Low temperatures promote Schizochytrium DHA accumulation
Fatty acid composition profiles of Schizochytrium when cultured under both cold and normal temperatures were analyzed. Samples used to analyze fatty acids were cultured and collected at an optical density 650 nm of around 0.7 at 28 °C or 16 °C, as indicated in Fig. 1a. Generally, Schizochytrium sp TIO01 had a similar total lipid content (16° C: 53.53% ± 2.18% (weight/cell dry weight); 28 °C: 51.05% ± 3.05% (weight/cell dry weight)) and lipid content profiles at these two temperatures. Pentadecanoic acid (C15:0), palmitic acid (C16:0), heptadecanoic acid (C17:0), docosapentaenoic acid (DPA, C22:5, ω-6), and DHA (C22:6, ω-3) were all detected under both conditions. Tetracosanoic acid (C24:0) was detected only when Schizochytrium was cultured at 28 °C. In low temperatures, Schizochytrium exhibited reduced saturated fatty acid biosynthesis and a preference for increased DHA synthesis. DHA constituted ~ 65% of the total fatty acid content at 16 °C compared to ~ 43% at 28 °C (Fig. 1b).
Schizochytrium genome assembly, assessment and annotation
To reveal the fatty acid biosynthesis pathways and further improve our understanding of the underlying mechanism by which low temperatures promote DHA accumulation in Schizochytrium, we performed de novo whole-genome assembly and annotation. Using 13.9 Gb of PacBio RS II subreads (217 × genomic data) and 31 Gb of Illumina PE250 clean data (480 × genomic data), a genome size of 64 Mb with a 45% GC base ratio, containing 34 scaffolds and 3 circular contigs (one of the circular contigs is mtDNA genome which was previously reported [24]) was obtained. The N50 scaffold and N50 contig were 5.83 Mb and 2.86 Mb, respectively. Table 1 shows the detailed information regarding the Schizochytrium assembled genome and the genome for the thraustochytriaceae species. To inspect the de novo assembly accuracy, multiple independent sources of reads were used to assess the assembled genome. Among the 62,457,386 paired Illumina PE250 reads (approximately 480 × coverage of the genome), over 99% could be aligned to the genome. The overall alignment rate of the transcriptomic reads from 14 independent culture conditions (approximately 900 × coverage of the genome) ranged from 95–97%, as shown in Table S1). These results suggested that the Schizochytrium assembled genome was of high-quality and nearly complete. We also evaluated the completeness of the genome assembly using BUSCO-v3.0 (database: eukaryota_odb9) [25]. The results showed that 90.4% of core genes were detected (C: 90.4% [S: 89.1%, D: 1.3%], F: 2.3%, M: 7.3%, 274/303). Based on the integration of RNA-seq data, protein alignment, and de novo predictions, 12,392 protein-coding genes were predicted, with an average transcript size of 1,876.3 bp and a mean of 1.7 exons per gene. In all, 6,796 out of the 12,392 predicted proteins (54.84%) could be classified into families according to their putative functions. The proportions for each database were as follows: KEGG (4,362, 35.20%), SwissProt (5,078, 40.98%), TrEMBL (6,336, 51.13%), Nr (6,063, 48.93%), GO (1,235, 9.97%), and InterPro (6,242, 50.37%).
Table 1
Genome comparison among Thraustochytriaceae species
General features | Schizochytrium TIO01 (This study) (GCA_004764695.1) | Schizochytrium M209059 [12] (GCA_000818945.1) | Aurantiochytrium acetophilum HS399 [26] (GCA_004332575.1) | Aurantiochytrium sp. KH105 [27] (GCA_003116975.1) | Aurantiochytrium sp. T66 [28] (GCA_001462505.1) | Aurantiochytrium FCC1311 [29] (GCA_002897355.1) | Thraustochytrium sp. ATCC 26185 [6] (GCA_002154235.1) |
Scaffold | N50 | 5,831,892 | 595,797 | 15,406 | 367,244 | 1,342,793 | 236,568 | 2,139 |
L50 | 4 | 23 | 1,036 | 68 | 3 | 47 | 2,470 |
N90 | 1,915,581 | 144,465 | 5,607 | 107,216 | 115,579 | 51,606 | 882 |
L90 | 12 | 79 | 1,770 | 215 | 42 | 177 | 7,665 |
Scaf Max length | 9,776,036 | 1,674,554 | 169,387 | 1,148,255 | 19,720,504 | 1,101,226 | 43,773 |
Num of scaffolds | 34 | 322 | 15,340 | 215 | 1,847 | 2,232 | 10,764 |
Contig | N50 | 2,864,487 | 52,007 | 13,661 | 196,455 | 12,952 | 22,474 | 2,139 |
L50 | 9 | 230 | 1,141 | 117 | 894 | 527 | 2,469 |
N90 | 1,558,441 | 14,718 | 1,699 | 57,189 | 3,515 | 5,763 | 882 |
L90 | 21 | 754 | 5,607 | 384 | 3,016 | 1,792 | 7,665 |
Ctg Max length | 4,854,459 | 236,430 | 169,387 | 729,578 | 98,696 | 129,397 | 10,764 |
Num of contigs | 67 | 1,608 | 15,923 | 848 | 6,833 | 4,504 | 10,768 |
Other | Plasmids | 2 | - | - | - | - | - | - |
Genes | 12,392 | - | - | - | - | 11,520 | - |
Average GC% | 44.95% | 56.6% | 45.19% | 57.17% | 62.83% | 57.13% | 64.04% |
Total BaseNum | 64,068,115 | 39,089,698 | 59,569,284 | 76,822,483 | 43,429,441 | 38,943,350 | 18,099,857 |
iTRAQ-based protein identification
To identify Schizochytrium proteins, six samples of Schizochytrium cells were grown at both normal temperatures as well as low temperatures and subjected to iTRAQ-based proteomic analysis. Tandem mass spectra were searched against the Schizochytrium protein database containing the genomics-predicted proteins and transcriptomics-predicted novel proteins. A total of 4,008 proteins were quantified (Detailed information regarding the iTRAQ identified proteins are shown in Table S2), of which 3,196 were annotated by the reference genome and 812 were predicted by transcriptomic analysis. Using KEGG pathway analysis, 2,939 proteins among the 4,008 were annotated in 45 pathways, these identified proteins are involved in global and overview maps, signal transduction, carbohydrate metabolism, lipid metabolism, amino acid metabolism, energy metabolism among others. The top20 KEGG pathways of iTRAQ identified proteins were shown in Figure 2a.
