Bone marrow fatty acid metabolism in patients with aplastic anaemia:
Changes in supernatant fatty acids in the bone marrow of patients with aplastic anaemia:
Orthogonal least squares discriminant analysis (OPLS-DA) were used to analyse the major fatty acids in the AA and NC groups (Tab 1,Fig 1). In the bone marrow supernatant, there was a significant difference in the short-chain fatty acid compositions, while there were no significant differences in the medium- and long-chain fatty acid compositions. There were significant differences in 3 of the 7 short-chain fatty acids tested. Among the 52 types of medium- and long-chain fatty acids detected, only one showed a significant difference. The major difference between patients with aplastic anaemia and normal controls was short-chain fatty acid metabolism.
Tab 1:OPLS-DA analysis
|
pre
|
R2X(cum)
|
R2Y(cum)
|
Q2(cum)
|
AABM vsNCBM(C6-C24FA)
|
2
|
0.543
|
0.614
|
0.272
|
AABM vs NCBM(C1-C6FA)
|
1+4+0
|
0.965
|
0.881
|
0.732
|
Compared to the NC group, the contents of docosatetraenoate (C22:4) (p < 0.05) were significantly decreased, and the contents of isovaleric acid (p < 0.001), isobutyric acid (p < 0.0001) and valeric acid (p < 0.005) were significantly increased (Tab 2, Fig 2).
Tab 2 .Changed fatty acids in the bone marrow
|
mean_AABM
|
sd_AABM
|
mean_NCBM
|
sd_NCBM
|
Fold Change_AABM/NCBM
|
log2(FC_AABM/NCBM)
|
p.value
|
C22:4
|
3.290286
|
0.954465
|
4.503714
|
1.01609
|
0.73057
|
-0.4529
|
0.011129
|
Isobutyric acid
|
0.03425
|
0.014858
|
0.0124
|
0.005125
|
2.7621
|
1.4658
|
9.79E-05
|
Isovaleric acid
|
0.030167
|
0.01777
|
0.0159
|
0.002726
|
1.8973
|
0.92393
|
0.000159
|
Valeric acid
|
0.025583
|
0.011033
|
0.0141
|
0.002767
|
1.8144
|
0.85951
|
0.002924
|
Acetic acid
|
2.572667
|
0.974088
|
1.5007
|
0.520259
|
1.7143
|
0.77763
|
0.005073
|
Changes in plasma fatty acids in patients with aplastic anaemia:
OPLS-DA were used to analyse the major fatty acids in the AA and NC groups (Tab 3 and Figs 3). In the peripheral plasma, there were significant differences in medium- and long-chain fatty acid compositions, while there were no significant differences in short-chain fatty acid copositions. Among the 52 types of medium- and long-chain fatty acids detected, there were significant differences in the contents of 16. Only one of the seven short-chain fatty acids evaluated showed a significant difference. The major difference between aplastic anaemia patients and normal controls is short-chain fatty acid metabolism.
Tab 3 the OPLS-DA analysis of fatty acids in plasma
|
pre
|
R2X(cum)
|
R2Y(cum)
|
Q2(cum)
|
AAPB vs NCPB(C6-C24FA)
|
3
|
0.74
|
0.837
|
0.535
|
AAPB vs NCPB(C1-C6FA)
|
1+2+0
|
0.935
|
0.357
|
0.276
|
Compared to the NC group, in the AA group, the contents of myristelaidate (C14:1T) (p < 0.001) and isobutyric acid (p < 0.05) were increased significantly. The medium and long-chain fatty acids with significant reductions were Caproate (C6:0)(P<0.01), palmitelaidate (C16:1T)(P<0.001), 10-heptadecenoate (C17:1)(P<0.01), 10-transsheptadecenoate (C17:1T)(P<0.05), stearate (C18:0)(P<0.01), petroselaidate (C18:1N12T)(P<0.01), transvaccenate ( C18:2N7T)(P<0.05), linoelaidate (C18:2N6T)(P<0.05), 7-transnonadecenoate (C19:1N12T)(P<0.001), eicosenoate (C20:1)(P<0.05), trans 11-eicosenoate (C20:1T)(P<0.01), erucate (C22:1N9)(P<0.05), brassidate (C22:1N9T)(P<0.05), docosadienoate (C22:2)(P<0.05), docosatetraenoate (C22:4)(P<0.05), and nervonoate(C24:1)(P<0.01)(Tab 4, Fig 4).
Tab 4 changed fatty acids(including long-chain fatty acids and short-chain fatty acids) in AA group in plasm.
