Sample characteristics
In our sample of 319 BED patients, 22% had either T2DM (n=25) or prediabetes (n=45). Of these, 8 did not meet further eligibility criteria, 10 declined, and 31 did not respond. Twenty-one participants were interviewed; of these, all were women. Participant characteristics are shown in Table 1.
Table 1. Participant characteristics (n=21 women)
|
Mean (range)
|
N (%)
|
Participant age, in years
|
|
|
Mean (range)
|
49 (19-66)
|
|
Participant race
|
|
|
White
|
|
19 (90)
|
Black or African American
|
|
1 (5)
|
Multiple race identities indicated
|
|
1 (5)
|
BMI
|
|
|
Mean (range)
|
43.8 (30.2-63.9)
|
|
30.0-39.9
|
|
7 (33)
|
40.0-49.9
|
|
10 (48)
|
50.0-59.9
|
|
3 (14)
|
60.0-69.9
|
|
1 (5)
|
Education history
|
|
|
Completed high school
|
|
1 (5)
|
Some college or technical school
|
|
6 (29)
|
College degree
|
|
11 (52)
|
Graduate degree
|
|
3 (14)
|
Employment status
|
|
|
Employed, full-time
|
|
10 (48)
|
Employed, part-time
|
|
5 (24)
|
Disabled, employed part-time
|
|
1 (5)
|
Disabled, not able to work
|
|
4 (19)
|
Student
|
|
3 (14)
|
Insurance plan (at time of interview)
|
|
|
Medicaid or Medicare
|
|
5 (24)
|
Group/private insurance through employer
|
|
13 (62)
|
Individual private insurance (self-purchased)
|
|
3 (14)
|
Treatment team composition (at time of interview)
|
|
|
Primary care (physician or nurse practitioner)
|
|
21 (100)
|
Therapist
|
|
11 (52)
|
Dietitian
|
|
4 (19)
|
Endocrinologist
|
|
7 (33)
|
Diabetes educator
|
|
1 (5)
|
Psychiatrist
|
|
8 (38)
|
Ten participants had T2DM diagnoses and 11 had prediabetes, as shown in Table 2. Almost three quarters of participants reported binge eating onset in childhood or adolescence. Persistence of binge behavior is noted with varying degrees of frequency in this population that received treatment for BED. EDE-Q data do not suggest high clinical concern of the eating disorder at the time of interview; on average, all mean scores were <4. However, some individual scores were elevated, and weight and shape concern subscales trended the highest.
Table 2. Participants’ diabetes and binge eating outcomes (n=21)
Characteristic
|
Mean (range)
|
N (%)
|
Diabetes diagnosis
|
|
|
Type 2 diabetes
|
|
10 (48)
|
Current hemoglobin A1c (%)
|
8.4 (6.4 – 14.0)
|
|
Diabetes duration (years)
|
12 (5 – 18)
|
|
Prediabetes
|
|
11 (52)
|
Years since prediabetes diagnosis
|
5.7 (1 – 19)
|
|
Number progressing to T2DM diagnosis
|
|
1 (9)
|
Age/Life stage of binge onset (self-reported)
|
|
|
Childhood
|
|
11 (52)
|
Adolescence
|
|
4 (19)
|
Young adulthood
|
|
4 (19)
|
Middle adulthood
|
|
2 (10)
|
Frequency of binge eating episodes
(at time of interview)
|
|
|
<1x/month
|
|
5 (24)
|
1-2x/month
|
|
2 (10)
|
1x/week
|
|
4 (19)
|
2-3x/week
|
|
3 (14)
|
4-6x/week
|
|
2 (10)
|
1x/day
|
|
3 (14)
|
>1x/day
|
|
2 (10)
|
EDE-Q scores*
|
|
|
Global Score
|
2.6 (0.6 – 5.3)
|
|
Restraint
|
1.5 (0 – 3.6)
|
|
Eating concern
|
2.5 (0 – 6)
|
|
Shape concern
|
3.1 (0.3 – 6)
|
|
Weight concern
|
3.5 (0.5 – 6)
|
|
*EDE-Q global and subscale scores range from 0-6; higher number indicates more problematic eating behaviors and attitudes; a cut-off of 4 on the global score generally represents clinical significance (24).
