Design of Trojan bacteria system. The basic concept of Trojan bacteria is schematically shown in Fig. 1a. The nanoagents consist of three components: the core particle of SiNP, the bacteria-targeting ligand of GP and the photothermal agent of ICG. As schematically illustrated in the synthetic route of GP-ICG-SiNPs (Supplementary Fig. 1), the GP molecules are firstly conjugated to the SiNPs surface based on the Schiff base reaction between the aldehyde groups of GP and the amino SiNPs41. After that, the ICG molecules are loaded on GP-SiNPs through electrostatic adsorption. The constructed nanoagents can selectively enter intracellular volume of bacteria (e.g., VNP, EC) to form Trojan bacteria system through the bacteria-specific ABC transporter pathway42–46. Fig. 1b schematically illustrates the Trojan bacteria serving as a carrier to deliver therapeutics to cross the BBB to achieve light-triggered combination therapy of GBM. In a typical experiment, after intravenous injection of Trojan bacteria, they could take the internalized therapeutics together to cross the BBB, and eventually target and penetrate GBM tissues. Under 808-nm irradiation, the ICG molecules loaded on SiNPs could convert light energy into the sufficient heat to lysis host bacterial cells and destruct tumour cells. As a result, a pool of tumour-associated antigens and bacterial residues could together promote antitumor immune responses47–51. Typically, immature dendritic cells (iDCs) recognize tumour-associated antigens and bacterial residues through pattern recognition receptors and become mature DCs (mDCs). Meanwhile, mDCs migrate to lymphoid organs to express a large number of cytokines and stable major histocompatibility complex to activate T cells (TCLs). As a consequence, the TCLs express cytokines like TNF-α and IFN-γ, leading to a remarkable immune therapeutic outcome.
Characterization of Trojan bacteria system. A series of experiments were carried out to demonstrate the successful preparation of GP-ICG-SiNPs including transmission electron microscopy (TEM), dynamic light scattering (DLS), UV-vis absorbance (UV), photoluminescence (PL) and flow cytometry. As shown in the TEM image in Supplementary Fig. 2, GP-ICG-SiNPs appear as spherical particles with a narrow size distribution of ~4.1 nm, which is slightly larger than that of bare SiNPs (e.g., ~2.7 nm). The DLS spectra in Supplementary Fig. 3 reveal the hydrodynamic diameter of GP-ICG-SiNPs is ~6.5 nm, also larger than the hydrodynamic diameter of bare SiNPs (~3.6 nm). As shown in Supplementary Fig. 4a, three distinct peaks located at 320 nm (assigned to SiNPs), 731 nm, and 790 nm (assigned to ICG) exist in the absorption spectrum of GP-ICG-SiNPs, confirming the successful loading of ICG molecules. As further revealed in Supplementary Fig. 4b, upon the treatment of phenol-sulfuric acid, the absorption spectrum of GP-ICG-SiNPs displays a new peak at 490 nm since the linked GP is hydrolyzed into furfural derivative, followed by the formation of furfural resin with phenol52. The new appearing peak confirms the successful conjugation of GP molecules. The amounts of linked GP and loaded ICG onto SiNPs can be quantified based on the corresponding calibration absorption curves (Supplementary Fig. 5), respectively. Supplementary Figs. 6a and 6b give the PL spectra of GP-ICG-SiNPs under the excitation of 405 nm or 780 nm, respectively. Typically, the two characteristic emission peaks located at 485 nm and 810 nm are respectively corresponding to SiNPs and ICG. The photothermal curves in Supplementary Fig. 7 suggest that the temperature of GP-ICG-SiNPs solutions can be enhanced by 32°C during 300-sec 808-nm laser exposure when the loading concentration of ICG is or more than 150 µg/mL. These results together demonstrate the successful modification of ICG molecules with SiNPs.