|
mean_AAB
|
sd_AAB
|
mean_NCB
|
sd_NCB
|
Fold Change_AAB/NCB
|
log2(FC_AAB/NCB)
|
p.value
|
C14:1T
|
20.41007
|
6.087152
|
14.15148
|
2.00612
|
1.4423
|
0.52833
|
0.000869
|
C19:1N12T
|
4.507297
|
0.7233
|
6.090836
|
0.770336
|
0.74001
|
-0.43438
|
0.000869
|
C16:1T
|
2.730239
|
0.552947
|
3.7321
|
0.519632
|
0.73156
|
-0.45096
|
0.001736
|
C17:1
|
3.526343
|
0.774811
|
4.735835
|
1.068266
|
0.74461
|
-0.42545
|
0.006211
|
C24:1
|
3.344069
|
0.897316
|
4.843347
|
1.091746
|
0.69045
|
-0.5344
|
0.006211
|
C18:0
|
405.9224
|
57.07996
|
481.828
|
62.47371
|
0.84246
|
-0.24731
|
0.009199
|
C18:1N12T
|
1.851153
|
0.43985
|
2.313218
|
0.34065
|
0.80025
|
-0.32148
|
0.009199
|
C20:1T
|
3.401346
|
0.501943
|
4.125306
|
0.597002
|
0.82451
|
-0.2784
|
0.009199
|
C17:1T
|
4.212472
|
0.721826
|
5.238189
|
0.767364
|
0.80418
|
-0.3144
|
0.011129
|
C20:1
|
4.555985
|
0.75348
|
5.501479
|
0.752388
|
0.82814
|
-0.27206
|
0.011129
|
C6:0
|
0.441762
|
0.28031
|
0.615143
|
0.140688
|
0.71814
|
-0.47765
|
0.013306
|
C22:1N9T
|
3.958385
|
0.607051
|
4.667704
|
0.664834
|
0.84804
|
-0.2378
|
0.022914
|
C22:1N9
|
7.894534
|
1.210693
|
9.309187
|
1.325933
|
0.84804
|
-0.2378
|
0.022914
|
C22:2
|
0.969069
|
0.331208
|
1.325357
|
0.314959
|
0.73118
|
-0.45171
|
0.022914
|
C22:4
|
2.972657
|
1.104194
|
3.86212
|
1.149583
|
0.7697
|
-0.37764
|
0.022914
|
C18:2N6T
|
1.0497
|
0.258317
|
1.28606
|
0.226167
|
0.81621
|
-0.29298
|
0.02718
|
C18:1N7T
|
7.464862
|
1.388793
|
8.935318
|
1.527666
|
0.83543
|
-0.2594
|
0.037797
|
Isobutyric acid
|
0.039
|
0.053662
|
0.0136
|
0.01152
|
2.8676
|
1.5199
|
0.034652
|
Faecal microbe changes in patients with aplastic anaemia:
Metagenomic sequencing showed that the microbial abundance in the faecal microflora of the AA group was changed at six levels: phylum, class, order, family, genus and species.
Species abundance changes in the AA group
β diversity analysis showed no significant difference in microbial abundance between the AA and NC groups, but the tendency of grouping is obvious.(Fig 5).
Phylum level: According to the α diversity analysis, there was no difference in coverage, sobs, or the Chao, ACE or Simpson index between the AA and NC groups, but the difference in the Shannon index, which was a parameter of colony diversity, was significant (p = 0.010)(Fig 6). The analysis of group differences confirmed that the overall microbial abundances of bacteria and eukaryotes at the phylum level were decreased in the AA group. The microbial abundances of Candidatus_ Zambryskibacteria, Candidatus_ Falkowbacteria, Candidatus_ Yanofskybacteria and Nematoda were increased in the AA group (Tab 5, Fig 7).
Tab 5. .the specific changed ID in the phylum level
level
|
.ID
|
p.value
|
p.signif
|
method
|
mean(AA)
|
n(AA)
|
mean(NC)
|
n(NC)
|
B
|
p__
|
0.005645
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
5326.235
|
12
|
8399.529
|
10
|
B
|
p__Candidatus_Falkowbacteria
|
0.043118
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
8.560287
|
12
|
1.824681
|
10
|
B
|
p__Candidatus_Yanofskybacteria
|
0.035419
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.015688
|
12
|
9.207157
|
10
|
B
|
p__Candidatus_Zambryskibacteria
|
0.019208
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.418214
|
12
|
0.118341
|
10
|
E
|
p__
|
0.011153
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
7.880836
|
12
|
1275.989
|
10
|
E
|
p__Nematoda
|
0.04257
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
223.77
|
12
|
327.3807
|
10
|
Class level:In the AA group, there were no significant differences in α diversity (Fig 8). The results showed no significant changes in the sequencing depth, species quantity, distribution uniformity, colony abundance, diversity, or microbial diversity in the AA group. The differential analysis showed that the abundances of Sphingobacteriia (bacteria), Oomycetes and Enoplea (eukaryotes) were decreased in the AA group (Tab 6, Fig 9).
Tab 6.the specific changed ID in the class level
level
|
.ID
|
p.value
|
p.signif
|
method
|
mean(AA)
|
n(AA)
|
mean(NC)
|
n(NC)
|
B
|
c__Sphingobacteriia
|
0.029961
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
56.00991
|
12
|
140.242
|
10
|
E
|
c__Oomycetes
|
0.008957
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.659821
|
12
|
6.989042
|
10
|
E
|
c__Enoplea
|
0.04257
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
217.3663
|
12
|
326.564
|
10
|
Order level: The same α diversity analysis showed no significant difference between the two groups(Fig 10). Specific difference analysis revealed decreased abundances of the bacterial orders Burkholderiales, Enterobacterales and Sphingobacteriales and the eukaryotic orders Peronosporales and Trichinellida in the AA group (Tab 7, Fig 11).
Tab 7. the specific changed ID in the order level
level
|
.ID
|
p.value
|
p.signif
|
method
|
mean(AA)
|
n(AA)
|
mean(NC)
|
n(NC)
|
B
|
o__Burkholderiales
|
0.029961
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
798.2971
|
12
|
3142.975
|
10
|
B
|
o__Rhodobacterales
|
0.035828
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
23.62861
|
12
|
43.59014
|
10
|
B
|
o__Sphingobacteriales
|
0.029961
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
55.21925
|
12
|
140.2076
|
10
|
E
|
o__Peronosporales
|
0.008957
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.659336
|
12
|
6.850161
|
10
|
E
|
o__Trichinellida
|
0.04257
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
217.3663
|
12
|
326.564
|
10
|
Family level: At the family level, the α diversity analysis also showed no significant difference between the two (Fig 12). The microbial abundances of Peronosporaceae, the Trichuridae family, alcaligenaceae in the eukaryotic kingdom, Rhodobacteraceae, Ruminococcaceae, Sphingobacteriaceae and Yersiniaceae family in the bacterial kingdom were decreased in the AA group. The microbial abundance of the Enterocytozoonidae family of the eukaryotic kingdom was elevated in the AA group (Tab 8, Fig 13).
