A total of 1,647 studies were identified through the database search, and 243 of these were retained after screening the titles and abstracts. Subsequently, 177 studies were excluded during the full-text review. Finally, 66 articles with 237 cases of severe neonatal enterovirus infection were included in the analysis. Figure 1 shows the flow diagram of the study selection process. Table s1, s2 and s3 in the supplementary material show the general characteristics of the included neonates and the assessment of the risk of bias. We classified and analyzed the severe cases according to the major complications in Table 1.
Table 1
Clinical features of neonates with severe enteroviral infections (%)
|
Hepatitis or coagulopathy
|
Myocarditis
|
Meningoencephalitis
|
Other
|
Total
|
Reference (n = 66)
|
17 (25.5)
|
31 (47.0)
|
10 (15.2)
|
9 (13.6)
|
66
|
Cases (n = 237)
|
109 (46.0)
|
88 (37.1)
|
26 (11.0)
|
14 (5.9)
|
237
|
Country (n = 37)
|
8 (21.6)
|
14 (37.8)
|
7 (18.9)
|
8 (21.6)
|
37
|
Sex
|
Male/Female: 57/46
|
Male/Female: 42/29
|
Male/Female: 11/10
|
Male/Female: 6/3
|
Male/Female: 116/88
|
GA (weeks)
|
Preterm/Full-term: 53/54
|
Preterm/Full-term: 26/25
|
Preterm/Full-term: 14/11
|
Preterm/Full-term: 8/6
|
Preterm/Full-term: 101/96
|
BW (g)
|
1735–4200
|
1730–4500
|
1100–4400
|
2260–4010
|
1100–4500
|
Mode of delivery
|
Caesarean/Vaginal: 51/50
|
Caesarean/Vaginal: 26/17
|
Caesarean/Vaginal: 11/13
|
Caesarean/Vaginal: 7/6
|
Caesarean/Vaginal: 95/86
|
Maternal manifestation
|
33 (30.3)
|
20 (22.7)
|
5 (19.2)
|
12 (85.7)
|
70 (29.5)
|
Days at onset < = 7
|
98 (89.9)
|
35 (39.8)
|
20 (76.9)
|
14 (100.0)
|
167 (70.5)
|
Virus isolation
|
|
|
|
|
|
Rectal/stool
|
77 (70.6)
|
16 (30.2) **
|
18 (69.2)
|
7 (50.0)
|
118 (58.4)
|
Respiratory*
|
74 (67.9)
|
18 (34.0) **
|
5 (19.2)
|
4 (28.6)
|
101 (50.0)
|
CSF
|
49 (45.0)
|
22 (41.5) **
|
19 (73.1)
|
5 (35.7)
|
95 (47.0)
|
Blood
|
24 (22.0)
|
33 (62.3) **
|
3 (11.5)
|
5 (35.7)
|
65 (32.2)
|
Urine
|
33 (30.3)
|
NA
|
1 (3.8)
|
2 (14.3)
|
36 (17.8)
|
Virus serotypes**
|
CVB: 71 (81.6);
Echovirus: 16 (18.4)
|
CVB: 39 (97.5);
Echovirus: 1 (2.5)
|
CVB: 7 (58.3); Echovirus: 4 (33.3); EV71: 1 (8.3)
|
CVB: 7 (63.6);
Echovirus: 4 (36.4)
|
CVB: 124 (82.7); Echovirus: 25 (16.7); EV71: 1 (0.7)
|
Clinical signs
|
|
|
|
|
|
Temperature abnormalities
|
82 (75.2)
|
24 (27.3)
|
16 (61.5)
|
5 (35.7)
|
127 (53.6)
|
Rash
|
73 (67.0)
|
NA
|
10 (38.5)
|
5 (35.7)
|
88 (37.1)
|
Poor feeding
|
23 (21.1)
|
23 (26.1)
|
11 (42.3)
|
1 (7.1)
|
58 (24.5)
|
Respiratory symptoms
|
11 (10.1)
|
24 (27.3)
|
5 (19.2)
|
5 (19.2)
|
45 (19.0)
|
Lethargy
|
20 (18.3)
|
13 (14.8)
|
5 (19.2)
|
2 (14.3)
|
40 (16.9)
|
Jaundice
|
32 (29.4)
|
5 (5.7)
|
1 (3.8)
|
NA
|
38 (16.0)
|
Circulatory failure or shock
|
1 (0.9)
|
35 (39.8)
|
1 (3.8)
|
NA
|
37 (15.6)
|
Arrhythmias
|
1 (0.9)
|
27 (30.7)
|
NA
|
1 (7.1)
|
29 (12.2)
|
Thrombocytopenia
|
9 (8.3)
|
11 (12.5)
|
NA
|
8 (57.1)
|
28 (11.8)
|
Ascites
|
27 (24.8)
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
27 (11.4)
|
Hepatomegaly
|
19 (17.4)
|
3 (3.4)
|
NA
|
3 (21.4)
|
25 (10.5)
|
Poor perfusion
