3.1 Good care in relation to MiL at two levels
Findings have meaning first of all at the individual level in their own context. We therefore provide six examples as results of the individual analysis, structured by modified framework of care ethical evaluation (Appendices 2–7). To enable the reader to understand the findings in context, the examples include all aspects of this framework. The examples are chosen from the four neighbourhoods (A-D) and display the diverse backgrounds of our participants (see Table 1).
Next, we present our findings at the overarching level structured by analytical aspects and themes (see Table 2: Themes). The background of participants is summarised in Table 1.
Table 2
Analytical questions | Themes |
Expectations What does the person expect from the nurse? | ‘Simply normal contact’, don’t expect consideration for MiL from nurses |
Adequate physical care, no MiL support |
Recognising MiL Does the nurse recognize the person’s MiL (and the way he/she deals with it)? | Setting the tone |
Showing interest in the person |
Being attentive to specific and hidden needs of patients |
Response How does the nurse respond to the patient (attunement to MiL)? | Maintaining a long, kind and reciprocal relationship |
Doing what is needed |
Skilled personalised care |
The special ones |
Consequence Does the care offered do well to the patient? What is the consequence of that? | A cheerful moment that lifts me up or a superficial encounter |
Feeling secure or insecure |
Feeling like a valuable equal person, a dependent patient, or the nurse’s coach |
Having a good day thanks to good humane care, or suffering due to bad care |
Emphasising what is important in healthcare |
3.2 Expectations of older persons
Participants shared their expectations with us regarding their contact with nurses and the provided care in relation to their MiL.
‘Simply normal contact’, don’t expect consideration for MiL from nurses
Participants expressed that they mainly expect ‘normal contact’. When we asked what ‘normal contact’ was for them, they mentioned many expectations about nurses’ attitudes. They expected nurses to be friendly and polite. Several participants reported experiences of nurses being impolite or rude. They wanted to be treated like a competent grown-up and not as a ‘demented granny’. Participants expected nurses to be discreet and not impertinent, for instance by not looking in cupboards unasked. Participants expected nurses to meet their duty to arrive on time and provide care as agreed.
‘I expect simply normal contact, just being kind to each other.‘ (C1.1, age 86–90)
Many participants told us that the contact with nurses is superficial. They said they don’t expect nurses to have regard for Mil and seldom share MiL issues with them. They preferred to share this with near ones or keep these issues to themselves, for they experience MiL as something they must achieve by themselves. They do not want to bother others with it.
I don’t think they [nurses] know what is important to me. We talk about normal superficial subjects like children, holidays. Things about meaning in life are mine. If I shared them with anyone, it would be with my son or other family members and not with the nurses. They go from one patient to the other and in the end I am not more than a number to them. (D2.2, age 96–100)
I told them about the loss of my last friends … eh … and they sympathised with me but you know, they have their own family. So I keep it as much as possible to myself. You know, you shouldn’t bother others with your grief and worries. You just shouldn’t. (A3.3, age 76–80)
Adequate physical care, no MiL support
Many participants believed that nursing is limited to physical care. First of all, they expected nurses to provide this care adequately and with technical proficiency.
They are there for their work. They help me with taking a shower; they dry and rub me with body lotion. They even dry the shower stall. (A3.2, age 76–80)
Some participants expressed that they don’t believe nurses are competent to provide support in MiL, but most of all they experienced that nurses lack the time, knowledge or attitude.
I am expecting practical things from them, like fastening a button. To ask: ‘Can I mean something for you?’… They can mainly do something for me. ‘To mean something’ is deeper. Then you have to sit down, stay seated and listen. (D5.3, age 96–100)
3.3 Recognising what is at stake
Although most participants did not expect nurses to take MiL into consideration in their care, they nonetheless shared several examples with us showing that nurses were open to patients’ MiL. Participants also provided examples where nurses neglected MiL.
Setting the tone
In our dialogues the older adults explained that nurses already set the tone for the encounter when entering the patient’s house. Participants said they immediately notice whether the nurse is in a good or a bad mood, when there is something bothering her, if she is in a hurry. They explained that they adapt to this condition of the nurse. For some participants the encounter had a large impact on their day, for others this was less important.
