Research question
The primary objective of this multicenter, randomized controlled trial is to evaluate the effect of the smartphone application Dnurse on glycemic management and disease control in individuals with T2DM. As secondary objectives, the trial will assess whether the application influences compliance with blood glucose monitoring, and it will measure user satisfaction with the application.
Study design
This will be a multicenter randomized controlled trial conducted in outpatient endocrinology clinics at two tertiary hospitals in Chengdu, China, which will be conducted from 2021 to 2023 using the convenience sampling method. Individuals will be randomly allocationed to Control group, Reminder group, App group and App + Reminder group.
Trial registration and ethics compliance
The trial protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee of the First Affiliated Hospital of Chengdu Medical College (2020CYFYIRB-BA-129-F01) and prospectively registered at the Chinese Clinical Trial Registry under registration number ChiCTR2100042297. The study will be carried out in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki. Written informed consent is obtained from participants prior to enrollment.
Study sites
Since October 2021, the trial has been underway at two tertiary general hospitals (“grade A” in the Chinese hospital classification scheme) in Chengdu, China. At each site, two researchers have been designated to carry out the trial. A SPIRIT schedule of procedures and events is demonstrated in Table 1.
Table 1
Schedule of procedures and assessments.
| STUDY PERIOD |
| Enrolement | Baseline | Intervention | Endpoint |
TIMEPOINT | - | 0 months | 3 months | 6 months |
ENROLEMENT: | | | | |
Eligibility screen | X | | | |
Informed consent | X | | | |
Allocation | X | | | |
INTERVENTIONS: | | | | |
Control group | | X | X | |
Reminder group | | X | X | |
App group | | X | X | |
App + Reminder group | | X | X | |
ASSESSMENTS: | | | | |
chronic complications related to diabete | | X | | X |
acute complications related to diabetes | | X | | X |
diabetes treatments | | X | | X |
DKN,HBQ,2-DSCS | | X | | X |
satisfaction with the smartphone application | | | | X |
height, weight, blood pressure, waist circumference, hip circumference and HbA1c | | X | X | X |
frequency of blood glucose monitoring | | | X | X |
Chronic complications related to diabete: hypertension, cardiovascular disease, cerebrovascular disease, peripheral vascular disease, kidney disease, peripheral neuropathy, eye disease and diabetic foot; acute complications related to diabetes: hypoglycemia and lactic acidosis or ketoacidosis; diabetes treatments: non-drug therapy, oral hypoglycemic drugs, and insulin therapy; DKN: Diabetes Knowledge Scale; HBQ: Health Belief Questionnaire; 2-DSCS: Type 2 Diabetes Self-management Behavior Scale; User satisfaction with Dnurse application and its paired glucose meter: Custom-made questionnaire to assess user satisfaction with Dnurse application and its paired glucose meter; HbA1c: glycosylated hemoglobin. |
Participants
Recruitment was carried out online, through announcements in outpatient departments, and by telephone from the National Center for Standardized Metabolic Management (Chengdu, China). For the online recruitment announcement, health education nurses at the the First Affiliated Hospital of Chengdu Medical College sent recruitment information to a WeChat group of individuals with T2DM that is managed by the National Center. Recruitment advertisements were posted on the bulletin boards of outpatient departments at the two study sites. Researchers also contacted patients using the telephone numbers on record at the National Center.
Individuals were enrolled only if they satisfied all the following inclusion criteria: (1) diagnosis with T2DM based on the criteria of the World Health Organization glycosylated hemoglobin (HbA1c) ≥ 7.0%) [8], (2) at least a primary school education, (3) at least 18 years of old, (4) smartphone literacy, (5) residence in Chengdu for at least the previous 12 months, and (6) willingness to participate and provide informed consent. Smartphone literacy was assessed by asking potential participants whether more than three commonly used applications were installed on their smartphones.
People were not enrolled in the study if they met any of the following criteria: (1) previous experience with a diabetes-related application, (2) history of mental illness, cognitive impairment, or communication disorder, based on self-report, (3) pregnancy or plans to become pregnant, (4) treatment for cardiac or other life-threatening condition during the previous six months or (5) current diabetes-related hospitalization.
After enrollment, data were collected from the individual and his or her blood was sampled, as described below.
