Up till now, the underlying mechanisms of subclinical hypogonadism is unclear, whether it is a precursor of hypognadism or marker of poor general health. We suggested that SCH is a distinct clinical entity that greatly differs from LOH in pathophysiology but both may be represent cardiovascular risk factors as both were associated with dyslipidemia, pro-inflammatory state, hemodynamic and morphological endothelial dysfunction and elevated ucOC levels. LH was independent predictor to hemodynamic change of peripheral muscular and central elastic arteries meanwhile LH and LH/T were independent predictors to CIMT. ucOC may be a link connects bone to inflammation, dyslipidemia , reproductive and endothelial functions among SCH . These issues were not mentioned before in literature.
We suggested that SCH is a diverse clinical state and not typical feature of hypogonadism. Main underling mechanisms are impaired both androgen sensitivity and aromatase activity with equivocal minimal contributing role of compensated impaired leydig cell function as evidence by high ASI , decreased E/T and mild elevated LH/T ratio with high normal testosterone respectively. Similar to Corona et al., 2014, we reported elevated LH with high- normal testosterone among SCH in range even that was insignificant higher than healthy eogondal subjects. In light of following knowledge and our results, we suggested SCH is not linked to leydig cell dysfunction but is attributed to hormone-resistant state: lack of feedback inhibition of androgen and estradiol on the pituitary that caused by insensitive pituitary androgen receptor and impaired aromatization respectively with reset new HPT set point to a higher level. Androgen receptor polymorphism alters LH/T ratio rather than being hall mark of primary leydig cell dysfunction. Both androgen receptor and aromatase genes mutation polymorphism are associated with impaired feedback inhibition with relative elevated testosterone and different individual HPT set point. In our study, SCH group had normal SHBG level and FSH level which is predominantly regulated by inhibins produced in testicular cells. This supported normal testicular function in SCH (2, 21, 22).
Corona et al 2014 suggested that SCH is not a novel clinical state but denotes the response of HPT axis to somatic illness with more psychiatric not sexual symptoms than overt hypogonadism. Recent follow- up study suggested that SCH is reversible process especially at young age and is not typical androgen deficiency but rather reflects worsening health with vicious circle exists as factors related to accelerated functional aging promote CVD (diabetes, chronic pain, physical inactivity) predispose to SCH occurrence which in turn, promotes further functional decline (decreased hemoglobin and impaired cognitive functions) along with CVD development (14). In contrary, other suggested it is precursor for overt hypogonadism with compensatory increased LH to stimulate the Leydig cell reserve to maintain normal T level similar to other subclinical endocrine disorders (6)
On the other hand, LOH was associated with marked impaired uncompensated leydig cell function (marked reduced TT and FAI and the highest ratio of LH/T); enhanced both androgen sensitivity and aromatase activity (low ASI and high E/T ratio respectively). It may be associated with impaired spermatogenesis with high FSH as well as high SHBG in our study. This was matched to previous described pathophysiology mechanisms of LOH (23, 24).
Undercarboxylated osteocalcin (ucOC) is an osteocalcin with deficient -carboxylation at one or more sites produced by osteoblast and represents the active metabolic form and majority of circulating OC. It stimulates both insulin secretion and sensitivity. Also, evidences in human and mice studies (murine model not in rate or mouse) suggested that ucOC may stimulate testosterone production by leydig cell in similar manner to LH hormone via binding to its receptor G-protein coupled receptor (GPRC6A) either in a bone -testicular axis independent on HPT axis or as enhancer to testosterone synthesis upon gonadotropin stimulation .Testosterone in turn stimulates osteoblasts proliferation and differentiation. So, testosterone and unOC are engaged in bidirectional relationship (10, 25).
We are pioneering in reporting elevated ucOC in primary LOH and SCH men, its positive correlation with LH, LH/T, estradiol and SHBG and negative relation with FAI. Accordance to previous reported elevated OC in male LH b-/- mice, idiopathic hypogonadotrophic hypogonadism men and among elderly men with testosterone (25-27), we hypothesized that elevated unOC may be a compensatory mechanism to androgen deficiency due to underlying impaired leydig cell function to increase T level or androgen insensitivity among LOH and SCH respectively . This suggestion may explain its positive correlation with impaired leydig cell function (LH/T) and LH level in our study. However, one study reported low OC in low testosterone males presenting to clinic for evaluation of hypogonadism and not mentioned as primary or secondary type (28)
Relation of ucOC with SHBG can be explained by similar molecular moieties between SHBG and ucOC and their competition to bind to common receptor GPRC6 with displacement of the SHBG by ucOC when co-incubated with high concentration (29). Inconsistent results exist regarding relation of testosterone (total and free) with OC or unOC in clinical and therapeutic male studies: positive correlation was observed mainly in secondary hypogonadism as among obese, type 2 diabetic, hyperthyroid or among men presenting to clinic for evaluation of hypogonadism while no association was detected among eugondal men or in young adults male from infertile couples (27,28,30-33). The different underlying pathophysiological mechanism and methodology might be accountable for such disparities. Our study was in line with Nah et al., 2017 as no and negative correlation with FAI were observed among subjects with normal (healthy and SCH groups) and low testosterone level (LOH group) respectively (data not shown). ucOC was correlated positively with SHBG not with testosterone and inversely with estradiol a large cohort of old men(34). On the other direction, increasing either endogenous testosterone or exogenous testosterone intake did not affect OC level in animal study while increased osteocalcin after testosterone replacement in hypo gonadal men in small, non- randomized nor placebo-controlled trial showed debates (28,35,36)
We recognized positive association of estradiol with ucOC. Neither estradiol production in leydig cell nor aromatase gene expression was affected by osteocalcin in experimental studies (26). However, decreased estradiol and increased testosterone following administration of aromatase inhibitors in elderly men were associated decreased OC in eugonadal but not in hypogonadal groups. Importantly, extra-glandular aromatization of circulating androgen precursors is the major source of estrogen in men. So, we supposed that elevated estradiol may regulate ucOC level (37-39).