They are like the weather: When they are in a bad mood they are unable to enter joyfully. And I won’t react too much. But if they enter with good cheer, it gives me a boost like: Cheer-up! Let’s go for it! (D4.1, age 76–80)
The nurse’s behaviour upon arriving also sets the tone for space for MiL. Many participants did not experience this space with nurses because of their time slots and their task-oriented behaviour.
Sometimes the nurse enters and from the hall she yells: ‘How are you?’ And I am here. Then she throws down her coat and focusses on the book (patient file). I don’t know what to answer then. ‘How are you’ is a big question. But if it is asked in such a way, I cannot respond. Yes, if you sit down and ask me while you sit close to me….’ (B1.1, age 86–90)
Showing interest in the person
Participants appreciated that most nurses show interest in them as a person. Nurses asked, for instance, if they slept well or about the plans for the day. Participants told that nurses sometimes have time for a short talk or a cup of coffee, although this had become rare after organisational changes by the home care provider. Although they considered most talks to be superficial, without touching upon their MiL, they explained that it was nevertheless important for them that nurses be interested in them as whole persons.
There are nurses who come back to a conversation we had three weeks ago! Then I conclude: they listened to me with attention, they took the effort to remember it and continue the conversation. And then I feel very happy. (D4.2, age 76–80)
And yet, participants also gave examples of nurses who seemed there only to carry out their technical tasks. They experienced this as denigrating.
When I feel that they solely come to pour that drop into my eye and put on those elastic stockings, only for the bare fact of doing this, it feels denigrating to me. I would like them to approach me with a basic interest in me. (D4.3, age 76–80)
Being attentive to specific and hidden needs of patients
Participants related experiences with nurses who noticed specific needs. Sometimes the older adults tried to hide their pain or sadness, but nurses who knew them for a long time immediately recognised the signs. Others told about situations they could not oversee, when a nurse understood perfectly what they needed.
Only those from the regular group, the ones I know already for a very long time, they immediately see if something is wrong … they see it in the person. I cannot hide it from them. Especially [name] and [name] … [name] asked: what is wrong? And I said: nothing. And we sat chatting for a little while and, eh … she just knew anyway!’ (A2.2, age 61–65)
By contrast, some participants mentioned situations when nurses were inattentive, sometimes failing to properly assess the needs of the patient or ommitting to ask follow-up questions to learn more about their situation.
They could keep their eyes and ears more open to the people in the neighbourhood. I think people show more than they notice. If you are telling something, they come up with a story that is ten times worse. And then I won’t tell it anymore … They could ask a bit deeper: what is it that isn't going well? It is this attentiveness that I’m missing. (A1.1, age 76–80)
According to some participants, the organisation asks too much attention, which blurs the focus of nurses’ real work: the patient.
The nurses are being jerked around. Those changes in the organisation are an excuse for other procedures here. And [name nurse] has to explain all that to us, in her free time. But that has nothing to do with us. That’s not our business. We listen to them but it distracts from what they come for. But most of all, it limits the pleasure they have in their work. And that is important to us too. (B5.2, age 71–75)
3.4 Nurse’s response
Although most participants mentioned that they don’t expect nurses to have consideration for their MiL, they nevertheless reported many experiences of care which they considered to be attuned to it. They also shared examples of non-attuned care.
Maintaining a long, kind and reciprocal relationship
Participants expressed special affection towards nurses or permanent staff who had cared for them for a long time. They explained that knowing the nurses was important to them. Then both patient and nurse share other things, like experiences with dear ones, hobbies, etc. Participants enjoyed this immensely. In our dialogues with participants the reciprocal character of the nurse-patient relationship emerged as pivotal theme. Participants appreciated nurses sharing their own lives with them. Many participants were already aware of the reciprocal character of the relationship, others realised it during our dialogues. Participants told that, just as nurses do with them, they do their best to be friendly and interested in the nurse as a person. Instead of only receiving, participants took pleasure in giving nurses something in return. Some offered fruit or drinks, others gave little presents.