Randomization and interventions
Before enrollment began, two groups of random numbers were generated using Microsoft Word and placed into serially numbered, opaque envelopes. After baseline assessment was complete (see above), each participant selected an envelope, which indicated his or her allocation to one of the four groups described below. Equal numbers of participants were recruited at each study site and allocated equally into the four groups. All participants received a free blood glucose meter during the trial as well as sufficient blood glucose test strips.
The Control group will undergo routine diabetes management: they will receive a standard portable glucose meter (Dnurse He pro wisdom; Beijing Dnurse Technology Ltd, Beijing, China) and blood glucose monitoring record book. The recommended timing and frequency of blood glucose monitoring will be explained to them according to national guidelines [9]. At the end of the trial, the Control group will be informed about the smartphone application given to the other groups, and they will be invited to use it if they wish.
The Reminder group will receive the same materials as the Control group as well as a weekly telephone reminder to self-monitor blood glucose regularly. These reminders will be given by specially selected nursing undergraduates who have been trained in the rationale, interventions and objectives of the study. Only nursing students who performed well on post-training testing are allowed to participate in the study. During the telephone call, students will ask participants whether they are self-monitoring regularly and, if not, what are the reasons.
The App group will receive a smart blood glucose meter (Dnurse SPUG mobile blood glucose uric acid tester; Beijing Dnurse Technology Ltd) and they will be led by a specially trainer researcher to download the Dnurse App 4.0.16 (dnurse.com/v2/app), designed to work smoothly with the smart blood glucose meter. The researcher will show the study participants how to open a personal account on the application and how to generate personalized diet and exercise programs, glucose control targets, and a blood glucose monitoring plan; how to access the food bank, disease information, and real-time blood glucose analysis and recommendations within the application; and how to set reminders to take medication and engage in other behaviors. This device has received ISO13485 and EU CE certifications.
The App + Reminder group will receive the same materials and training as the App group, together with weekly telephone reminders like the Reminder group.
If members of the Control group and the Reminder group experience acute complications of diabetes, such as excessively high or low blood glucose, trial investigators will advise them to seek medical treatment as per standard procedures. If members of the App group and the App + Reminder group trigger a “critical value” alarm on the application, the customer service staff of the application’s manufacturer will call them by telephone and provide advice or information as per standard procedures.
Allocation concealment and blinding
Participants will not be blinded to their group allocation, but investigators will be blinded during baseline assessment.
Sample size
Using GPower 3.1 (University of Kiel, Kiel, Germany), we determined a minimal sample of 260 individuals for a default medium effect size of 0.26, two-sided A = 0.05, test power (1-β) of 0.9, and the F-test. To compensate for an estimated 20% loss to follow-up, we plan to recruit 65 subjects into each of the four groups.
Outcomes
The primary outcome is level of HbA1c, which reflects blood glucose levels over the preceding 2–3 months and is a good indicator of blood glucose control [10–11]. All determinations will be made by high-performance liquid chromatography at the same certified external laboratory to ensure consistency.
Secondary outcomes include frequency of blood glucose monitoring, body mass index, waist-to-hip ratio, blood pressure, diabetes-related medical costs, diabetes progression or improvement, knowledge about diabetes, health beliefs related to diabetes, and diabetes self-management behavior. The App and the App + Reminder groups will also be asked about their satisfaction with the smartphone application.
Assessments
The workflow of the study is summarized in Fig. 1. At baseline, demographic data will be collected on age, sex, ethnicity, educational level, marital status, employment status, current residence, and method of paying for medical expenses.
At baseline, data will be collected on the following clinical variables: chronic complications related to diabetes, such as hypertension, cardiovascular disease, cerebrovascular disease, peripheral vascular disease, kidney disease, peripheral neuropathy, eye disease and diabetic foot. Any chronic complications of diabetes that arise during the study will be recorded at 6 months. Similarly, data on acute complications related to diabetes will be collected at baseline, such as hypoglycemia and lactic acidosis or ketoacidosis; and current diabetes treatments, including non-drug therapy, oral hypoglycemic drugs, and insulin therapy. Any acute complications of diabetes that arise during the study will be recorded at 6 months.
At baseline and again at 6 months, all participants will be asked to fill out three questionnaires (Table 2). In addition, the App and the App + Reminder groups will fill out a fourth questionnaire at 6 months, which assesses their satisfaction with the smartphone application and glucose meter (Table 3). All questionnaires will be filled out online using Questionnaire Star (www.wjx.cn).
