4.2 Chemical characterization of MPs
FTIR spectroscopy is effective at discriminating paints based on different types of resin, but not discriminating resins prepared with similar constituents mixed in different proportions, which makes it difficult to identify many alkyd compounds by FTIR [35]. However, when complemented with Raman spectroscopy, it was possible to infer that sample P1 was an alkyd resin composed of phthalic acid modified with polystyrene (SI-1). The identification of styrene is supported by the presence of bands at 3059, 3026, 1952, 1458, 1375, 1153, 1020, 876, 700 and 538 cm−1 [36, 37]. Furthermore, the bands at 1271 cm−1 and 1724 cm−1 are characteristic of the ester group and the band at 729 cm−1 represents the aromatic ring of the phthalate group [37]. The two bands at 2920 and 2849 cm−1 are due to the stretching of -CH2 groups [36]. The bands at 1103 and 1020 cm−1 can also be attributed to the presence of silica, which is added as a chain extender in many resin compounds [38, 39]. The FTIR results are displayed in Table SI-2.
In agreement with the FTIR results, the Raman spectrum enabled the identification of the main bands of the ester group and polystyrene in addition to the characteristic bands of titanium dioxide (TiO2) in the composition of the alkyd resin (SI-1). TiO2 is added to various polymers as a filler, pigment and a UV blocker and was clearly identified in the Raman spectrum due to its three intense characteristic bands at 608, 443, 226 cm−1 [11, 40]. The bands attributed to alkyd resin are well established. Phthalate exhibits a low intensity band at 1032 cm−1, whereas styrene has an intense medium band at 1002 cm−1, ester groups exhibit a band at 1727 cm−1 and the phenyl group exhibits a band at 1613 cm−1 [35]. The bands of the fatty acids at 1300 and 1460 cm−1 and the resin groups between 3500 and 2800 cm−1 were masked by the high fluorescence of the inorganic material (TiO2), which overpowers the weaker bands of the alkyd resin [37]. The Raman spectrometric results are displayed in Table SI-2.
The DSC analysis revealed a pronounced glass transition temperature (Tg) at approximately 20°C, which is considered the Tg of a cured alkyd resin that contains ricinoleic acid in its composition [41]. This findinig is in agreement with the spectroscopic analyses. However, the degradation processes of cured materials are complex and their thermal stability also increases with the degree of branching of alkyd groups in addition to curing time, increasing the Tg [41]. The calorimetric curve (SI-1) shows an endothermic peak with a melting temperature (Tf) of 117°C, which is related to LDPE, but no relationship was found between alkyd resin and LDPE. Therefore, it could have been adhered to the resin particle. Alkyd resins are synthetic polyester polymers widely used in the manufacturing of organic paints, varnishes and lacquers [42, 43] as well as to protect metals from corrosion [44]. Alkyd resins have high strength, durability and compatibility, but dry relatively slowly compared to other synthetic resins and modifications are therefore performed with styrene to accelerate the drying process [45]. The addition of PS confers water repellency to the compound [46]. Thus, one may infer that one of the main source of these MPs in the study area is the protective coating found on watercraft, which is subject to wear and abrasion when in contact with water.
