of short-chain fats, including acetyltransferase and CoA transferase, were significantly increased..
Gene ontology (GO) annotation and enrichment analysis
GO is an international standardized gene functional classification system. In this study, Go was used to comprehensively describe the properties of genes in the transcriptome library of S. natalensis HW-2. According to the results of sequence alignments (Figure 3a), there were 1265 DEGs at 40 h and they were classified into 46 functional groups which belonged to three main categories: biological processes (53.02%), cellular components (22.90%) and molecular functions (24.08%). In the biological processes category, many DEGs were involved in biological regulation, metabolic processes, cellular process, single-organism process and responses to stimuli. In the cellular component category, most of DEGs were localized to cell part, cell and membrane. In the molecular function category, a large number of DEGs were involved in catalytic activity, transporter activity and binding.
Figure 3b showed that there were 2196 DEGs and they were classified into 33 functional groups at 80 h which belonged to three main categories: biological processes (47.91%), cellular components (32.55%) and molecular functions (19.54%). In the category of biological processes, many DEGs were involved in biological regulation, responses to stimuli, metabolic processes, single-organism process and localization. In the cellular component category, most of DEGs were localized to membrane part and membrane, followed by cell and cell part. In the molecular function category, a lot of DEGs were involved in binding, catalytic activity and nucleic acid binding transcription factor activity. In total, the results indicated that most of the identified DEGs were responsible to fundamental processes which were associated with biological regulation and metabolism.
GO enrichment analysis of DEGs showed significant enrichment in biological processes. The results showed that 12 biological processes were significantly enriched at 80 h. Among them, organic cyclic compound biosynthetic process, aromatic compound biosynthetic process and heterocyclic biosynthetic process showed enrichment (Table S3). These processes had important relationship with the biosynthesis of some secondary metabolites.
Kyoto encyclopedia of genes and genomes (KEGG) pathway mapping and enrichment analysis
To understand the interaction of genes and metabolic biological functions, different unigenes which had significant match in KEGG database using BLASTx were assigned to some different pathways. KEGG analysis showed that the fungal elicitor affected the expression level of some genes about cellular process, metabolism and genetic information, especially EMP, TCA and amino acid metabolism. The results showed that 988 unigenes could be assigned to 123 pathways at 40 h, and they were grouped into four groups which were cellular process, environmental information process, metabolism and genetic information process, respectively. In metabolism pathway, 887 unigenes were divided into 12 sub-categories, in which most of the representation unigenes were global and overview maps (447), carbohydrate metabolism (112) and amino acid metabolism (100), respectively. The DEGs of the biosynthesis pathway of siderophore group nonribosomal peptides were significantly enriched.
At 80 h, 891 unigenes could be assigned to 113 pathways which were divided into four groups. The metabolism group showed more significant by treated with the elicitor, followed by genetic information process and environmental information process. In metabolism pathway, 769 unigenes were divided into 12 sub-categories which included amino acid metabolism (155), global and overview (149) and carbohydrate metabolism (141).
The change of transcriptional levels of glycolytic pathway (EMP) and Pentose Phosphate Pathway (PPP) related genes
EMP and PPP are important to the biosynthesis of natamycin by providing the carbon flux. Transcriptome analysis showed that the transcriptional levels of some genes related to PPP and EMP were enhanced at the both points, especially in 80 h (Table 2). At 40 h, the transcription levels of SNA_RS15280, SNA_RS33595, SNA_RS17980 and SNA_RS18050 in EMP were significantly enhanced, but the expression levels of SNA_RS05450, SNA_RS32155, SNA_RS02615 and SNA_RS02620 decreased. SNA_RS33595 which codes fructose-bisphosphate aldolase was the important gene. The enzyme can influence the utilization of glucose in EMP. Its value of log2FC increased by 33% compared with the control. In PPP, the levels of SNA_RS08865 (fructose 5-dehydrogenase) was enhanced, but SNA_RS02355 (6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase) and SNA_RS34475 (gluconate kinase) decreased. At 80 h, the levels of SNA_RS 09030, SNA_RS 16550, SNA_RS 05360, Pgk, SNA_RS 08155, SNA_RS 36040 and SNA_RS10315 were significantly enhanced. But, there were only two genes, SNA_RS 02685 (2-oxoisovalerate dehydrogenase) and SNA_RS 04695 (acetyl-CoA synthetase) decreased in EMP. In PPP, the levels of SNA_RS 33825, SNA_RS 27695, SNA_RS 10335, SNA_ RS16550, SNA_RS13075, SNA_RS 06470 were enhanced. There was no gene to decrease. The log2FC value of SNA_RS 27695 (2-dehydro-3-deoxy- phosphogluconate aldolase) and SNA_RS 10335 (6-phosphogluconolactonase), increased by 107% and 200% compared with the control. The results conformed that the fungal elicitor enhanced the carbon source utilization. The conclusion agreed with the result of our previous report.
