Prevalence of human alveolar echinococcosis in China: a systematic review and meta-analysis

doi:10.21203/rs.3.rs-16578/v1

Download PDF

Research article

Prevalence of human alveolar echinococcosis in China: a systematic review and meta-analysis

https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-16578/v1

This work is licensed under a CC BY 4.0 License

Journal Publication

published 14 Jul, 2020

Read the published version in BMC Public Health →

You are reading this older preprint version

Read the latest preprint version →

Background Human alveolar echinococcosis (HAE) is a severe parasitic disease that is a major public health concern. A review has indicated that new HAE cases in China account for 91% of the global HAE burden every year. Although there are a few studies and systematic reviews (SRs) on the prevalence of HAE in China, trends in the prevalence have not been estimated. Therefore, this study aims to describe the overall variation in the trend of HAE prevalence, and provide evidence for preventive measures in the future.

Methods Thirty-five eligible studies were retrieved from PubMed, Web of Science, EMBASE, CNKI, Wanfang Data, and VIP, and included in the SR and meta-analysis. An adjusted Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality checklist was used to evaluate study quality. We used the arcsine transformation to adjust the individual reported prevalences and also calculated the pooled HAE prevalence. We evaluated heterogeneity using the chi-square test and I 2 statistic, as well as random-effects models and fixed-effects models. We generated forest plots for the meta-analysis results and assessed publication bias of the studies using the Egger’s test and funnel plots. We conducted subgroup analyses, sensitivity analyses, and meta-regression analyses to analyze the source of heterogeneity and factors potentially influencing the prevalence of HAE.

Results The meta-analysis indicated that the pooled HAE prevalence in China was 0.96% (95% CI: 0.71 to 1.25%). Factors potentially influencing HAE prevalence are female sex (OR=1.60, 95% CI: 1.35 to 1.91), being ≥30 years of age (OR=4.72, 95% CI: 2.29 to 9.75), and being farmers and/or herdsmen (OR=2.54, 95% CI: 1.60 to 4.02). The results of the meta-regression analysis (R 2 =38.11%, P < 0.01) indicated that HAE prevalence is on a downward trend.

Conclusions HAE prevalence has decreased over time and maintained low levels after 2005 in China. This decline was influenced by the utilization of One Health strategies as intervention measures. Therefore, these One Health strategies should be used as references to formulate future programs for HAE control. More high-quality epidemiological investigations and surveillance programs ought to be conducted in order to improve HAE control in the future.

Health Policy

Human alveolar echinococcosis prevalence

systematic review and meta-analysis

One Health

disease control

Alveolar echinococcosis (AE) is a severe zoonosis caused by the larva of Echinococcus multilocularis that has an adverse impact on human and animal health [1]. Parasite eggs are excreted through the feces of the definitive hosts, which are usually foxes and dogs. Once the eggs are ingested by the intermediate hosts such as rodents and humans, oncospheres released from the eggs under the action of gastrointestinal digestion go on to form metacestodes in the liver or other organs. A large number of protoscolices (PSCs) are usually generated by metacestodes through asexual reproduction. After the definitive hosts ingest the viscera that include the metacestodes, the PSCs attach to the definitive hosts’ intestine wall and develop into adult worms to complete the life cycle [2]. As one of the intermediate hosts, humans can contract hydatid disease through contaminated food or water, with the liver primarily being the infected organ. If not treated in time, the disease will lead to jaundice, cirrhosis, and other clinical symptoms, which can result in liver failure or even death. The mortality of untreated human alveolar echinococcosis (HAE) patients or inadequately untreated patients is 90% at 10–15 years after diagnosis [3, 4]. Hence, HAE is also known as "the parasite cancer" [5].

HAE has become a global threat to public health [6–8]. There are 18,235 new cases of HAE every year in the world, with the disease burden reaching 666,433 disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) [9, 10]. In the past, it was generally believed that HAE cases were mainly distributed across the northern hemisphere, especially in Asia [11]. However, in recent years, new cases of HAE have been found in some European countries; the incidence of HAE has doubled in France and Germany [12–14]. Some regions of Canada have also reported cases of HAE [15]. China is one of the countries seriously affected by HAE, accounting for 91% of the global burden of new HAE cases every year [10]. The prevalence increased to 9.43% in Banma County, Qinghai in 2014 [16] and 3028 cases were reported in Shiqu County, Sichuan between 2015–2017 in China [17]. HAE has also become a burden in endemic regions and has constrained the development of animal husbandry in China [18].

Although a few studies and systematic reviews (SRs) have explored HAE in China, the trend in the variation of HAE prevalence remains unclear. As a consequence, it is important to depict the overall trend in the variation of HAE prevalence, which will help provide evidence for preventive measures and HAE studies in the future. Therefore, this SR and subsequent meta-analysis aim to estimate the characteristics and trends in the variation of HAE prevalence in China and to explore potential influencing factors.

Search strategy and study selection

The SR and meta-analysis were performed according to the guidelines of PRISMA [19]. The online search was carried out using 6 databases (PubMed, Web Of Science, EMBASE, CNKI, Wanfang Data, and VIP) with keywords and Boolean operators AND/OR: “((((((((alveolar echinococcosis) OR alveolococcosis) OR echinococcus multilocularis infection) OR alveolar hydatid disease) OR multilocular echinococcosis)) AND ((prevalence) OR epidemiology)) AND ((human OR people OR person OR man OR men OR women OR woman OR patient))) AND ((China) OR Chinese).” All the screened articles were published before December 1, 2019.