In the FTIR spectrum of samples P2 and P10, the main absorption bands (SI-3) and comparisons to the reference spectrum from Wiley's KnowItAll library as well as other studies enabled the identification of PE. These bands are 2920, 2851, 1468, 721 cm−1 [36, 47]. The characteristic band at 1374 cm−1 (more representative for sample P2 than P10) enabled differentiating low-density PE (LDPE) from high-density polyethylene (HDPE), as the band corresponds to the bending vibration of the methyl group, which is more abundant in highly branched LDPE [47]. Thus, the findings indicate that sample P2 sample is LDPE and sample P10 is HDPE. The bands at 3423, 1711 and 1643 cm−1 indicate hydroxyl (O-H), carbonyl (C=O) and C=C bonds, respectively, which may be related to material degradation processes [48]. The hydroxyl group can also appear due to the presence of moisture during the measurement. The carbonyl band may be related to the oxidation of MPs due to the high availability of oxygen to which the particles would be exposed as a result of weathering [49]. The bands at 1165 and 1032 cm−1 may be related to the degradation process [48] as well as the presence of silicon-based compounds, which are widely used as additives in the manufacturing of polymeric materials [38]. The spectrum of sample P10 (SI-3) also had a band at 860 cm−1, which was not observed in sample P2, suggesting a degradation process or a type of cross-linked PE [50]. Degradation processes cause changes in the “characteristic” band of LDPE at 1374 cm−1 and may also appear in HDPE, making it difficult to identify the types of PE. The FTIR results are displayed in Table SI-4. However, the calorimetric curve of sample P2 (SI-3) showed a predominance of HDPE, as an endothermic peak was observed with a Tf at 143°C (characteristic of HDPE), which may have been displaced from the mean value (approx. 130°C) [28]. This can occur due to degradation processes, which exert an influence on the length of PE chains and molecular weight distributions or can degrade amorphous phases, resulting in high crystallinities [51]. Furthermore, the Tf depends on the density of the material, as materials with greater density have a higher melting temperature [52]. In DSC analysis, HDPE can be differentiated from LDPE based on its higher melting temperatures resulting from its greater degree of branching [28].
The Raman analysis of sample P2 (SI-3) enabled the identification of copper phthalocyanine pigment (CuPc), also known as pigment blue 15 (PB15). CuPc is a polycyclic synthetic organic pigment widely used in coatings and paints and has three different polymorphic modifications: alpha (PB15:1), beta (PB15:3 and PB15:4) and epsilon (PB15:6) [53]. Due to the characteristics and intensities of the bands, the sample has high probability of being CuPc with a polymorphic beta modification (PB15:3). The spectral range from 100 to 1800 cm−1 is the most important for the identification of organic pigments [54, 55]. In the Raman spectrum of CuPc, the bands between 100 and 1000 cm−1 are due to macrocycle vibrations, the band at 953 cm−1 is attributed to the aromatic bending vibration of benzene, the band at 1107 cm−1 is due to the bending vibration in the isoindole group, bands at 1143 and 1341 cm−1 correspond to the pyrrole group and bands between 1350 and 1550 are characteristic of bonds between phthalocyanines and different metal ions (in this case, copper) [53]. It is important to point out that it was impossible to check bands between 200 and 500 cm−1 in the Raman spectrum due to the saturation of the detector (CCD) in this region. The Raman spectrometric findings are displayed in Table SI-4. The presence of pigments masks the identity of the polymer, making identification difficult and leading to mistaken conclusions. This is a common problem, especially with dark pigments, such as blue and black [56]. The peaks of the CuPc overlapped the main PE peaks, which is why PE was not identified by Raman spectrometry. It was possible to confirm that sample P2 had a combined spectrum of PE + CuPc [57]. Measures such as increasing the beam wavelength or making multiple measurements by changing the beam contact point with the sample can help solve the problem [56]. Raman spectroscopic analysis of sample P14 sample identified the blue fiber as PP (SI-5), which was compared to the database of Raman spectra of aged MPs [58] and spectra from other studies [40, 59]. However, the interval between 2000 and 1050 cm−1 had high fluorescence, which nearly masked the peaks in this region. Characteristic bands of PP found were at 809, 841, 973, 999, 1152, 1170, 1221, 1434 and 1458 cm−1 [60, 61] as well as the range between 2780 and 2980 cm−1 [11]. The bands at 809 and 841 cm−1 are specific to PP due to the helical chains [59]. The Raman spectroscopic findings are displayed Table SI-6. PE and PP are low-cost polymers with easy processing and high production [7]. PE is widely used in the production of food packaging, reusable bags, trays, containers and household items. PP is used in the production of food packaging, household appliances, rope, rigging, belts, automotive parts, etc. [3]. These plastics are quickly discarded, which leads to their greater presence in environmental samples.