Effects of fungal elicitor on transcription levels of tricarboxylic acid cycle (TCA) related genes
Fungal elicitor had less effect on TCA compared with that on EMP (Table S4). There were 7 DEGs at the both time. SNA_RS33855, SNA_RS06030, SNA_RS33475 and SNA_RS07675 were up-regulated at 40h. SNA_RS 34985 and SNA_RS 34190 were up-regulated, and SNA_RS 33480 was down-regulated at 80 h. The value of log2FC of SNA_RS33855 which encodes phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase (PEPC) was 1.79-fold increase compared with the control. The enzyme catalyzed the conversion of phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) into oxaloacetic acid (OOA) which was one precursor to macrocyclic antibiotics. OAA was an important enzyme to produce malonyl CoA and methylmalonyl CoA which were the precursors of natamycin. SNA_RS07675, encoding pyruvate dehydrogenase, was enhanced a little and the enzyme catalyzed the conversion of pyruvate into acetyl-CoA which was an important precursor to macrocyclic antibiotics. The expression levels of citrate synthase and fumarate reductase were also up-regulated. The results showed that the fungal elicitor improved the flux of TCA.
At 80 h, the transcriptional level of SNA_RS 34190, encoding NAD(P)H dehydrogenase, increased by 136%, but that of SNA_RS 33480, encoding succinate dehydrogenase, decreased by 143%. The two genes were related to the respiratory chain which attended the energy metabolism. Interestingly, the fungal elicitor could lead to the former increase, but the latter decrease. The change of energy levels is not studied in this work, and needs to further study. These results suggested that fungal elicitor influenced the providing of precursors and energy metabolism in S.natalasis HW-2.
Effects of fungal inducer on transcriptional levels of branched-chain amino acids (BCAAs) metabolism related genes
BCAAs, including Isoleucine (Val), Leucine (Leu) and Valine (Ile),are often used in the antibiotics fermentation to stimulate the antibiotics production. The degradation of BCAAs can provide many important precursors for polyketide biosynthesis, such as acetyl-CoA, propionyl-CoA and butyryl-CoA [25]. In this study, KEGG pathway showed that fungal elicitor significantly influence the transcription level of some genes related to the synthesis and metabolism of BCAAs. As we can see from Table 3, 10 DEGs associated with BCAAs biosynthesis were up-regulated and 13 DEGs associated with BCAAs degradation were down-regulated at the two time points.
At 40 h, l the transcriptional levels of SNA_RS29605 and SNA_RS29610, encoding 3-isopropylmalate dehydratase large subunit and small subunit, increased by 806% and 494%, respectively. The level of SNA_RS29600 which encoded pyruvate carboxyltransferase also increased by 948%. Inversely, acetolactate synthase gene, encoding BCAAs synthesis protein, was down-regulated. Among the genes of BCAAs degradation, 4 DEGs were up-regulated. Comparing with the control, the transcriptional levels of SNA_RS24915 (acyl-CoA dehydrogenase), SNA_RS05930 (methylcrotonoyl-CoA carboxylase), SNA_RS05920 (hydroxymethylglutaryl-CoA lyase), SNA_RS35365 (acetyl-CoA carboxylase) and SNA_RS32205 (methylmalonyl-CoA mutase) increased by 150%, 223%, 158%, 39% and 139%, respectively. These enzymes catalyzed BCAAs to convert into acetyl-CoA and methylmalonyl-CoA.
