3.1 Total Phenol and Total Acid Content in BPF, UP and LP
The pH, density, yield, moisture content and heating value of BPF were measured in the study period (See supplementary materials). When the pyrolysis temperature was low (300–400℃), the aliphatic hydroxyl groups on the branched chain of lignin structure were broke, and the cellulose would depolymerize and dehydrate. The main products of their reactions were acetic acid, formic acid and other acid compounds, a small amount of tar substances and phenolic compounds (Ren et al. 2017). Therefore, as shown in Fig. 1a, the acid content was higher at a lower temperature, up to 139.23mg/g. With the increase of pyrolysis temperature, the secondary pyrolysis of BPF was strengthened and the organic acids decomposed. For example, levoglucose was decomposed into small molecular gas products through molecular reforming, decarboxylation and other reactions, thus reducing the acid content. On the other hand, the increase of the total amount of BPF also led to the decrease of the proportion of acid compounds in the total organic matter. The higher the pyrolysis temperature was, the more intense the pyrolysis reaction of lignin was. Guaiacol (also known as o-methoxy-phenol), one of the main products of pyrolysis, and tar-like substances produced at low temperature had secondary cracking. The GC-MS analysis of BPF showed that the content of guaiacol did decrease with the increase of pyrolysis temperature (See supplementary materials) (Chen et al. 2020). This led to an increase in the number of phenols and a rapid increase in TP content. In addition, the chemical bonds of oxygen-containing compounds in BPF broke in the order of C-O, C-H and C-C bonds from weak to strong, and decarboxylation, decarbonylation and dehydrogenation occurred respectively (Hoyong et al. 2018), so oxygen-containing compounds converted into more stable phenolic compounds. Therefore, as shown in Fig. 1a, TP reached the minimum 67.27mg /g at 300℃ and the maximum 76.79mg /g at 700℃.
From Fig. 1b and supplementary materials, it can be seen that the two-phase product obtained by salting-out extraction, UP was much smaller than LP product, and the yield of LP product was first increased and then decreased, the highest yield was 96.29% at 500 ℃. TP were mainly enriched in UP. The average TP content in UP was 193.27 mg/g, while that in LP was 64.52 mg/g (Fig. 1c). Because when inorganic salt solutions were added, the cations produced by ionization attract more water molecules to form a hydration layer, causing more organic molecules to be repelled into the organic phase (Xiao et al. 2009) (See supplementary materials). As shown in Fig. 1d, the effect of salting-out extraction on the TA of UP and LP in each temperature segment was the same as that of BPF, and the TA content in UP was slightly higher than LP after the salting-out extraction of BPF at each temperature.
3.2 Potted plant experiment
Firstly, BPF was diluted to a factor of 0,200,400,600 and was added to saline-alkali soil. The effects of BPF on the growth of Chinese cabbage were investigated by pot experiment. As we can see (see supplementary material), only a 600-fold dilution of BPF resulted in very few seeds germinating, with a germination rate of only 13.33%. This was because BPF contained more phenols and acids, which have a great impact on the germination rate of plants (Muscolo et al. 2001).
Next, LP with different dilution ratio (50,100,200,400) was added into saline-alkali soil for pot experiment. Compared with CK, LP had a significant effect on the germination rate (3 d), plant height (35 d) and plant weight (35 d) of Chinese cabbage (Fig. 2a-c). In particular, a 400-fold dilution of LP increased the germination rate by 25.76% on average, while a 50-fold dilution of LP only increased the germination rate by 2.4%. The plant average height and plant weight of Chinese cabbage, which reached a maximum height of 6.7 cm and a maximum weight of 0.9661 g, both of which were higher than CK, by 67.51% and 93.22%, respectively. As the dilution increases the plants grew better (see supplementary material). When the dilution was low, the phenolic concentration in LP was higher, and the excessive phenolic compounds have an inhibitory effect on seed germination and plant growth. On the other hand, the addition of sulfate, which increases the soluble salt content in the soil, will change the osmotic pressure in the plant, thus causing some hindrance to the plant root system for nutrient and water uptake. It even inhibits plant growth, while salt stress can cause ion toxicity in the plant body (Shahzad et al. 2021). This also results in severe plant senescence and high MDA content (Fig. 2d). With 400-fold LP diluted in each temperature segment having a good effect on the plant's MDA, with an average decrease of 42.35% compared with the blank control group. Through pot experiments, we found that BPF inhibited plant growth, while LP promoted plant growth to varying degrees. In order to further investigate the specific mechanism of LP, soil nutrients, enzyme activities and microbial community structure were analyzed.