Table 2
Description of questionnaires in the trial.
Questionnaire | Description | Score range | Assessment timepoint(s) |
Diabetes Knowledge Scale [17](DKN) | Chinese version of the Diabetes Knowledge Questionnaire [18]. The Cronbach α coefficient of each question of the scale was above 0.70, and the content validity was above 0.60 [19]. The scale consists of 23 single-choice questions, among which questions 1–14 are general while questions 15–23 are specific to individuals taking treatments involving insulin, diet, exercise, drug therapy, blood glucose testing, foot care, or prevention of hypoglycemia. | Each item is scored from 0 to 1, and the total score ranges from 0 to 23. Higher scores indicate greater knowledge of diabetes. | Baseline 6 months |
Health Belief Questionnaire [20](HBQ) | Chinese version of the questionnaire designed by Becker [21]. The reliability of the scale was 0.82, and Cronbach α coefficient was 0.79 [20]. Health beliefs across five dimensions are explored: the 20 items ask about beliefs concerning the benefits of diabetes treatment (7 items), the necessity of diabetes treatment (5 items), harms associated with diabetes treatment (2 items), motivation for staying healthy (3 items), and harms related to diabetes (3 items). | Responses are scored on a 5-point Likert scale. Scores on each item range from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree). Several items apply inverted scoring. Total score ranges from 20 to 100. | Baseline 6 months |
Type 2 Diabetes Self-management Behavior Scale [22](2-DSCS) | Chinese version of the questionnaire by Hurley and Shea [23]. The Cronbach α coefficient was 0.87, the construct validity was 0.68 [22]. Six dimensions are assessed: dietary control (6 items), regular exercise (4 items), compliance with prescribed medication (3 items), blood glucose monitoring (4 items), foot care (5 items), as well as prevention and management of hypo- and hyperglycemia (4 items). | Responses are scored on a 5-point Likert scale, with 1 indicating complete failure and 5, complete success. Total score ranges from 26 to 130. | Baseline 6 months |
User satisfaction with Dnurse application and its paired glucose meter | Custom-made questionnaire to evaluate the participants’ satisfaction with the smartphone application (8 items) and paired glucose meter (3 items). | Responses are scored on a 5-point Likert scale. Total score ranges from 11 to 55. | 6 months |
Table 3
Custom-made questionnaire to assess user satisfaction with Dnurse application and its paired glucose meter.
Item | Very satisfied | Satisfied | Neither satisfied nor dissatisfied | Slightly dissatisfied | Very dissatisfied |
1. Your satisfaction with the application interface | | | | | |
2. Your satisfaction with the application’s ease of use | | | | | |
3. Your satisfaction with how the application records blood glucose | | | | | |
4. Your satisfaction with the health information provided by the application | | | | | |
5. Your satisfaction with using the application to manage diabetes | | | | | |
6. Your satisfaction with the application’s safety | | | | | |
7. Your satisfaction with the application’s performance (accuracy of results, speed of responses) | | | | | |
8. Your overall satisfaction with the application | | | | | |
9. Your satisfaction with the ease of operation of the glucose meter | | | | | |
10. Your satisfaction with the stability of the connection between the glucose meter and application | | | | | |
11. Your overall satisfaction with the glucose meter | | | | | |
Instructions: Please choose the one response with which you agree most. |
At baseline and again at 3 and 6 months, data will be collected on height, weight, blood pressure, waist circumference, hip circumference and HbA1c. At 3 and 6 months, all participants will be asked about their frequency of blood glucose monitoring.
Statistical analysis
Data will be analyzed using SPSS 23.0 (IBM, Chicago, IL, USA) using the intention-to-treat principle. Data will be expressed as mean ± standard deviation, or as n (%) in the case of categorical data,and differences between the four groups will be assessed for significance using the chi-squared test in the case, analysis of variance in the case, or non-parametric rank-sum test in the case of skewed continuous data. Differences between different time points within each group will be assessed for significance using generalized estimation equation. These models will include intervention variables, time as a categorical variable represented by dummy variables, the interaction between intervention and time, and baseline values. Differences associated with P < 0.05 will be considered significant.