In this study, we found no significant association between CCR5 SNP genotype and infant virological failure. This is similar to two early Kenyan studies by Katz et al 2008, and John et al 2001. who found no significant differences in plasma HIV loads by CCR5 promoter genotype among pregnant and breast feeding mothers.
The relationship between CCR5 promoter polymorphisms and HIV disease progression has been extensively studied and sound associations between certain CCR5 SNPs and HIV disease progression have been reported (12). But, most paediatric genetic studies of this kind have been conducted among the Caucasian and Asian origins and less remains explored in the African race, in particular Uganda. Moreover, the few studies conducted in sub-Saharan Africa have used allele specific-PCR or amplification refractory mutation system (ARMS-PCR) for SNP typing (9, 10), a genotypic method unable to detect novel SNPs as its biased to capture only known ones (13). Our study used capillary electrophoresis (Sanger sequencing) to characterise and determine CCR5 promoter polymorphisms including novel mutations that could be associated with persistent viremia or viral non-suppression among HIV-1 infected infants on combination antiretroviral therapy. Indeed, we report for the first time, four novel CCR5 promoter SNPs observed in our study population including CCR5 (58227G/A, 58636A/G, 59802A/C and 60024A/G). Closer analysis of these SNPs reveal interesting features, for instance, the first pair (58227G/A, 58636A/G) and last pair (59802A/C, 60024A/G) sit up-stream and down-stream of the previously reported SNPs respectively. The last pair seems to be in a linkage disequilibrium as it occurred in same frequencies and in the same infant IDs. In addition, the same SNP pair showed relatively higher odds of infant virological failure at both six and 12 months. A study by Lu, Sheng, et al. 2012, found a complete linkage disequilibrium between CCR2-V641 with SNPs CCR5 58755G/A, 59029G/A, 59353C/T and 59402G/A in a Northern Han Chinese population, suggesting that the two SNPs may jointly influence the process of HIV-1 infection.
6 of the 10 CCR5 SNPs including 58934T/G, 59029G/A, 59353T/C, 59356C/T, 59402G/A and 59653C/T have been reported before. SNP 59402G/A (94.2%) was most frequent in our population. This was in agreement with a similar study in neighboring Kenya by Katz and colleagues (2010) who identified the same SNP at 80% (14) among HIV-1 seropositive pregnant women. On the contrary, two other studies by Kaur et al. (2007) and Lu et al. (2012) reported the SNP at relatively lower frequencies of 47.8% and 66.4% among HIV-1 infected patients in a Northern Han Chinese population and North Indians (11, 15). These findings emphasize the impact of ethnicity and geographic location on human population genetics as we observe data similarities in regions in close proximities.
As expected, infant HIV plasma load decreased significantly with cART initiation by six months (p = 0.001) and twelve months (p = 0.006). This is a scientific fact as past studies have shown cART to suppress HIV multiplication by blocking multiple steps in the virus replication cycle (16, 17). On the other hand, however, it is imperative to note that only 50 of 85 infants (58.8%) and 34 of 53 infants (64.2%) achieved viral suppression by six and twelve months respectively. These findings are in agreement with the earlier cited viral suppression rate in six months among infants of 59.3% versus 88.4% in the general population by the Uganda Viral load dashboard (Central Public Health Laboratory of Republic of Uganda, 2018). The global community continues to set tougher targets to end the HIV pandemic, recently the Joint United Nations Program on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS) shifted the 90-90-90 goals to 95-95-95, implying that 95% for all HIV infected people on ART should be virally supressed by year 2030 (UNAIDS). Additionally, Chan M. K et al reported 89% viral suppression rate by 12 months of cART initiation among infants in Europe and Thailand (18). It is against this background that our findings emphasize the urgent need for enhanced and robust measures to improve cART coverage and adhereance, vis-à-vis scientific research aimed at bridging knowledge gap on the likely factors associated with virological failure among the HIV infected paediatric population in Uganda. It is also important to note that while viral suppression in the adult Uganda populaion is approaching 90%, the pediatric suppression rates are still lagging behind (19). In addition to the low viral suppression rates we have seen in these babies compared to adults, there is a big proportion of babies who are harboring low level viremia (10–999 copies/ml). It is possible that such virus continues to replicate and also harbor drug resistant mutations that may prevent total viral suppression. More indepth analysis using Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) is being done on these patient samples to see if they harbor any drug resistant mutations even at levels less than 20% that could explain the incomplete viral suppression.
Although we did not find any significant associations between CCR5 promoter SNPs and virological failure, we picked interest in certain SNPs that showed consistency with earlier studies. CCR5 59029G/A and 59353T/C showed higher odds among non-suppressors wheras CCR5 59356C/T and 59402G/A showed to be protective with lower odds among the same group. This is in agreement with John et al, 2001 who reported similar findings among an HIV seropositive mother-infant cohort in kenya (10). Additionally, several other studies (11, 20, 21) have linked CCR5 59029G/A and 59353T/C to high HIV plasma loads.
In summary, following sanger sequencing, we have re-characterised the CCR5 promoter single nucleotide polymorphism genotype including four novel SNPs. No significant association was found between CCR5 promoter SNPs and infant virological failure, however, in agrrement with earlier studies SNPs CCR5 59029G/A, and 59353T/C correlated with high plama HIV loads wheras CCR5 59356C/T and 59402G/A appear protective against viral non-suppression. Similar to Uganda national viral load data, we also report a 59% viral suppression rate among infants on cART at six months and showing the need for more enhanced measures and scientific work to be done in this population. Our study augments previous studies that CCR5 promoter SNPs play a role in modulating patient virological status however, strong conclusions could be drawn from either utilizing in-vitro studies or large epidemiological studies.
Limitations
The small study population was attributed to the slow participant accrual into the parent study which in turn could have been attributed to (1) the effectiveness of PMTCT programs in the urban areas of Uganda as compared to rural-Uganda which has greatly reduced numbers of newborns acquiring HIV infection from their mothers (22). (2) the COVID-19 pandemic that caused total lockdowns and almost put the parent study to halt as both study participants and healthcare workers could hardly move to meeting points.