Fatty acid biosynthesis pathway
Based on genome annotations and protein identification, the fatty acid biosynthesis pathways of Schizochytrium, including the saturated fatty acids synthesis pathway and the PUFA synthesis pathway were reconstructed (Figure 3). Annotations regarding these proteins and their detailed LC-MS-MS information are listed in Table S3 & Table S2, respectively.
As shown in Figure 3, the FAS pathway and the polyketide synthase (PKS) pathways are separately responsible for saturated fatty acid and PUFA synthesis. There are two principal pathways involved in short saturated fatty acid (SSFA) synthesis in Schizochytrium. Similar to fungi which uses type I fatty acid synthase (FAS) to synthesize SSFA, Schizochytrium utilizes a single large multifunctional polypeptide to synthesize SSFA, which contains 4,230 amino acids and shares approximately 99% identity with the fatty acid synthase from Aurantiochytrium mangrovei (AKV56231.1).
Genes involved in type II fatty acid biosynthesis which utilize a set of discrete monofunctional enzymes are usually found in archaea and bacteria [30]. These genes were annotated, except for 3-hydroxyacyl-ACP dehydratase (FabZ). 3-Hydroxyacyl-ACP dehydratase catalyzes the third step of fatty acid biosynthesis, dehydrating 3-hydroxyacyl-ACP to form trans-2-enoyl-ACP. These results suggest that the type II fatty acid pathway in Schizochytrium sp TIO01 is incomplete and that type I FAS is responsible for the synthesis of C16:0 and odd-length short fatty acids (C15:0 and C17:0) [31]. In Schizochytrium, the long-chain fatty acid elongation process uses C16:0 as a substrate to synthesize long-chain saturated fatty acid (C24:0). This procedure consists of four sequential reactions—condensation, reduction, dehydration, and reduction. Genes participating in the elongation process were all annotated (Table S3).
The entire pathway of polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFAs) synthesis was conventionally thought to occur via two routes. The first is the fatty acid synthase (FAS) pathway which involves serial desaturation and elongation of saturated fatty acids (C16:0 or C18:0); the second is the polyketide synthase (PKS) pathway [6]. According to Schizochytrium genome annotation, we found that the desaturase involved in the FAS pathway for PUFA synthesis was completely absent (the intermediates of PUFA compounds involved in the FAS pathway for PUFA synthesis, such as C16:1, C18:1, C18:2, C18:3, and C20:3, were not detected by GC). This indicates that the FAS pathway for PUFA synthesis in Schizochytrium is incomplete and that the PKS pathway is responsible for PUFA synthesis. Similar to other Thraustochytriidae species [32], Schizochytrium contains three large multifunctional PKS pathway genes, namely, PfaA, PfaB and PfaC. These three genes were highly homologous (>99%) to proteins from another PUFA-producing species Aurantiochytrium sp. L-BL10.
Transcriptomic profiling under cold temperatures
To improve the understanding of the mechanism by which low temperatures promote DHA accumulation, transcriptomic analysis was performed on six samples at both normal and lowertemperatures as described previously. The obtained reads represented an average of 207.11 times the Schizochytrium genome length. Of these,11,215 expressed genes were detected, including 9,660 genome predicted genes and 1,555 novel predicted genes. A total of 1,546 genes among 11,215 expressed genes were significantly associated with the low-temperature response (|Fold change| >= 2 and adjusted p-value <= 0.001), including 1,237 downregulated genes and 309 upregulated genes. Using KEGG pathway analysis,846 of the 1,546 differentially expressed genes were annotated in 45 pathways. These differentially expressed genes were involved in amino acid metabolism, carbohydrate metabolism, lipid metabolism, global and overview maps, signal transduction, the endocrine system, and so on. The top20 KEGG pathways of differentially expressed genes were shown in Figure 2b.
