Per the hydrodynamic theory, blocking the opened dentinal tubules could reduce discomfort from DH by reducing fluid movement through dentinal tubules [3]. In this study, intratubular crystals were formed in PBS after the experimental material was applied to the exposed dentin surface and filled the dentinal tubules more densely as the period of storage in PBS increased.
In the case of intratubular crystal formation in a previous study [18], when using a calcium silicate-based sealer for root canal treatment, calcium silicate was continuously present inside the root canal and in contact with the dentinal tubules. For DH treatment, a desensitizer should be applied to the dentin surface exposed to the outside, which is not in contact with the surface of dentin continuously exposed due to physical and chemical factors in the oral cavity. Therefore, to improve intratubular occlusion, desensitizers must efficiently penetrate the dentinal tubules.
In this study, efforts were made to achieve efficient penetration of experimental particles as greater penetration of particles into the dentinal tubules would have occurred. First, the experimental material used in this study consisted of particles with a smaller diameter than in other studies using calcium silicate (lower than 85 µm or 0.5 mm) [20, 21] or calcium silicate in commercially available mineral trioxide aggregate products [22]. The diameter of dentinal tubules of sensitive dentin is larger than that of non-sensitive dentin; however, it is only 0.83 µm on average [2]. The small dimension of dentinal tubules makes it difficult for desensitizers to efficiently penetrate [12]. According to a study by Kim et al. [23], comparing the degree of absorption according to the particle size of the desensitizer, desensitizers with small-sized particles were more likely to penetrate the dental tubules. Therefore, the experimental materials consisting of specially designed nanoscale particles used in this study would effectively penetrate the dentinal tubules and form occluding plugs, as in other studies [24]. Second, C2S/C3S was applied via a brushing motion to the dentin surface. This indicated that calcium silicate was contained in toothpaste and applied to the surface of the dentin when brushing. A total of 10,000 repeated strokes (1 stroke/second) of brushing simulated for about 18.5 days assuming brushing three minutes/time and three times a day [25]. It can more likely push desensitizing materials into dentinal tubules compared with just dropping or rubbing with a micro-brush on the specimen surface. As a result, the occluding plug was formed below the dentinal tubule orifice in applying the experimental material to the brushing motion (Fig. 3).
The occluding plugs can act as a reservoir of calcium ions, continuously dissolving calcium ions and forcing the inside of the dentinal tubules into a supersaturation state [26]. The supersaturation condition was expected to cause the local aggregation of calcium ions and phosphate ions due to their interaction with ions present on the inner surface of the dentinal tubules, which caused the growth of the intratubular crystals [24]. From this reaction, it can be inferred that the lower part of the occluding plug was rough, and plate-shaped crystals were formed below (Fig. 3b, white arrowheads).
The intratubular crystal formation reaction by diffusion per the concentration gradient of ions can occur at a deep point in the dentinal tubules. In this study, the intratubular crystals were formed at a depth of more than 50 µm from the exposed dentin surface (Fig. 3a, white arrows). In a clinical situation, the superficial occlusion of dentinal tubules has a short-term effect as the precipitates can be easily removed due to daily tooth brushing, dissolution by saliva, and the consumption of acidic beverages [27]. For the long-term effect of desensitizers, the material blocking the dentinal tubules should be deep enough [28].
Crystal formation reactions continuously occur in dentinal tubules forming denser crystal complexes as the duration of storage in PBS increases (Fig. 4). The crystal complex is expected to contribute to preventing the movement of the pulpal fluid through the dentinal tubules and reduce discomfort from DH more effectively [7, 29]. Further research will be needed on the clinical effectiveness of the experimental material.
When C2S and C3S are in contact with water, they are hydroxylated, and the surface dissolves according to the equation below [30]:
$$2(2CaO\bullet Si{O}_{2})+4{H}_{2}O\to 3CaO\bullet 2Si{O}_{2}\bullet 3{H}_{2}O+Ca{\left(OH\right)}_{2}$$
$$2(3CaO\bullet Si{O}_{2})+6{H}_{2}O\to 3CaO\bullet 2Si{O}_{2}\bullet 3{H}_{2}O+3Ca{\left(OH\right)}_{2}$$
As a result of these reactions, calcium and hydroxyl ions are released, resulting in a highly alkaline environment [31]. After the hydration reaction of calcium silicate, the hydroxyapatite-like crystals are formed during contact with PBS [32, 33]. A previous study showed calcium-deficient and B-type carbonated apatite with a 1.4–1.5 Ca/P ratio formed from Portland cement in PBS [33]. Other studies demonstrated that calcium silicate in PBS could make hydroxyapatite after hydration [34–36]. In this study, the Ca/P ratio of formed intratubular crystals was 1.68 after three months. Considering that the Ca/P ratio of hydroxyapatite is 1.67 [37], it can be expected that the intratubular crystals made in this experiment would be hydroxyapatite-like crystals.
However, this experimental design could not simulate a real oral environment, such as an acid challenge from the diet. Therefore, further studies need to be performed to evaluate the effect of the acid-neutral cycle on intratubular crystal formation.