The FTIR spectrum of the white fragments from sample P3 (SI-7) shows the main bands of PA6 (nylon) with EPDM rubber. The main bands attributed to the EPDM elastomer are 2918, 2849, 1462, 1379 and 714 cm−1 [62] and the main bands of nylon are at 1643, 1551 and 1267 cm−1 [47]. The bands at 1462 and 1379 cm−1, which were attributed to the EPDM elastomer, could also be attributed to nylon [47]. The bands at 1726 and 1043 cm−1 may be related to polymer oxidation, the intensity of which varies depending on the aging time. The band at 3431 cm−1 suggests the presence of moisture in the medium or oxidation of the polymer [63]. The FTIR findings are displayed in Table SI-8. The PA6 and EPDM blend is considered a TPE and exhibits simultaneous thermoplastic and elastomeric properties [64]. The addition of compatible elastomer copolymers to PA materials has recently been studied to give these materials elastomeric properties and improve their impact resistance and ductility [65]. For such, the most commonly used elastomer is an EPDM terpolymer [64]. PAs are one of the most common engineering thermoplastics and are used in automotive parts, fibers, textiles, films, coatings, industrial machinery and packaging. Other specialized uses include the manufacturing of propellers for marine vessels [64]. In the spectrum of sample P8, which was a PA-cellulose blend (SI-9), the bands at 3273, 2920, 2857, 1645, 1557, 1460, 1377 and 708 cm−1 were assigned to the PA [47]. Cellulose has numerous hydroxyl groups and repetitive cellobiose units, which comprise two glucopyranose rings linked by a glycosidic bond [66]. The bands that enabled the characterization of cellulose were at 3439 and 1315 cm−1, between 1157 and 901 cm−1 [66] as well as between 847 and 600 cm−1 [67]. The FTIR findings are displayed in Table SI-10.
The FTIR spectral analysis of sample P5 (HDPE-cellulose) (SI-11) was compared to the reference spectrum from Wiley's KnowItAll database. The main bands that indicate the presence of HDPE were those at 2920, 2853 and 1464 cm−1, the low intensity band at 1375 cm−1 of both HDPE and cellulose and a small band close to 710 cm−1, which was nearly masked by the cellulose bands in this region [68]. The main bands indicating cellulose were those at 3395, 1423, 1375 and 1327 cm−1, the most prominent bands between 1155 and 897 cm−1 [66] and those between 858 and 600 cm−1 [67]. The FTIR findings are displayed in Table SI-12. The thermal analysis showed a certain degree of agreement with the FTIR spectrum, revealing a mixture of polymers (in this case, HDPE and cellulose) (SI-11). The peak with a Tf at 133 ºC is characteristic of HDPE and an exothermic peak was found around 360 ºC due to the oxidative degradation of cellulose [67, 69]. It is possible that an endothermic peak (cellulose decomposition) was masked by the exothermic peak (oxidative degradation), with both events occurring simultaneously [67]. However, a Tg around 44 ºC and a Tf around 258 ºC were also observed, which are characteristic of a PA [28]. As some FTIR characteristic bands of HDPE are similar to some characteristic bands of PA, these could have been confused or the HDPE, PA and cellulose could have been mixed. Repeated analyses or a more specific analysis could help clarify this issue. Both the FTIR and DSC analyses of sample P5 (SI-11) suggest the presence of HDPE and cellulosic material, the latter of which is used as a reinforcing filler for plastic materials, forming a composite. As reported in previous studies, HDPE is among the most widely used thermoplastics as a matrix for composites reinforced with cellulose, which enables enhancing the mechanical properties [70]. Coupling agents, such as isocyanates and silanes, are normally used to obtain better adhesion of the matrix to the reinforcement material, which also helps improve the mechanical properties of the composite [70]. Plant fibers, such as cellulose, have the potential to reinforce polymeric materials due to their good mechanical and thermal properties, biodegradability and lower cost compared to other traditional reinforcement materials, such as fiberglass, talcum or mica [67, 70, 71].