The study selection was performed independently by two researchers (XZW and GDD). Disagreements were resolved by consensus. First, we inspected the titles and abstracts of all the studies. Studies were included if they were screening studies, cross-sectional studies, case-control studies, and cohort studies regarding HAE in China. Subsequently, we browsed through all full-text articles. Studies were included if they used both imaging examinations (B-ultrasonography) and serological examinations as diagnostic methods for HAE [20, 21]. Studies were excluded if they had been published repeatedly with the same samples, had inaccessible full texts, or had no data on HAE prevalence in China. We also identified relevant papers from the reference lists of the articles for the meta-analysis.

Data extraction and quality assessment

We used Microsoft Excel (version 2016) to record data that included the first author, published year, language, years during which the study was conducted, study areas, the sample size, number of HAE patients, and patient demographic details (sex, age, occupation) for each of the studies included. All the data were extracted independently by two researchers (XZW and ML). Disagreements were resolved by consensus.

The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) checklist was used to evaluate the quality of the studies. Of the 11 items in the AHRQ checklist, two items were unsuitable for these studies: item 4 (“Indicate whether or not subjects were consecutive if not population-based”) and item 11 (“Clarify what follow-up, if any, was expected and the percentage of patients for which incomplete data or follow-up was obtained”). Therefore, 9 items were used to score the studies (Additional file 1). If an item was answered with a "yes," it was scored “1”; if it was answered with a "no or unclear," it was scored “0.” The quality of the studies was classified using a number system, where low-quality studies scored 0–2, medium-quality studies scored 3–5, and high-quality studies scored 6–9.

Statistical analysis

R software (version 3.6.1) was used for all analyses. The arcsine transformation was calculated for the prevalence of each study and the pooled prevalence of HAE was calculated as part of the meta-analysis. Heterogeneity was evaluated using the chi-square test and I² statistic. If the P-value＜0.10 and I² ≥ 50%, substantial heterogeneity between studies was indicated, and the random-effects model was used [21]; otherwise, we used the fixed-effects model. The results of the meta-analysis were presented using forest plots, and publication bias of the studies was assessed by the Egger’s test and funnel plots. Subgroup analyses, sensitivity analyses, and meta-regression analyses were performed to analyze the source of heterogeneity and factors potentially influencing the prevalence of HAE.

Ethical Approval

Not applicable.

Literature search results

Based on the screening strategy, 426 studies were considered, of which 87 were from Chinese databases. Ninety-seven studies that were duplicates were excluded by the document management software NoteExpress (version 3.2). After screening the titles and abstracts, 254 studies were removed. The full texts of the remaining 75 papers were then screened by the selection criteria. A total of 35 eligible articles were included in the meta-analysis after screening, according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria. The details of the selection process are shown in Fig. 1. Due to the study discussed in literature 7 being conducted across two time periods (1997 and 2003), we treated the data from the two periods as two different studies (literature 7-1, 7-2) in the meta-analysis. Similarly, the data for the study discussed in literature 33 were acquired from 6 areas (Gansu, Ningxia, Qinghai, Sichuan, Tibet, and Xinjiang), therefore literature 33 was regarded as 6 separate studies (literature33-1, 33-2, 33-3, 33-4, 33-5, 33-6).

Basic information of included literatures

Of the 41 selected studies (the splitting up of literature 7 and literature 33 were included), 11 (27%) were in English and 30 (73%) in Chinese (Table 1). The periods of time during which these studies were carried out and published were from 1991 to 2016 and from 1992 to 2019, respectively. All surveys were cross-sectional studies and were conducted in 6 provinces in China: 9 in Gansu, 3 in Ningxia, 8 in Qinghai, 8 in Sichuan, 9 in Tibet, and 4 in Xinjiang. A total of 2,032,811 subjects were included, of which 7522 were HAE patients. Table 1 shows the general features of the included studies.

Table 1 List of included articles in the meta-analysis

Literature quality evaluation

The quality of the cross-sectional studies was evaluated by the adjusted AHRQ checklist (9 items). The results (Table 1) showed that there were 7 low-quality studies (17%), 27 medium-quality studies (66%), and 7 high-quality studies (17%). The details of the quality evaluation were shown in Additional file 2.

Meta-analysis of the prevalence of HAE in China

Substantial heterogeneity was observed among the included studies (I²=100%, P<0.01, Fig. 2), which is common in most meta-analyses studying prevalence. Therefore, we used a random-effects model to calculate the pooled prevalence. The result indicated that the pooled prevalence of HAE in China was 0.96% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.71 to 1.25%) (Table 2). The funnel plot was shown in the Additional file 3 and the Egger’s test did not indicate any publication bias (P=0.06). The sensitivity analysis indicated that despite excluding studies, the pooled prevalence remained stable (Additional file 4).

All the studies were divided into 6 groups based on the geographical areas for the subgroup analysis. The prevalences of HAE in these 6 areas were statistically significant (P<0.01, Table 2). The highest prevalence of HAE was in Sichuan (2.03%, 95% CI: 1.30 to 2.92%), while the lowest was in Xinjiang (0.013%, 95% CI: 0.001 to 0.036%). There were not enough studies based in Xinjiang (4 studies) and Ningxia (3 studies), therefore it is possible the pooled prevalences of these two areas may not be accurate.

