The epithelial CTBs need to alter their expression profile to achieve their invasiveness while differentiating into EVTs. In this study, we strived to unravel the occurrence of EMT during CTB to EVT differentiation and analyze its pattern. We observed that EVTs possess a novel quasi-mesenchymal state which is different from other known biological contexts of EMT. We also found three transcription factors and one receptor tyrosine kinase molecule that may be regulating this novel state of EVTs.
Three individual datasets containing gene expression profile of CTBs and EVTs isolated from first trimester placenta were analyzed. We chose dataset GSE57834 as the primary dataset since the PCA and UMAP analysis showed clear distinction between CTBs and EVTs while cells within a sub-population had a high degree of correlation. Also, compared to the other two datasets available, GSE57834 showed the maximum number of DEGs of which 44.82% were upregulated and 55.18% genes were downregulated in EVTs compared to CTBs. This indicates that the distinct behaviour of the EVTs can be attributed to differential gene expression.
The hallmark enrichment analysis identified EMT phenomenon being positively enriched in the DEGs. EMT is a trans-differentiation process, where the epithelial cells lose their polarity and acquire the ability of invasion, a mesenchymal trait 20. This is manifested by the change in expression of some defined set of genes called EMT-associated genes 22,23,49. EMT is vital for CTB to EVT differentiation since EVTs need to detach from the anchoring villi tip and invade the endometrial tissue. Previous study, using PCR profiler array with 84 EMT associated genes, provided evidence of EMT signature during this differentiation and its regulation through one of the EMT master regulator transcription factor ZEB2 26,50.
In all the datasets analysed to compare expression of EMT associated genes in CTBs and EVTs, epithelial marker CDH1 reduced while mesenchymal markers, FN1 and VIM increased. However, there was no change found in the expression of the mesenchymal marker, CDH2. This suggests that although EMT is taking place during EVT differentiation, EVTs have a novel quasi mesenchymal state with the process being different from other well-known biological contexts of EMT 20. Expression pattern of the EMT master regulator transcription factors varied between the different datasets. The primary dataset GSE57834 documented increased expression of ZEB2 in EVTs which is supported by an earlier study indicating the role of ZEB2 in EVT differentiation 50. Further, the higher expression of the TIMP1 and TIMP2 genes may indicate that trophoblast invasion is more tightly regulated than the metastatic cell migration / invasion 51.
Although, epigenetic regulation of EMT associated gene expression pattern during placental development has been suggested earlier 52 but the upstream regulators of this unique mesenchymal state of EVTs remain unknown. It is therefore intriguing to identify the key molecules that may have the potential to regulate this quasi-mesenchymal state. Through the topological analysis of the PPI network, four known upstream regulators of EMT were identified as HIF1A, ERBB2, NOTCH1, and CTNNB1 (Fig. 7B).
Hypoxia has been shown to be critical for placental development and trophoblast lineage differentiation 53–57. HIF1A is one of the key proteins involved in the molecular response to low oxygen tension 58,59. HIF1A is also involved in regulating EMT in various physiological and pathological states including cancers 44,60−62. Interestingly, HIF1A can influence trophoblast invasion both positively and negatively by modulating different proteins 63,64. This study identified higher expression of HIF1A in EVTs compared to CTBs in all the individual datasets suggesting that the quasi-mesenchymal nature of the EVTs might be regulated by HIF1A. Increased HIF1A may also help in preventing anoikis of EVTs under normal physiological conditions, wherein EVTs need to detach from the chorionic villi and invade the endometrium 65.
Receptor tyrosine kinase ERBB2 has also been shown to regulate anoikis and apoptosis 66,67. Our study has identified ERBB2 as a hub gene that showed significantly increased expression in EVTs (Fig. 8), which may be due to copy number variation of the gene 68. ERBB2 stabilizes HIF1A in cancer cells which also aids in drug resistance 69. Hence, it is possible that higher HIF1A in EVTs is attributable to upregulated expression of ERBB2. Additionally, ERBB2 is also known to promote EMT in various cancers 45,46. Therefore, higher ERBB2 in EVTs may contribute to the mesenchymal features in these cells either directly or through HIF1A.
NOTCH1 has also been identified as a potent regulator of EMT 47,48,70. Higher expression of NOTCH1 contributes to drug resistance in cancer, another mesenchymal trait 71. Interestingly, NOTCH1 was identified as another hub gene that demonstrated increased expression in EVTs (Figs. 7B and 8). A previous study also showed NOTCH1 as one of the critical regulators for the EVT fate specification during placentation 72. It has also been demonstrated that NOTCH1 can control trophoblast migration and invasion by upregulating MMPs in trophoblast cells 73.
In addition, many studies point towards the role of HIF1A/NOTCH1 crosstalk in EMT induction in various physio-pathological contexts 74–76. Hypoxia can induce angiogenic mimicry by trophoblast cells through NOTCH1 protein 77. Study using trophoblast cell lines identified that HIF1A regulates cell migration and invasion in NOTCH1 dependent manner 78. Increase in both HIF1A and NOTCH1 therefore may regulate the EMT phenomenon in the trophoblast cells.
Another known upstream promoter of EMT in multiple type of malignancies is CTNNB1, which is an adherens junction protein as well as a key mediator of the canonical Wnt signaling pathway 79–85. Interestingly, this study identified CTNNB1 as one of the hub genes, however, it showed decreased expression of CTNNB1 in EVTs (Figs. 7B and 8). A recent study also identified CTNNB1 as one of the regulators of the trophoblast lineage specification with reduced expression in EVTs 86. Hence, the novel quasi-mesenchymal nature of the EVTs may be attributed to the down-regulated expression of CTNNB1 that may function as a checkpoint for acquisition of full mesenchymal state.
It was also reported that HIF1A is involved in tumour progression and induces EMT in various cancers by enhancing CTNNB1 expression or activity 43,60,87−89. In contrast, some other studies suggest that HIF1A can decrease CTNNB1 gene expression which corroborates our observations 90,91. It has also been reported that EMT is regulated by the HIF1A/CTNNB1/NOTCH1 crosstalk in cancer 92. Taken together, we can postulate that the balanced expression of these four hub genes, HIF1A, NOTCH1, CTNNB1, and ERBB2, may be responsible for regulating this unique mesenchymal state of EVTs.
Few studies have examined the role of these four hub genes in different pregnancy associated pathological conditions. HIF1A shows higher expression in preeclamptic placenta compared to the normal placental tissue 93,94. This indicates prolonged hypoxia exposure to the trophoblast cells during the gestation period may be detrimental for both the mother and the fetus. Similarly, elevated levels of ERBB2 are found in the serum of preeclamptic patients which may lead to lower activity of ERBB2 in the trophoblast cells 95,96. On the contrary, NOTCH1 is downregulated in preeclampsia 97–100. The expression level of CTNNB1 in pregnancy-associated disorders is ambiguous with some of the studies reporting higher expression of CTNNB1 in preeclamptic tissue while another demonstrating lowered CTNNB1 expression in preeclampsia 101–103.