The FTIR spectrum of sample P4 (SI-13) revealed characteristic bands of PU resin. However, as a commercial material with varied composition, PU-based resins include several systems with different properties, which increases the complexity of material identification. Indeed, the composition of PU comprises polyols, diisocyanate and chain extenders as possible chemical precursors [38]. Hexamethylene diisocyanate (HDI) is one of the most common monomeric aliphatic diisocyanates used in PU coatings and polyols contain ester, ether, amide and acrylic groups in their structure, which can also influence absorption bands in FTIR [38, 72]. Other compounds that can be added to PU resins include solvents (esters, ketones and ethers), chain extenders (barites, calcium carbonate, talc, mica and silica) as well as inorganic or organic pigments [38]. The bands at 2920 and 2853 cm−1 correspond to the presence of HDI. The band at 1730 cm−1 is due to ester and/or acrylic groups (most likely the acrylate group due to the presence of other characteristic bands) of the polyol used in resin manufacturing [38]. The band at 1639 cm−1 is attributed to the urethane group [38, 39] and the band at 1520 cm−1 may be related to a secondary amide of the urethane group. The band at 1458 cm−1 is attributed to the HDI monomer. The band at 1267 cm−1 is related to urethane and acrylate groups [38, 39]. The band at 1123 cm−1 is related to the acrylate group. The band at 1065 cm−1 is due to urea and acrylate groups [39], but may also be attributed to the presence of crystalline silica, with bands at 1032 and 787 cm−1. The band at 739 cm−1 may be related to the HDI isocyanurate skeleton [38]. The FTIR findings are displayed in Table SI-14. In the Raman spectrometric analysis of the same sample (SI-13), polymer masking also occurred due to the presence of the pigment, as occurred above with PE being masked by CuPc. The characteristics and band intensities in the region between 1000 and 1700 cm−1 indicate the acetoacetic arylide-type monoazo yellow pigment, which is commercially known as PY74 [54]. Defeyt et al. (2017) also mentioned the use of yellow monoazo pigments in PU-based paint formulations [38]. Peaks in the spectral region between 1000 and 200 cm−1 were due to fluorescence. Recently, several urethane-based coatings and high modulus polyurethane varnishes have been used in furniture and marine applications [64]. These coatings are suitable for outdoor and marine uses, such as wood finishes on boats due to their good weather resistance [42]. Therefore, PUs likely enter the marine environment in the same way as alkyd resins.
The main bands of samples P6, P7 and P11 characterized rubber compounds when the FTIR spectra (SI-15) were compared to rubber spectra from other studies [29, 73, 74]. The bands in the region between 1500 and 800 cm−1 are attributed to the elastomeric components SiO2 and carbon black, whereas bands in the region between 800 and 400 cm−1 correspond to sulfur bonds [75]. The following bands were observed: 2955, 2920, 2849, 1464 and 1375 cm−1. A band around 1548 cm−1 also appeared, which may be attributed to C=C stretching [73] or the C-S bond in vulcanized rubber [74]. The band at 1259 cm−1 has two possible attributions: the out-of-plane angular deformation of the -CH2 group [73] or C-O stretching due to the zinc stearate ester group formed during vulcanization [76]. The band at 1158 cm−1 corresponds to thioamide formed by the presence of the vulcanization accelerator tetramethylthiuram monosulfide (TMTM) [76]. The wide band at 1038 cm−1 is attributed to carbon black and the band at 721 cm−1 results from the out-of-plane deformation of -C=C-H [75]. The FTIR findings are displayed in Table SI-16. Regarding the Raman spectrum (SI-15), only two broad bands were identified at 1579 and 1336 cm−1 in samples P6 and P11, which are assumed to be due to C-C stretching of the carbon black in the rubber composition [40, 56]. The Raman spectrometric findings are displayed in Table SI-16. Carbon black is added to tire at a proportion of 22 to 40% as a reinforcing filler and to make the tire UV resistant [77]. In the present analyses, its high content masks the identity of the rubber polymer, which constitutes a problem in the identification of dark colored rubber particles [56] and hinders spectroscopic methods based on single particle analysis [77].