Tab 8. the specific changed ID in the family level
level
|
.ID
|
p.value
|
p.signif
|
method
|
mean(AA)
|
n(AA)
|
mean(NC)
|
n(NC)
|
B
|
f__Alcaligenaceae
|
0.0169
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
15.96707
|
12
|
22.477
|
10
|
B
|
f__Rhodobacteraceae
|
0.035828
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
23.18635
|
12
|
42.36301
|
10
|
B
|
f__Ruminococcaceae
|
0.02058
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
113635.9
|
12
|
47871.68
|
10
|
B
|
f__Sphingobacteriaceae
|
0.02058
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
53.83421
|
12
|
131.7942
|
10
|
B
|
f__Yersiniaceae
|
0.024916
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
120.5516
|
12
|
153.3019
|
10
|
E
|
f__Peronosporaceae
|
0.008957
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.659336
|
12
|
6.850161
|
10
|
E
|
f__Enterocytozoonidae
|
0.015062
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.964247
|
12
|
0.124079
|
10
|
E
|
f__Trichuridae
|
0.04257
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
217.3663
|
12
|
326.564
|
10
|
Genus level: There was no significant difference in α diversity at the genus level(Fig 14). In eukaryotes, however, the abundances of Arabidopsis, Cucurbita and Enterocytozoon, as well as Cruoricaptor, Absiella, Afifella, Desulfobacca, Desulfosarcina, Dokdonia, Drancourtella, Enhydrobacter, Helicobacter, Lentzea, Rhodoferax, Smithella, Subdoligranulum, and Thiomargarita in the bacterial kingdom, were increased in the AA group. The abundances of Lambdavirus, Rtpvirus, Achromobacter, Burkholderia, Mycoavidus, Thiomonas, Caecibacter, Catenibacterium, Chloroherpeton, Citrobacter, Desulfatirhabdium, Friedmanniella, Haematomicrobium, Megasphaera, Oceanicaulis, Petrimonas, Serratia, Sneathia, Treptobacillus, Succinispira, and Sulfuricurvum in the bacterial kingdom showed the opposite trend (Tab 9, Fig 15).
Tab 9. the specific changed ID in the genus level
level
|
.ID
|
p.value
|
p.signif
|
method
|
mean(AA)
|
n(AA)
|
mean(NC)
|
n(NC)
|
B
|
g__Achromobacter
|
0.007145
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
10.09373
|
12
|
12.26749
|
10
|
B
|
g__Burkholderia
|
0.003436
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
14.80387
|
12
|
31.55629
|
10
|
B
|
g__Cruoricaptor
|
0.008635
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
103.0674
|
12
|
0.00011
|
10
|
B
|
g__Mycoavidus
|
0.005645
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.850142
|
12
|
5.981828
|
10
|
B
|
g__Thiomonas
|
0.008957
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
8.839875
|
12
|
26.5866
|
10
|
B
|
g__Absiella
|
0.029961
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
205.4508
|
12
|
89.55985
|
10
|
B
|
g__Afifella
|
0.027812
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.100013
|
12
|
0
|
10
|
B
|
g__Caecibacter
|
0.015976
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.729265
|
12
|
15.54945
|
10
|
B
|
g__Catenibacterium
|
0.02058
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
305.7946
|
12
|
2616.767
|
10
|
B
|
g__Chloroherpeton
|
0.028942
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.004109
|
12
|
0.128666
|
10
|
B
|
g__Citrobacter
|
0.04257
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
736.4254
|
12
|
2760.517
|
10
|
B
|
g__Desulfatirhabdium
|
0.02215
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.157288
|
12
|
0.743299
|
10
|
B
|
g__Desulfobacca
|
0.013201
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.065557
|
12
|
0
|
10
|
B
|
g__Desulfosarcina
|
0.029085
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.209741
|
12
|
0.168518
|
10
|
B
|
g__Dokdonia
|
0.035916
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.552809
|
12
|
0.037748
|
10
|
B
|
g__Drancourtella
|
0.024916
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
499.5553
|
12
|
131.7744
|
10
|
B
|
g__Enhydrobacter
|
0.018256
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.629597
|
12
|
0.045162
|
10
|
B
|
g__Friedmanniella
|
0.035706
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.019968
|
12
|
0.512966
|
10
|
B
|
g__Haematomicrobium
|
0.018657
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.010867
|
12
|
0.541071
|
10
|
B
|
g__Helicobacter
|
0.04257
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
119.9702
|
12
|
50.31599
|
10
|
B
|
g__Lentzea
|
0.029085
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.151672
|
12
|
0.007282
|
10
|
B
|
g__Megasphaera
|
0.0169
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
120.5764
|
12
|
5919.09
|
10
|
B
|
g__Oceanicaulis
|
0.021299
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0
|
12
|
1.017431
|
10
|
B
|
g__Petrimonas
|
0.032066
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
1.570891
|
12
|
15.53802
|
10
|
B
|
g__Rhodoferax
|
0.042226
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.437173
|
12
|
0.068321
|
10
|
B
|
g__Serratia
|
0.0169
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
93.35629
|
12
|
116.9199
|
10
|
B
|
g__Smithella
|
0.035001
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
1.334781
|
12
|
0.008958
|
10
|
B
|
g__Sneathia
|
0.026317
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.0823
|
12
|
2.193245
|
10
|
B
|
g__Streptobacillus
|
0.035828
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
4.371066
|
12
|
9.960238
|
10
|
B
|
g__Subdoligranulum
|
0.035828
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
6958.998
|
12
|
2711.458
|
10
|
B
|
g__Succinispira
|
0.011106
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.329153
|
12
|
1.923889
|
10
|
B
|
g__Sulfuricurvum
|
0.024787
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.163208
|
12
|
0.507412
|
10
|
B
|
g__Thiomargarita
|
0.01856
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
5.323346
|
12
|
0.009884
|
10
|
B
|
s__Armatimonadetes_bacterium_CG_4_8_14_3_um_filter_66_20
|
0.027812
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.068908
|
12
|
0
|
10
|
E
|
g__Arabidopsis
|
0.034593
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.131755
|
12
|
0.006128
|
10
|
E
|
g__Cucurbita
|
0.027812
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.037481
|
12
|
0
|
10
|
E
|
g__Enterocytozoon
|
0.015062
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.964247
|
12
|
0.124079
|
10
|
E
|
g__Plasmopara
|
0.01377
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.629125
|
12
|
6.22372
|
10
|
E
|
g__Trichuris
|
0.04257
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
217.3663
|
12
|
326.564
|
10
|
V
|
g__Lambdavirus
|
0.006674
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.13463
|
12
|
2.01234
|
10
|
V
|
g__Rtpvirus
|
0.008557
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
0.001132
|
12
|
912.9737
|
10
|
Species level: Similarly, there were no significant differences observed in the α diversity analysis at the species level(Fig 16). However, in the AA group, the abundances of 84 species were increased, including 2 species in the viral kingdom (Staphylococcus_phage_phiSA_BS2, Streptococcus_phage_P0092), 2 species in the eukaryotic kingdom (Candida_maltosa, Enterocytozoon_bieneusi), 2 species in the archaea kingdom (Methanobacterium_congolense, Methanosarcina_spelaei) and 78 species in the bacterial kingdom (Proteus species, Clostridioides species, Ruminococcus species, etc.). A total of 125 microbial species were downregulated in the AA group, including 6 species in the viral kingdom(Stx1-converting_phage_phi-O153 , Enterococcus_phage_EFDG1 , Enterococcus_phage_EFLK1 , Escherichia_phage_vB_Ecos_CEB_EC3a, Escherichia_virus_186, Streptococcus_virus_ALQ132), 1 species in the eukaryotic kingdom (Plasmopara_halstedi),2 species in the archaea kingdom(Candidatus_Altiarchaeales_archaeon_WOR_SM1_79, Methanosphaera_sp._rholeuAM270 ) and 116 species in the bacterial kingdom(Prevotella_sp._CAG:386, Bifidobacterium_dentium, [Eubacterium]_eligens, Clostridium_sp._CAG:7, Catenibacterium_mitsuokai, etc(Tab 10,Fig 17).