Table 2 Meta-analysis of HAE prevalence in China

Factors potentially influencing HAE prevalence

Three factors potentially affecting HAE prevalence were considered in our meta-analysis: sex, age, and occupation. Due to the small number of articles addressing “age” and “occupation” (<10 articles), publication bias was only evaluated for “sex.” Heterogeneity was indicated within all groups (sex, age, and occupation) (Additional file 5), with statistically significant differences observed (P<0.01) (Table 2).

Of the included studies, 11 articles (1-3, 8-11, 13, 14, 18, 22) reported data on sex in their study populations. The meta-analysis showed that the prevalence of women with HAE (3.47%, 95% CI: 2.69 to 4.34%) was higher than that of men with HAE (2.14%, 95% CI: 1.55 to 2.82%) (Table 2). The overall pooled odds ratio (OR) for women with HAE was 1.60 (95% CI: 1.35 to 1.91, P＜0.01). After excluding literature 1 from the sensitivity analysis, we found that the heterogeneity reduced (I²=27%, P=0.20), and the adjusted OR was 1.50 (95% CI: 1.30 to 1.73, P＜0.01), as shown in Additional file 6. The funnel plot (Additional file 3) and Egger’s test did not indicate the existence of publication bias.

Five articles (1, 13, 14, 16, 22) had data on the age of the subjects. The prevalence of HAE was higher in those whose age was ≥30 years old (6.41%, 95% CI: 3.50 to 10.12%) than those whose age was <30 years old (1.64%, 95% CI: 0.36 to 3.83%) (Table 2). Being in the ≥30 years old age group was associated with an increase in HAE prevalence (OR=4.72, 95% CI: 2.29 to 9.75, P＜0.01). The sensitivity analysis (Additional file 7) indicated that the OR was relatively stable when any study was excluded.

The occupations of the subjects were investigated in 4 articles (3, 9, 18, 22). The analysis showed that HAE prevalence was higher in farmers and/or herdsmen (2.90%, 95% CI: 1.82 to 4.21%) than in people in other occupations (1.20%, 95% CI: 0.63 to 1.94%), and the OR was 2.54 (95% CI: 1.60 to 4.02, P＜0.01). The sensitivity analysis indicated that heterogeneity decreased (I²=50%, P=0.14) when literature 22 was excluded; the adjusted OR was 3.01 (95% CI: 2.02 to 4.48, P＜0.01) (Additional file 8).

Trend in the variation of HAE prevalence in China

Fig. 3 shows the trend in the variation of HAE over time. The overall HAE prevalence has remained low since 2005—despite its resurgence in prevalence from 2005–2010, it remained stable after 2010. Additionally, the meta-regression analysis indicated that there was negative correlation between the time period during which the studies were conducted and the HAE prevalence in China (R²=38.11%, P < 0.01) (Fig. 4).

This SR and meta-analysis included 41 studies published in 1992–2019, including 2,032,811 subjects and 7,522 HAE patients. All included studies were cross-sectional studies, however, only seven were high-quality (17%). This means that researchers need to improve the quality of their studies for more reliable results. In the process of the literature search, we found that although researchers have carried out epidemiological investigations on HAE in recent years, there were very few nationwide epidemiological studies [22]. Therefore, this SR and meta-analysis summarized the HAE prevalence and provided epidemiological data about HAE in China for future prevention.

In China, we found that the overall HAE prevalence was 0.96% (95% CI: 0.71 to 1.25%). The subgroup analysis indicated that there were 6 provinces (Table 2) with high HAE prevalence, which aligns with results from another study [10]. Of the 6 provinces, the prevalences in Sichuan and Qinghai were higher than in other provinces; since most of the included studies in Sichuan and Qinghai were conducted in communities residing in Tibetan autonomous prefectures, it is possible the higher prevalence is related to the proximity to the Tibetan plateau [23]. The low-temperature climate caused by the high altitude in the Tibetan plateau makes survival easier for the E. multilocularis eggs in the environment, which is conducive to the spread of HAE [22]; additionally, certain religious beliefs such as not killing dogs, and the poor health habits of Tibetan residents also allow for the spread of HAE [24]. However, the results of the meta-analysis indicated that the HAE prevalence in Tibet was relatively low (0.19%, 95% CI: 0.13 to 0.25%). This may be due to the Tibetan studies being conducted after 2010, when the national prevention and control project of echinococcosis was popularized in China. It is indicated that prevention measures should be implemented in the Tibetan plateau as well as the surrounding areas.