3.3 Effects of LP on soil nutrients and enzyme activities
The change in soil pH was inversely proportional to the TA content in LP (Fig. 3a). The salt used in the test was (NH4)2SO4, which was a strong acid and weak base salt. Its solution was acidic, so it made a more significant impact on soil pH value. In addition, the addition of (NH4)2SO4 had a certain influence on soil total salt content (Fig. 3b) and alkali-hydrolyzable nitrogen content (Fig. 3d). Also, the addition of high concentration of LP promoted the formation of macromolecule complexation in the soil, but it was not discharged in a short time (Shang et al. 2021). With the increase of test period, small molecule salt was regenerated, leading to the increase of salt content. When using the appropriate dilution ratio (200 and 400 times), it could effectively complex salt ions and reduce the total salt content in the soil. LP was rich in organic materials, so when it was added to the soil, the larger the dilution ratio of LP was, the less the content of organic matter was in the soil. When LP was diluted by 50, 100, 200 and 400 times, the average organic matter content of soil increased by 66.75%, 47.16%, 29.39% and 24.76% respectively (Fig. 3c).
As shown in Fig. 3d-f, LP can significantly increase the effective soil nutrient content. LP contained a certain amount of acidic organic matter. On the one hand, the acid dissolution, chelation dissolution and desorption of these acidic substances had an important and direct effect on the increase of soil nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium elements. And small molecular acids could inhibit the mineralization of these elements and promote the release of available elements in soil (Li et al. 2020). The migration of colloidal ions in soil was promoted by acidic ions and organic active molecules in LP. This resulted in the release of the original fixed nutrients in the soil and at the same time increased the activity of the original nutrients (Zhang et al. 2019b). On the other hand, the acidic components of LP could interact with materials in the soil at the right concentrations. This could promote enzyme and microbial activity, thus further improve soil activity (Zhang et al., 2019a). Therefore, with the addition of LP, the contents of basic nitrogen, available phosphorus and available potassium significantly increased, up to 139.56 mg/kg, 14.82mg/kg and 71.53mg/g respectively.
Soil colloids and minerals had adsorption effects on enzymes, this can reduce soil enzyme activity(Li et al. 2021). LP contained a large amount of acidic substances such as acetic acid, which can compete with soil colloids and minerals for adsorption sites on soil enzymes, thus reducing adsorption (Kabiri et al. 2016). From Fig. 4, it can be seen that LP had a significant promotion effect on soil enzyme activity. The urease and alkaline phosphatase activity increased with the increase of the dilution ratio of LP. Especially when the dilution ratio of LP was 200 and 400 times, the promotion of both enzymes was greater. Compared with CK, urease activity increased on average 3.13-fold (Fig. 4a). The trend graph of alkaline phosphatase activity (Fig. 4c) was consistent with the change in the trend graph of fast-acting phosphorus (Fig. 3e). Sucrase activity was related to the metabolism of carbon (Bastida et al. 2016). At lower dilutions, the LP contained more carbon sources, which led to increased microbial metabolism. So the sucrase activity was higher (Fig. 4b). The activity of catalase was negatively correlated with pH. Therefore, a small dilution of LP with high organic acid content was more favorable to promote the activity of catalase (Fig. 4d) in the soil.
To further represent more visually the effects of pyrolysis temperature and dilution times on soil nutrients, physicochemical properties and enzyme activity, we did a correlation analysis, as shown in Fig. 4e. The similarity of the color level indicates that the effect was close. As can be seen from the figure, the dark red color is mainly concentrated in the area of dilution multiples 50 and 400. Low dilutions have a positive effect on organic matter, total salinity, alkaline nitrogen, sucrase and catalase activity in the soil. Higher dilutions had positive effects on fast-acting phosphorus, fast-acting potassium, plant growth, alkaline phosphatase and urease in the soil. In order to investigate more clearly which microorganisms are affected by LP at high and low dilutions, high throughput sequencing was performed in this study.
3.4 Changes of microbial communities in acclimatized soil
We made gene sequencing on 16SRNA to evaluate the richness and diversity under various suitable conditions. Figure 5a displayed the Shannon-Wiener curve of bacterial communities in this research. As the increase of measured sequence, the Shannon-Wiener curve leveled off. LP diluted 50 times and 400 times at different temperatures were added to LP. Generally, The Shannon and Simpson indices reflected the diversity and uniformity of samples, and Chao 1 and ACE reflected the richness of communities (Pd et al. 2021). As can be seen from the Table 2, Shannon values of samples were all higher than CK, indicating that the addition of LP was beneficial to enrich microbial community. Simpson value in low dilution ratio samples decreased, while that in high dilution ratio samples increased. This was due to the fact that LP at low dilutions contained more phenolics, which affected the biological activity of some microorganisms. And the appropriate concentration of LP had positive effect on the growth of microorganisms. Compared with the values of Chao 1 and ACE, CK increased, indicating that the richness of microorganisms in the samples raised. It can also be seen from the abundance class curves (Fig. 5b). PCA results of multiple samples (Fig. 5c) showed that samples at different pyrolysis temperatures and in the same dilution multiple did not appear aggregation. The results showed that the microbiota of each sample changed in different degrees during the adaptation process.