To test the generality of the proposed Trojan bacteria strategy, two representative bacteria of VNP and EC were selected for the following experiments. The VNP or EC were incubated with the synthesized GP-ICG-SiNPs at 37 oC for 2 h, and then washed with phosphate buffered saline (PBS) buffer for several times. As revealed in the scanning electron microscope (SEM) images in Fig. 2a, the surface and the morphology of Trojan bacteria is similar to that of pristine bacteria. As further confirmed by elemental mapping in high-angle annular dark field-scanning transmission election microscope (HAADF-STEM) images (Fig. 2b), the silicon element exists only in Trojan EC or Trojan VNP rather than in pure EC or VNP. SEM and TEM images together prove that the prepared therapeutics indeed enter bacteria rather than nonspecifically absorb on the bacterial surface. Moreover, Trojan bacteria have the same growth curve compared with the untreated bacteria (Supplementary Fig. 8a), and their survival rate could maintain as high as 90% or more (Supplementary Fig. 8b), indicating the growth and activity of host bacteria would not be greatly influenced by the internalized therapeutics.
As shown in the confocal laser scanning microscope (CLSM) images in Fig. 2c, the green fluorescence from SiNPs (first column, λex = 405 nm, λem = 500-550 nm) and the red fluorescence from ICG (second row, λex = 633 nm, λem = 700-800 nm) could be simultaneously observed in the Trojan bacteria. On the contrary, no fluorescent signals are detected when EC or VNP are treated with ICG-SiNPs under the same conditions (Fig. 2d). Quantitatively, the uptake efficiency of nanoagents by EC or VNP cells was further determined by flow cytometry. As revealed in Fig. 2e, the uptake efficiency of GP-ICG-SiNPs by EC or VNP after 2 h of incubation is gradually rising when increasing the concentration of GP-ICG-SiNPs. Typically, when the GP-ICG-SiNPs is 10 mg/mL, the uptake efficiency is 56.8% for EC and 50.5% for VNP. If further enhancing the concentration to 15 mg/mL, the uptake efficiency does not improve significantly, e.g., 62.1% for EC and 55.7% for VNP. As such, 10 mg/mL GP-ICG-SiNPs is employed in the following experiments.
We further performed inhibition assay and competition assay to confirm whether GP-ICG-SiNPs entering bacteria was through the ABC transporter pathway. For the inhibition assay, no fluorescent signals are measured when EC or VNP are co-incubated with sodium azide (NaN3) and GP-ICG-SiNPs, in which NaN3 serves as the inhibitor of ABC transporter (Supplementary Fig. 9)53. For the competition assay, EC or VNP were first incubated with 0, 5 and 20 mg/mL of GP and then incubated with GP-ICG-SiNPs. As indicated in Supplementary Fig. 10, the fluorescence of bacteria becomes gradually weaken with the increase of GP concentrations. To testify the selectivity of GP-ICG-SiNPs for bacteria over mammalian cells, the mixture of human blood and bacteria were incubated with GP-ICG-SiNPs for 2 h. As shown in Fig. 2d and Supplementary Fig. 11, fluorescence signals are only observed in EC or VNP rather than in red blood cells (RBCs). These results together demonstrate that GP-ICG-SiNPs can be internalized into bacteria to form the Trojan system via the bacteria-specific ABC transporter pathway.
Trojan bacteria against tumour in vitro. We next studied the photothermal ability of Trojan bacteria. Under 808-nm laser irradiation, the constructed Trojan bacteria (Trojan EC or Trojan VNP) could heat up to 55℃ within 400 s, slightly lower than the temperature achieved by the equivalent free GP-ICG-SiNPs (Fig. 3a). Accordingly, the bacterial cell viability gradually decreases as the temperature increases from 48 to 55 oC (Fig. 3b). In particular, the bacterial cell viability is only 37% at 52 oC. Meanwhile, the overall morphology of the Trojan bacteria begins to rupture when the temperature rises to 48 oC, as shown in the SEM image in Fig. 3c. These results manifest that the constructed Trojan bacteria feature good photothermal activity.