Well, they see all those materials on my table and they ask about it and say: ‘you have been making such nice things!’ And I give them away to them. [name] had had a grandson and I have a little basket with baby socks which I made. And I asked her to choose one for her grandson. And then later on she gave me a picture of the child with the socks. And that is so nice! (B3.1, age 81–85)
Sometimes when they have a free hour they come to my home. I tell them: come to me. I’ll make you tea, coffee, whatever you want. And then they eat their lunch sandwich here and I really enjoy that. Then you have different conversations. More about what’s on their mind. And they say to me: You are just like a mom to us. And then we’re joking around. (A3.3, age 76–80)
Participants also told us that they functioned as a ‘sounding board’ for the nurses. They listened carefully to their worries and gave them advice.
This morning [name] was here and she told me about the problems she had with her children. And I was able to give her some advice. She also tells her own stories and that’s fine with me. We have a good relationship and that is part of it. (A2.2, age 61–65)
Participants felt sorry for the nurses’ poor working conditions. They tried to help them by doing as much as possible by themselves. They also refrained from asking for more time or attention. Many participants complained about the large number of temporary workers. They feel less at ease with them.
Doing what is needed
Participants especially valued nurses’ decisiveness. They told us about incidents when they genuinely were in trouble, due to extreme pain, sickness, exhaustion or an unforeseen situation. The nurse who visited them immediately understood the position of the patient (attentiveness) and acted adequately, for instance by calling the family doctor, arranging devices, providing the right physical care, or by sitting next to the patient and listening.
There are a few women [nurses], especially [name], who I really trust. I know her from the very first day and she would take care of anything I needed, without me even telling or asking her. She just did it. She arranged the dial-a-bus, a shower chair, everything. (D1.1, age 86–90)
Skilled personalised care
Participants expressed that skilled personalised care is very important to them. They have their own habits and wishes, fitting with their values. Besides, adequate care means less pain and fatigue.
They do their work well: fast and well … When they dress my wound they are very careful not to hurt me. That’s humane. And they bind my slippers onto my feet, so bacteria don’t get into my wound, because I cannot see it. They are caring.’ (C6.2, age 81–85)
Participants shared that they preferred to be cared for by nurses they already knew for a long time: those nurses knew exactly what to do and how to do it properly. Additionally, those nurses do not take over activities that participants can still do themselves, or exactly the opposite: nurses do take over extra activities on a bad day. Participants complained about the frequent interim personnel. Some of the temporary workers showed limited technical skills. Every detail had to be explained to them, exhausting patients and causing them distress.
Those few nurses do the care well. My leg is extremely painful. If you touch it like that, it hurts already. And one of those temporary nurses, she didn’t know how to bandage, although I told her how. And yes, after a little while the bandages fell off. And the consequence was that my legs became thicker and even more painful during that day. (A2.3, age 61–65)
Many participants complained about the fact that home nurses were rarely on time. Others expressed their appreciation for nurses who were on time, so they could for instance go to church, which was important for them.
Almost every participant mentioned a favourite nurse, ‘a special one’. These were nurses with whom a special connection was felt; they were attuned in a special way to the personality and needs of the patient. Many of these nurses showed all the positive themes mentioned in Sect. 3.3 and 3.4, and more. According to our participants, these ‘special ones’ did something extra for patients, something that was not prescribed in the nursing plan, even against the rules of the organisation, but which was highly appreciated. We heard many stories of ‘special ones’. For instance, a favourite nurse took letters to the mailbox for a patient with limited mobility; came by in her private time to show her new-born baby; walked the dog for a sick patient; enjoyed and danced to music together.
[name] is my darling. When she visits me and my son’s music plays, she stands here dancing and I say: Hey, there is Tina Turner again! And she jokes about my untidy hair. We make fun of each other. And I say to the Lord: You give me exactly the girl I need! (C3.2, age 76–80)
3.5 Consequences for the older person
Our participants explained how the care, which they considered to be attuned to their MiL, or the lack thereof, impacted their life. Participants also mentioned a consequence for healthcare service.
A cheerful moment that lifts me up or a superficial encounter
For most participants the visits of the home nurse were gleeful moments during the day, especially if the nurse was one of their favourites. They told that a pleasant visit of a nurse helps start the day joyfully, it breaks the day and as a consequence they feel uplifted.
