In this study, we examined whether women with early breast cancer and obesity have a different toxicity profile as compared to women without obesity when they receive chemotherapy with curative intent, and whether symptom experience impacts treatment completion. This is an important question because high BMI is common at BC diagnosis4 and women often experience weight gain after diagnosis1,2 which, in turn, can impact BC incidence, severity and outcomes45–50. The obesity-breast cancer link is of particular concern in states experiencing ever-rising obesity rates and within minoritized populations that have been especially burdened by the obesity epidemic4,51.
In our sample of 286 patients, 41% had obesity at BC diagnosis, with more than twice the rate of obesity observed among Black patients as compared to White. Unmarried patients also had significantly higher rates of obesity compared to married patients. Patients with obesity had higher mean number of comorbidities, most of them obesity related. There were no significant differences between patients with and without obesity with regard to BC stage or phenotype, although there were significant differences in specific chemotherapy regimens.
Prior to chemotherapy initiation, patients with obesity performed worse on the Short Physical Performance Battery and a higher proportion scored “lower cognition”. Patients with obesity reported more falls and being less physically active, but they also reported less alcohol consumption compared to patients with no obesity. Higher proportions of patients with obesity reported limitations in instrumental activities of daily living, more depression, lower tangible social support, and lower physical, social/family, and functional well-being. A higher proportion of women with no obesity as compared to patients with obesity were rated “robust” on the Carolina Frailty Index. Prior to start of chemotherapy, higher proportions of patients with obesity reported moderate, severe or very severe (MSVS) fatigue, dyspnea, arthralgia, and peripheral neuropathy. The findings would suggest a potential for patients with obesity to have greater difficulties with treatment toxicities as compared to patients without obesity.
In multivariable (MV) analyses of symptom severity during chemotherapy treatment adjusted for race and marital status, patients with obesity in fact had significantly higher risk for MSVS fatigue, dyspnea, arthralgia, peripheral neuropathy, edema of arms and legs, and abdominal pain. Similarly, in MV analyses of symptom interference with daily activities adjusted for race and marital status, patients with obesity were more likely to report greater interference for symptoms related to dyspnea, arthralgia, myalgia, edema of the limbs, abdominal pain, general pain, diarrhea, and peripheral neuropathy. As an exploratory finding, we also report that unmarried patients were more likely to report MSVS symptom severity for dyspnea, peripheral neuropathy, and edema of the limbs, as well as greater interference with daily living with regard to arthralgia, myalgia, peripheral neuropathy, and general pain.
Yet, despite higher risk for symptom severity and symptom interference with activities of daily living among patients with obesity, there were no significant inter-group differences in hospitalizations during chemotherapy or chemotherapy dose reductions, dose delays or early treatment discontinuation. This finding is corroborated by other studies showing no significant association between BMI and receipt of adjuvant chemotherapy3. This is a key finding, but does not detract from the overall caution that women with obesity reported greater sensitivity to chemotherapy side-effects.
Our study has some limitations. Our sample was limited to patients who agreed to participate in a moderate exercise program during chemotherapy. As such, both the patients and their treating clinicians deemed the patients able to participate in a self-directed walking intervention. Our sample also includes a high proportion of women with more than a college education. These “fitness” and education characteristics limit the generalizability of our sample to the larger population of women with early breast cancer scheduled to receive chemotherapy. However, this does not limit the overall purpose of our analysis, which is a comparison of similarly “fit” patients with and without obesity.
Our study contributes to the on-going exploration of the potential impact of obesity on cancer treatment. Because of the tradition of basing chemotherapy dosing on Body Surface Area52 (BSA) and concerns that under-dosing may undermine the effectiveness of cytotoxic agents53–55, best practice is for patients with obesity to receive higher doses of chemotherapy as compared to patients with no obesity10,56,57. One would expect higher doses in women with obesity to be associated with greater symptom severity leading, in turn, to reduced treatment completion, but this was not found in our study.
In our sample, there were no significant inter-group differences in breast cancer stage and phenotype. The proportion of patients receiving anthracycline-based regimens was somewhat higher in women with obesity (59%) compared to women without obesity (47%); however, the difference failed to reach statistical significance (p = 0.06). This may contribute to the higher rates of MSVS peripheral neuropathy reported among patients with obesity, along with their higher rate of peripheral neuropathy symptoms prior to chemotherapy initiation. Nevertheless, we found no significant differences in treatment completion between patients with or without obesity, nor in dose delays, dose reductions or hospitalizations during chemotherapy.
Our overall observation that women with obesity had greater fatigue, dyspnea, arthralgia, peripheral neuropathy, edema of the limbs, and abdominal pain most likely reflects the higher doses of chemotherapy they are receiving. Greater symptom severity among patients with obesity during treatment may also be a function of their greater symptom reports prior to chemotherapy initiation. Our findings point to the need for extra vigilance in monitoring chemotherapy toxicities in women with obesity treated with weight-appropriate doses, with the aim of offering interventions that may help them maintain quality of life as they continue receiving treatment at full dosage.