Next, we investigated whether the photothermal effects produced by the Trojan bacteria could destroy glioblastoma G422 cells. In live-dead cell staining, the red fluorescence is only observed in most of Trojan bacteria-treated G422 cells (Fig. 3d). In MTT assay, under the irradiation of 808 nm for 5 min, the cell viability of G422 cells dramatically decreases to less than ~20% when they are incubated with Trojan bacteria or equivalent free GP-ICG-SiNPs for 6 h, much lower than the 100% of other control groups (p <0.001) (Fig. 3e).
In the constructed Trojan bacteria system, tumour-associated antigens and bacterial residues produced by PTT might trigger an effective immune response. To testify this hypothesis, we designed a transwell system to study this effect in vitro. As shown in the Fig. 3f, G422 cells with different treatments are placed in the upper chamber of the transwell system, and DCs are seeded in the lower chamber. After that, the maturation of DCs are evaluated by flow cytometry. The up-regulation of co-stimulatory factors CD80 and CD86 as the typical markers on the surface of DCs indicate the level of DCs maturation54,55. As revealed in Figs. 3g-3h, compared with the control groups, the level of DCs maturation can be significantly improved when G422 cells were treated with Trojan bacteria system under 808-nm irradiation (e.g., 60.6% DC maturation in Trojan EC group, 64.8% DC maturation in Trojan VNP group). These results indicate that the tumour-associated antigens and bacterial residues produced by PTT could trigger effective DC maturation.
In vivo behaviors of bacteria in mice. Before cancer treatment, we have systematically studied the behavior of bacteria in mice after tail vein injection. We first determined the safe dose of bacteria injected into the mice. The body weights were measured for healthy mice injected with EC or VNP at ~1×106, ~1×107 and ~1×108 CFU (Fig. 4a). Specially, at the high dose of ~1×108 CFU EC or VNP, the mouse body weights rapidly dropped, and one or two of five mice died respectively in the EC or VNP-treated groups, implying the severe toxicity of bacteria at such a high dose. Under lower doses, i.e., ~1×106 and ~1×107 CFU per mouse, the mouse body weights did not change significantly, and no mice died in the corresponding group. Therefore, EC or VNP at a moderate dose (~1×107 CFU per mouse) with a tolerable side effect were employed in the following experiments.
To reveal the in situ and real-time location of bacteria in vivo, we transformed the pRSETB-mCherry plasmids into EC ([email protected]) or VNP ([email protected]) to express red fluorescence protein of mCherry (Supplementary Fig. 12). Afterwards, the female health Balb/c mice were injected with these engineered VNP or EC through the tail vein at the dose of ~1×107 CFU per mouse. The mice were then sacrificed at 12, 24, 72, 120 and 360 hours after intravenous injection to obtain their main organs (e.g., brain, heart, liver, spleen, lung and kidney), followed by the detection of red fluorescence of mCherry by an in vivo optical imaging system (IVIS Lumina III). As shown in Figs. 4b-4d, the fluorescence signal mainly exists in the liver, and is gradually weakened over time, which is basically undetectable at 15 days. We then homogenized the extracted organs, serially diluted (10-fold), and plated them on solid LB agar plates. In consistent with the results of ex vivo images, bacteria mainly accumulated in the liver and were quickly cleared from all extracted organs. The total elimination was basically achieved at 15 days (Figs. 4e-4g).
To further ensure the safety of bacterial injection, routine blood tests including complete blood and serum biochemical analysis were performed on the tested dose, i.e., ~1x107 CFU per mouse (Figs. 4h-4q). Compared with untreated healthy mice, all serum biochemical parameters and most blood routine data were within the normal range at the first day of bacterial injection, except for a decrease in white blood cell (WBC) and platelet count. At the fifth day of bacterial injection, the WBC count and platelet count of the bacteria-treated mice returned to normal ranges, indicating that the acute inflammation caused by EC and VNP infection was mild and tolerated by the mice and did not develop chronic toxicity within 5 days.
