We analyzed, for the first time, the population structure and reproductive of seal lice strategies under natural conditions in two species of pack-ice seals on the Antarctic Peninsula. Our main conclusion is that A. lobodontis, from crabeater seals, and A. carlinii, from Weddell seals have different reproductive strategies. Although we did not have information on the reproductive season of crabeater seals, our results confirm that A. lobodontis would reproduce at least during the molting season of the seals, whereas the reproduction of A. carlinii would occur mainly during the reproductive season of seals(Soto et al. 2022). As we will discuss, these differences may be related to their host's habitat use and foraging behavior.
We found all lice stages (N1, N2, N3, and adults) and potentially viable eggs in crabeater seals. We conducted a preliminary essay on incubated eggs simulating natural conditions (humidity and temperature), and their hatching was successful under these conditions (Soto, unpublished results). These results could indicate that A. lobodontis could reproduce whenever seals haul out during the molting season. The lice would then take advantage of their host’s diving behavior, as CS dives shallower and for less time than WS. From the previous study, we know that the mean dive depth of CS was 61 m for 3.8 min (Costa et al. 2010). In summer, they use to dive during darkness and haul out during daylight (see diving details in (Southwell et al. 2012)), probably in response to prey availability (Bengtson and Cameron 2004). Therefore, the combination of short and shallow dives and the continuous haul-out may allow eggs development. This idea is supported by the fact that transmission of A. lobodontis should be horizontal, especially between juveniles (Soto et al. 2020). Juveniles spent more time on land than adults. However, this needs to be tested experimentally.
In contrast, only N3 and adults were found in Weddell seals. Accordingly, one of the transmission strategies of A. carlinii could be through the mobility of mainly adult lice, which can reproduce and complete a generation in a short period of time. However, as WS dives deeper and longer than CS (91 m for 11.5 min; (Costa et al. 2010)), lice would have less time to reproduce or at least to successfully hatch eggs. As we described in a previous study (Soto et al. 2022), the main way of transmission of A. carlinii should be from female seals to their pups. We also observed that adult A. carlinii were more likely to be transmitted than nymphs and females more likely than males, the same pattern described for A. microchir from sea lions [6].
Seal lice appear to have different reproductive strategies to ensure their reproductive success. For example, A. microchir from South American sea lions completes its cycle when the host spends enough time ashore and only newborn pups spend enough time outside of the water (Aznar et al. 2009; Leonardi et al. 2014). In this context, at least during host molting season, A. lobodontis probably has more time to complete a generation than A. carlinii, depending on the amount of time that its host spends ashore. Such strategies reflect strong co-adaptation and co-evolutionary mechanisms, depending their host life history and behavior.
Regarding the infestation parameters, during the molting season, female crabeater seals reach higher mean abundance and mean intensity than female Weddell seals. Therefore, we assume that A. lobodontis is reproducing while the seals are molting. We know from a previous study (Murray et al. 1965) that in Weddell seals dispersion of A. carlini (formerly A. ogmorhini) occurs by the transmission of adult lice exclusively from female seals to their pups during the reproductive season, reaching a complete generation in 3–4 weeks. As we did not find any eggs in this sample, we need to elucidate when A. carlinii has the opportunity to lay eggs.
When comparing age classes, juveniles of both species had higher prevalence and abundance than adults. From previous studies, we know that these parameters depend mainly on the age class of the hosts (Soto et al. 2020, 2022), with juveniles being more abundant than adults. This pattern may also be related to the diving behavior of the host. Juveniles used to spend less time submerged than adults (Burns et al. 1999) and consequently spend more time on land, which improves lice dispersal.
Recently, a phylogenomic analysis of seal lice showed no divergences between A. lobodontis, A. carlinii, and A. ogmorhini (Leonardi et al. 2019). Some authors postulate that the genetic differences between them are not sufficient to be considered as different species (Dong et al. 2022). However, the differences in the population structure of the two species observed here could indicate that they are different species, or at least that they have undergone different co-evolutionary processes depending on the habit of their hosts.
In conclusion, the study of different seal-lice systems allows us to understand how evolutionary history has shaped the life cycle of each species. Further experimental is needed to fully understand the life cycle of both lice species and to characterize the reproductive strategies they use to ensure their reproductive success.