Our study is the first to reported established markers of subclinical atherosclerotic among SCH with hemodynamic and morphological endothelial dysfunction using different standard measures: impaired FMD% of brachial artery, increased CIMT as well as AS. The use of these imaging to detect subclinical atherosclerosis has the potential to predict the risk of future cardiovascular events (40). Interestingly these findings of our results were supported by previous two studies. One study reported identical increased cardiovascular risk and a nearly 10-fold increased risk of cardiovascular mortality among SCH compared to overt hypogonadism while other reported exciting sharing common contributing factors and viscous circle(7,14).
Our study suggested greatly association of elevated LH, LH/T with atherosclerosis as LH was independent predictor to impaired endothelium function and morphology (FMD%, CIMT, AS) and LH/ T was predictor to increase CIMT.
In accordance to our findings, LH “with a normal T” was related to CIMT among andropausal middle-aged men; and increased ischemic heart disease events was reported among either elderly men with elevated LH or those with primary hypogonadism than secondary hypogonadism (9,41). LH /T were associated with CVD mortality among elderly men in a prospective study (42). Presence of extra-gonadal LH receptor expression in vascular and smooth muscle cell and in addition to association of increased its expression with endothelial proliferation may theoretically illuminate its suggested atherosclerotic role in our study. This was similar to atherosclerotic role of endothelial expressed TSH receptor in subclinical hypothyroidism (43-45).
Estradiol level and E/ T were negatively correlated to AS but not contributors to it. Estradiol enhances vasodilation in men via several mechanisms. Estradiol receptors and aromatase are expressed in endothelium and vascular smooth muscle cell. Although endogenous estradiol in men exerts anti-atherosclerotic effect via limiting their proliferation and migration, estradiol exposure increased atherosclerosis in coronary arteries harvested from men,. Aromatase inhibition also decreases FMD% in men (46). Higher estradiol was associated with lower CIMT among diabetic men but other reported lack of association or positive association ( 47-49) This may be attributed to the fact that estradiol level in adult men do not exactly indicate tissue activity owing to extra-gonadal aromatization activity and partly estradiol elimination in situ .
In our study, FSH was significant correlated to CIMT but not contributor to it, FSH receptors are expresses endothelium with enhancement of through stimulating vascular endothelial growth factor expression (50). In prostate cancer, also administration of androgen deprivation therapy agonist which leads to elevated FSH level showed increased cardiovascular risk than androgen deprivation antagonist therapy (51).
Overall, the evidence is conflicting regarding effect ucOC on vascular function: both an anti-atherosclerotic effect with improved endothelial function and unrecognized impact on endothelial function and hemostasis were reported in vivo and vitro studies (12, 13). In our study, ucOC was positively correlated to CIMT and negatively correlate to FMD% in bivariate analysis but these findings were not confirmed in multivariate analysis. Also ucOC was positively correlated to hsCRP, cholesterol and DBP. In this context, ucOC positively associated with CIMT in offspring with positive family of metabolic syndrome but negatively among chronic kidney disease (52, 53). Meta-analysis of global human studies showed that no clear relation could be built between measured total OC or ucOC and extent of calcification or atherosclerosis as positive and negative relation , as well as no association were reported among these mostly cross-sectional observational studies that are limited in their clarification as a cause–effect relationship (11). One longitudinal study showed that baseline total OC was correlated positively baseline carotid plaque score but delta change of OC was negatively correlated with final score changes. They hypothesized that atherosclerotic plaques may initially enhance OC secretion as protective mechanism to suppress atherosclerosis or calcification progression (54). However, all studies measuring OC positive cells or histological staining of OC showed a positive relationship with calcification may be due to its role in calcification rather than atherosclerosis by mediating abnormal vascular repair via activation of osteogenic genes with further mineralization (11, 55).
Perspectives and significance
We concluded that SCH is distinct clinical entity and not androgen deficiency state: pituitary androgen insensitivity and impaired aromatase activity with equivocal minimal role of impaired leydig cell with normal SHBG and FSH while late onset hypogonadism is a state of impaired leydig cell and Sertoli cell , enhanced both aromatase and androgen sensitivity with increased SHBG. Similar to late onset hypogonadism, SCH is associated with impaired both haemdynamic and morphological endothelial function of peripheral and central elastic artery. Also both conditions are associated with elevated ucOC as compensatory mechanism to impaired leydig cell or androgen insensitivity respectively, atherogenic lipid profile and inflammation. ucOC correlated to reproductive hormone ,lipid, inflammation endothelial function and atherosclerosis
Luteinizing hormone is independent predictor for FMD% and aortic stiffness index while LH and LH/ T are independent predictor for CIMT.
Limitation of our studies: the present study is cross section study. So, causal relationship could not be established. We did not involve secondary hypogonadism in our study. Further studies to address relation of SCH with coronary artery disease, stroke, peripheral arterial disease are recommended