During the growth and maturation, steroid sex hormones including testosterone play an important role in regulating bone metabolism. Androgens have an inhibitory effect on the osteoclastic bone resorption and they are necessary for achieving and maintaining normal bone and shape among males [32–34]. In addition, they stimulate protein synthesis to increase muscle mass and affect the deposition of calcium in the bones. Moreover, testosterone deficiency results in the inhibition of the development of mental and physical characteristics of cockerels [21, 28, 35]. As indicated by earlier studies, caponization influenced the weight gain and increased pectoral and leg muscle mass [19, 36–37], which is undoubtedly beneficial for their breeding. On the other hand, an imbalance in the ratio of muscle mass to bone mass can lead to excessive overload, resulting in bone deformities and even in fractures.
Our study showed that caponization had no effect on body weight in a group of 20-week-old individuals. These results correspond with several other studies [25, 36, 38]. Moreover, in presented study a drop in body weight in capons, compared to cockerels was noticed in the group of 16-week-old animals, and was also observed in ealier study [21]. In contrast, our study also showed that 24-week-old capons achieved significantly higher body weight compared to cockerels. Similar results were observed in a different study [30, 31, 37]. The differences in body weight of capons, shown in many studies, are likely due to the use of various breeds, lines or crossbred, as well as differences in the duration of rearing, different feeding and the age of the birds at which the castration procedure was performed [39].
An important criterion for evaluating bone abnormalities is the measurement of bone density. To determine bone quality and risk of bone fracture are used densitometric methods such us dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry DXA. Numerous studies show that androgen deficiency reduces bone mineral density in both humans and other mammals [40–43]. On the contrary, in the case of birds, the results of studies are not conclusive. As reported in Zawacka et al. (2018) [44] in the study conducted on inviduals at 12-week-old and 24-week-old Polish native breed, Greenleg Partridge, they observed higher BMD values within combined compact and cancellous bone of tibiotarsal bone in capons, compared to cockerels. Furthermore, Muszyński et al. [30] determined BMD and BMC values for the whole bone and separately for proximal and distal heads and middiaphyseal part of the femur and tibia of 24-week-old Polbar cockerels and capons. They showed reduced values of BMD in the midshaft of both bones and in the proximal epiphysis of femur in capons, compared to cockerels. In turn, Tomaszewska et al. [54] assessed tibia and femur densitometric parameters of total bone, midshaft and proximal and distal region of 24-week-old cockerels and capons of two breeds, i.e. Polbar and Greenleg Partridge. They found a reduction in BMD of total femoral bone in capons, compared to cockerels in both breeds. Additionaly, in the case of Greenleg Partridge, they noted lower values of BMC of total and midshaft part of femur, as well as midshaft part of tibia in capons, compared to cockerels. Also, what it is important, authors did not observe a negative effect of caponization on the other densitometric parameter of tibia bone, which is consistent with present study, where no significant effect of castration on the BMD and BMC levels of tibia bone of 16-, 20- and 24-week-old inviduals were observed. Taking some reports into account it was shown that androgen deficiency has led to decrease in bone mineral density and consequently osteoporotic changes in bone tissue [45–46]. It seems that factors such us breed, nutrition, age, living conditions or used testing methods also influence densitometric parameters.
The anatomical structure as well as the size of bone determines its mechanical strength [47–48]. The adaptation of bones to counteract pressures exerted on them occurs through variations in their shape and size and the internal structure of the bone tissue. Many studies analyzing changes in the mechanical strength of the avian skeletal system associated with individual growth have shown that the body weight of birds is mainly based on the tibia bone, therefore it is considered as a model bone in this type of studies [30, 49]. Literature data indicate that steroid hormones are necessary for the proper metabolism of bone tissue, and as a result of their deficiency, pathological changes may occur within it [50–51]. Confirmation of these observations could be osteometric studies. Chen et al. [52] in a study conducted on the 26-week-old Leghorn birds observed that caponization decreased tibia length. This result is in accordance with similar studies [35, 44, 53]. In the conducted research, it was noted that castration did not influence the tibia length in all analyzed rearing period groups of animals, which is consistent with other studies [7, 20, 30, 31, 54]. Varied results also apply to the bone mass. Negative effects of caponization on this parameter was reported by Chen et al. [20] and Chen et al. [53]. A similar reduction in bone mass of tibia bone among capons, compared to cockerels was shown by Zawacka et al. [44], but only among individuals slaughtered at 24 weeks of age, whereas in the case of 12-week-old animals authors found no such effect. However, similarly to the presented study, other studies report that caponization has no significant effect on tibia and femur bone mass [14, 30, 31, 52, 54, 55].