Significantly differentially expressed genes involved in fatty acid synthesis
As shown in Figure 1b, Schizochytrium exhibited reduced saturated fatty acid biosynthesis and a preference for increased DHA synthesis when cultured under cold temperatures. Transcriptomic and q-PCR analysis indicated that genes involved in the FAS pathway responsible for saturated fatty acid synthesis (such as those encoding fatty acid synthase (FAS), long-chain fatty acid elongase (ELO), and very-long-chain 3-oxoacyl-CoA reductase (VLCR)) were significantly downregulated (Figure 4 & Figure 6a), which was consistent with the reduced saturated fatty acid (reduced C15:0, C17:0, C24:0 content). However, the production of C16:0 was not affected (Figure 1b). Further analysis showed that two genes involved in fatty acid metabolism in mitochondria were significantly regulated (Figure 4). One of these genes was encodes enoyl-CoA hydratase (ECHS), which catalyzes the third step of fatty acid synthesis, and was significantly upregulated. The other gene encodes acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (ACADM), which catalyzes the first step of fatty acid degradation, and was significantly downregulated. These findings suggest that fatty acid metabolism in mitochondria plays an important role in C16:0 synthesis and complements the biosynthesis of C16:0 at low temperatures. Although low temperature has a significant impact on the production of DHA, genes involved in the PKS pathway responsible for the biosynthesis of PUFAs were not significantly regulated according to the transcriptomic analysis (Figure 4) and q-PCR results (Figure 6a). This suggests that the increased DHA content was not a result of the expression of the PKS pathway genes.
Significantly differentially expressed genes associated with glycolysis, the pentose phosphate pathway and the TCA cycle
Glycolysis and the pentose phosphate pathway directly produce the substrates (acetyl-CoA and NADPH) for fatty acid synthesis. When Schizochytrium was cultured under cold conditions, genes involved in glycolysis such as those encoding glycolysis hexokinase (HK),6-phosphofructokinase (PFKA), and phosphoglycerate mutase (PGAM) were significantly downregulated (|Fold change| >=2 and adjusted p-value <0.001) (Figure 4 & Figure 6a), indicating that the glycolysis pathway was inhibited to some extent under cold stress. This result is consistent with the glucose consumption analysis (Figure 1a). Glucose-6-phosphate 1-dehydrogenase (PGD), which plays a critical role in microbial and algal lipid accumulation [31, 33], is involved in the pentose phosphate pathway and catalyzes the conversion of gluconate-6P to D-ribulose-5P to produce a large amount of NADPH. Our findings show that this enzyme was significantly upregulated (Figure 4 & Figure 6a). These indicatest that a relatively large amount of glucose is degraded via the pentose phosphate pathway in order to produce NADPH for fatty acid biosynthesis at low temperatures.
Most of the genes that participate in the TCA cycle were not significantly regulated at lower temperatures except succinyl-CoA synthetase (LSC). Downregulated succinyl-CoA synthetase reducs the production of the TCA intermediate compound succinate. To compensate, the levels of succinate and the downstream compound malate could be increased by upregulation of Tyr and Ile degradation pathways (Figure 5). Malic enzyme (ME) which is responsible for degrading malate and producing NADPH was downregulated in this study. This enzyme has been demonstrated to promote fatty acid production [34]. These results indicated that more of the malate could enter the TCA cylce to produce the acetyl-CoA precursor citrate (Figure 5). Although downregulated malic enzyme reduces the production of NADPH, recent studies have shown that the NADPH produced by malic enzyme enters exclusively into the FAS pathway for SFA biosynthesis and is not involved in the PKS pathway for PUFA biosynthesis [35, 36]. Downregulated ME coupled with decreased SFA content was also observed in this study.
Significantly differentially expressed genes involved in branched-chain amino acid metabolism
Amino acid degradation leads to the production of acetyl-CoA which is an important substrate for fatty acid synthesis. According to the results of the differentially expressed genes analysis, low temperatures induced significant regulation of 20 genes involved in branched-chain amino acids degradation (upregulation of 16 and downregulation of 4) (Figure 5 & Figure 6b). The four significantly downregulated genes included genes encoding hydroxymethylglutaryl-CoA synthase (HMGCS), acyl-CoA dehydrogenase (ACADM) and ketol-acid reductoisomerase (BCATC). HMGCS catalyzes the reverse reaction of Leu degradation, leading to the consumption of acetyl-CoA. ACADM participates in Ile degradation and fatty acid degradation in mitochondria. There are six copies of ACADM genes in Schizochytrium, two of which were significantly downregulated. It is uncertain whether these two downregulated ACADM genes play roles in Ile degradation or in the first reaction of fatty acid degradation in mitochondria (Figure 4). Generally, low temperatures enhanced the degradation of branched-chain amino acids leading to increased production of acetyl-CoA and intermediate products of the TCA cycle (fumarate and succinyl-CoA)(Figure 4 & Figure 5). Fumarate and succinyl-CoA could further be degraded via the the TCA cycle to produce acetyl-CoA precursor citrate.