In the present study, we investigated the prevalence of CMV UL97 gene mutations in Japanese patients with CMV reactivation in the colon for the first time. We revealed that several UL97 mutations were frequently detected, such as in codons Q126L (100%), T75A (93.3%), and D605E (80%). Q126L and T75A have not been reported previously. However, no known GCV resistance mutations were found in our series of GCV-naive patients, and, furthermore, there was no significant difference between the ratio of mutations in the UC and the non-UC patients. Our results suggest that it is not necessary to consider CMV drug resistance in the initial treatment of CMV colitis. The Q126L, T75A, and D605E mutations could be used as genetic markers for CMV in East Asian countries because UL97 mutations were suggested to have regional differences.
Human CMV remains the most common infection in solid organ recipients, HCT recipients, HIV-infected patients, and children with congenital immunodeficiencies. It remains an important pathogen despite advances in the prophylaxis and acute treatment of CMV. The emergence of CMV resistance in a patient reduces the clinical efficacy of antiviral therapy, complicates therapeutic and clinical management decisions, and, in some cases, results in death of the patient. According to recent reports, the incidence of GCV resistance is 5–12% among solid organ recipients [20–22] and 31% in intestinal and multivisceral organ transplant recipients [23]. GCV resistance is 7.9% in HCT recipients from matched related or unrelated donors [21, 24] and 14.5% in high-risk patients [25]. GCV resistance in HIV-infected patients is reported to be 19.5% [26].
Common mechanisms of CMV resistance to ganciclovir have been described chiefly with UL97 mutations. GCV is an acyclic nucleoside analog of 2of oguetions. GC. In a multistep process dependent on both viral and cellular enzymes, GCV is converted to ganciclovir triphosphate, the chemical form that is active against CMV. The initial phosphorylation is catalyzed by an unusual protein kinase homolog encoded by the CMV UL97 open reading frame. Resistance to GCV arises from mutations in the UL97 gene. In several reports, numerous GCV-related mutations have been described. Most UL97 mutations conferring GCV resistance are strongly clustered at codons 460, 520, or 590 to 607 [16, 27, 28]. In daily medical care, timely results of resistance testing would be useful for making clinical decisions. If no drug resistance is identified, clinical management may focus on improving host defenses rather than switching antivirals. If there is confirmed genotypic evidence of resistance, the specific mutation, host immune status, and disease severity should all factor into these decisions, to continue or intensify current treatment, to switch to a non-cross-resistant drug, to use drug combinations, or to try experimental drugs. Management algorithms have been proposed by several groups [29].
In this study, we did not detect the mutations of the UL97 gene associated with GCV resistance. Our results indicated that the uniform use of GCV is appropriate for initial antiviral therapy in CMV colitis associated with or without UC in GCV-naive patients, when antiviral therapy is needed, as there are no data regarding the prevalence of UL97 gene mutations in CMV colitis associated with or without UC. On the other hand, several mutations of the UL97 gene not associated with GCV resistance were detected, such as Q126L (100%), T75A (93.3%), and D605E (80%). The D605E variant of UL97 was first described in 1 of 8 CMV isolates from an immunocompromised host in France [30], but it has not been commonly observed in the human CMV strains circulating in western countries. Some reports have shown that the D605E mutation has frequently been detected in only Asian countries, and is estimated at 91.8% in Japanese infants and children and 78% in Chinese transplant recipients [10, 11]. Thus, they suggested that this mutation could be an important molecular marker of CMV evolution in East Asian countries. Q126L, T75A, and D605E mutations, which were detected in this study, could potentially be used as genetic markers for CMV in East Asian countries.
There are several limitations in this study. First, the present study included a small number of patients, all of whom were GCV-naive patients. Therefore, the results should be interpreted only in GCV-naive patients. It is speculated that a high rate of UL97 mutations may be identified in patients who have been treated with GCV for a longer period. Second, we used the Sanger sequence to detect the mutations in this study. This cannot detect mutants that are present in < 10–20% of the viral population. Recently, several studies have been reported which detected the mutation of the CMV gene using a next-generation sequence (NGS) [31, 32]. NGS methods have an improved ability to detect mixed populations and have been used to assess low-abundance variants. Third, we did not assess the mutation of DNA polymerase UL54 gene in this study, which is related to GCV resistance and cross-resistance to other antiviral drugs [33]. Therefore, further studies using NGS targeting both UL97 and UL54 in patients who have been treated with GCV are expected to provide more reliable evidence than this study.
Recognizing these limitations, the implications of our report are that no drug-resistant CMV strains were detected in the mucosa of the colon in patients with gastrointestinal CMV reactivation without a history of GCV administration, suggesting that it would not be necessary to consider CMV drug resistance at treatment initiation. In addition, these results were similarly observed when associated with UC and non-UC disease. Furthermore, the Q126L, T75A, and D605E mutations could potentially be used as genetic markers for CMV in East Asian countries. We look forward to further research in this area.