Trojan bacteria crossing BBB, targeting and penetrating glioblastoma. Next, we performed a series of experiments to demonstrate the constructed Trojan bacteria could cross the BBB. We first built an in vitro human brain microvascular endothelial cell (HBMEC) model to investigate whether the Trojan bacteria could cross the BBB (Fig. 5a) 56,57. The construction of HBMEC model was evaluated by the measurement of transepithelial electrical resistance (TEER) (Supplementary Fig. 13a). Experimentally, Trojan bacteria were inoculated with HBMEC cells in the upper chamber (apical chamber) of transwell at a dose of ~8×104 CFU/well, followed by collecting 10 µL of culture medium from the lower chamber at 1h, 2h, 3h and 4h, respectively. The penetration rate of Trojan bacteria crossing the BBB was determined by counting the number of colonies on the LB solid medium the next day (Supplementary Fig. 13b). As revealed in Fig. 5b, the penetration rate of EC and VNP increases gradually with time, climbing to 49.7% and 60% at 4h, respectively. These results demonstrate the Trojan bacteria can cross the BBB in the in vitro model.
Afterwards, the female Balb/c mice with in situ GBM were injected with these [email protected] or [email protected] through the tail vein at the dose of ~1×107 CFU per mouse. As revealed in ex vivo images in Figs. 5c- 5e, the red fluorescence of bacteria could be found in GBM after 12 h of bacteria injection, gradually increasing following the time. By contrast, the fluorescence from bacteria in other organs like liver decreases exponentially following the time. Such difference might be resulted from the selective proliferation of bacteria in the hypoxic, immunosuppressive, and biochemically unique glioblastomas microenvironment33,58−60. And through the results of the plates, the amount of EC or VNP in brain counted in each plate was much higher than that in other organs. Specifically, the CFU of bacteria in brain reached its peak up to ~0.51×106 CFU/g for EC and ~0.74×106 CFU/g for VNP at the 120 h post-injection with bacteria (Figs. 5f- 5h).
With an aim to study the intratumoural transport of constructed system, we first constructed an ex vivo model of three dimensional cultured multicellular spheroids (MCSs), which were made of U87MG cells when the diameter of MCSs arrived at ~750 µm. PBS, GP-ICG-SiNPs (8 mg/kg ICG), [email protected] (~1.0x107 CFU) and Trojan bacteria (GP-ICG-SiNPs (8 mg/ml ICG) internalized into ~1.0x107 CFU [email protected]) were co-incubated with U87MG MCSs for 12h, respectively. Fluorescence signals at different depths of MCSs were collected by CLSM. The three-dimensional confocal images show that the MCSs treated by Trojan bacteria display distinct green (from SiNPs) and red (from [email protected]) fluorescence signals at both the edge and internal space, with a penetration depth of ~260 µm (Fig. 5i). In addition, the distribution of Trojan bacteria in MCSs is basically consistent with that of pure [email protected], but much deeper than that of free GP-ICG-SiNPs. These results indicate that the constructed Trojan bacteria could penetrate deep GBM tissues in vitro.
To verify the constructed Trojan bacteria could penetrate the deep GBM tissues in vivo, the female Balb/c mice with in situ GBM were intravenously injected with PBS, GP-ICG-SiNPs, EC, VNP, Trojan EC or Trojan VNP, respectively. Afterwards, the excision and section of deep GBM tissue was performed at 12 h post injection, followed by hypoxia inducible factor-α (HIF-α) analysis and the bacterial 16S RNA fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis. The expression level of HIF-α indicates the hypoxia situation in GBM tissues and the expression of 16S RNA indicates the location of injected bacteria in GBM tissues. As revealed in Fig. 5j, we can observe distinct green fluorescence signal of HIF-α in all groups, suggesting the high hypoxia level of deep GBM tissues. In addition, the distinct red fluorescence signals of 16S RNA are only found in EC, VNP, Trojan EC and Trojan VNP-treated groups, suggesting Trojan bacteria with hypoxia-targeting ability indeed penetrate GBM tissues in vivo.
