Our results emphasize the green manure influence on soil chemical properties through their plant biomass production and further incorporation into soil profile in a Tropical ecosystem over 6 consecutive years. Essentially, we wanted to understand how the biomass incorporation into soil profile created a positive effect on soil ecosystem by improving soil properties without any input of fertilizers or soil conditioners. Our hypothesis about soil fertility improvement by green manure practice was not supported for Olsen’s available P, while for Ca2+, K+, and SOC stock it was supported. Our results also supported the Liebig's Law of the Minimum states that biomass production is proportional to the amount of the most limiting nutrient (Touhami et al. 2022). In our study, the limiting nutrient was P since its content decreased overtime on plots where all plant species were cultivated.
Green manure system based on leguminous plant species has been described as a management practice that would promote positive changes on SOC stock (103% more SOC stock), and soil nutrient contents (23.5, 17, and 31.5% more Ca2+, Mg2+, and K+, respectively) (Ashworth et al. 2019; Demir and Işık 2019; Melo et al. 2019). In our study, we observed SOC stock increases overtime, but even the leguminous plant species increasing both SOC stock, Ca2+, and K+ they were not able to improve soil P content (e.g., It was one factor that influenced both shoot dry biomass and root density as described in our predictive models). Many studies have reported soil P decline after consecutive monocropping systems (Liu et al. 2021; Xu et al. 2021), and in our study the green manure system considering monostands of Fabaceae and Poaceae plants showed the same phenomenon.
Considering that the Olsen’s available P content was not enough to supply plant P requirement, all studied plant species were unable to complete a normal life cycle and to produce their maximum sustainable yield in terms of shoots (aboveground biomass) and roots (belowground biomass) (Fontana et al. 2021; Fan et al. 2021). We have expected an increase on shoot dry biomass (e.g., as the soil ability to provide plant habitat) and soil quality after 6 consecutive years of green manure practice. Our results also highlighted the concept of soil quality that defines the soil capacity of a specific kind of soil function, within natural or managed ecosystem boundaries, to sustain plant productivity (Seaton et al. 2021; Ma et al. 2021).
It is important to described that we based our findings here considering that root density, Olsen’s available P, shoot dry biomass, Ca2+, K+, and SOC stock were the soil chemical properties that most contributed to soil quality changes and data variance (Nascimento et al. 2021). We also determined other soil abiotic traits (ESM_1), predictive models (ESM_2), and polynomial regression to estimate soil quality decay rate (ESM_3). We observed that there is a reduction in soil quality for all studied plant species, possibly by the 6 consecutive years using the green manure practice in a monocropping system. These findings support the ecological collapse hypothesis that describes soil function loss because of an event occurring on a short time scale, such as our treatments (Martins et al. 2021; Zhang et al. 2021).
The root density was a factor that explained about 54% on soil quality index. Thus, the belowground biomass production can be considered more important than the aboveground biomass production (e.g., since the shoot dry biomass just explained about 5% on soil quality index). We found that N. wightii showed after the 3rd year the highest root density values and it have contributed to soil quality index, and to reduce soil quality decay rate overtime. These results agree with previous studies done by Parhizkar et al. (2021), Ma et al. (2021), and Mortensen et al. (2021), which reported that soil ecosystems with high rootability and constant nutrient-rich organic amendments may increase soil chemical properties.
The green manure practice that this tropical soil type has been put through over the last 6 years has led to a soil quality decline, especially on plots where C. ensiformis, C. spectabilis, D. lablab, M pruriens, and S. aterrimum were cultivated. This soil quality decline has also been observed in agricultural fields (Soto et al. 2021; Thomaz and Antoneli 2021), degraded areas (Huang et al. 2021; Yeilagi et al. 2021), where values of soil quality index are lower and rarely reach 100 and 50, respectively. The way that we applied the green manure practice (monostands) must also be responsible for the soil P reduction (Wang et al. 2021; Freund et al. 2021). Such a decrease in soil nutrient contents limits the soil quality (e.g., since Olsen’s available P explained about 24% of soil quality variance).