At 80 h, 3 DEGs associated with the biosynthesis of BCAAs were up-regulated. The transcriptional level of SNA_RS 31700 increased from 742 to 2072 (log2FC=1.41). The gene encoded acetolactate synthase large subunit and the enzyme is important in BCAAs to catalyze pyruvic acid to acetyl lactate. The transcriptional level of SNA_RS 31630, encoding branched chain amino acid aminotransferase (BCAT), increased from 141 to 348 (log2FC=1.23). The BCAT enzyme could catalyze the conversion of BCAAs and α-ketoglutarate into glutamate and branched chain α-keto acid.
To further assess the effect of BCAAs in the biosynthesis of natamycin, L-Ile, L-Leu and L-Val with different concentrations (0.2, 0.5 and 1 g/L) were added into the fermentation medium of S. natalensis HW-2 and natamycin production was measured at 120 h. As shown in Fig.4, the yield of natamycin was enhanced after supplementation with L-Val and L-Ile. As compared with the control, 0.2 g/L of L-Ile and 0.5 g/L of L-Val increased the yield of natamycin by 17.6% (1.4 g/L) and 37.8% (1.64 g/L), respectively. However, there is no obvious effect with the addition of L-Leu. These results showed that the concentration of BCAAs was an important factor to natamycin production in S. natalensis HW-2.
Effect of the fungal elicitor on the transcriptional levels of natamycin biosynthesis genes
The biosynthesis of natamycin in S. natalensis requires a complex type I modular polyketide synthase (PKS I) and additional modification enzymes. The gene cluster encodes 13 PKS modules within five multifunctional enzymes (PimS0, PimS1, PimS2, PimS3, PimS4), and 12 additional proteins that catalyze post-PKS modifications of the polyketide skeleton. PimR and pimM were two important transcriptional regulators in natmaycin biosynthesis [2,26]. In the study, the transcriptional levels of natamycin biosynthesis genes were checked at 40 h and 80 h. As shown in Table 4, 16 DEGs which belongs to the natamycin biosynthetic gene cluster showed differential transcription at the both times. The expression level of PKS I was enhanced and the values of log2FC were 0.86 and 1.56 at 40 h and 80 h, respectively. According to the results, 9 natamycin biosynthesis genes were up-regulated and 3 genes were down-regulated at 40 h. pimD and pimJ were significantly up-regulated. At 80 h, all of 12 genes changed. Among them, 9 genes were significantly up-regulated. The two transcriptional regulator, pimR and pimM, were up-regulated at the both time. The transcriptional levels of pimR were increased by about 1.5-fold at 40 h and 8-fold at 80 h. The transcriptional level of pimM increased by about 2.3-fold at 40 h and 4.7-fold at 80 h. The data demonstrated that the fungal elicitor had stronger effect on the transcriptional levels of natamycin biosynthesis genes at 80 h than that at 40 h. The results confirmed that the natamycin biosynthesis was at stationary phase and the expressions of the related genes were mainly at late exponential phase.
Validation of transcriptome data by quantitative RT-PCR
The dependence of transcription changes of selected genes on the fungal elicitor was validated by quantitative RT-PCR (qPCR; see Fig. 5). For qPCR, 14 functional genes were randomly selected, i.e. SNA_RS12245, SNA_RS18705, SNA_RS26515, SNA_RS26355, SNA_RS16550, SNA_RS11825, SNA_RS29280, SNA_RS09665, SNA_RS25540, SNA_RS05940, SNA_RS15480, SNA_RS05805, SNA_RS22675 and SNA_RS21375. These selected genes included the related genes of strain growth and biosynthesis of natamycin. The result was shown in Figure 4. There were some differences in the degree of gene change, but these gene expression trends agreed with the changes of transcript abundance by RNA-Seq. To sum up, the study indicated the accuracy and quality of DGEs sequencing, and it was a true reflection of the transcriptome level changes on S. natalensis HW-2 with the fungal elicitor.