Congenital amusia (CA), colloquially labeled tone deaf, is a developmental disorder of the central auditory system that results in behavioral impairments of pitch perception and memory, that cannot be attributed to lack of exposure, intellectual disability, or brain damage after birth(Peretz et al. 2002; Peretz et al. 2007; Ayotte et al. 2002). What characterizes them behaviorally is their difficulty with detecting both their own and others singing out of tune, with distinguishing a familiar tune without the assistance of the lyrics, and with maintaining memory of short tunes(Ayotte et al. 2002). It is widely distributed in the population, accounting for about 4.2% of the total population(Kalmus and Fry 1980), with no obvious gender difference between men and women. Although there is testimony that recovery is possible through training, CA is believed to be innate(Whiteford and Oxenham 2018). While CA is not seriously harmful and does not affect the normal life of the individual, its underlying abnormalities brain structural and/or functional may be important to understand human brain. To nearly everyone, the appeal of music is documented across the lifespan. In this context, lack of musical inclination is bewildering and calls for an analysis of its causes(Peretz 2016). Therefore, characterization of the disorder sheds light on the neuro-cognitive architecture (musical processing) and highlights possible etiologies of disordered brain development at a cognitive and neurobiological level. Systematically investigating the disorder of the neural basis and cognitive has been a relatively recent endeavor.
Recent years studies in amusics suggested that the deficit music ability of CA may be related to emotional information processing disorder. Music can express emotional information via controlling the pitch, tempo, and volume(Dissanayake 2000). Research on the behavioral preferences of CA has shown that the perceptual impairment restricts the level of music appreciation, which is manifested as lower participation in music activities and weaker emotional arousal of music and negative attitude towards music(Arias Gómez 2007). Therefore, the reduction of CA individual’s sensitivity to emotional content in music could either result from impaired music procession or emotion processing.
The core performance of CA are the deficits of musical perception and production, especially the significant pitch, expression(Hyde et al. 2011; Foxton et al. 2004) and memory difict(Albouy et al. 2013; Albouy et al. 2015). At present, the Montreal Battery of Evaluation of Amusia (MBEA) (Peretz et al. 2003) is the most widely used tool to diagnose CA which consisting of four sections (melodic, rhythmic, metric, and memory) with six sub-tests. Three sub-tests are under the classification of melodic (violate key, pitch interval, and pitch contour) and one sub-test in every other section.
Individuals of CA have been associated to changes in brain structures and brain functions. The dominant theory of the neural basis of amusia focused on the right inferior frontal gyrus (IFG), right superior temporal gyrus (STG), and the connectivity between them in structure and function in the right hemisphere. Individuals with amusics have been implicated of having a higher grey matter and lower white-matter density in the right IFG(Hyde et al. 2006; Hyde et al. 2007; Albouy et al. 2013), the levels of grey-matter density in the right STG is abnormal(Albouy et al. 2013; Hyde et al. 2007), as well as a decreased arcuate fasciculus to connect the two clusters(Zhao et al. 2016), compared with musically intact subjects. But there is limited research on the left hemisphere of CA: Mandell et al demonstrated the existence of a left fronto-temporal network(Mandell et al. 2007) and Jasmin et al found prominent reductions in functional connectivity between left prefrontal language-related regions and right hemisphere pitch-related regions of CA(Jasmin et al. 2020). Current fMRI resting-state research in CA are also limited to pre-defined resting state networks or seed-voxel correlations(Tillmann et al. 2016; Loui et al. 2009). However, the body of evidence suggests that musical processing is based on a widely distributed neural network and amusia may involve abnormal connectivity and cooperation with the interhemispheric(Schuppert et al. 2000; Peretz 1985; Schurz et al. 2015). Therefore, further study of the whole brain could further improve our understanding of the neural basis of amusia.
In our previous study(Sun et al. 2021), we used the degree centrality (DC) method to discern abnormal functional network centrality and found decreased DC values in the right primary sensorimotor areas in a amusics group compared with healthy control (HC) groups. In our current study, we used Regional Homogeneity (ReHo) to further explore neural networks and discover underlying mechanisms leading to CA. ReHo is a data analysis method of rs-fMRI(Wang et al. 2011; Zang et al. 2004) which is a voxel-based measure of brain activity that evaluates the synchronization/similarity between the time series of a given voxel and its nearest neighbors, and use the Kendall's coefficient of concordance(KCC) as an index(Zang et al. 2004). ReHo mainly reflects the consistency of the local neurons spontaneous activity. The increases in the ReHo value indicate that the local brain area neuron activity tends to be synchronized in the certain time. So the abnormal ReHo value can reflect if neurons are abnormally synchronized. This approach has been used in a variety of mental disorders and has shown to be a promising biomarker(Lai and Wu 2012; Jiang and Zuo 2016; Wu et al. 2009; Tan et al. 2016; Liu et al. 2017; Gao et al. 2015). As far as we know, this is the first article using ReHo to study CA.
In our study we aimed to explore the potential brain biomarkers of congenital amusia in whole brain. We investigated the abnormal consistency of the local neurons spontaneous activity of amusics’ brains at rest compared with healthy controls based on the ReHo method using resting state-functional MRI. In addition, the correlations between the ReHo values in the abnormal brain regions and scores of MBEA with 6 subtests were calculated to investigate the associations between abnormal regions and musical skills in amusics.