|
10 (9.2)
|
11 (12.5)
|
1 (3.8)
|
1 (7.1)
|
23 (9.7)
|
Irritability
|
7 (6.4)
|
1 (1.1)
|
9 (34.6)
|
NA
|
17 (7.2)
|
Seizure
|
1 (0.9)
|
4 (4.5)
|
10 (38.5)
|
NA
|
15 (6.3)
|
Hypotonia
|
5 (4.6)
|
1 (1.1)
|
3 (11.5)
|
NA
|
9 (3.8)
|
Diarrhea
|
NA
|
2 (2.3)
|
6 (23.1)
|
1 (7.1)
|
9 (3.8)
|
Other manifestation
|
Myocarditis: 24; DIC: 8; Encephalitis: 5; Intracranial hemorrhage: 5; Pneumonitis: 3; Renal insufficiency: 3
|
Meningoencephalitis: 10; Hepatitis: 7; DIC: 6;
Renal failure: 3
|
Hepatitis: 4; Acute renal tubular necrosis, DIC, myocardial necrosis, pneumonitis: 1; Central diabetes insipidus: 1;
|
Table 2
|
NA
|
Auxiliary examination
|
AST or ALT elevated: 85 (78.0)
|
BNP elevated: 20 (22.7); Troponin I or T elevated: 30 (34.1); ECG: myocardial ischemia: 30 (34.1); Echocardiograph: ventricle dilation or function depression: 56 (63.6)
|
MRI: white matter injury: 21 (80.8); Ultrasonography: extensive periventricular echogenicity: 16 (61.5)
|
NA
|
NA
|
Treatment
|
|
|
|
|
|
Systematic support
|
Blood component transfusions: 94 (86.2); Mechanical ventilation: 17 (15.6); Blood exchange transfusion: 4 (3.7); Peritoneal dialysis: 4 (3.7)
|
ECMO: 43 (48.9); Mechanical ventilation: 27 (30.7); Cardiopulmonary resuscitation: 5 (5.7)
|
Mechanical ventilation: 4 (15.4)
|
Blood component transfusions: 6 (42.9); Mechanical ventilation: 3 (21.4)
|
Blood component transfusions: 100 (42.2); Mechanical ventilation: 51 (21.5); ECMO: 43 (18.1)
|
Antibiotics
|
95 (87.2)
|
16 (18.2)
|
8 (30.8)
|
8 (57.1)
|
127 (53.6)
|
IVIG
|
56 (51.4)
|
31 (35.2)
|
2 (7.7)
|
8 (57.1)
|
97 (40.9)
|
Antivirals
|
Pleconaril: 9 (8.3);
Pocapavir: 1 (0.9)
|
Pleconaril: 5 (5.7);
Pocapavir: 2 (2.3)
|
NA
|
NA
|
Pleconaril: 14 (5.9);
Pocapavir: 3 (1.3)
|
Organ specific treatment
|
Liver transplantation: 3 (2.8)
|
Cardiac transplantation: 4 (4.5); Mitral valve replacement: 1 (1.1)
|
NA
|
Liver transplantation: 1 (7.1)
|
9 (3.8)
|
Outcome
|
Survived/Died: 80/29
|
Survived/Died: 54/34
|
Survived/Died: 23/3
|
Survived/Died: 8/6
|
Survived/Died: 165/72
|
* included throat, nasopharynx, or tracheal
** Data of some patients were not available and were not included in the calculation
CVB: Coxsackievirus B; EV71: Enterovirus 71; NA: Not available; DIC: Disseminated intravascular coagulation: AST: Aspartate aminotransferase; ALT: Alanine transaminase; BNP: Brain natriuretic peptide; MRI: Magnetic resonance imaging; ECMO: Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; IVIG: Intravenous immunoglobulin
Overall, 237 patients developed severe complications of enterovirus infection, with a male/female ratio of 116/88, and birth weight ranging from 1730 to 4500 g. In total, 51.3% (101/197) of the preterm infants and 52.5% (95/181) of the neonates were delivered by cesarean section. In 70.5% of the cases, the age at the onset of symptoms was less than 7 days. Seventy cases were associated with maternal disease before delivery, while 16 cases reported siblings or friends with symptoms. Enterovirus was identified mostly from the rectal or stool samples (118, 49.8%), followed by respiratory samples (101, 42.6%). Additionally, 82.7% of the neonates had coxsackievirus B (CVB) infection, 16.7% had echovirus infection, and 0.7% had enterovirus 71 (EV71) infection. The clinical manifestations included temperature abnormalities (127, 53.6%), rash (88, 37.1%), poor feeding (58, 24.5%), respiratory symptoms (45, 19.0%), lethargy (40, 16.9%), jaundice (38, 16.0%), circulatory failure or shock (37, 15.6%), arrhythmias (29, 12.2%), thrombocytopenia (28, 11.8%), poor perfusion (23, 9.7%), irritability (17, 7.2%), hypotonia (nine, 3.8%), and diarrhea (nine, 3.8%). A total of 111 patients were treated with empirical antibiotics and 97 patients with intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG). Antiviral medications included pocapavir (3, 1.3%) and pleconaril (14, 5.9%). Altogether, the mortality rate was 30.4% (72/237).
A total of 109 cases of hepatitis or coagulopathy from 17 studies(7–22) were included (57 boys, 46 girls). Maternal illness in the period from 2 months prepartum to 1 week postpartum was reported in 33 cases (30.3%), including fever in 23, abdominal pain in six, flu-like syndrome in five, and diarrhea in four cases. In three cases, siblings had symptoms of a febrile illness and sore throat a few days before delivery. Neonates presented with the first symptoms between the day of birth and 1 month; 98 (89.9%) presented within 7 days of birth. Eighty-seven records of enterovirus serotypes were extracted, comprising 16 cases of echovirus infection (echovirus 3 in one, echovirus 21 in one, echovirus 11 in four, echovirus 30 in two, echovirus 7 in two, echovirus 6 in two, echovirus 5 in one) and 71 cases of CVB (CVB1 in 22, CVB2 in one, CVB3 in 46, CVB4 in one, CVB5 in one). The most common symptom was temperature abnormalities, with 60 cases of temperature instability, 17 cases of fever, and five cases of hypothermia. Other presenting symptoms were rash (73, 67.0%), jaundice (32, 29.4%), and ascites (27, 24.8%). Complications associated with hepatitis accounted for 23 cases of myocarditis, one case of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, five cases of intracranial hemorrhage, five cases of encephalitis, eight cases of disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC), three cases of renal insufficiency, and three cases of pneumonitis. Elevation of aspartate aminotransferase (AST) or alanine transaminase (ALT) was reported in 85 cases. A total of 95 (87.2%) patients were treated with antibiotics and 56 (51.4%) were treated with IVIG. Antiviral medications utilized were pocapavir (1, 0.9%) and pleconaril (9, 8.3%). Moreover, 94 neonates required blood component transfusions, such as fresh-frozen plasma, platelets, and red blood cell concentrate. Other systematic supportive treatment included mechanical ventilation (17, 15.6%), peritoneal dialysis (4, 3.7%), hemodialysis (1, 0.9%), blood exchange transfusion (4, 3.7%), and continuous venovenous hemofiltration (1, 0.9%). Three patients received liver transplants. Twenty-nine of the 109 (26.6%) patients died and were aged between 8 days and 2 months.