Qualitative Themes
We identified four central themes in our qualitative analysis: 1) Early Onset and Delay in Diagnosis of Binge Eating, 2) Dieting Drives Binge Patterns; 3) Bidirectional Impact of DM and BED; and 4) Need for Synergy in Treatment Recommendations.
Early Onset and Delay in Diagnosis of Binge Eating
Study participants almost universally reported that binge eating behaviors preceded the T2DM/prediabetes diagnosis, often by several decades. Many reported binge eating in childhood or adolescence:
I mean, I’ve binged since I was a kid. I’m not sure I had an official diagnosis that I was aware of, but I was aware that I binged.
– Participant #5, age 66, T2DM
Only two participants described BED developing later in life and cited mid-life changes and increased loneliness as factors in binge eating onset:
It wasn’t really until my 50s, when my kids were gone out of the house, and I was on my own, and I didn’t have anybody there. I had a very busy lifestyle raising three kids. And that, I think, kept me from bingeing and giving in to food because they always filled up my life.
– Participant #12, age 66, T2DM
Most participants also described delays in getting diagnosed with BED, spending much of those early decades without treatment. Many participants reported they were only diagnosed with BED when they chose to disclose behaviors to their medical team or therapists with the goal of seeking admission to a BED treatment program, which they’d often identified on their own from an internet search. In most cases, receiving the BED diagnosis was not as scary to participants as the diabetes diagnosis was; it was a source of relief and validation, opening up the possibility of treatment.
Dieting Drives Binge Patterns
Participants frequently mentioned longstanding efforts at dieting or limiting intake of food (particularly sources of sugar and other carbohydrates) in their weight-loss efforts. This occurred prior to and concurrent with diabetes diagnoses. Participants described oscillating between windows of controlling intake with windows of binge episodes. Some described feeling like their efforts at dieting or food restriction were related to increased binge eating. Participants also described early-life dieting as contributing to a sense of deprivation, followed by the guilt or shame associated with binge eating. These experiences contributed to repeating cycles of restrict-binge-restrict:
The weight definitely influenced the binge eating disorder because I would do everything, all my eating and all my exercise was to the goal of losing weight to look thin. … I would eat so many veggies and so many low-carb, low-fat, whatever… and later I would binge and feel bad about it, and those foods that I do like felt like demons.
– Participant #17, age 22, prediabetes
I thought about what led to my binge eating because that’s not a behavior I would ever have thought I would have. And I think, I really do think that the restriction is what made me start to binge.
– Participant #10, age 57, prediabetes
Weight loss was also a priority articulated in health-care discussions with providers and family members. Weight-loss surgery was recommended for most participants; for those who underwent surgeries in the years preceding their attendance in the eating disorder treatment program, loss-of-control eating continued post-surgery and weight was regained.
Bidirectional Impact of DM and BED
Binge eating behaviors were responsible for development of diabetes
Many participants felt that binge eating directly contributed to their diabetes and prediabetes; they endorsed feelings of guilt and shame around the diagnosis associated with fears that they “did this to themselves” because of disordered eating behaviors.
Heterogeneous impact of diabetes on binge eating
Participants with diabetes described the diagnosis experience as scary and prompted new realizations for the health implications of binge eating. Some described increased but ultimately unsustainable efforts to control binge episodes in the wake of the diabetes diagnosis:
The stakes were higher [with diabetes diagnosis], and when I failed it was more devastating. When I was first diagnosed [with diabetes] I was scared, and I would go through periods of being scared and controlling my eating really well and thereby controlling my blood sugars really well. And the problem was it didn’t last more than 2, 3, maybe 4 months. And then it regressed.
– Participant #13, age 59, T2DM
Others, however, experienced increases in binge episodes in response to the stress of the diagnosis. Participants with prediabetes expressed less concern about the way binge eating impacted their current glycemia or future T2DM risk.
Binge eating made diabetes outcomes worse
Participants described binge episodes negatively impacting diabetes management, causing chronically elevated blood glucose levels that were difficult to bring down to goal ranges. Most participants described how difficult it was to interrupt binge cycles or reduce binge behaviors on their own even though they valued improving diabetes outcomes:
It disables me. The binge eating is the crux of it all. Like, if I could just stop that, managing diabetes would not be a problem. But because I have such an unhealthy attachment to food, I can’t stop. You know, I can’t stop because I’m gonna die, because I’m gonna lose my feet, because I’m gonna lose my sight… it still isn’t enough, and that’s pretty pathetic.