Female sex, being ≥30 years of age, and working as a farmer and/or herdsman were the three influencing factors discussed in the context of HAE prevalence in our meta-analysis. A higher odds of HAE infection was observed in women (OR=1.60, 95% CI: 1.35 to 1.91) than men. This may be due to the women being responsible for feeding dogs in some Tibetan farming and pastoral areas, leading to frequent contact with a definitive host, which would explain the higher risk of HAE in women [25]. Women are also more involved in housework, such as collecting yak feces and sheep-shearing. As a result, they are exposed to possible contaminants in dog feces and/or E. multilocularis eggs [26, 27]. Thus, specific living habits are a likely cause for the increase in the potential HAE risk in women. Five articles indicated that being ≥30 years of age increased the odds of an HAE infection (OR=4.72, 95% CI: 2.29, 9.75). This may be because older people have a greater chance of being infected [28, 29], and the long incubation period (5–15 years) of HAE can lead to a delayed onset of clinical symptoms [2, 30], which would make the disease more detectable in age groups ≥30 years. Sex and age are typically regarded as confounding factors, therefore it is important for investigators to distinguish confounders with well-designed studies and analyses. Regardless, it is still important for concerned departments to focus on women and individuals older than 30 years for the prevention of HAE. Regarding occupation, the odds of HAE infection were higher in farmers and herdsmen (OR=2.54, 95% CI: 1.60 to 4.02) than in people in other occupations. It is assumed that farmers and herdsmen are more easily exposed to dogs as a result of their occupation, which could increase the risk of infection. Yang et al. presented a similar result [31].

The sensitivity analysis indicated that literature 1 likely caused heterogeneity in the 11 articles addressing sex. The OR decreased to 1.50 (95% CI: 1.30 to 1.73) and the heterogeneity decreased (I²=27%, P=0.20) when literature 1 was excluded. With regards to the sensitivity analysis for articles concerning occupations, literature 22 was regarded as one of the sources of heterogeneity. The heterogeneity decreased (I²=50%, P=0.14) after literature 22 was excluded, and the OR shifted to 3.01 (95% CI: 2.02 to 4.48). The sensitivity analysis for age suggested that the heterogeneity was not from any of the articles and that the pooled OR was stable (Additional file 7).

Compared to earlier years, the overall HAE prevalence has remained low since 2005, and there has been no indication that it has surged since 2010 (Fig. 3). However, it is necessary to keep monitoring levels through continuous surveillance and investigation in the future [8]. Additionally, the meta-regression analysis suggested that there was a negative correlation between the time period during which the studies were conducted and the HAE prevalence, which corroborates the variation trend of HAE prevalence. A national echinococcosis control project has been carried out in China since 2005 [2], with new control programs and targets being formulated every five years since 2010 [32]. The measures of these programs were developed from three aspects: the population (screening and treatment), animals (dog management and deworming), and the environment (drinking water safety and rodent control). Based on the declining trend in HAE prevalence, it is proven that these prevention and control measures were effective and have resulted in the HAE prevalence being effectively controlled. Given the massive size of population, the magnitude of the susceptible population in China is still higher than in other countries [10, 22]. As a result of this, we should continue to implement One Health strategies that focus on the human control measures and establish a continuous surveillance system for HAE prevention [33-35].

In this SR and meta-analysis, we found that the prevalence of HAE in most studies was close to 0. This would have resulted in the confidence intervals spanning negative numbers, if the prevalence was directly used in this meta-analysis [36]. Therefore, the arcsine transformation was performed on the prevalence reported in each study to make the pooled results more reasonable. This method of data transformation also applies to other meta-analyses addressing disease prevalence. However, the literature included in this meta-analysis has substantial heterogeneity that may cause the pooled results to be inaccurate. Additionally, there was limited information available about HAE for data extraction, leading to insufficient information for the subgroup analysis.

The prevalence of HAE varied in different areas in China. We found female sex, being ≥30 years of age, and working as a farmer and/or herdsman were the three influencing factors of HAE prevalence in our meta-analysis. It is important to focus on these people who may be with high risk of prevalence. We also described trends in the variation of HAE prevalence in China. HAE continues to pose a threat to public health in some regions of China, and several echinococcosis prevention programs utilizing One Health control strategies have been proposed to combat it. The One Health strategies emphasize interdisciplinary, cross-sectoral, and trans-regional cooperation as well as comprehensive control measures focused on the human-animal-environment relationship. Since One Health strategies were utilized for the preventive measures, HAE prevalence has been on a downward trend and has maintained low levels after 2010. Therefore, these One Health approaches should be used as reference points to formulate programs. High-quality epidemiological investigations and continuous surveillance programs ought to be conducted in the future in order to establish more measures for HAE control.

AE, Alveolar echinococcosis; PSCs, protoscolices; HAE, human alveolar echinococcosis; DALYs, disability-adjusted life years; SR, systematic review; AHRQ, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality; OR, odds ratio; CI, confidence interval

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Not applicable.

Consent to publish

Not applicable.

Availability of data and materials

All the data associated with this article are included in the supplementary information files.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Funding

This study was supported by the Guangdong Provincial Science and Technology Project (2018B020241002) and the National Key Research and Development Plan (2017YFD0501301). The funds had no role in the design of the study, data collection, analysis, and interpretation of data.

Authors' contributions

JH L, WZ J, XZ W conceived and designed the study. XZ W, GD D, M L performed the literature research/quality evaluation/statistical analysis. XZ W, WZ J, ZM G contributed to the writing and revising of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Acknowledgments

We acknowledge all the members of the State Key Laboratory of Veterinary Etiological Biology, Lanzhou Veterinary Research Institute, who helped to revise this manuscript. We also would like to thank Editage (www.editage.cn) for English language editing.