A total of 88 patients in 31 studies(17, 23–52) developed the major complication of myocarditis, with a male/female ratio of 42/29. In total, 54.7% (35/64) patients were less than 7 days old at the onset of symptoms. Twenty patients had a history of maternal disease before delivery, while eight cases reported siblings or friends with symptoms. Thirty-nine neonates had CVB infection (CVB1 in 13, CVB2 in 2, CVB3 in 13, CVB4 in 5, CVB5 in 3, and CVB2 in 1). One patient had an echovirus 6 infection. Clinical signs of temperature abnormalities (eight patients with hypothermia, 15 with fever, and one with temperature instability) were observed in 24 patients. Signs of myocarditis included respiratory symptoms (24, 27.3%), arrhythmias (27, 30.7%), circulatory failure or shock (35, 39.8%), and poor perfusion (11, 12.5%). Myocarditis was reportedly accompanied by other complications including meningoencephalitis (10 cases), renal failure (three cases), DIC (six cases), and hepatitis (seven cases). Elevations of troponin and brain natriuretic peptide (BNP) were observed in 30 and 20 cases, respectively. Other primary auxiliary examinations undertaken were electrocardiogram (ECG) for signs of myocardial ischemia (30, 34.1%) and echocardiography for signs of ventricle dilation or function depression (56, 63.6%). Mechanical ventilation was used in 27 neonates, and cardiopulmonary resuscitation was required in five patients. In addition, 43 patients received extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) support. The medications included antibiotics (16, 18.2%), IVIG (31, 35.2%), pocapavir (2, 2.3), and pleconaril (5, 5.7). Moreover, four patients survived after heart transplantation and one underwent mitral valve replacement. The mortality rate was 38.6% (34/88) in neonates with myocarditis, and 40.7% (22/54) of the survivors had sequelae or required cardiac medication.
Twenty-six cases in 10 studies(53–62) were diagnosed with meningoencephalitis, with a male/female ratio of 11/10. Manifestations of meningoencephalitis in the mother and other family members were found in five and three cases, respectively. The enterovirus serotypes included four cases of echovirus (echovirus 6 in one, echovirus 30 in two, echovirus 31 in one), seven cases of CVB (CVB1 in four, CVB2 in two, CVB3 in one), and one case of EV71. Signs of central nervous system disease included seizures (10, 38.5%), lethargy (5, 19.2%), irritability (9, 34.6%), tonic–clonic movements of the upper extremities (one, 3.8%), right-sided hemiparesis (one, 3.8%), weak gag reflex (one, 3.8%), and full fontanelle (one, 3.8%). Complications of central diabetes insipidus occurred in one patient. White matter injury was detected by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in 21 cases, while 16 cases exhibited extensive periventricular echogenicity on brain ultrasonography. Four patients were treated with mechanical ventilation and two were administered IVIG. Altogether, 23 of the 26 neonates survived, with neurological sequelae reported in six.
