To induce the hexagonal CrN2 phase formation in the CrN matrix, the composition must change simultaneously with the crystal structure, which quite differs from conventional PCMs showing amorphization/crystallization without overall composition change. Thus, the Cr or N atoms should diffuse during the formation of N–N dimers upon phase change in the CrN layer. As confirmed by EDX in Fig. 2b, a poor Cr concentration was clearly observed in the active region of the CrN layer, indicating the diffusion of Cr atoms during phase transition. However, it is difficult to accurately detect the light element such as N using EDX. Therefore, the electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) exhibiting high sensitivity for N atoms was employed. Figure 3a, b shows the TEM image and EELS mapping of the CrN layer near the active region, obtained in the energy range of 408–422 eV. The N K-edge mapping clearly indicates a higher N concentration in the active region than in the CrN matrix. Hence, the combination of this EELS analysis with the EDX results (Fig. 2b) confirms a Cr-poor and N-rich composition of the active region. Note that, in our device substrate, there was an ultrathin TiN sidewall adhesion layer (3–5 nm) between the W plug heater and surrounded SiO2 insulator, as observed from the EDX mapping of Ti (Fig. 2b) and EELS mapping of N (Fig. 3b). As shown in Fig. 3a, the phase-change active region in the CrN layer was just above the TiN thin layer rather than on the whole surface of the W plug, which is quite different from the dome-like active region of conventional PCRAM3. Such a local composition variation under electrical pulses is similar to the switching phenomenon of ReRAM, where the formation/rupture of the conductive filament is realized by ion diffusion due to the application of electrical pulses. Unlike traditional materials for ReRAM, the CrN matrix is noninsulating and, therefore, does not need the formation of a conductive path. Hence, the phase change between LRS and HRS is more like the switching mechanism of traditional materials for PCRAM, where a high-resistance amorphous volume is formed in a conductive crystalline matrix by Joule heating. To rule out the role of unintentionally doped O in the CrN layer on switching properties, the EELS of O K-edge was taken in matrix (Point 1), N-rich (Point 2) and near electrode surface (Point 3) parts, as indicated in Fig. 3a. The peak intensity of O K-edge is equally weak compared to N K-edge, suggesting a negligible influence of O for phase change of the CrN layer. (Fig. 3c) To make it more convincing, we also tried to fabricate a pure CrN film (designated as CrN’ hereafter). The vacuum condition of a sputtering chamber and sputtering condition to obtain a pure CrN film without O contamination are very strict, which has become a remained open question in many fields such as coating and thermoelectric applications.27–29 Here, we found that the O content decreases by lowering the working pressure of the sputtering chamber. (Supporting information 7). Based on the results, we successfully obtained an O-free CrN’ film exhibiting the same crystal structure (NaCl-cubic) with the CrN film (Fig. S8) The CrN’ memory device exhibits similar RV characteristics and the TEM observation after the RESET operation reveals that the CrN’ device undergoes the phase change from NaCl-type cubic CrN to WC-type hexagonal CrN2, implying that this phase change is an intrinsic behavior in a CrN film. (Supporting information 9) In addition, interestingly enough, different carrier type was detected in CrN (p-type) and CrN’ (n-type) thin films by both Seebeck and Hall measurements. (Fig. S10) The same switching behavior between the CrN- and CrN’-based devices strongly supports that the defects or the carrier type have a minor effect on the switching properties of a CrN film.
Thus, to understand the driving force of nitrogen atom diffusion and phase change in the CrN devices, we simulated the thermal distribution under the application of a voltage30. In this simulation, thermoelectric effects such as the Thomson effect, Peltier effect, and thermal boundary resistance were ignored, as well as the contact resistance between the low resistive CrN (semi metallic-like) and metal electrodes because of its minor effect on the device operation. The specific structure and size of the simulated CrN-based memory device are presented in Fig. 3d. To understand the effect of the TiN adhesion layer between the W plug electrode and SiO2 insulator on the thermal distribution when applying a voltage, a single TiN plug-type memory device was also simulated. A positive voltage input of 0.2 V to the BE was simulated, along with a Joule heating generated within the memory structure (Supporting information 11). For the CrN-based memory device, the simulated temperature distribution (Fig. 3e) suggested that when a TiN adhesion layer exists between the W plug and SiO2 insulator, the hottest region inside the CrN layer is circularly distributed in an arc from near the top of the TiN sidewall layer to the middle of the CrN layer. This hottest region agrees well with the active region showing phase change in the CrN layer, which strongly demonstrates that Joule heating is key in the phase-change phenomenon. For the single TiN plug heater, instead, the hottest region covers the entire interface between the TiN and CrN layers. In this case, the phase change cannot occur just above the W plug heater because the Joule heat dissipates easily toward it due to the higher thermal conductivity of W compared with TiN, resulting in less residual heat above the heater 31. We also simulated the electrical field distribution under the application of a voltage in a CrN device with a W plug/TiN sidewall heater or a TiN plug heater (Fig. S11). The electric field was concentrated near the surface of the W plug heater rather than the inside the CrN layer due to the highly conductive W, similar to most electrical distributions in ReRAM devices 32. These results further indicate that the atomic diffusion in the middle part of the CrN layer and the phase change are driven by the thermal effect rather than the electrical field effect. The established thermophoresis/diffusion called Soret–Fick diffusion of atoms or vacancies can well explain the non-electrical field dependency of N atoms in this case 33. A large radial temperature gradient can be created and the Soret effect can become the dominant factor influencing atomic migration; the sign of the applied electrical field and the carrier types in CrN are not important for the Soret effect 34. It is noteworthy that the phase change after the above thermal diffusion process can be stable and nonvolatile at room temperature as indicated in current-time measurements which shows minor drift. (Fig. 3f) The cyclic resistive switching of the CrN device was also tested to be over 104 cycles, indicating good feasibility of the nitride PCM. (Supporting information 12)
Here, the switching mechanism of phase-change CrN can be shortly summarized in Fig. 4. The SET state originally shows the low resistance of a cubic CrN phase. When applying a voltage pulse, the lighter N atoms can diffuse to the hot active region (RESET-1 state) driven by Soret-effect and, synchronously, the phase change from cubic CrN to hexagonal CrN2 occurs (RESET-2 state). The hexagonal CrN2 phase can go back to the cubic CrN phase under mild Joule heating, where the SET operation can be performed with much less energy than the RESET operation. The above process is generally different with the conventional amorphous-crystalline chalcogenides-based PCMs.