On the other hand, analyzing the effect of caponization on such parameters as: proximal and distal epiphysis width and relative bone weight of tibia bone, in our study these parameters were not influenced by the castration in all of the analyzed age groups of birds. The relative bone weight results included in this work are consistnt with the previous reports [30, 55]. Contrary to these however, were the results observed by Chen et al. [20] and Chen et al. [52], where the caponization decreased the relative bone weight. Similarly, Tomaszewska et al. [54] and Kwiecień et al. [31] showed the negative effect of castration on the value of this parameter for both femur and tibia bones. Furthermore, the results of geometric parameters of bones are ambiguous. In the experiment of Muszyński et al. [30], they found that tibia and femur midshaft of capons were characterized by larger diameters, compared to cockerels. Tomaszewska et. al. [54] found that caponization led to the increase of horizontal internal and external diameter and vertical external diameter of tibiotarsal bones of Polbar individuals. No effect of castration was observed in the case of either vertical internal diameter of Polbar and all diameters of tibia midshaft of Greenleg Partridge. Additionally, the same research shows higher values of horizontal external diameter and vertical internal and external diameter of femur bone of Polbar capons compared to cockerels. In the femur of Greenleg Partridge, the diameter dimension did not differ those of cockerels. However, similar results were reported by Kwiecień et. al. [31]. Our study showed no significant effect of castration on these parameters, except for the horizontal internal diameter of the 16-week-old individuals’ tibia bone, where significantly higher values were observed among capons compared to cockerels. The differences in the geometric parameters of the long bones of capons in relation to those of cockerels are observed in the literature. The values of these parameters are determined not only by castration, but also by the age, breed and types of bones. In this experiment, the lack of gonadal hormones among capons also did not affect the mean relative wall thickness MRWT and the cortical index CI of tibia bone, which is consistent with the results reported by Muszyński et al. [30], Tomaszewska et. al. [54] and Kwiecień et al. [31]. However, in our study, different results were obtained for the cross sectional area A parameter. Muszyński et al. [30] noted a larger cross sectional area of the tibia and femur of capons compared to cockerels. Similar alteration in the Polbar’ femur, has been observed by Tomaszewska et. al. [54]. On the other hand, in the case of tibia bone of Polbar and Greenleg Partridge, the authors showed no effect of caponization on the value of this parameter. It is consistent with our study and other observations [31]. Only few of the scientific reports take into account the parameters, i.e. moment of inertia and moment of gyration, which are not a direct geometric parameter, but serve to determine its mechanical strength (material properties) [30, 56]. Some researchers observed an increase in the moment of inertia and moment of gyration of the tibia and femur of capons compared to cockerels [30, 31]. In contrast, in the present study, castration did not affect the moment of inertia and moment of gyration of tibia in all analyzed rearing period groups of animals. There are many indications that the differences in osteometric and geometric properties between capons and cockerels, observed in the literature, may be due to the use of different breeds, lines, rearing and feeding technologies.