Other rare complications are shown in Table 2, including hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis (HLH)(63–66), pulmonary hemorrhage(67), pulmonary hypoplasia(68), persistent pulmonary hypertension(69), bone marrow failure(70), and congenital skin lesions(71). Among the six patients with HLH, four developed fever, abdominal pain, and flu-like symptoms before delivery. All patients developed the disease within 5 days. Five patients were treated with IVIG. In the end, one patient died and another received a liver transplant at the age of 2 months. In four cases consisting of two sets of twins with pulmonary hemorrhage, both the mothers had developed fever and other symptoms on the day of the delivery. The onset ages of the two sets of twins were 7 days and 5 days, respectively. Only one neonate survived with mild disease. There was a single case of pulmonary hypoplasia characterized by a total failure of the development of terminal respiratory units. Echovirus 11 was positive in the amniotic fluid. The neonate was delivered at 38 weeks gestational age and died one hour later. Another case involved intrauterine echovirus 11 infection with persistent pulmonary hypertension and pneumonia. The patient died 36 hours after birth. There was also a case of bone marrow failure and concomitant enteroviral infection. Bone marrow aspiration and biopsy revealed hypocellularity. The patient finally improved. A boy with congenital disseminated papulovesicular, nodular, bullous, and necrotic ulcerated rash was also reported. He subsequently developed pneumonia, carditis, and hepatitis. CVB3 was identified in the patient’ s serum. The boy survived with sequelae at 6 months of age.
Table 2 Clinical features of neonates severe enteroviral infections of rare complications (%)
|
Hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Reference
|
Miyoshi, 2020
|
Fukazawa, 2013
|
Watanabe, 2019
|
Lindamood, 2011
|
|
|
|
|
Country
|
Japan
|
Japan
|
Italy
|
Canada
|
|
|
|
|
Sex
|
Female
|
Male
|
Male
|
Male
|
Male
|
Female
|
|
|
GA (weeks)
|
38
|
35
|
37
|
37
|
38
|
41
|
|
|
BW (g)
|
2860
|
2260
|
NA
|
4010
|
3550
|
3120
|
|
|
Mode of delivery
|
Vaginal
|
Caesarean
|
NA
|
Caesarean
|
Vaginal
|
Caesarean
|
|
|
Maternal manifestation, days onset before delivery
|
Fever, 0
|
Abdominal pain, 1; Fever, 0
|
Fever, 0
|
Flu-like illness, 0
|
NA
|
Flulike illness, 2 weeks
|
|
|
Days at onset
|
3
|
4
|
4
|
3
|
5
|
0
|
|
|
Virus isolation (serotype)
|
Blood, NPS, stool, urine (CVB3)
|
NPS, stool (CVB1)
|
CSF, pharyngeal fluid, stool, urine (Echovirus 7)
|
Blood
|
Blood
|
Blood, CSF
|
|
|
Clinical signs
|
Apnea, fever, petechiae, poor feeding, thrombocytopenia
|
Apnea, hepatosplenomegaly, thrombocytopenia
|
Apnea, lethargy
|
Bleeding, fever, hepatosplenomegaly, thrombocytopenia
|
Cyanosis, hemodynamic instability, respiratory distress, thrombocytopenia
|
Lethargy, petechiae, splenomegaly, thrombocytopenia
|
|
|
Other manifestation
|
Coagulopathy, liver dysfunction
|
Coagulopathy
|
DIC
|
Coagulopathy, liver failure
|
Coagulopathy
|
Coagulopathy, meningoencephalitis
|
|
|
Auxiliary examination findings
|
Hyperferritinemia
|
Leukocytosis
|
Elevated LDH, AST, ferritin levels
|
Anemia
|
Anemia, elevated ferritin level
|
Elevated ferritin level
|
|
|
Treatment
|
Blood component transfusions, IVIG