Tab 10. the specific changed IDs in the species level(only shows the top 20 species ID)
.ID
|
p.value
|
p.signif
|
method
|
mean(AA)
|
n(AA)
|
mean(NC)
|
n(NC)
|
s__Subdoligranulum_sp._APC924/74
|
0.035828
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
4554.301
|
12
|
611.9317
|
10
|
s__Erysipelotrichaceae_bacterium_3_1_53
|
0.0169
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
3758.78
|
12
|
76.15913
|
10
|
s__Ruminococcus_sp.
|
0.04257
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
2141.948
|
12
|
97.13947
|
10
|
s__Bifidobacterium_dentium
|
0.04257
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
729.3444
|
12
|
6287.88
|
10
|
s__Catenibacterium_mitsuokai
|
0.0169
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
295.1914
|
12
|
1497.776
|
10
|
s__Ruminococcus_sp._DSM_100440
|
0.007145
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
281.9453
|
12
|
17.78605
|
10
|
s__Absiella_dolichum
|
0.029961
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
205.4508
|
12
|
89.55985
|
10
|
s__Drancourtella_massiliensis
|
0.029961
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
165.5897
|
12
|
11.95476
|
10
|
s__Clostridiales_bacterium_VE202-13
|
0.029961
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
160.2015
|
12
|
31.45474
|
10
|
s__Bifidobacterium_sp._MSTE12
|
0.02058
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
106.8885
|
12
|
881.9638
|
10
|
s__Cruoricaptor_ignavus
|
0.008635
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
103.0674
|
12
|
0.00011
|
10
|
s__Sulfurospirillum_halorespirans
|
0.015853
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
95.34377
|
12
|
0.006698
|
10
|
s__Clostridium_acetireducens
|
0.04257
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
86.51676
|
12
|
38.70515
|
10
|
s__Fusobacterium_sp._CM21
|
0.02058
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
68.64265
|
12
|
25.16005
|
10
|
s__Bifidobacterium_saeculare
|
0.02058
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
65.66262
|
12
|
16.88376
|
10
|
s__Curvibacter_putative_symbiont_of_Hydra_magnipapillata
|
0.035828
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
57.01436
|
12
|
9.584941
|
10
|
s__uncultured_actinobacterium_HF0500_35G12
|
0.003436
|
**
|
Wilcoxon
|
14.16386
|
12
|
2.742277
|
10
|
s__Citrobacter_werkmanii
|
0.024916
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
14.11588
|
12
|
118.4372
|
10
|
s__Enterococcus_saccharolyticus
|
0.037581
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
11.35573
|
12
|
0.137005
|
10
|
s__uncultured_alpha_proteobacterium_HF0070_14E07
|
0.029961
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
10.1125
|
12
|
20.48859
|
10
|
Changes in the KEGG signalling pathway in the AA group
Compared with the normal control group, there were significant differences in the abundances of genes involved in 12 signalling pathways in the AA group. Among them, the abundances of genes involved in 2 metabolism-related pathways were upregulated (penicillin and cephalosporin biosynthesis and tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis). In addition, the abundances of genes involved in eight metabolism-related pathways, including nonribosomal peptides, betalain biosynthesis, and lysine degradation, showed the opposite trend. We also observed the downregulation of genes involved in pathways related to type I diabetes mellitus in humans (Fig 18, Tab 11).