Authors’ Information

*Correspondence: Zhongmin Guo: [email protected]; Jiahai Lu: [email protected]

¹School of Public Health, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, Guangdong Province, China. ² State Key Laboratory of Veterinary Etiological Biology, Key Laboratory of Veterinary Parasitology of Gansu Province, Lanzhou Veterinary Research Institute, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Lanzhou, Gansu Province, China. ³ Experimental Animal Center, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, Guangdong Province, China. ⁴Key Laboratory for Tropical Diseases Control of Ministry of Education, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, Guangdong Province, China. ⁵One Health Research Centre, School of Public Health, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, Guangdong Province, China

Eckert J, Deplazes P. Biological, epidemiological, and clinical aspects of echinococcosis, a zoonosis of increasing concern. Clin Microbiol Rev. 2004; 17(1):107-135.
Wen H, Vuitton L, Tuxun T, Li J, Vuitton DA, Zhang W, et al. Echinococcosis: Advances in the 21st Century. Clinical Microbiology Reviews. 2019; 32(2).
McManus DP, Gray DJ, Zhang W, Yang Y. Diagnosis, treatment, and management of echinococcosis. BMJ : British Medical Journal. 2012; 344:e3866.
Jenkins DJ. WHO/OIE manual on Echinococcosis in humans and animals: a public health problem of global concern. International Journal for Parasitology. 2001; 31(14):1717-1718.
Cheng Z, Liu F, Li X, Dai M, Wu J, Guo X, et al. EGF-mediated EGFR/ERK signaling pathway promotes germinative cell proliferation in Echinococcus multilocularis that contributes to larval growth and development. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2017; 11(2):e0005418.
Thompson RC, McManus DP. Towards a taxonomic revision of the genus Echinococcus. 2002; 18(10):452-457.
Yang YR, Craig PS, Sun T, Vuitton DA, Giraudoux P, Jones MK, et al. Echinococcosis in Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region, northwest China. TRANSACTIONS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY OF TROPICAL MEDICINE AND HYGIENE. 2008; 102(4):319-328.
Han X, Kim J-G, Wang H, Cai H, Ma X, Duc Hieu D, et al. Survey of echinococcoses in southeastern Qinghai Province, China, and serodiagnostic insights of recombinant Echinococcus granulosus antigen B isoforms. PARASITES & VECTORS. 2019; 12(323).
Budke CM, Jiamin Q, Qian W, Torgerson PR. Economic effects of echinococcosis in a disease-endemic region of the Tibetan Plateau. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene. 2005; 73(1):2-10.
Torgerson PR, Keller K, Magnotta M, Ragland N. The global burden of alveolar echinococcosis. PLoS neglected tropical diseases. 2010; 4(6):e722.
Torgerson PR, Budke CM. Echinococcosis--an international public health challenge. Research in veterinary science. 2003; 74(3):191-202.
Deplazes P, Rinaldi L, Alvarez Rojas CA, Torgerson PR, Harandi MF, Romig T, et al. Global Distribution of Alveolar and Cystic Echinococcosis. Advances in parasitology. 2017; 95:315-493.
Vuitton DA, Demonmerot F, Knapp J, Richou C, Grenouillet F, Chauchet A, et al. Clinical epidemiology of human AE in Europe. Vet Parasitol. 2015; 213(3-4):110-120.
Gottstein B, Stojkovic M, Vuitton DA, Millon L, Marcinkute A, Deplazes P. Threat of alveolar echinococcosis to public health--a challenge for Europe. Trends Parasitol. 2015; 31(9):407-412.
Massolo A, Liccioli S, Budke C, Klein C. Echinococcus multilocularis in North America: the great unknown. Parasite. 2014; 21:73.
Ren L, Zhang L, Zhou F, Fan H, Deng Y, Wang H, et al. Epidemiological investigation on hepatic hydatid disease in Banma County of Guoluo Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture of Qinghai Province. Chin J Dis Control Prev. 2016; 20(10):1032-1035.
Yu W, Wang Q, Liao S, Zhong B, Liu L, Huang Y, et al. Echinococcosis prevalence in humans in Shiqu county of Sichuan in 2017. J Prev Med Inf. 2018; 34(05):545-549.
Restrepo AMC, Yang YR, McManus DP, Gray DJ, Barnes TS, Williams GM, et al. Spatial prediction of the risk of exposure to Echinococcus spp. among schoolchildren and dogs in Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region, People's Republic of China. GEOSPATIAL HEALTH. 2018; 13(6441):143-156.
Shamseer L, Moher D, Clarke M, Ghersi D, Liberati A, Petticrew M, et al. Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015: elaboration and explanation. BMJ. 2015; 349(1):g7647-g7647.
Tamarozzi F, Covini I, Mariconti M, Narra R, Tinelli C, De Silvestri A, et al. Comparison of the Diagnostic Accuracy of Three Rapid Tests for the Serodiagnosis of Hepatic Cystic Echinococcosis in Humans. Plos Neglected Tropical Diseases. 2016; 10(2):e0004444.
Possenti A, Manzano-Román R, Sánchez-Ovejero C, Boufana B, La Torre G, Siles-Lucas M, et al. Potential risk factors associated with human cystic echinococcosis: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. PLoS neglected tropical diseases. 2016; 10(11):e0005114.
Wu W, Wang H, Wang Q, Zhou X, Wang L, Zheng C, et al. A nationwide sampling survey on echinococcosis in China during 2012-2016. Chin J Parasitol Parasit Dis 2018; 36(1):1-14.
Zhang W, Zhang Z, Wu W, Shi B, Li J, Zhou X, et al. Epidemiology and control of echinococcosis in central Asia, with particular reference to the People's Republic of China. Acta Trop. 2015; 141(Pt B):235-243.
Wang Q, Huang Y, Huang L, Yu W, He W, Zhong B, et al. Review of risk factors for human echinococcosis prevalence on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau, China: a prospective for control options. Infectious diseases of poverty. 2014; 3(3):(29 January 2014)-(2029 January 2014).
Raoul F, Hegglin D, Giraudoux P. Trophic ecology, behaviour and host population dynamics in Echinococcus multilocularis transmission. Veterinary parasitology. 2015; 213(3-4):162-171.
Wang Q, Qiu J, Yang W, Schantz PM, Raoul F, Craig PS, et al. Socioeconomic and behavior risk factors of human alveolar echinococcosis in Tibetan communities in Sichuan, People's Republic of China. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2006; 74(5):856-862.
Cai H, Guan Y, Ma X, Wang L, Wang H, Su G, et al. Epidemiology of echinococcosis among schoolchildren in Golog Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture, Qinghai, China. AMERICAN JOURNAL OF TROPICAL MEDICINE AND HYGIENE. 2017; 96(3):674-679.
Conraths FJ, Probst C, Possenti A, Boufana B, Saulle R, La Torre G, et al. Potential risk factors associated with human alveolar echinococcosis: Systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2017; 11(7):e0005801.
Xue C, Wu W, Han S, Zheng C, Wang Y, Wang L, et al. Prevalence and influencing factors of hydatid disease among children in Tibet Autonomous Region. Chinese Journal of Parasitology and Parasitic Diseases. 2018; 36(1):20-25.
Kern P, Menezes Da Silva A, Akhan O, Müllhaupt B, Vizcaychipi KA, Budke C, et al. The Echinococcoses: Diagnosis, Clinical Management and Burden of Disease. Advances in parasitology. 2017; 96:259-369.
Yang S, Li M, Tian T, Zhao J, Wu W. Epidemiological characteristics of human hydatidosis and risk factors in Habahe County, Xinjiang. Disease Surveillance. 2015; 30(6):485-488.