Sometimes I am alone all day and they come twice a day. Most times they are busy, but sometimes I offer them a cup of coffee and we have a little talk. It gives a pleasant atmosphere, and provides me with a cosy feeling. (D5.3, age 96–100)
I feel happy when the nurse enters my home, even if she can only stay for five minutes. It is attention and I always say: for human beings attention is more important than food. And when they pass my window they always wave, and in fact that is already contact. Marvellous. (D3.3, age 91–95)
As explained before by participants, temporary staff, or a negative tone when the nurse arrives, resulted in encounters that remained superficial.
Feeling secure or insecure
The friendly, reciprocal contact with nurses provided participants with a sense of security: a known, trusted person was watching over them.
They come to look after me because I am very old and have nobody. They check on me. That feels safe. They sit here for a little while and they always say: it is so cosy with you. They can rest here for a little while. I can relate to them, start a light conversation with them, because I worked with people all my life. (B4.3, age 96–100)
A few participants told about nurses who did not respect their privacy or even displayed intimidating behaviour, which resulted in feelings of stress and unsafety.
The big man [male nurse] was standing in front of me and said: you can hire me privately and I will be on time. You can pay me directly. And I thought: If I don’t promise to hire him, he’ll hit me … That’s unseemly behaviour. I have been of service to others my entire life in my job. I think things are moving the wrong way with healthcare. (D6.2, age 86–90)
Feeling like a valuable equal person, a dependent patient, or the nurse’s coach
Participants shared with us that the long reciprocal relationship with permanent staff nurses, particularly the special ones, provided them with a feeling of trust and equality. They explained that it is important for them to be regarded as equal human beings instead of dependent patients. Participants felt valued when nurses thanked them for listening.
Yes, they are open to me, so nice. They don’t sit here like a nurse but more like a good acquaintance. That’s what I like so much … As a patient you can be pitiable and as a human being you just feel normal. That’s it: I don’t feel like a patient. I don’t want to. I just want to be human among other humans … There is one nurse who calls me her friend. That’s so nice. (D1.3, age 86–90)
I appreciate the trust she has in me. Because when she is asking me, she knows I have an honest opinion ... however, most times I am just listening to them. (A1.3, age 76–80)
Although participants appreciated a reciprocal relationship with familiar nurses, for some of them the balance between giving and receiving was off: the attention they paid to nurses’ worries overshadowed their own problems.
When they run into difficulties in their work they come to me. [Tells an example of another patient.] And then they turn to me for advice. Honestly, that puts a burden on me, because I keep thinking about it … There is hardly any focus on me. Well, on the other hand, I don’t take the opportunity to tell about myself … (A1.3, age 76–80)
Having a good day thanks to good humane care, or suffering due to bad care
Participants explained how skilled care has a large impact on their life. If physical care is done correctly it limits pain, suffering and exhaustion, leaving room for them to do what is important to them, like gardening or visiting family. The provided care is a prerequisite for having a good day, living their life as they want to.
They [permanent staff] are good women. They know everything, I don’t have to explain and they do their work very well and then it is not painful. I am not stressed anymore. I can sleep again and eat again. (C5.1, age 66–70)
Waiting for the nurse for no reason feels pointless for participants and limits the activities of that day.
We still have an active life. I do as much as I can by myself. I had to be in the hospital on time. The taxi will not wait. It intrudes in my life when they are too late. I was there sitting and waiting, and they even didn’t call to say they were late … I was used to care independently for myself and my partner all my life. And when they don’t come on time I lose part of my life. We don’t blame those nurses we know. It’s taken away by the policy of an organisation. It makes me feel curtailed. (B5.2, age 70–75)
Emphasising what is important in healthcare
Many participants considered healthcare services to be deteriorating. Participants stressed that nurses’ concern for patients’ MiL was not only important for them as individuals, but also for healthcare in general. They explained that the focus on patients’ MiL also restored attention to what’s really important in healthcare.
Well, I think that the higher you come in the organisation, the less focus there is on this aspect [MiL] and on emotions. And that is important for the people who give those trainings: that these very tiny spiritual notes are most important in the big picture.’ (D4.3, age 76–80)