Considering the importance of antioxidant capacity in oxidative stress defense in the body, this study investigated blood and hair levels of potential antioxidant trace minerals and their associations with the oxidative stress marker 8-OHdG according to various health parameters. Different levels of serum or hair trace minerals were observed according to subjects’ characteristics such as age or exercise. We found significant associations of hair zinc and chromium with urinary 8-OHdG among older participants, those with poor health status, and those with an irregular diet.
The mean serum zinc concentration in this study was 1003.71 µg/L, which is within the range reported in published Korean studies (600–1900 µg/L) (18, 19). Hair zinc concentrations also ranged within the reference range of Medinex Korea (20), which performed the hair test (mean of 181.67 µg/g), and corresponded with values ranging from 150 to 210 µg/g in published Korean studies (20–22). An international study also reported a range of 120–250 µg/g (23). Zinc concentration may vary depending on factors such as age, BMI (obesity status), and residence, with younger people (24, 25), those who are not obese (20), those who exercise (26), and those who live in cities (27) showing higher zinc concentrations. In this study, serum zinc concentration differed significantly with age. Serum zinc concentration also tended to decrease with increasing BMI; however, the difference was not significant. Despite not showing a significant difference, the concentration change with BMI followed the same trend as that reported in a previous study (28). A sustained deficiency of zinc may lead to increased fat mass and decreased lean body mass. In obesity, zinc metabolism is prone to instability, with reduced absorption in the small intestine and increased excretion from the body (29, 30). Therefore, zinc concentration is of particular interest in the context of obesity. Additionally, serum zinc concentration was significantly different depending on the exercise status. Serum zinc concentrations in the exercise group were lower than those in the control group, which may have been due to higher 8-OHdG concentrations in the exercise group than in the control group. These findings suggest that serum zinc acts as an antioxidant against exercise-induced stress. Compared to previous studies on exercise, in one case, the control group had higher levels than the exercise group (31), but in other cases, the exercise group had higher levels than the control group (32). These differences may be due to interactions with other factors, such as age, sex, and diet, which may influence serum zinc concentration. Therefore, we suggest that further studies should be conducted to investigate changes in concentration with exercise after controlling for these factors. As shown in the results above, this study showed that serum zinc concentration was significantly different from the general characteristic factors, but hair zinc concentration was not.
In the present study, serum manganese concentration was 1.45 µg/L, in line with the range reported in previous studies (0.7–3.4 µg/L) (33, 34). Hair manganese concentration averaged 0.19 µg/g, which was slightly below the reference range of Medinex Korea (20). Compared to the concentrations reported in domestic and international studies (average 0.15–0.4 µg/g), the result was within the range (20, 21, 35, 36). In this study, serum manganese concentration tended to decrease with age, although the difference was not significant. Hair manganese levels were significantly higher in those in good health than in those in poor health. Manganese is a particularly diet-sensitive nutrient, characterized by a decrease in the body owing to low food intake or when its bioavailability is reduced in conditions such as disease (37). Manganese concentration may also be influenced by occupation and environment, with welding workers and those living near steel industrial parks having higher manganese concentrations than control subjects (33, 38). Excessive accumulation of manganese in the body has been reported to cause anemia and to negatively affect the nervous system (39). Constant exposure to metals in the environment or due to occupation necessitates close attention to this factor.
The mean serum selenium concentration in this study was 156.43 µg/L, corresponding with the range reported in Korean studies (84–284 µg/L) (40, 41). Comparisons with other countries (average 67–136 µg/L), including China, Malaysia, Syria, Iran, and Sweden, indicated higher concentrations in Korea (42). Differences in concentrations between countries may be attributed to diet and environment. Hair selenium in this study averaged 0.60 µg/g, within the reference range of Medinex Korea (20). Serum selenium concentrations decreased with increasing age and were significantly different between the groups. The results of published studies on selenium concentrations with age vary. We found some studies that showed a positive correlation (43), others that showed a negative correlation (44), and others that showed no association (45). Different age ranges and characteristic dietary profiles, as well as different health conditions of the sample population, may have triggered these discrepancies.