Tab 11.Changed abundance of specific KEGG pathway ID in AA group
.ID
|
p.value
|
p.format
|
p.signif
|
method
|
mean(AA)
|
n(AA)
|
mean(NC)
|
n(NC)
|
Betalain biosynthesis
|
0.035828
|
0.036
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
23.44387
|
12
|
30.77787
|
10
|
Biosynthesis of siderophore group nonribosomal peptides
|
0.024916
|
0.025
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
202.6813
|
12
|
394.1924
|
10
|
Caprolactam degradation
|
0.035828
|
0.036
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
61.81826
|
12
|
90.93364
|
10
|
Drug metabolism - cytochrome P450
|
0.04257
|
0.043
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
148.2111
|
12
|
213.5611
|
10
|
Lysine degradation
|
0.029961
|
0.030
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
701.4266
|
12
|
923.5934
|
10
|
Metabolism of xenobiotics by cytochrome P450
|
0.04257
|
0.043
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
148.3814
|
12
|
215.1718
|
10
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
0.035828
|
0.036
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
63.28539
|
12
|
95.42845
|
10
|
Penicillin and cephalosporin biosynthesis
|
0.0169
|
0.017
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
197.2371
|
12
|
136.6711
|
10
|
Phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis
|
0.04257
|
0.043
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
4709.729
|
12
|
4261.92
|
10
|
Type I diabetes mellitus
|
0.029961
|
0.030
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
371.8122
|
12
|
426.242
|
10
|
Ubiquinone and other terpenoid-quinone biosynthesis
|
0.035828
|
0.036
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
978.2562
|
12
|
1304.532
|
10
|
Valine, leucine and isoleucine degradation
|
0.011153
|
0.011
|
*
|
Wilcoxon
|
1148.773
|
12
|
1354.179
|
10
|
Changes in fatty acid levels in the AA group were associated with microbial species
Correlation between fatty acid content in the bone marrow supernatant and faecal microbial abundance
The abundance of the uncultured_ actinobacterium_ HF0500_ 35g12 species in the bacterial kingdom was positively correlated with the valeric acid content, which is negatively correlated with the microbial abundances of the Candidatus_ Zambryskibacteria phylum, the genus Cruoricaptor, the Cruoricaptor_ ignavus species, the genus drancourtella, the Bifidobacterium_ Saeculare species, the Drancourtella_ Massiliensis species, the Pseudomonas_ Syringae species, the Sulfurospirillum_ Halorespirans species and the Staphylococcus_phage_phiSA_BS2 species in the viral kingdom. There as a positive correlation between isobutyric acid and the microbial abundances of the Sphingobacteriia class, Sphingobacteriales order, Sphingobacteriaceae family, Afifella genus , and Enterococcus_sp._4E1_DIV0656 species. The abundance of microbes in the bacterial kingdom that showed a negative correlation with the isobutyrate content included those in the Absiella genus, Absiella_dolichum species, Cruoricaptor genus, Cruoricaptor_ignavus species , Mycoavidus genus , Mycoavidus_cysteinexigens species and 8 other microbial species. The abundance of Catenibacterium genus and Catenibacterium_mitsuokai speices in the bacterial kingdom was positively correlated with the content of Docosatetraenoate, which is negatively correlated with the microbial abundance of the Enhydrobacter genus, Enhydrobacter_aerosaccus species, Smithella genus, Bifidobacterium_sp._MSTE12 genus and 7 other species. The content of isovaleric acid showed a negative correlation with the abundances of the Drancourtella genus, Chloroflexi_bacterium_GWB2_49_20 species, Geobacillus_thermodenitrificans species, Kocuria_kristinae species, and Polaromonas_sp._JS666 species in the bacterial kingdom and the Methanobacterium_congolense species in archaea kingdom (Tab 12, Fig 19).
Tab 12.the specific correlation between the microbial abundance and fatty acids in the bone marrow supernatant in AA group(the species level showed in supplementary files)
nameA
|
nameB
|
correlation
|
P.value
|
method
|
star
|
group
|
B__c__Sphingobacteriia
|
Isobutyric.acid
|
0.677197
|
0.015554
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__f__Sphingobacteriaceae
|
Isobutyric.acid
|
0.722811
|
0.007911
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__g__Absiella
|
Isobutyric.acid
|
-0.61404
|
0.033666
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__g__Afifella
|
Isobutyric.acid
|
0.626033
|
0.029428
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__g__Cruoricaptor
|
Isobutyric.acid
|
-0.63042
|
0.027977
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__g__Mycoavidus
|
Isobutyric.acid
|
-0.62106
|
0.031136
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__o__Sphingobacteriales
|
Isobutyric.acid
|
0.722811
|
0.007911
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__g__Drancourtella
|
Isovaleric.acid
|
-0.61378
|
0.033762
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__g__Cruoricaptor
|
Valeric.acid
|
-0.65606
|
0.020517
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__g__Drancourtella
|
Valeric.acid
|
-0.68652
|
0.013674
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__p__Candidatus_Zambryskibacteria
|
Valeric.acid
|
-0.60596
|
0.036759
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__g__Catenibacterium
|
C22:4
|
0.643357
|
0.024003
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__g__Enhydrobacter
|
C22:4
|
-0.62678
|
0.029178
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__g__Smithella
|
C22:4
|
-0.60184
|
0.038407
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
Correlation between fatty acid content in the plasma and faecal microbial abundance
There were positive correlations between the abundances of the Citrobacter_rodentium species and Dysgonomonas_sp._BGC7 species in the bacterial kingdom and the content of stearate. The abundances of the Sphingobacteriia class, Sphingobacteriaceae order, Sphingobacteriales family, and Sphingobacterium_gobiense species were proportional to the contents of 10-heptadecenoate, petroselaidate, nervonoate and trans 11-eicosenoate. The abundances of the first three were also proportional to the contents of linoelaidate, and the latter was related to the contents of eicosenoate, rucate, brassidate and docosadienoate. There was a positive correlation between the abundances of the Catenibacterium genus, Catenibacterium_mitsuokai and Ralstonia_pickettii species and the content of docosatetraenoate. The abundance of Enterobacter_sp._50793107, Lactobacillus_equigenerosi, and Lactobacillus_pobuzihii species and the content of nervonoate showed the same correlation. The abundance of the Enterococcus_phage_EFDG1 species in the viral kingdom was also positively correlated with the contents of transvaccenate, linoelaidate, 7-transnonadecenoate and nervonoate.