Wang L. Prevention and control of echinococcosis: estimation of 12th Five-Year Plan and the program of 13th Five-Year Plan. China Animal Health. 2017; 19(7):13-19.
Giraudoux P, Zhao Y, Afonso E, Yan H, Knapp J, Rogan MT, et al. Long-term retrospective assessment of a transmission hotspot for human alveolar echinococcosis in mid-west China. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2019; 13(8):e0007701.
Del CM, Hugo MC, Salvitti JC, Uchiumi L, Sustercic J, Panomarenko H, et al. Early diagnosis, treatment and follow-up of cystic echinococcosis in remote rural areas in Patagonia: Impact of ultrasound training of non-specialists. PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases. 2012; 6(1).
Merino V, Westgard CM, Bayer AM, García PJ. Knowledge, attitudes, and practices regarding cystic echinococcosis and sheep herding in Peru: a mixed-methods approach. Bmc Veterinary Research. 2017; 13(1):213.
Barendregt JJ, Doi SA, Lee YY, Norman RE, Vos T. Meta-analysis of prevalence. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health. 2013; 67(11):974-978.
Craig PS, Deshan L, MacPherson CN, Dazhong S, Reynolds D, Barnish G, et al. A large focus of alveolar echinococcosis in central China. Lancet. 1992; 340(8823):826-831.
Craig PS, Giraudoux P, Shi D, Bartholomot B, Barnish G, Delattre P, et al. An epidemiological and ecological study of human alveolar echinococcosis transmission in south Gansu, China. Acta Trop. 2000; 77(2):167-177.
Qiu J, He J, Zhang Z, Chen X, Liu F, Peter S, et al. Epidemiological study on human hydatidosis in Tibetan region of western Sichuan. Chinese Journal of Zoonoses. 2000; 16(2):77-80.
He D, Wang H. A report on the epidemiological evaluation of hydatid disease in Zeku County, Qinghai Province. ENDEMIC DISEASES BULLETIN. 2001; 16(4):36-38.
Wang Q, Qiu J, Schantz P, He J, Ito A, Liu F. Investigation of risk factors for development of human hydatidosis among households raising livestock in Tibetan areas of western Sichuan province. Chinese Journal of Parasitology and Parasitic Diseases. 2001; 19(2):93-96.
Schantz PM, Wang H, Qiu J, Liu FJ, Saito E, Emshoff A, et al. Echinococcosis on the Tibetan Plateau: prevalence and risk factors for cystic and alveolar echinococcosis in Tibetan populations in Qinghai Province, China. PARASITOLOGY. 2003; 127S:S109-S120.
Shi D, Zhao Y, Guo Z, Bao G, LI F, Chen G, et al. Analysis of the prevalence and related factors of alveolar echinococcosis in Dingxi Area of Gansu Province. Chinese Journal of Zoonoses. 2004; 20(9):815-818.
Li TY, Qiu JM, Yang W, Craig PS, Chen XW, Xiao N, et al. Echinococcosis in Tibetan populations, Western Sichuan Province, China. EMERGING INFECTIOUS DISEASES. 2005; 11(12):1866-1873.
Yu W, Li D, Chen X, Yang W, Qiu J. Epidemiological survey on human echinococcosis in four counties of Gaizi Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture, Sichuan. Parasitoses and Infectious Diseases. 2005; 3(4):170-172.
Wang H, Zhang J, PM S, Ito A, Craig PS, Wu X, et al. Epidemiologic survey and analysis on echinococcosis in humans and animals from 1995 to 2005 in Qinghai province. Chinese Journal of Zoonoses. 2006; 22(12):1129-1134.
Yang YR, Ellis M, Sun T, Li Z, Liu X, Vuitton DA, et al. Unique family clustering of human echinococcosis cases in a chinese community. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2006; 74(3):487-494.
Yang YR, Sun T, Li Z, Zhang J, Teng J, Liu X, et al. Community surveys and risk factor analysis of human alveolar and cystic echinococcosis in Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region, China. BULLETIN OF THE WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION. 2006; 84(9):714-721.
Wu X, Wang H, Chuan Z, Sen D, Ma X, Liu P, et al. Epidemiologic survey and studies on echinococcosis in humans in Jiuzhi county of Qinghai province. Chinese Journal of Zoonoses. 2007; 23(8):813-815.
Wu X, Wang H, Zhang J, Ma X, Liu Y, Han X, et al. An epidemiological survey on echinococcosis in Zhiduo County of Qinghai Province. Chin J Parasitol Parasit Dis. 2007; 25(3):229-231.
Han X, Wang H, Cai H, Ma X, Liu Y, Wei B, et al. Epidemiological survey on echinococcosis in Darlag County of Qinghai Province. Chin J Parasitol Parasit Dis. 2009; 27(01):22-26.
Wang G, Feng X, Chu X, Er X, Amina, Zhou J, et al. Epidemiologieal study on human echinococcosis in Hobukesar Mongolian Autonomous County of Xinjiang. Chin J Endemiol. 2009; 28(2):214-217.
Li T, Chen X, Zhen R, Qiu J, Qiu D, Xiao N, et al. Widespread co-endemicity of human cystic and alveolar echinococcosis on the eastern Tibetan Plateau, northwest Sichuan/southeast Qinghai, China. Acta Trop. 2010; 113(3):248-256.
Shi D, Li W, Bao G. Approach to risk factor of human behavior on epidemic of alveolar echinococcosis. Chin J Public Health. 2003; 19(8):81-82.
Dao J, Liu J, Lu M, Wang Z. Epidemiological analysis on echinococcosis in Ganzi Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture of Sichuan Province, 1962-2012. Parasitoses and Infectious Diseases. 2015; 13(2):73-80.
Feng X, Qi X, Yang L, Duan X, Fang B, Gongsang Q, et al. Human cystic and alveolar echinococcosis in the Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR), China. J Helminthol. 2015; 89(6):671-679.
Ma X, Wang H, Han X, Zhang J, Liu Y, Zhao Y, et al. Survey on Echinococcosis in Maqing County of Qinghai Province. Chin J Parasitol Parasit Dis. 2015; 33(04):269-272.
QI X, Feng X, Freya van K, Li H, Song T, Duan X, et al. Epidemic status of echinococcus granulosus and risk factors of human cycstic echinococcosis in Hoboksar Mongolian Autonomous County of Xinjiang. Chin J Endemiol. 2015; 34(1):56-60.
Wang Q, Shang W, Zhao C, Zhang S, Lu S, Liu X. Epidemic status of echinococcosis in Gannan Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture of Gansu Province during 2007-2011. Chin J Parasitol Parasit Dis. 2015; 33(01):45-48.
Ma X, Tang D, Pei H, Wang A. Epidemiologic survey of hydatid disease in Zhang county, Gansu province. Bulletin of Disease Control and Prevention. 2016; 31(6):35-37.
Baima Y, Wu W, He R, GongSang q, Kang Z, SuoLang w, et al. Prevalence of echinococcosis in Shannan City. Chin J Parasitol Parasit Dis. 2018; 36(01):63-67+74.
Bianyang z, Li B, Chen W-q, Wang D, Xiao D, Bian B, et al. Current prevalence of echinococcosis in Shigatse City. Chin J Parasitol Parasit Dis. 2018; 36(1):80-86.
Chen W, Zhang Y, Gongsang Q, Wu W, Han S, Xue C, et al. Analysis of hydatid disease cases in Tibet Autonomous Region. Chinese Journal of Parasitology and Parasitic Diseases. 2018; 36(1):43-53.
Danzhen w, Xue C, Gongsang Q-z, Ai J, Luo Z, Danzeng Q, et al. Analysis of echinococcosis prevalence in Nagqu Prefecture. Chin J Parasitol Parasit Dis. 2018; 36(1):47-53.
Gongsang Q, Li B, Chen W, Ga S, Suolang W, Wang D, et al. Prevalence of echinococcosis in Changdu City. Chin J Parasitol Parasit Dis. 2018; 36(1):68-74.
Wang D, He R, Gongsang q, Xiao D, Suolang w, Xue L, et al. Prevalence of echinococcosis in Nyingchi City. Chin J Parasitol Parasit Dis. 2018; 36(01):75-79.
Xiao D, Wu W, Xue L, GongSang q, Ciren l, Bianba z, et al. Prevalence of hydatid disease in Ali Prefecture. Chin J Parasitol Parasit Dis. 2018; 36(01):54-57.