Trojan bacteria-induced photothermal immunotherapy. Based on the proven ability of Trojan EC and Trojan VNP to cross the BBB, target and penetrate GBM, we next investigated the photothermal immune efficacy of Trojan bacteria in the treatment of orthotopic GBM-bearing mice. As schematically illustrated in Fig. 6a, the orthotopic tumour model was constructed by in situ inoculation of ~8×105 Luc-G422 cells per mouse at day -7. At day 0, the tumour-bearing mice were divided into six groups, including intravenous injection of (G1) PBS, (G2) ~1×107 CFU EC, (G3) ~1×107 CFU VNP, (G4) GP-ICG-SiNPs (8 mg/kg ICG), (G5) Trojan EC (e.g., GP-ICG-SiNPs (8 mg/kg ICG) internalized into ~1×107 CFU EC) and (G6) Trojan VNP (e.g., GP-ICG-SiNPs (8 mg/kg ICG) internalized into 1×107 CFU VNP).
The fluorescence signals of ICG can be employed for monitoring the dynamic distribution of GP-ICG-SiNPs as well as Trojan bacteria in the body. Supplementary Fig. 14 shows the fluorescence signals of ICG in the brain peaked at ~12-hour post-injection of Trojan bacteria. Therefore, at the 12-hour post-injection of Trojan bacteria, the brains of those mice were suffered by an 808 nm irradiation (1.2W/cm2, 5 min). As revealed in the photothermal images record by an IR camera (Fig. 6b), the rapid GBM temperature rising only occurs in Trojan EC or Trojan VNP-treated groups. In particular, the GBM-surface temperature can increase to 50.7 oC in Trojan EC group after 5-min irradiation, and 51.7 oC in Trojan VNP group after 5 min irradiation (Fig. 6c). By contrast, significant heating is not observed in other control groups under the same conditions. Next, at 5-day and 10-day post-injection, GP-ICG-SiNPs, Trojan EC, Trojan VNP at the same dose were intravenously injected into the mice again. Analogously, at 5-day and 12-hour post-injection or 10-day and 12-hour post-injection, the GBM sites of these mice were irradiated by 808 nm laser and the temperature of GBM sites was stabilized at 50oC for 5 min by adjusting the 808 nm laser power. Afterwards, bioluminescence imaging was applied to visualize the anti-tumor effect every four days. As displayed in Figs. 6d-6e, the bioluminescence signals of luc-G422 cells in Trojan EC or Trojan VNP groups are much weaker than that of the other treatment groups. The quantitative analysis shows that Trojan bacteria system has obvious inhibitory effect on tumour growth, and the corresponding inhibition rates are 66.25% of Trojan EC and 70.11% of Trojan VNP, respectively, which are much better than 16.14% of EC, 11.88% of VNP and 8.01% of GP-ICG-SiNPs (Fig. 6f). Also, survival analysis shows that survival time of mice has been significantly prolonged in Trojan bacteria group compared with other control groups (Fig. 6g). To further evaluate the antitumor effects of Trojan bacteria system, H&E staining of GBM tissues were performed. As shown in Fig. 6h, the most apparent tumour cell destruction, tissue necrosis and nuclear pyknosis are found in Trojan bacteria-treated group. Taken together, these therapeutic data demonstrated the adaptable anticancer ability of Trojan bacteria in vivo.