– Participant #11, age 56, T2DM
It was very clear to me that those [BED] behaviors were making my diabetes and numbers worse. And it felt like this awful conundrum, that I need to treat the diabetes, but I can’t treat the diabetes until I deal with the eating, and the eating is making the diabetes worse. It felt like a diabolical combination. The two things were just intertwined and interlocked, and each was making the other worse.
– Participant #13, age 59, T2DM
Self-care and diabetes management decreased in response to binges
Most participants who self-monitored blood glucose described skipping glucose checks after bingeing as a means of avoiding information, or out of feelings of shame. They reported not wanting to have elevated numbers provide visible evidence of the binges to themselves or when showing their glucose logs to their diabetes treatment teams:
You don’t want to look at that [high glucose] number because you know it was your fault. You did it, and you could’ve avoided it… I would be afraid to look at the number because it would confirm that I’m a failure.
– Participant #18, age 63, T2DM
In terms of medication and insulin, participants endorsed adherence, reporting taking oral medications and insulin as prescribed. Notably, some described estimating an insulin dose that might cover the binge episode despite not knowing the carbohydrate content of the binge:
If I’m going to be on a binge, I’m going to be way above 350. So I feel like I’m pretty safe at a 20 [unit] dose. Which is not what my – my endocrinologist would just flip out if she heard me say that because that’s not at all a responsible, healthy way to maintain your diabetes. And I do realize that, but it’s better than doing nothing.
– Participant #11, age 56, T2DM
Binge eating treatment improved diabetes self-care
Many participants reported treatment increased awareness of how BED and diabetes were connected. They reported learning how meal timing, nutritional content of foods, and binge patterns impacted their blood glucose levels. Some reported seeing improvements in diabetes control, such as fewer glycemic excursions and more consistent T2DM self-care, as binge behaviors decreased:
Managing the binge eating disorder helped me manage the prediabetes, which had taken more of the backburner… I really have been making a lot of progress. I binge so much less than before. I restrict so much less than before.
– Participant #17, age 22, prediabetes
Need for Synergy in Treatment Recommendations
Participants described experiencing conflict when they attempted to integrate differing treatment recommendations, resulting in frustration and confusion:
I was always going back and forth with, you know, working on trying to heal the eating disorder but then also freaking out: ‘but I have diabetes, I need to get serious about this, I need to buckle down, like, I’m doing damage to myself.’
– Participant #1, age 40, T2DM
For example, some participants described a lack of cohesion when incorporating foods that were typically viewed as “off-limits” from the diabetes-management lens in the context of BED treatment. Specifically, the inclusion of carbohydrate-based foods into the meal plan designed to normalize eating patterns concerned some individuals and challenged treatment buy-in. Participants also experienced conflict when diabetes recommendations focused on caloric restriction for weight loss while BED treatment prioritized reducing or extinguishing bingeing, taking a weight-neutral approach. Some described these circumstances as stressful and contributed to a decreased sense of well-being, particularly regarding diabetes self-care and psychosocial stress.
In contrast, some participants described a process of treatment synergy occurring when providers explicitly accounted for both BED and diabetes diagnoses in treatment discussions and recommendations, resulting in self-reported improvement in glycemia. They described how first and foremost providers needed to be aware of both diagnoses and that when BED was kept secret and not openly disclosed, medical providers did not inquire about symptoms or incorporate BED into the treatment plan:
I think part of my denial before treatment was not getting the connection between my eating and my blood sugar levels.
– Participant #15, age 32, prediabetes
Similarly, participants noted how some BED providers had limited knowledge of diabetes care, compromising their ability to integrate diabetes-management goals.
Finally, participants stated that the integrated discussion of both diagnoses helped address the negative thoughts, self-judgment and self-blame that contributed to both binge eating and poor diabetes management:
I think they [BED and T2DM recommendations] were in sync about forgiving yourself, being kinder to yourself, giving you permission to fail and rebound… Because I do believe it’s the emotional beating yourself up that starts that vicious, vicious cycle of binge eating and feeling like a failure … I’m more consistent with [blood glucose] monitoring because, again, I try to tell myself it’s really just a number. It’s like a road map… rather than have it be a judgment. And it helps me to go in a different direction.
– Participant #18, age 63, T2DM