Table 1 List of included articles in the meta-analysis
Study ID	Reference	Language	Conducted year	Study areas	Sample size	Cases	Score
1	[ 37]	English	1991	Gansu	1312	65	4
2	[ 38]	English	1997	Gansu	2482	84	6
3	[ 39]	Chinese	1998	Sichuan	3999	76	4
4	[ 40]	Chinese	2000	Qinghai	1046	3	3
5	[ 41]	English	1998	Sichuan	1858	43	2
6	[ 42]	English	1998	Qinghai	3703	29	5
7-1	[ 43]	Chinese	1997	Gansu	3116	113	2
7-2	[ 43]	Chinese	2003	Gansu	393	6	2
8	[ 44]	English	2002	Sichuan	3199	198	3
9	[ 45]	Chinese	2003	Sichuan	3018	37	3
10	[ 26]	English	2003	Sichuan	7138	223	3
11	[ 46]	Chinese	2005	Qinghai	6528	125	2
12	[ 47]	English	2002	Ningxia	159	8	3
13	[ 48]	English	2003	Ningxia	4773	96	5
14	[ 49]	Chinese	2005	Qinghai	1549	39	3
15	[ 50]	Chinese	2006	Qinghai	979	2	2
16	[ 51]	Chinese	2007	Qinghai	1723	141	3
17	[ 52]	Chinese	2007	Xinjiang	712	2	2
18	[ 53]	English	2008	Sichuan	10186	311	3
19	[ 54]	Chinese	1997	Gansu	2485	86	3
20	[ 55]	Chinese	2009	Sichuan	538208	4386	3
21	[ 56]	English	2007	Tibet	1511	11	2
22	[ 57]	Chinese	2008	Qinghai	1561	34	3
23	[ 58]	Chinese	2013	Xinjiang	532	2	4
24	[ 59]	Chinese	2011	Gansu	257823	3	3
25	[ 31]	Chinese	2013	Xinjiang	42356	2	3
26	[ 60]	Chinese	2015	Gansu	118476	40	5
27	[ 61]	Chinese	2016	Tibet	10287	3	4
28	[ 62]	Chinese	2016	Tibet	21497	26	4
29	[ 63]	Chinese	2016	Tibet	77049	136	5
30	[ 64]	Chinese	2016	Tibet	11897	33	4
31	[ 65]	Chinese	2016	Tibet	14289	39	5
32	[ 66]	Chinese	2016	Tibet	5016	5	5
33-1	[ 22]	Chinese	2016	Sichuan	112605	301	6
33-2		Chinese	2016	Tibet	80384	153	6
33-3		Chinese	2016	Gansu	198131	10	6
33-4		Chinese	2016	Qinghai	109122	573	6
33-5		Chinese	2016	Ningxia	62348	13	6
33-6		Chinese	2016	Xinjiang	302121	24	6
34	[ 67]	Chinese	2016	Tibet	4740	13	4
35	[ 33]	English	2006	Gansu	2500	28	4