As the FTIR analysis suggested rubber compounds in sample P7 (SI-15), we can assign Tg at -50 ºC to these compounds and Tg at -18 and 8 ºC and Tf at 171 ºC to PP in the DSC analysis [42]. PP can have different Tg values depending on the polymer chain arrangement. Thus, Tg at -18 ºC may be related to syndiotactic PP and Tg at 8 ºC may be related to isotactic PP [42]. The combination of these analyses suggests that sample P7 is an EPM-type or EPDM-type thermoplastic rubber, which have PP in their composition and the Tg of this type of elastomer is in a range of -30 to -60 ºC, depending on the composition and percentage of PP in the material [78]. However, the presence of another rubber material cannot be not ruled out, since Tg at -18 ºC could also be attributed to polybutadiene, which is also used in the manufacturing of thermoplastic rubbers. Furthermore, Tg at -50 ºC could be due to styrene-butadiene rubber (SBR), which is compatible with other main elastomers and can be used in mixtures [79]. The composition of rubber is varied and these compounds have a wide Tg range. Typical tire rubber includes a mixture of natural (polyisoprene) and synthetic (SBR, polybutadiene) rubber, reinforcing filler compounds (carbon black, silica and chalk), softener (oil or resin), vulcanizing agents (sulfur and zinc oxide) and other additives [80, 81]. As thermoplastic rubbers (TPRs) are widely used in the manufacturing of tires, several studies suggest that the wear of automobile tires due to mechanical abrasion from contact with the road surface is an important source of MPs in the environment [77, 82]. Similar wear occurs with bicycle tires, conveyor belts, artificial grass, ground tires, rubber mats and automobile brake pads [77]. Small particles of worn tire are dispersed in the environment mainly by air, whereas larger particles are transported by rainwater runoff, sewage and/or surface water [77].
The FTIR spectrum of sample P9 (SI-17) revealed bands (although not intense) at 3057, 3024, 2920, 2849, 1944, 1871, 1800, 1741, 1597, 1549, 1463, 1373, 1313, 1155, 1032, 908, 752, 698 and 542 cm−1 characteristic of PS [36]. The FTIR findings are displayed in Table SI-18. The bands at 3424 and 1711 cm−1 correspond to hydroxyl and carbonyl, respectively, indicating the possible oxidation of weathered PS [49]. The Raman spectrum (SI-17) exhibited high agreement with the PS reference spectrum in previous studies [59, 83]. The spectral bands suitable for detecting PS are at 1584, 1602, 1002 and 1032 cm −1 [11]. The Raman spectrometric findings are displayed in Table SI-18. PS is an aromatic polymer made of a styrene monomer belonging to the thermoplastic family. Its main application is in packaging (more than half of the market). PS has low biodegradability and is not widely recycled, which increases its persistence in the environment [64].
For samples P12 and P13, the Raman spectrometric analyses (SI-19) determined that both were polyester fibers, specifically polyethylene terephthalate (PET), which was confirmed by comparing the sample spectrum with the PET spectrum of the Raman spectral database created by Dong et al. (2020) as well as spectra described in other studies [84]. The main bands that enabled the identification of PET were at 1725, 1613, 1291, 793 and 858 cm−1 [59, 85]. High fluorescence was found in the region from 1375 cm−1 to approximately 1500 cm−1 due to the presence of glass from the microscope slide used in the analysis, which nearly masked a small peak at 1415 cm−1. The Raman spectrometric findings are displayed in Table SI-20. PET is a thermoplastic traditionally used in the production of fibers for textile products and films for food packaging [64]. PET textile fibers are used for the manufacturing of various fabrics, such as clothes, carpets, airbags and bags. Indeed, the demand for polyester exceeded that of cotton in 2002 [86]. Household laundry is a potentially important source for the release of microfibers into aquatic environments [32, 87]. These fibers enter the marine environment mainly through domestic sewage contaminated with synthetic fibers from the washing of clothes as well as through effluents from wastewater treatment plants [88, 89], demonstrating the potentially important role that textiles, laundry and wastewater discharge play in the contamination of oceans by MPs [32].