Cholestasis is a key clinical feature that is usually present in the first 3 months [6]. In our retrospective study, the vast majority (8/10, 80%) of children were admitted to hospital with cholestasis. The most conserved feature of ALGS is bile duct paucity. Liver histology typically reveals a reduction in the concentration of intrahepatic bile ducts (bile duct to portal tract ratio < 0.4)[7]. As few as 60% of patients < 6 months showed paucity, whereas it was commonly found in 95% of infants aged > 6 months[6, 8]. However, the paucity tend is uncertain and controversy still exists. More clinical data are certainly needed for it.
Currently, there is a growing consensus that liver biopsy is not required if clinical biochemical evidence shows cholestasis and other characteristics of ALGS[8]. This tendency prevents pediatric patients from undergoing an invasive liver biopsy for definitive diagnosis. In our study, liver biopsies had been performed for only two cases, but this did not affect diagnosis. Typical pathology is helpful for diagnosis of ALGS, but the detection of typical clinical manifestations and gene mutations have decreased clinician dependency on pathology.
The most common differential diagnosis of ALGS is BA. BA is characterized by significant small bile duct hyperplasia. Ductular hyperplasia may also occur in ALGS patients, but it is milder than BA[9, 10]. The result of liver biopsy of our case# 7 was ductular proliferation. However, liver ultrasound and magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography did not find the typical changes of BA. Case#10 showed acholic stool and even liver ultrasound suggested common bile duct dysplasia. However, both children had cardiac problems. The butterfly vertebrae in case #10 was typical. Combined with the genetic test, ALGS was confirmed.
Kamath et al. reported that serum bile salts can remain elevated even when hyperbilirubinemia has been resolved[11]. Case #8 in the study showed normal total and direct bilirubin, but total bile acid remained elevated. GGT is also commonly elevated. The median value of GGT in the ten children in this study was 223 U/L (normal, 9–64 U/L). Case #3 was a 2-month-old boy with a normal GGT level (34 U/L). In children with normal GGT levels, familial progressive cholestasis is first suspected. However, this child also had pulmonary artery stenosis, facial features associated with ALGS. A liver biopsy suggested typical intrahepatic bile duct paucity. His JAG1 pathogenic variant was novel (c.1464delC). Functional validation of the gene is ongoing. There are only a few reports of normal GGT levels in ALGS[10]. We speculate that normal GGT may represent an early stage ALGS in children. As the disease progresses, GGT increases, resulting in a pathological state.
Several larger descriptive studies showed renal and vascular abnormalities in many patients. Renal symptoms were not uncommon in our cases and were seen in three children. Rough renal parenchyma or hydronephrosis of the left kidney was found by ultrasound. Epilepsy was a unique symptom of Case #6, which is rare in ALGS. Extracranial or intracranial vascular abnormalities could be the cause, although we found no evidence for this.
Ocular abnormalities are one of the major features in initial diagnosis of ALGS. Surprisingly, none of the children in our study showed ocular symptoms. We thought there may be two reasons. First, posterior embryotoxon is so rare that our ophthalmologists could not identify it accurately; second, we hypothesize that this may be a feature of the Chinese children with ALGS. More cases are needed to confirm it.
In ALGS, 94–95% of patients have a heterozygous pathogenic variant in JAG1, and 1–2% of patients have a heterozygous pathogenic variant in NOTCH2[12]. Pathogenic variants in the JAG1 gene were identified in nine patients (90%): five nonsense pathogenic variants (55.6%), three frameshift pathogenic variants (33.3%), and one splicing pathogenic variant (11.1%). The only identified NOTCH2 pathogenic variant was nonsense. Significantly, most of these genetic pathogenic variants have not been reported, indicating our cases may have a unique variants spectrum.
ALGS cases with JAG1 pathogenic variants usually present facial dysmorphism, heart involvement compared to NOTCH2[13, 14]. Renal abnormalities may be more common in cases with NOTCH2 pathogenic variants[15]. However, many studies have reported no clear correlation between genotype and phenotype in this disease. The phenotypic variability was seen among patients with the same pathogenic variants[16]. This type of variability has been associated with liver disease, with clinical manifestations ranging from mild liver function abnormalities to severe cholestasis [17]. In the present study, cases #2 and #8 had the same genetic pathogenic variant although the clinical manifestations differed. This supports the changeable phenotypic penetrance of ALGS. Some studies have suggested that this may be due to the existence of other genes as genetic modifiers, such as the Fringe protein family, including LFNG, RFN, and MFNG, which can alter NOTCH signaling by regulating glycosyltransferase activity. THBS2 has also been considered a potential genetic modifier[18, 19].
The system of graded diagnosis and treatment in China is not good enough. Almost all children with severe cholestasis will choose the best hospital for the first diagnosis. Through the study, we have realized that the primary pediatricians’ cognition of ALGS is insufficient, which is why we wrote this manuscript.
The characteristic of our study is that pathogenic variants in JAG1 and NOTCH2 are the primary variants in Chinese children with ALGS, but we had our own unique variants spectrum. The other surprising finding was that none of the patients had any ocular symptoms. Whether this is a feature of Chinese children with ALGS is unknown. We need more cases to prove it. ALGS should be considered for cholestasis in infants and young children, especially those with multi-organ abnormalities.