Table 2 Meta-analysis of HAE prevalence in China
Groups	Number of studies	Sample size	Prevalence,%(95%CI)	I²,%	P heterogeneity	P difference	Odds ratio(95%CI)	P Eggers’s test
Overall	41	2032811	0.96(0.71-1.25)	100	＜0.01			0.06
Areas						<0.01
Gansu	9	586718	1.24(0.81-1.75)	99	＜0.01			-
Ningxia	3	67280	1.49(0.02-5.19)	99	＜0.01			-
Qinghai	8	126211	1.55(0.65-2.82)	99	＜0.01			-
Sichuan	8	680211	2.03(1.30-2.92)	100	＜0.01			-
Tibet	9	226670	0.19(0.13-0.25)	86	＜0.01			-
Xinjiang	4	345721	0.013(0.001-0.036)	75	＜0.01			-
Sex						<0.01
female	11	22595	3.47(2.69-4.34)	91	＜0.01		1.60 (1.35-1.91)	0.59
male	11	23147	2.14(1.55-2.82)	91	＜0.01		-	0.98
Age group						<0.01
≥30 years	5	4720	6.41(3.50-10.12)	95	＜0.01		4.72(2.29-9.75)	-
＜30 years	5	6198	1.64(0.36-3.83)	96	＜0.01		-	-
Occupation						<0.01
farmer and/or herdsman	4	9987	2.90(1.82-4.21)	90	＜0.01		2.54(1.60-4.02)	-
others	4	8777	1.20(0.63-1.94)	86	＜0.01		-	-

Download PDF

Journal Publication

published 14 Jul, 2020

Read the published version in BMC Public Health →

Review #2 received at journal
19 Mar, 2020
Editorial decision: Major revision
19 Mar, 2020
Review #1 received at journal
15 Mar, 2020
Editor assigned by journal
05 Mar, 2020
Reviewers invited by journal
05 Mar, 2020
Reviewer #1 agreed at journal
05 Mar, 2020
Reviewer #2 agreed at journal
05 Mar, 2020
Submission checks completed at journal
04 Mar, 2020
Editor invited by journal
04 Mar, 2020

You are reading this older preprint version

Read the latest preprint version →

Prevalence of human alveolar echinococcosis in China: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Status:

Journal Publication

Version 1

Abstract

Figures

Background

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusions

Abbreviations

Declarations

References

Tables

Supplementary Files

Status:

Journal Publication

Version 1