Analysis of the bone’s supportive properties is possibile by studying the strength parameters. One method of assessing them is the three-point bending test. It is known that bone strength is affected by many factors, one of which is sex steroid hormones. Hence, the analysis of hormone levels on the mechanical parameters of bone tissue has been the subject of numerous studies among both birds and mammals [9, 58, 59]. In presented work, caponization resulted in the reduction of the yield load Fel of the tibia bone only in the group of 20-week-old and 24-week-old birds. Another study has also shown no effect of caponization on yield load although, in contrast to our experiment, this study involved both femur and tibia bone [30]. Similarly, Tomaszewska et al. [54] found a reduction in the value of this parameter in capons but only in the case of the femur of Greenleg Partridge birds. On the other hand, in the case of femur of Polbar and the tibia of Polbar and Greenleg Partridge individuals, authors did not observe differences in yield load between cocks and capons. Kwiecień et al. [31] also showed a reduction in yield load in capons compared to cockerels, but only in the femur. In the case of the tibia bone, authors noted no effect of caponization on the value of this parameter, which is consistent with our results among 16-week-old individuals. The varied results of the study also apply to the ultimate load parameter. Muszyński et al. [30] found no effect of caponization on the value of this parameter for both tibia and femur. Also, Kuźniacka et al. [60] did not demonstrate the effect of castration on ultimate load of the tibia and femur of 16-, 18- and 20-week-old Plymouth Rock birds. In contrast, Tomaszewska et al. [54] observed a reduced value of the ultimate strength of the femur of 24-week-old capons of Greenleg Partridge compared to cockerels of the same breed and age. No difference in ultimate load between cockerels and capons within the femur of Polbar individuals and tibia bone of both breeds were observed by the authors. Similarly, Kwiecień et al. [31] showed that caponization affects the reduced value of this parameter in capons compared to cockerels, but only in the case of tibia bone. A number of studies also have shown that sex steroid hormone deficiency in capons leads to lower values of ultimate load of tibia bone compared to individuals with normal level of testosterone [20, 52, 53], which is also consistent with the results of our study. Moreover, the available literature lacks information on the effects of caponization on mechanical strength properties, i.e. elastic energy, work to fracture, stiffness and toughness modulus. Only Muszyński et al. [30] conducted this type of analysis, but excluding the toughness modulus. However, the authors did not demonstrate the effect of castration on the values of the above-mentioned parameters. No differences in elastic energy and work to fracture between capons and cocks were also found in the presented work. In contrast, stiffness (describing the bone resistance to deformation) in our experiment showed a reduced value among capons compared to cockerels, but only among 20-week-old and 24-week-old animals. Whereas in the group of birds slaughtered at the 16th week of age, there was no siginificant effects of caponization on the value of this trait. Martens et al. [61] and Stromsoe et al. [48] indicate that bone geometry has a significant effect on its properties during deflection. Hence, it can be assumed that changes in the mechanical parameters of bone may be related to changes in the geometry of the marrow cavity.
More complete information related to changes in the structure of bone tissue are provided by studies of the material parameters of bone. In our study, the castration had no significant effect of Young modulus in all of the analyzed age groups of birds. On the contrary, Muszyński et al. [30] note that castration decreases Young modulus, for both femur and tibia bone. Moreover, the results of our experiment and previous studies demonstrated that bending moment M of bone decreased after caponization [30, 53]. Research conducted on birds bred until the 16th, 18th and 20th week of age, showed that there were no differences between cocks and capons in terms of yield strain εy of tibia bone in all tested age groups of animals [60], which is consistent with the results of our study. However, in another experimental trial [30] an increase in the yield strain of femur and tibia bone of capons compared to cockerels were shown. It should be noted that bone fracture usually occurs when the learning of the „material” on the opposite side to the applied force happens. The deformation arising during this process is referred to as ultimate strain εf. Hence, this indicator is very important to evaluating the material parameter of bones. In our study, as well as in Muszyński et al. [30] work, no effect of caponization on the value of this parameter was observed. Confirmation of these results may also be provided by the observation of Kuźniacka et al. [60], who reported no changes in deflection at the femur and tibia fractures between capons and cockerels at 18th and 20th weeks of age. Interesting information is also provided by Muszyński et al. [30], which determined the effect of caponization on the yield stress σy. The authors observed a reduced value of this parameter in both long bones (femur and tibia) among capons compared to cocks. On the other hand, in the presented work, caponization did not influence the yield stress σy in all analyzed rearing period groups of animals. On this basis, it can be concluded that stresses developed during deflection in presented experiment, were similar in the bones of cockerels and capons, and this may indicate that their response was the same as the deformation. It has been speculated that the castration procedure may also affect the ultimate stress σf (maximum stress that a bone could hold off in bending before fracture) which is supported by reports by Lin and Hsu [7], who observed a reduction value of this parameter in the tibia bone of the 28-week-old capons of Taiwan country compared to cockerels of the same age and breed. Similar results were obtained for tibia bone in the current study, but only among 20-week-old and 24-week-old individuals. Another studies has also shown reduced values of this parameters as a result of caponization [20, 30, 52]. On the other hand, Chen et al. [53] found no effect of caponization on tibia ultimate stress of 40-week-old Taiwan country birds, which was also observed among 16-week-old individuals in the presented experiment. The discrepancies in the present study may indicate that caponization affects the deterioration of bone tissue in the tibia bone region, but does not interfere with its ability to perform its support-bearing function, probably due to adaptive changes in bone geometry.