These results can be justified to the frequency of green manure practice following a monostand for each studied plant species without nutrient inputs (via mineral or organic fertilizers), which have led to the drastically reduction of the natural low P content. There was greater variation among green manure species over the years with respect to influences on soil parameters, plant traits, and soil quality. It is well established that green manure exhibit positive influence on soil fertility which tends to accumulate its effects overtime (Chen et al. 2021; Adetunji et al. 2021). This may be related to the capacity of some plant species used as green manure to improve SOC, and nutrient contents through their incorporation into soil profile (Torres et al. 2021; Crespo et al. 2021). Our data on SOC stock, Ca2+ and K+ (See also ESM_1) corroborates our first hypothesis that green manure practice improve soil chemical properties. However, all plant species were not very efficient at improving Olsen’s available P. Our results emphasize that even the green manure practice needs additional inputs (chemical or organic fertilizers), since the soil P content is an important factor for the plant nutrition that aim to improve plant traits (Wang et al. 2021; Zhou et al. 2021).
For all the species tested here, we observed significantly soil quality index variability among plant species, which is consistent with previous studies (Gunasekaran et al. 2021; Santos et al. 2021). A variation from 84.24 to 628.65 in soil quality index has been associated with the following traits: root density, Olsen’s available P, shoot dry biomass, Ca2+, K+, and SOC stock (e.g., each traits have been influenced 53.94, 27.37, 5.43, 3.17, 2.15, and 1.73% of soil quality index variance, respectively), suggesting that soil quality index cannot be solely predicted based on above- or belowground biomass production (Gunasekaran et al. 2021; Islam et al. 2021). Observing the soil quality decay rate when associated with each plant species corroborates our second hypothesis that plant species elicits distinct traits after at least 3 consecutive years of its cultivation as described by Souza et al. (2015). This tended to be more evident on the SQk in 2019 compared with 2016. The 6th year was more affected than the 3rd year when soil P content were significantly reduced. These results corroborate other findings that soil quality responses may depend on several soil and plant traits (Yan et al. 2021; Zhang et al. 2021), and we cannot exclude the Liebig’s law (Ledari et al. 2021; Wu et al. 2021). The mechanisms responsible for the asymmetric effects of green manure on tropical soil traits are not fully understood (Ding et al. 2021; Peralta-Antonio et al. 2021). The asymmetry in soil traits over the studied years (Amede et al. 2021), or variations in the same year (Abera and Gerkabo 2020) has already been widely reported in the literature (Ma et al. 2021).
It is suggested, however, that the variation in plant traits such as allocation of nutrients, nutrient uptake, root traits (e.g., morphology, thickness, and development of root hair), nutritional requirements, and growth forms (annual vs. perennial), may account for some of these involved mechanisms (Freschet et al. 2020; Han et al. 2021). Plant species with high root density (e.g., N. wightii) can improve rootability (Restovich et al. 2019), and rhizodeposition around the rhizosphere by the allocation of C-rich compounds (Zhang et al. 2021; Kelly et al. 2022). Plant roots may influence the input of SOC into soil profile (Rossi et al. 2020). We found that N. wightii provided the highest values for soil quality index in 2019. In our plots, we observed that N. wightii developed a dense perennial root system during the six years of our experiment, in addition this plant species showed an extraordinary regrowth capacity (Acosta et al. 2020; Forstall-Sosa et al. 2020).
Our results highlighted the importance to take care with green manure practice following a monocropping system (Haruna et al. 2020). It may act as a driver for reducing the soil P content, especially if we are considering the effect of the green manure practice over 6 consecutive years. It has been widely reported that sandy soils with high organic matter inputs tends to increase soil P loss by vertical mobilization (Koutika et al. 2020; Kalkhajeh et al. 2021). This suggest that mechanisms related to the capacity of green manure to increase soil P leaching and soil quality decay rate are complex and depend on several factors such as root traits, soil P content, soil texture, plant species diversity, SOC stock, and time (Tran et al. 2021; Vandermoere et al. 2021; Zhang et al. 2021).