In the AA group,there was a negative correlation between the abundance of microbes in the faeces and fatty acid content in the plasma, which showed a correlation between the abundances of the Desulfosarcina genus, Desulfosarcina_cetonica species, Succinispira genus, Succinispira_mobiliz species and 9 other species in the bacterial kingdom and the content of caproate. There was also a correlation between the content of docosadienoate and the abundances of the Enhydrobacter genus, Enhydrobacter_aerosaccus species, Mycoaviduss genus, Mycoavidus_cysteinexigens species and 5 other species in the bacterial kingdom. Therefore, there was a correlation between the content of isobutyric acid and the abundances of the Citrobacter genus, Citrobacter pasteurii species and Citrobacter sp. MGH106 species. The species abundances of Chloroflexi_ bacterium_ GWB2_ 49_ 20, Kocuria_ kristinae, and Lactobacillus_ Equigenerosi were negatively correlated with the content of petroselaidate, the latter two with the content of transvaccenate and the latter with the content of linoelaidate. The species abundances of Chloroflexi_bacterium_GWB2_49_20, Enterobacter_sp._50793107, Lactobacillus_equigenerosi, and Serratia_sp._TEL were negatively correlated with the contents of trans 11-eicosenoate, linoelaidate, brassidate, and erucate, the former 1 with the content of linoelaidate. There were also negative correlations between microbial abundance and the contents of various fatty acids, which showed a correlation between the abundance of the Lactobacillus_equigenerosi species and the contents of palmitelaidate, 10-heptadecenoate, 10-transsheptadecenoate, petroselaidate, transvaccenate, linoelaidate, 7-transnonadecenoate, eicosenoate, trans 11-eicosenoate, erucate, brassidate, docosadienoate, docosatetraenoate, nervonoate, and caproate. There was also a correlation between the abundances of the Cruoricaptor genus and Cruoricaptor_ignavus species and the contents of palmitelaidate, transsheptadecenoate, stearate, and caproate; a correlation between the abundance of the Lactobacillus_pobuzihii species the contents of 7-transnonadecenoate, nervonoate, and isobutyric acid; and a correlation between the abundance of Serratia_sp._TEL and the contents of 11-eicosenoate, trans 11-eicosenoate, erucate, brassidate, docosadienoate, and isobutyric acid. A negative correlation was also found between the species abundance of Enterobacter_sp._50793107 and the contents of trans 11-eicosenoate, erucate, brassidate, nervonoate and isobutyric acid. There was a negative correlation between the genus abundance of Lentzea and the contents of linoelaidate, 7-transnonadecenoate, and 11-eicosenoate; a negative correlation between the species abundance of Chloroflexi_bacterium_GWB2_49_20C and the contents of petroselaidate, linoelaidate, and 11-eicosenoate; a negative correlation between the species abundance of Bifidobacterium_saeculare and the contents of docosatetraenoate and caproate; a negative correlation between the species abundance of Gulbenkiania_indica and the contents of caproate and isobutyric acid; a negative correlation between the species abundance of Kocuria_kristinae and the contents of petroselaidate and transvaccenate; and a negative correlation between the species abundance of Xenorhabdus_innexi and the contents of docosadienoate and isobutyric acid. There was also a negative correlation between microbial abundance in the eukaryotic kingdom and fatty acid content in the plasma, which showed a negative correlation between the genus abundance of Arabidopsis and the content of 11-eicosenoate; and negative correlations between the species abundance of Candida_maltosa and the content of stearate,the genus abundance of Cucurbita and the contents of 10-heptadecenoate, petroselaidate, transvaccenate, linoelaidate, docosatetraenoate and the species abundance of Cucurbita_moschata and the contents of 10-heptadecenoate, petroselaidate, transvaccenate, linoelaidate, and docosatetraenoate. The abundances of the Nematoda phylum, Enoplea class, Trichinellida order, Trichuridae family, and Trichuris genus were also negatively correlated with the contents of 11-eicosenoate and docosatetraenoate,and the first was correlated with the content of transsheptadecenoate (Tab 13,.Fig 20).
Tab 13. the specific correlation between the microbial abundance and fatty acids in the plasma in AA group(only the top and last 20 showed here)
nameA
|
nameB
|
correlation
|
P.value
|
method
|
star
|
group
|
B__s__Dialister_invisus_CAG:218
|
C14:1T
|
0.839161
|
0.000643
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__g__Catenibacterium
|
C22:4
|
0.797203
|
0.0019
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Catenibacterium_mitsuokai
|
C22:4
|
0.797203
|
0.0019
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Ralstonia_pickettii
|
C22:4
|
0.74081
|
0.005847
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Sphingobacterium_gobiense
|
C18:1N12T
|
0.739001
|
0.006033
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Lactobacillus_pobuzihii
|
C14:1T
|
0.734316
|
0.006538
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Citrobacter_rodentium
|
C18:0
|
0.734266
|
0.006543
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Sphingobacterium_gobiense
|
C20:1
|
0.727804
|
0.007291
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Cellulomonas_marina
|
C14:1T
|
0.681607
|
0.014642
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
V__s__Enterococcus_phage_EFDG1
|
C18:2N6T
|
0.679284
|
0.015117
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
V__s__Enterococcus_phage_EFDG1
|
C19:1N12T
|
0.668087
|
0.017569
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__s__Dysgonomonas_sp._BGC7
|
C18:0
|
0.664336
|
0.018453
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__s__Dialister_invisus
|
C14:1T
|
0.65035
|
0.022034
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__s__Sphingobacterium_gobiense
|
C17:1T
|
0.645693
|
0.023332
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__f__Sphingobacteriaceae
|
C17:1
|
0.636364
|
0.026097
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__o__Sphingobacteriales
|
C17:1
|
0.636364
|
0.026097
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
V__s__Enterococcus_phage_EFDG1
|
C18:1N7T
|
0.630764
|
0.027866
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__c__Sphingobacteriia
|
C17:1
|
0.629371
|
0.02832
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__f__Sphingobacteriaceae
|
C18:1N12T
|
0.629371
|
0.02832