Table 2
Microbial diversity index of the flora
| Simpson | Chao1 | ACE | Shannon |
CK | 0.99826 | 2366 | 2366 | 10.32 |
L-3-50 | 0.994174 | 3064.3 | 3299.12 | 9.54 |
L-4-50 | 0.993492 | 3749.14 | 4141.72 | 9.74 |
L-5-50 | 0.986293 | 2639.5 | 2827.96 | 9.16 |
L-6-50 | 0.989704 | 3195.91 | 3365 | 9.11 |
L-7-50 | 0.990269 | 2873.36 | 3093.39 | 9.16 |
L-3-400 | 0.998486 | 4186.03 | 4588.54 | 10.72 |
L-4-400 | 0.998096 | 3956.81 | 4276.93 | 10.57 |
L-5-400 | 0.998278 | 4296.08 | 4674.51 | 10.69 |
L-6-400 | 0.998256 | 3484.17 | 3709.49 | 10.48 |
L-7-400 | 0.997807 | 4542.93 | 4971.09 | 10.69 |
Multiple studies have shown, in phylum level, Proteobacteria had an absolute advantage in the alkali-saline soils (Bai et al. 2019). As shown in Fig. 5d, there are also distributions of Acidobacteria, Gemmatimonadetes, Chloroflexi, Firmicutes and Acidobacteris. When LP (L-50) diluted 50 times was added, the abundance of Proteobacteria raised to varying degrees, while the abundance of Acidobacteria reduced and the abundance of Firmicutes greatly increased. The reason was that LP contains more (NH4)2SO4 at lower dilution ratio, resulting in higher overall salt content than CK. The abundance of Proteobacteria, as the dominant bacteria, increased. From the analysis of order level (Fig. 5e), Clostridiales had strong resistance under high salt condition, and became the dominant bacteria under the condition of abundant organic matter (Du et al. 2022). From the analysis of genus level (Fig. 5f), it showed that Pseudomonas mostly appeared in poor environment and releases catalase while consuming organic matter in soil. This was also one of the reasons for the high catalase content in soil at low dilution ratio (Fig. 4d). Soil organic matter content was too high, causing C: N was higher than 70:1. Under this condition, nitrogen-fixing bacteria start to fix nitrogen, which was the main reason why Azoarcus became the dominant genus (Du et al. 2021). Therefore, the content of alkali-hydrolyzed nitrogen was higher at low dilution ratios. Desulfosporosinus (Pester et al. 2012), a reductive microorganism often found in environments of high sulfate concentrations, restored sulfate to stable sulfides. At low dilution ratio, the abundance of dominant bacteria in saline-soil environment increased and the diversity of bacteria was low due to the addition of sulfate. Soil fertility was poor which leaded to poor growth of, but it also improved to a certain extent compared with CK.
LP diluted 400 times added, the richness of Proteobacteria slightly reduced, while Acidobacteria and Gemmatimonadetes significantly increased, sequenced in phylum level. Studies have shown that Actinomycetes mainly undertook the decomposition of organic matter, played a beneficial role in improving soil fertility, and could provide certain protection against abiotic stress(Shi et al. 2022). The increase in the abundance of Gemmatimonadetes was attributed to the raising available potassium, available phosphorus and organic matter content (Mk et al. 2020). From the analysis of order level, Micrococales and Rhizobiales (Aliashkevich et al.) were the main phospho-solubilizing bacteria orders, and the abundance of these two orders was higher when the dilution ratio was higher, which was also one of the reasons why the content of available phosphorus in soil was higher. Nitrosomonadales becoming the dominant bacterium mainly because the soil was rich in NH4+, under the action of which, NH4+ can be converted into nitrate that can be directly used by the Chinese Cabbage (Boden et al. 2017). From genus level analysis, Sphingomonas and Pseudarthrobacter can be used for degradating aromatic compounds (Lha et al.). Because LP contained part of phenolic substances, the emergence of these two bacteria also meant the degradation of phenolic substances. Therefore, under the high dilution ratios, Chinese Cabbage grew better.