One of the factors affecting the mechanical strength of bone is the degree of its mineralization [62, 63]. According to Currey [64] and Schaffler and Burr [65] there is a relationship between mineralization and the elastic modulus of bone, which directly affects its behavior during elastic deformation. A high degree of mineralization increases the bone fragility and lowers the total energy required to break it. In turn, too much reduced mineralization increases the work to fracture bone and increases the deformability [66]. According to the literature, sex hormones play an important role in the mineralization of the skeletal system [67]. Tomaszewska et al. [54] determined ash content of long bones (tibiae and femora) of 24-week-old cockerels of the Polbar and Greenleg Partridge breed. They found a negative effect of the castration procedure only in the femur of Polbar birds. In the case of the tibia bone of Polbar capons and the tibia and femur of capons of Greenleg Partridge did not differ in the level percentage of bone ash compared to the cockerels. Similarly, Lin and Hsu [7] showed no changes in the level of tibial ash of 28-week-old capons compared to cockerels of the same age. Chen et al. [55] analyzing the tibial ash content of 26-week-old Leghorn capons, found lower levels of bone ash among capons compared to cockerels. Other authors have also proved reduced bone (femoral and tibia) mineralization in capons [30, 31]. These observations also confirm the results obtained in the present study, which indicate reduced mineralization of the tibia bone as a result of caponization, but only among 20-week-old and 24-week-old individuals. In a group of 16-week-old birds, there was no effect of castration on the value of this parameter and this suggests that persistent testosterone deficiency as capons age slow down the rate of mineralization and mineral formation in the tibial bone matrix. The mineralization depends on the content of calcium Ca and phosphorus P in the bone and their molar ratio [68]. Previous studies indicate that lack of testosterone may contribute to the disruption of these macroelements levels in the bones [9, 55]. Muszyński et al. [30] analyzed the Ca content of the tibial and femoral bones of 24-week-old Polbar cockerels and capons. Authors showed that lack of sex steroids contribiutes to lower Ca level only in the femur. Similar results were obtained by Kwiecień et al. [31]. On the other hand, the negative effect of caponization on Ca levels in the tibia bone was shown by Lin and Hsu [7] among the individuals at their 28th week of rearing period. Also, Lin et al. [9] showed a reduction in Ca content in the tibia bone of capons at 26th and 30th week of age compared to cockerels of the same age. In the other groups (at the 14th, 18th, 22nd and 35th week of age), the authors noted no effect of castration on the Ca level. Another study has also shown no effect of caponization on the Ca content in the femur and tibia bone [54]. Similar results were obtained for the tibia bone in the presented experiment for all analyed age groups of animals. These observations are also consistent with the results of Chen et. al. [55], where they also observed no effect of caponization on Ca content of tibia bone of Leghorn capons and cockerels at their 26th week of age. As mentioned earlier, P is an essential factor regulating the bone mineralization. In the present study, the caponization did not cause changes in the P content of the tibia bones, which was also observed in previous investigations [7, 31, 54]. On the other hand, some reports noted different results. Muszyński et al. [30] found that capons’ long bones (tibial and femoral) were characterized by lower level of P compared to cockerels’ bones. Moreover, similar results were reported by Chen et al. [55]. In contrast, Lin et al. [9] observed a reduction in the P content of tibia bone of capons compared to cockerels, but only at the 18th, 26th and 30th week of their rearing period. In the case of other groups, at the 14th, 22nd and 35th week of age, the castration had no effect on value of this parameter. It is not only the determination of Ca and P in the bones that is used to assess the mineral composition of the bones, but also their mutual ratio which is important. Similar to the presented experiment, most of the previous studies found no changes in the ratio of Ca:P in the tibial and femoral bones as a result of caponization [31, 54]. On the other hand, Muszyński et al. [30] noted an increased ratio of these macroelements, but only in the tibia bone of capons compared to cockerels.
In conclusion, our study has shown that caponization negatively affected the bone mineralization and some mechanical and material tibia bone parameters, especially among the 20-week-old and 24-week-old individuals.