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__f__Sphingobacteriaceae
|
C20:1T
|
0.629371
|
0.02832
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
E__f__Trichuridae
|
C22:4
|
-0.76224
|
0.00395
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
E__g__Trichuris
|
C22:4
|
-0.76224
|
0.00395
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
E__o__Trichinellida
|
C22:4
|
-0.76224
|
0.00395
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
E__g__Cucurbita
|
C22:4
|
-0.7642
|
0.003803
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
E__s__Cucurbita_moschata
|
C22:4
|
-0.7642
|
0.003803
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Serratia_sp._TEL
|
Isobutyric.acid
|
-0.77335
|
0.003173
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Paenibacillus_sp._Aloe-11
|
C6:0
|
-0.79499
|
0.010445
|
spearman
|
*
|
AA
|
B__s__Lactobacillus_equigenerosi
|
C17:1T
|
-0.79728
|
0.001897
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Enterococcus_durans
|
C6:0
|
-0.8
|
0.009628
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Enterobacter_ludwigii
|
Isobutyric.acid
|
-0.80911
|
0.001435
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Lactobacillus_equigenerosi
|
C18:2N6T
|
-0.83643
|
0.000696
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Lactobacillus_equigenerosi
|
C16:1T
|
-0.83999
|
0.000627
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Lactobacillus_equigenerosi
|
C18:1N12T
|
-0.83999
|
0.000627
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Lactobacillus_equigenerosi
|
C22:1N9
|
-0.83999
|
0.000627
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Lactobacillus_equigenerosi
|
C22:1N9T
|
-0.83999
|
0.000627
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Lactobacillus_equigenerosi
|
C22:2
|
-0.84355
|
0.000564
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Lactobacillus_equigenerosi
|
C24:1
|
-0.85423
|
0.000404
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Lactobacillus_equigenerosi
|
C20:1T
|
-0.85779
|
0.000359
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Myxococcus_stipitatus
|
C6:0
|
-0.87636
|
0.001935
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
B__s__Vibrio_quintilis
|
C6:0
|
-0.87636
|
0.001935
|
spearman
|
**
|
AA
|
Changes in fatty acid levels in the AA group were correlated with the KEGG signalling pathway
There was a positive correlation between isovaleric acid, which was elevated in the bone marrow supernatant of individuals in the AA group, and the abundance of genes involved in the type I diabetes mellitus pathway. The lysine degradation pathway was positively correlated with the content of isobutyric acid, which was upregulated in both the peripheral plasma and bone marrow supernatant from the AA group but negatively correlated with stearate, which was downregulated in the peripheral plasma. The downregulated levels of docosadioate, 11-eicosenoate, stearate and docosatetraenoate in the peripheral plasma in the AA group were negatively associated with phenylalanine, tyrosine, and tryptophan biosynthesis, N-glycan biosynthesis, and betaine biosynthesis, respectively. The same correlation was also found between the content of docosadienoate and N-glycan biosynthesis (Tab 14, Fig 21).
Tab 14.the correlation between the abundance of KEGG pathway and fatty acids in plasma and bone marrow supernatant in AA group.
nameA
|
nameB
|
correlation
|
P.value
|
method
|
star
|
group
|
Betalain biosynthesis
|
C18:0
|
0.58042
|
0.047856
|
spearman
|
*
|
AABM
|
Lysine degradation
|
C18:0
|
0.608392
|
0.035806
|
spearman
|
*
|
AABM
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
C20:1
|
0.643357
|
0.024003
|
spearman
|
*
|
AABM
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
C22:2
|
0.678322
|
0.015317
|
spearman
|
*
|
AABM
|
Phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis
|
C22:2
|
-0.58042
|
0.047856
|
spearman
|
*
|
AABM
|
Ubiquinone and other terpenoid-quinone biosynthesis
|
C22:4
|
0.622378
|
0.030676
|
spearman
|
*
|
AABM
|
Type I diabetes mellitus
|
Isovaleric.acid
|
0.61378
|
0.033762
|
spearman
|
*
|
AAPB
|
Lysine degradation
|
Isobutyric.acid
|
-0.57793
|
0.049049
|
spearman
|
*
|
AAPB
|
Correlations between microbial abundance alterations and KEGG signalling pathways in the AA group
The abundances of the Mycoavidus genus, Mycoavidus_cysteinexigens species, Achromobacter_sp._ATCC35328 species and Xenorhabdus_innexi species in the bacterial kingdom were negatively correlated with type I diabetes mellitus and positively correlated with the abundances of the Geobacillus_thermodenitrificans species and Kocuria_kristinae species in the bacterial kingdom and the abundance of the Methanobacterium_congolense species in the archaea kingdom. Ubiquinone and other terpenoid-quinone biosynthesis was positively correlated with the abundances of the Catenibacterium genus, Catenibacterium_mitsuokai and Ralstonia_pickettii species and negatively correlated with the abundances of the Desulfosarcina genus, Bifidobacterium_saeculare, Desulfosarcina_cetonica and Megasphaera_massiliensis species in the bacterial kingdom. The abundance of Planctomycetes_bacterium_TMED75 in the bacterial kingdom and Sphingobacterium_gobiense species was positively correlated with N-glycan biosynthesis, which was also negatively correlated with the abundances of Enhydrobacter, the Sulfuricurvum genus, Enhydrobacter_aerosaccus and 6 other species in the bacterial kingdom and the Nematoda phylum, Enoplea class, Trichinellida order, Trichurida family, Arabidopsis, and Trichuris genus in the eukaryotic kingdom. A positive correlation was also found between the abundances of Enhydrobacter and the Sulfuricurvum genera, Enhydrobacter aerosaccus, Enterobacter sp. CC120223-11 and 5 other species in the bacterial kingdom and the phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis signalling pathways, as well as the abundances of the Citrobacter genus, Citrobacter_pasteurii, Citrobacter_rodentium, Citrobacter_sp._MGH106 and 3 other species in the bacterial kingdom and the lysine degradation signalling pathway. The correlation between the abundances of the Cucurbita genus and Cucurbita moschata species in eukaryotes and the phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis signalling pathways was negative. A positive correlation was also found in the betalain biosynthesis signalling pathway and the abundances of the Citrobacter genus, Citrobacter_pasteurii, Citrobacter_rodentium, Citrobacter_sp._MGH106 and 4 other species (Tab 15,Fig 22).
