NK expression by flask culture and fed-batch experiment
At least five different NK activity assay methods have been reported to date [6, 11, 12, 18, 19]. Among these, the fibrin plate method and chromogenic method are the most widely used, but the casein-degradation and JBSL (Japan Bio Science Laboratory Co., Ltd) methods may show much higher values of enzyme activity [11, 12, 14].
The NK activity obtained at 24 h in flask culture was 380.14 ± 5.71 U mL-1, while the OD600 reached 13.45 ± 0.45.
Many studies have demonstrated the significant contribution of media ingredients [20, 21] and nutrient feeding strategy to NK production [6, 15]. Berenjian confirmed that glycerol was a noteworthy carbon source influencing cell density during the fermentation of B. subtilis natto, and that the highest activity of NK was obtained by adding 3% glycerol as a carbon source [15]. It has also been reported that 2,6-pyridine dicarboxylic acid (PDCA) and metal ions such as Ca2+ and Mg2+ could improve osmotic pressure and help to maintain enzyme conformation, thereby improving the NK activity [17, 22]. Moreover, Wang demonstrated that glucose, K2HPO4·3H2O and MgSO4·7H2O played key roles in the production of NK, and they obtained an activity of 12.34 FU mL-1 [23]. Taken together, the results of these studies showed that NK activity could be improved dozens of times by media optimization.
In addition to media, feeding solutions are critical factors that influence NK activity, which should support cell growth and recombinant protein production while avoiding substrate inhibition and other related problems [12, 15].
Based on this information, we selected a mixture of glycerol, yeast extract, PDCA and a concentrated inorganic mixture solution as the fermentation broth, and a mixture of glycerol and yeast extract as the feed broth.
The strategy of induction, including cell density at the time of induction, inducer concentration, pre-induction growth and post-induction incubation time, can also affect the efficiency of protein expression. The aim of this study was to investigate the effects of using pH-stat and low-glycerol-level-maintaining strategies on NK expression by B. subtilis 168/pHT01-aprN1.
Three experiments were performed to examine the effects of induction time, feeding time and feeding rate on the NK activity of fermentation broth. The results are presented in Figure 1 and Table 1.
Two-stage fermentation strategy has been used for production of recombinant protein and other metabolites [24-27]. For FB A, we proposed a two-stage fermentation strategy and expected to get a high production. In the first stage (cell growth stage), we fed 600 mL of media into the fermenter with a high flow rate at the eighth hour. Because the nutrition was not sufficient for cell growth, the glycerol concentration decreasing rapidly to about 70 mmol L-1 at 12 h and the OD600 not varying markedly after 13 h. However, the NK activity still increased significantly until 18 h. The final NK activity was 2910.5 ± 21.6 U mL-1 and the specific activity was 30.32 U ml-1 OD600-1.
Although we achieved a 7.7-fold activity compare to flask culture, the cell density and the total activity were not as high as reported previously [6, 12]. It suggested that later induction and lower feeding rate maybe to the benefit of higher cell density and thus higher enzyme activity [28, 29]. According to this hypothesis, for FB B, the expression was induced at the fifth hour, which was 1 h later than FB A, and the induced OD600 was up to 27.3 ± 1.0, which was higher than that of FB A (17.6 ± 0.4). A three-stage feeding strategy was used, and the feeding of FB B started at 14 h, when the glycerol concentration was as low as 119.8 ± 1.3 mmol L-1, which might have favored cell growth by reducing substrate inhibition. The glycerol content was sufficient to support the cell growth for 24 h. Although the OD600 values from 15 h to 19 h were not varied significantly due to dilution and a new medium environment, it finally reached a high value of 208.8 ± 1.9 at 24 h, with a 11.9-fold activity of 4521.8 ± 23.8 U mL-1. However, the specific activity was 21.66 U ml-1 OD600-1 at 24 h, which was lower than that of FB A, and the NK activity did not synchronously increase following cell growth during the late fermentation stage, which implied that there should be a balance between the cell growth rate and enzyme expression.
The results of FB A and FB B suggested that maybe we should not unilaterally pursue high cell density, and instead the expression should be induced at an earlier time and kept a low glycerol content during the feeding period. Consequently, for FB C, continuous feeding was adapted, starting at 10 h when the OD600 had reached 105.3 ± 1.1 and almost two-thirds of the initial glycerol had been consumed. The glycerol concentration was controlled to around 50 mmol L-1 by adjusting the feeding rate.
As expected, an activity of 7778.0 ± 17.3 U mL-1 and a specific activity of 44.86 U ml-1 OD600-1 was achieved, and these values were 1.7-, 2.6-, and 26-fold higher than those of batch B, batch A and the flask culture, respectively. According to our knowledge, this was the highest ever reported activity value by the fibrin plate method [9, 10, 12, 15].
Recovery rate of NK by purification
The recovery rate of NK obtained by ammonium sulfate precipitation was 89.1% (Table 2), which was consistent with a study by Garg [16]. The high recovery rate and simple operation showed that this method could be used to purify NK on a large scale.
The purification was followed by Ni–NTA affinity chromatography, and the total recovery rate was 65.2% (Table 2). The high imidazole concentration in wash buffer B led to a high loss of NK when samples were purified using Ni–NTA affinity chromatography. Accordingly, the imidazole concentrations were adjusted to zero in wash buffer A and incubated supernatant, and to 10 mmol L-1 in wash buffer B; thus, a recovery rate of 88% was obtained in this step. Different imidazole concentrations in elution buffer C were also investigated, but there were no significant differences in the range of 100 mmol L-1 to 500 mmol L-1. According to the NK expression level and the recovery rate, the process developed here may be applied for large scale production of NK.
SDS-PAGE and Western blotting analysis of NK
SDS-PAGE analysis demonstrated that a 28 kDa protein was a crucial component in the supernatant from induced B. subtilis 168/pHT01-aprN1, but that it was not present in the supernatant from B. subtilis 168/pHT01 and non-induced B. subtilis 168/pHT01-aprN1 fermentation broth (Fig. 2 A/B), suggesting that recombinant NK could be expressed in a soluble form. Western blotting with a His-tag-specific monoclonal antibody also showed a specific signal at 28 kDa, whereas no cross-reaction occurred in the total soluble proteins from non-induced B. subtilis 168/pHT01-aprN1 broth, which confirmed that the 28 kDa protein was the recombinant NK, as expected (Fig. 2 C).
In view of these reports, NK was produced by fed-batch cultures of recombinant B. subtilis, and its production was improved to 7,778 U mL-1 from 380 U mL-1 of flask culture using pH-stat and low-glycerol-level strategies. Future studies will design a process and set a kinetic model for fermentation optimization.