In February 2018 (time T0) a first structural MRI was performed. Our patient was effectively treated with risperidone at a dosage of 1.5mg/day until June 2018. Following the incongruous suspension of antipsychotic treatment, a relapse of psychotic symptoms occurred and our patient showed resistance to treatment with both atypical and typical neuroleptics. In December 2018 (time T1), after 6 months of pharmacological resistance, a second structural MRI was performed. The cortical and subcortical areas brain analysis was performed through cortical surface-based analysis, consisting of automatic segmentation through the FREESUFER software. As per protocol, this segmentation used a high-contrast volumetric isotropic image between white and gray matter of the SIEMENS 3 Tesla tomograph. The neuroimaging data collected for our patient were compared with those of a control subject. 165 cortical and subcortical areas were considered, of which the volumetric difference between the first MRI at time T0 and the second MRI at time T1 was evaluated. Using the MINITAB v. 17, initially we have verified that these volumetric differences follow or not a normal distribution through the probability plot test for the normality evaluation. We found that considered volumetric (post-pre) differences distribution does not follow a normal distribution. Therefore, non-parametric tests have been chosen for statistical analysis. In particular, the Sign test for Median was used to verify that distribution of the volumetric differences was significantly different between our patient and the control subject. Furthermore, Mann-Whitney Test was used to verify that the volumetric differences distribution did not have the same median between our patient and the control subject. The differences distribution for the control subject does not have a significantly different median (p = 0.45 and median=-27 mm3). On the contrary, the differences distribution for our patient has a significantly different median from zero (p = 0.01 and median = 46 mm3). The two distributions have no equal median (p = 0.01). In our patient, we have found significant volumetric variations in specific brain regions before treatment and after drug resistance has been established. The POST-PRE difference is at least (in absolute value) of about 200 mm3 (value considered as a limit beyond which it cannot be a freesurfer segmentation error). The % POST-PRE difference is at least (in absolute value) 15% (value considered as a limit beyond which it cannot be a freesurfer segmentation error). The volumetric variations have a different trend depending on the brain areas considered and in particular some brain areas have a similar trend both on the left and on the right (in “WHITE” in Table 1) and others an opposite trend on the left and on the right (in “GREY” in the Table 1).
In our patient with regard to temporal cortex (superior and inferior temporal gyrus, superior and inferior temporal surface), frontal cortex (medial orbital surface, olfactory sulcus, rectum gyrus and subcallus gyrus), hippocampus, amygdala, thalamus, basal ganglia (caudate, putamen and pallidum) and cerebellum GM volumes decrease both on the left and on the right. On the contrary, with regard to other regions of frontal cortex (superior and inferior frontal gyrus, anterior and postero-dorsal cingulate cortex, inferior orbital cortex) and the precuneus of the superior parietal lobule GM volumes have an opposite trend on the left and on the right, or if they decrease to the left they increase to the right and vice versa (as an example see Figs. 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5).
Interestingly, in our patient the volumetric variations affect different brain areas that are candidates for Schizophrenia (SCZ). Several studies have shown that inside the temporal cortex the superior temporal gyrus (STG) represents a core cerebral cortical area for the pathophysiology of Schizophrenia [4, 13] and it is one of the most consistently reported region with reduced GM volumes in this disorder [14]. The STG play an important role in auditory processing, in language function, in auditory memory, in recognition of learned social-emotional values and non verbal cues [15–17]. The abnormality of STG-GM may be related to auditory and higher cognitive deficits in patients with Schizophrenia [18]. Moreover, STG connects to limbic system (hippocampus and amygdala), thalamus and the part of prefrontal cortex, which have been thought to be related to the pathophysiology of Schizophrenia, particularly in auditory hallucinations and disordered thoughts [19, 20]. Cortical thickness anomalies of the frontal lobe, interesting its various areas and specifically the prefrontal cortex, have been documented in Schizophrenia [21–23]. Frontal cortical areas are important for executive functioning and their volume reduction has often been reported to be associated with negative symptoms of Schizophrenia [24]. Hippocampal anomalies with an important role in the formation and emergence of Schizophrenia have been documented in this disorder: in fact, patients with Schizophrenia exhibit significant bilateral volume reduction and progressive hippocampal volume decrease in first-episode patients with Schizophrenia has been shown in many neuroimaging studies [25]. Moreover, inside the hippocampus smaller CA1 volumes and CA1 hyper-activation may be predictive of conversion in subjects at high risk of psychosis, as well as smaller CA1 and CA4/DG volumes in first-episode of Schizophrenia and more