The serum chromium concentration in this study was 0.34 µg/L, slightly lower than the range (0.37–3.96 µg/L) reported in domestic and international studies (46–48). Hair chromium concentration averaged 0.40 µg/g, falling within the reference range of Medinex Korea (20) and that of domestic and international studies (0.15–2.2 µg/g). Serum chromium concentration was not significantly different from the general characteristic factors; however, hair chromium concentration differed significantly according to sex (men > women), alcohol consumption (drinker > non-drinker), and eating habits (regular > irregular). Hexavalent chromium is toxic, whereas trivalent chromium has beneficial effects in humans. Drinking alcohol sensitizes the organs of the body, such as the liver, to hexavalent chromium toxicity (49). In this study, 89% of the men and 52% of the women were drinkers. Sex differences in alcohol consumption may have influenced hair chromium concentration. However, there have been only a few clinical and mechanistic studies on the relationship between alcohol consumption and hair chromium concentration. Therefore, further studies are needed to understand the mechanisms of action and association between alcohol and chromium.
The mean urinary 8-OHdG level was 130.83 ng/mg creatinine. When comparing men and women, men had a mean concentration of 122.91 ng/mg creatinine, and women had a mean concentration of 136.71 ng/mg creatinine, with women having a slightly higher mean concentration than men, but there was no significant difference between the sexes. A review of published studies suggests that establishing a reference range for 8-OHdG concentrations may be difficult because it is sensitive to sex, age, body composition, smoking status, diet, ionizing radiation (50, 51), and occupational and environmental factors, resulting in a wide range of measured concentrations and difficulty in assessing the impact of only one factor (52). In one clinical study, urinary 8-OHdG concentration increased with age (53), whereas other studies showed no difference (54). A comparison of urinary 8-OHdG concentration in smokers and non-smokers showed that smokers had 2.84 times higher concentration of urinary 8-OHdG than non-smokers among subjects with a BMI of ≤ 25 (50), contrary to the results that 8-OHdG was a good prognostic factor in non-small cell lung cancer and was positively correlated with non-smokers (55). Another study examining changes in 8-OHdG concentration by alcohol consumption and exercise did not show a significant correlation, but an association was observed between 8-OHdG concentration and nutritional supplement intake (56). Additional studies are required to determine the sensitivity of this marker to environmental factors and nutritional status.
In the present study, 8-OHdG concentrations were significantly higher in exercisers than in non-exercisers. Although there were differences in the type and duration of exercise, previous studies have reported similar results (57, 58). We found no significant differences between 8-OHdG concentrations and any of the other general characteristic factors except exercise status. In the correlation analysis, 8-OHdG and hair zinc concentrations were negatively correlated in subjects aged > 60 years with poor health status, whereas 8-OHdG and hair chromium concentrations were positively correlated in subjects with irregular eating habits. However, no correlation was found between 8-OHdG concentration and serum antioxidant trace minerals. One possible explanation for this result is that the subjects in this study were relatively healthy adults who were influenced by defense systems other than antioxidant trace minerals (59). However, it is possible that the study participants would have had different results if their concentrations of trace antioxidant minerals were below or above this range. Accordingly, our finding of a significant association between hair zinc and chromium levels and urinary 8-OHdG levels in more vulnerable subjects with older age, poorer health status, and irregular diet is significant. However, this was a cross-sectional study with limitations in the causal interpretation of these associations, and there is a need for future longitudinal studies to elucidate the relationship between these minerals and various oxidative markers.
We simultaneously determined antioxidant trace minerals in the serum and hair and compared the antioxidant trace mineral concentrations between groups within the general characteristics. Some results showed significant differences in concentrations based on general characteristics. In addition, we correlated serum and hair antioxidant trace mineral concentrations with oxidative stress markers and found a partially significant correlation. However, the limitations of this study include the fact that participants were recruited from a limited space in and around a university hospital; therefore, the sample size was small and not representative of the entire population. Second, only one oxidative stress marker, 8-OHdG, was used, and a variety of other oxidative stress markers were not included. Third, the study did not include an assessment of the subjects’ intake of macrominerals and antioxidant trace minerals. Fourth, because this study was conducted in normal subjects, a study of normal subjects with a wide range of measured concentrations and a comparative study of antioxidant trace mineral concentrations between normal and abnormal subjects is required. Despite these limitations, this study is significant for several reasons. First, this study compared antioxidant trace mineral concentrations between groups within general characteristic factors in healthy subjects, which may be used as a basis for future observational studies on antioxidant trace minerals according to general characteristics. Second, we observed correlations between serum or hair antioxidant trace minerals and 8-OHdG levels, with some results showing significant correlations. These results may be used as a basis for evaluating the applicability of antioxidant trace minerals to specific disease groups associated with oxidative stress.