As previously reported, the lysates of tumour and bacterial cells can function as tumour vaccines and initiate tumour-specific immune responses33,61. Hence, the in vivo DCs maturation triggered by Trojan bacteria system was evaluated. On the third day of the last treatment, we harvested the carotid lymph nodes and homogenized them into single cell suspensions. After staining with fluorophore labeled anti-CD11c, anti-CD86 and anti-CD80 antibodies, the cell suspensions were collected for flow cytometry analysis. As shown in Figs. 6i and 6j, compared with control groups, the highest level of DC maturation was observed in the groups of Trojan bacteria+laser (e.g., 39.4% DC maturation for Trojan EC, 42.7% DC maturation for Trojan VNP), which could be attributed to the release of tumor-associated antigens and bacterial residues upon photothermal effect. On the other aspect, splenocytes from each group were co-stained with anti-CD3, anti-CD4 and anti-CD8a antibodies, and the percentage of CD3+ CD8a+ T cells was measured by flow cytometry. As shown in Supplementary Fig. 15 and Fig. 6k, no significant difference on CD8a+ T cell response was observed between GP-ICG-SiNPs group (21.2%) and PBS control (19.8%). On the contrary, the percentage of CD8a+ T cells in splenocytes after the combined photothermal ablation with Trojan EC treatment (30.6%) and Trojan VNP treatment (34.1%) were much higher than that of EC (27.3%) and VNP (26.3%) with laser irradiation. At the same time, we assessed the percentage of CD3+ CD8a+ T cells in the tumours by flow cytometry. As revealed in Supplementary Fig. 16 and Fig. 6l, no significant difference on CD8a+ T cell response was observed between GP-ICG-SiNPs group (8.31%) and PBS control (7.06%). On the contrary, the percentage of CD8a+ T cells in splenocytes after the combined photothermal ablation with Trojan EC treatment (19.1%) and Trojan VNP treatment (22.4%) were much higher than that of EC (10.8%) and VNP (11.4%) with laser irradiation. In addition, we also evaluated the cytokine levels of TNF-α and IFN-γ in serum samples of mice after various treatments. In the cytokine assay of serum samples, levels of both cytokines (IFN-γ and TNF-α) were higher in mice treated with Trojan bacteria than those in mice treated with pure bacteria and nanoagents (Figs. 6m and 6n). The increasing TNF-α and IFN-γ levels combined with the elevation of the percentage of CD8a+ T cells further confirm the boosted immunity in the mice injected with Trojan bacteria under laser irradiation.
The elimination of residual bacteria after photothermal immunotherapy. Next, we examined whether the photothermal immunotherapy induced by Trojan bacteria could facilitate the elimination of bacteria from the GBM-bearing mice. In detail, the GBM-bearing mice were intravenously injected with (G1) PBS, (G2) ~1×107 CFU [email protected], (G3) ~1×107 CFU [email protected], (G4) Trojan [email protected] (e.g., GP-ICG-SiNPs (8 mg/kg ICG) internalized into ~1×107 CFU [email protected]) or (G5) Trojan [email protected] (e.g., GP-ICG-SiNPs (8 mg/kg ICG) internalized into 1×107 CFU [email protected]), respectively. At the 12-hour post-injection, the brains of those mice were suffered by an 808 nm irradiation (1.2W/cm2, 5 min), followed by ex vivo imaging of the main organs at 5-day post-injection. As shown in Figs. 7a and 7b, relatively strong red fluorescence signals of mCherry could be detected in GBMs and livers in G2-G5 groups. Of note, the fluorescence intensity in the Trojan bacteria treatment groups (G4 and G5) is significantly lower than that in pure bacteria treatment groups (G2 and G3). These findings are further confirmed by major organs and GBM tissues harvesting, homogenization and then culturing the homogenates on plates (Figs. 7c and 7d). It is found that sporadic colonies grew from homogenates of GBM and livers in the Trojan bacteria treatment groups (G4 and G5), much less than those in pure bacteria treatment groups (G2 and G3). Accumulating evidence demonstrated only Trojan bacteria-treated mice under NIR irradiation could help to eliminate bacteria from the body.