|
Blood transfusions, recombinant thrombomodulin,
IVIG
|
Blood component transfusions, mechanical ventilation, thrombomodulin, antibiotics, IVIG
|
Blood component transfusions, cryoprecipitate, IVIG, liver transplantation at 2 months of age
|
Blood component transfusions, continuous venovenous hemofiltration, cryoprecipitate, mechanical ventilation
|
Blood component transfusions, cryoprecipitate, IVIG
|
|
|
Outcome, last follow-up
|
Survived, 25 days
|
Survived, 11 months
|
Survived, 18 months
|
Survived, 2.5 years
|
Died, 14 days
|
Survived, 2 weeks
|
|
|
|
Pulmonary hemorrhage
|
|
|
|
Bone marrow failure
|
Congenital Skin Lesions
|
Pulmonary hypoplasia
|
Persistent pulmonary hypertension
|
Reference
|
Orbach, 2016
|
|
|
|
Tarcan, 2001
|
Sauerbrei, 2000
|
Tassin, 2014
|
Willems,2006
|
Country
|
Israel
|
|
|
|
Turkey
|
America
|
France
|
Belgium
|
sex
|
NA (2 twins)
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
Male
|
Male
|
NA
|
Female
|
GA (weeks)
|
30
|
30
|
36
|
36
|
40
|
39
|
38
|
36
|
BW (g)
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
3800
|
NA
|
NA
|
2810
|
Mode of delivery
|
Caesarean
|
Caesarean
|
Vaginal
|
Vaginal
|
Caesarean
|
Vaginal
|
Vaginal
|
Caesarean
|
Maternal manifestation, days onset before delivery
|
Abdominal pain, seizures and fever, 0
|
Abdominal pain, seizures and fever, 0
|
Fever, a few hours
|
Fever, a few hours
|
Diarrhea and fever, 2 weeks
|
Mild signs of respiratory infections, 2 weeks
|
Spontaneous demise of a co-twin, 14 gestational weeks
|
Abdominal pain and fever
|
Days at onset
|
7
|
7
|
5
|
5
|
5
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
Virus isolation (serotype)
|
CSF (CVB3)
|
CSF (CVB3)
|
Brain, liver, lung, stool (CVB2)
|
CSF, stool (CVB2)
|
Stool (Echovirus 11)
|
Serum (CVB3)
|
Amniotic fluid, lung (Echovirus 11)
|
Intestine, lung, stool, tracheal aspirate (Echovirus 11)
|
Clinical signs
|
Cutis marmorata, poor response, thrombocytopenia
|
Cutis marmorata, hemodynamic instability, tachycardia, respiratory distress, thrombocytopenia
|
Cutis marmorata, fever, poor perfusion, thrombocytopenia
|
Fever
|
Diarrhea, fever, hepatosplenomegaly, petechiae, rash
|
Atopic dermatitis with Candida infection, bronchopulmonal dysplasia, impaired central coordination, papulovesicular, nodular, bullous and ulcerative rash
|
32 WG a bilateral abnormal lung development
|
Respiratory distress, purpura
|
Other manifestation
|
DIC, intraventricular hemorrhage
|
DIC
|
NA
|
NA
|
Transient pancytopenia concurrent
|
Hepatitis, myocarditis, pneumonia
|
NA
|
DIC, meningitis, pneumonia
|
Auxiliary examination findings
|
Acidosis, elevated transaminase, leukopenia
|
Leukopenic
|
NA
|
NA
|
Bone marrow aspiration and biopsy: hypocellularity
|
NA
|
Ultrasound and MRI: bilateral abnormal lung development
|
NA
|
Treatment
|
Antibiotics, IVIG
|
Mechanical ventilation, antibiotics, IVIG
|
Antibiotics
|
Antibiotics
|
Antibiotics, IVIG
|
Mechanical ventilation, antibiotics
|
Adrenaline, mechanical ventilation
|
Inhaled nitric oxide, prostacyclin infusion, antibiotics, surfactant
|
Outcome, last follow-up
|
Died, 8 days
|
Died, 12 days
|
Died, 8 days
|
Survived
|
Survived
|
Survived
|
Died, 1 hour
|
Died, 36 hours
|
CVB: Coxsackievirus B; NA: Not available; DIC: Disseminated intravascular coagulation; IVIG: Intravenous immunoglobulin