widespread smaller hippocampal sub-region volumes may be associated with longer duration of illness [26]. The thalamus holds a key anatomic position in the brain as part of the circuit that modulate perception, emotion and thinking and their integration in conscious experience [27]. Several studies have shown that the thalamic volume appeared to be reduced in patients with Schizophrenia [28]. The cerebellum is known to be involved with motor coordination, as well as with aspects of cognitive functioning such as attention, working memory and sensory discrimination [29] and this brain region has been implicated in the pathophysiology of Schizophrenia, especially with cortico-thalamo-cerbellar network [30]. In fact, decreased GM density in the vermis and tonsil of cerebellum [31] and decreased left cerebellar lobules VI and X volumes [32] are present at the early stage of Schizophrenia and appear to be associated respectively with nonverbal executive dysfunction and cognitive deficits [31, 32]. Numerous scientific evidence has documented the ability of antipsychotic medication to modulate brain morphology and produce volumetric change even over a short period of time [33]. Typical and atypical antipsychotics might affect brain structures differently due to their different pharmacological actions [34]. Based on our knowledge, studies on atypical antipsychotics seem to converge on their ability to maintain or increase the GM volume in Schizophrenia regardless of the age of onset of the disorder. Through structural RMI studies, some of which they have used region of interest technique and others voxel-based morphometry analysis, increased thalamus volumes in patients with schizophrenia was observed after use of atypical antipsychotics [13, 34–36]. It is believed that the thalamus can mediate the effects the clinical effects of antipsychotic drug due to its role in the integration and coordination of brain activity [37]. Moreover, exposure to antipsychotics has been shown to increase the expression levels of Fos-like protein in the midline thalamic nuclei and the use of atypical antipsychotics increases the thalamic N-acetyl-aspartate levels [38]. Increased frontal cortex volume, especially at the level of the prefrontal cortex, was found after atypical antipsychotic treatment in first episode of Schizophrenia [13, 39, 40]. Moreover, increased cortical thickness in the prefrontal cortex was associated with improvement of negative symptoms [39]. A decrease in negative symptoms has been related to dopamine release in the prefrontal cortex, which can be modulated by combined D2 and serotonin 5-HT2A receptor antagonism [41]. Atypical antipsychotics use has been found associated with an increased hippocampal volume and an increased BDNF levels in this brain region in patients at first episode of Schizophrenia [25]. Increased GM volume in cerebellum was found after atypical antipsychotic treatment in Schizophrenia [13, 41]. In a animal model atypical antipsychotics (clozapine) was associated with an increased NR2C expression in cerebellum relative to a typical antipsychotics (haloperidol) [29]. Findings from both cross-sectional studies of first-episode patients and longitudinal studies in Childhood-Onset and Adolescent-Onset Schizophrenia support the concept of EOS as a progressive neurodevelopmental disorder with both early and late brain abnormalities [42]. However, it is widely demonstrated that early antipsychotic treatment can significantly modify the course of the disease [43]. Despite this, the drug resistance issue cannot be overlooked. Kane and colleagues define drug resistance as the persistence of symptoms after at least three treatments with neuroleptic drugs of at least two different drug classes and last at least 6 weeks in the last 5 years [44]. Drug resistance may depend on several factors, such as pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic variables, neuro-immuno-endocrinological features, that could influence the subjective response to typical and atypical antipsychotics, duration of untreated psychosis (DUP), number of relapses, early onset of the disease and lack of treatment compliance [43]. In the case of our patient the drug resistance seems to be due to the lack of compliance with the treatment: in fact, it appeared after the risperidone incongruous interruption. This occurred during a critical period in the development of the central nervous system (CNS) and could explain the particular pattern of volumetric variations found in our patient through the structural MRI. In fact, GM volumes increase before puberty and decrease during adolescent through a competitive elimination of redundant synapses also known as synaptic pruning [42]. In a study of patients with Childhood-Onset Schizophrenia treated with clozapine compared to healthy subjects, no significant differences in cerebral volumes and lateral ventricles size were found [45]. Therefore, it appears that a clozapine successful treatment may lead to a convergence of the development trajectories of CNS between subjects suffering from EOS and healthy controls. Based on the clinical course of our patient, we hypothesize that early and effective treatment with risperidone and/or other atypical antipsychotic might have the same effect of clozapine on development trajectories of CNS. Therefore, the incongruous interruption of pharmacological treatment could have triggered a dysregulated pruning responsible for the drug resistance and volumetric variations observed in our patient by structural MRI.