Tab 15.the correlation between the microbial abundance and the KEGG pathway abundance.
nameA
|
nameB
|
correlation
|
P.value
|
method
|
star
|
level
|
B__g__Catenibacterium
|
Ubiquinone and other terpenoid-quinone biosynthesis
|
0.587413
|
0.044609
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__Catenibacterium_mitsuokai
|
Ubiquinone and other terpenoid-quinone biosynthesis
|
0.587413
|
0.044609
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__Ralstonia_pickettii
|
Ubiquinone and other terpenoid-quinone biosynthesis
|
0.592648
|
0.042283
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__g__Desulfosarcina
|
Ubiquinone and other terpenoid-quinone biosynthesis
|
-0.73677
|
0.00627
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Bifidobacterium_saeculare
|
Ubiquinone and other terpenoid-quinone biosynthesis
|
-0.85315
|
0.000418
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__g__Enhydrobacter
|
Phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis
|
0.683116
|
0.014339
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__Desulfosarcina_cetonica
|
Ubiquinone and other terpenoid-quinone biosynthesis
|
-0.84355
|
0.000564
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__g__Sulfuricurvum
|
Phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis
|
0.647234
|
0.022896
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__Megasphaera_massiliensis
|
Ubiquinone and other terpenoid-quinone biosynthesis
|
-0.72727
|
0.007355
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Citrobacter_sp._MGH106
|
Phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis
|
0.601399
|
0.038588
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__Enhydrobacter_aerosaccus
|
Phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis
|
0.683116
|
0.014339
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__Enterobacter_sp._CC120223-11
|
Phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis
|
0.65035
|
0.022034
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__Lactobacillus_equigenerosi
|
Phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis
|
0.597959
|
0.040012
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__Oceanobacillus_oncorhynchi
|
Phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis
|
0.717863
|
0.008563
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Streptomyces_scabiei
|
Phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis
|
0.626434
|
0.029293
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__uncultured_bacterium_5G12
|
Phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan biosynthesis
|
0.643357
|
0.024003
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__Planctomycetes_bacterium_TMED75
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
0.70182
|
0.010957
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__g__Enhydrobacter
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.73241
|
0.006752
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__g__Sulfuricurvum
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.81099
|
0.00137
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Clostridium_sp._3-3
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.70629
|
0.010245
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__Sphingobacterium_gobiense
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
0.604638
|
0.037281
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__g__Citrobacter
|
Lysine degradation
|
0.748252
|
0.005124
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Citrobacter_pasteurii
|
Lysine degradation
|
0.776224
|
0.002993
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Citrobacter_rodentium
|
Lysine degradation
|
0.594406
|
0.041521
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__Citrobacter_sp._MGH106
|
Lysine degradation
|
0.769231
|
0.003446
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Enterobacter_ludwigii
|
Lysine degradation
|
0.881119
|
0.000153
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Enterobacter_sp._CC120223-11
|
Lysine degradation
|
0.79021
|
0.002223
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Enhydrobacter_aerosaccus
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.73241
|
0.006752
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Megasphaera_massiliensis
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.71329
|
0.009202
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Oceanobacillus_oncorhynchi
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.78312
|
0.002591
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__uncultured_Citrobacter_sp.
|
Lysine degradation
|
0.748252
|
0.005124
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__g__Citrobacter
|
Betalain biosynthesis
|
0.888112
|
0.000114
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Pontibacillus_litoralis
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.67182
|
0.016722
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__Citrobacter_pasteurii
|
Betalain biosynthesis
|
0.818182
|
0.001143
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Citrobacter_rodentium
|
Betalain biosynthesis
|
0.839161
|
0.000643
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Citrobacter_sp._MGH106
|
Betalain biosynthesis
|
0.867133
|
0.00026
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__uncultured_bacterium_5G12
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.71329
|
0.009202
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Enterobacter_ludwigii
|
Betalain biosynthesis
|
0.671329
|
0.016831
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
B__s__Enterobacter_sp._CC120223-11
|
Betalain biosynthesis
|
0.776224
|
0.002993
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__uncultured_Citrobacter_sp.
|
Betalain biosynthesis
|
0.839161
|
0.000643
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
B__s__Yersinia_enterocolitica
|
Betalain biosynthesis
|
0.594406
|
0.041521
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
E__c__Enoplea
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.6014
|
0.038588
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
E__f__Trichuridae
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.6014
|
0.038588
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
E__g__Arabidopsis
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.71288
|
0.009261
|
spearman
|
**
|
PB
|
E__g__Trichuris
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.6014
|
0.038588
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
E__o__Trichinellida
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.6014
|
0.038588
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
E__p__Nematoda
|
N-Glycan biosynthesis
|
-0.60839
|
0.035806
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
E__g__Cucurbita
|
Lysine degradation
|
-0.57705
|
0.049477
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
E__s__Cucurbita_moschata
|
Lysine degradation
|
-0.57705
|
0.049477
|
spearman
|
*
|
PB
|
A__s__Methanobacterium_congolense
|
Type I diabetes mellitus
|
-0.69406
|
0.012279
|
spearman
|
*
|
BM
|
B__g__Mycoavidus
|
Type I diabetes mellitus
|
0.58042
|
0.047856
|
spearman
|
*
|
BM
|
B__s__Achromobacter_sp._ATCC35328
|
Type I diabetes mellitus
|
0.587342
|
0.044641
|
spearman
|
*
|
BM
|
B__s__Geobacillus_thermodenitrificans
|
Type I diabetes mellitus
|
-0.7866
|
0.002405
|
spearman
|
**
|
BM
|
B__s__Kocuria_kristinae
|
Type I diabetes mellitus
|
-0.71596
|
0.008825
|
spearman
|
**
|
BM
|
B__s__Mycoavidus_cysteinexigens
|
Type I diabetes mellitus
|
0.58042
|
0.047856
|
spearman
|
*
|
BM
|
B__s__Xenorhabdus_innexi
|
Type I diabetes mellitus
|
0.585976
|
0.045263
|
spearman
|
*
|
BM
|