To our knowledge, this cross-sectional study is the largest NP carriage investigation in healthy children in Hainan Province. We present the results of a population-based survey on NP carriage prior to adopting PCVs in China’s national immunization schedules. The baseline data will enable the estimation of the vaccine impact of PCV13 implementation. The overall NP carriage rate was 30.4% in our study. Previous surveillance studies of NP carriage, prior to the introduction of PCV13, have revealed a higher rate of NP carriage in children under 5 years of age in some Asian countries. In Thailand, Indonesia and India, the overall carriage rates were 35.9%, 49.5% and 54.5%, respectively[18–20]. A meta-analysis performed from studies conducted in southeast Asia showed that the pooled prevalence of NP carriage in healthy children under 5 years of age was 36.0% (95% CI: 34.2%–37.8%)[21].The overall NP carriage in our study was higher than that reported from other regions in China. Earlier studies of NP carriage in Beijing, Shanghai and Chongqing indicated that the overall carriage rates were 22%, 16.6% and 16.6%, respectively[22–24]. In 2017, prior to the introduction of PCV13 in China, a meta-analysis of data from young children found that the pooled prevalence of NP carriage was 21.4% (95% CI: 18.3–24.4%)[24]. Several factors could account for the discrepancy observed in our study, including geography, socioeconomic status, sample collection and differences in laboratory procedures used for Spn identification. For example, higher NP carriage rates were observed in less-developed countries[25,26]. In the sample collection and processing procedures, we ensured that the NP swabs were placed within STGG medium on dry ice as quickly as possible (within 30 minutes). This allowed for storage and transport of NP specimens at temperatures below -70℃, which proved to be optimal conditions without loss of colony-forming units (CFU)[17]. In addition, molecular biology methods were used for detection, thereby enhancing sensitivity and detection rates compared to culture-based procedures alone. In our laboratory procedures, we extracted DNA from enriched cultures and detected the targeting lytA gene using real-time PCR method, and this result was very useful for the detection of pneumococci in culture procedures, especially for the samples with low organism concentrations.
The top 5 serotypes in our study (6B, 19F, 23A, 6A, and 23F) accounted for 64.7% of all carriage strains. In line with other carriage studies and systematic reviews conducted in China[22,23,27,28], vaccine serotypes 6B, 19F, 6A and 23F were highly prevalent; other vaccine serotypes 1, 4, 5, 7F, 8 and 9 were relatively rare in our study. Notably, the serotype distribution was relatively consistent with the serotypes frequently associated with IPD in China[29]. Of significant concern was the high prevalence of certain non-vaccine serotypes, which could potentially reduce the benefits of vaccination. The top 3 non-vaccine serotypes (23A, 34 and NT) accounted for 24.4% of all carriage strains. Serotype 23A was prevalent in our study, particularly in Haikou, where it was the dominant serotype. In contrast, it was rarely observed in other carriage studies conducted in different regions of China and other countries. Considering the relatively high PCV13 immunization rate in Haikou, the potential risk of serotype replacement by non-vaccine serotypes requires vigilance. Throughout Asia and Australia[18,19,30,31], NT pneumococci were the most commonly isolated organisms, with some NT pneumococci being co-colonizing isolates. Our findings also revealed that some NT pneumococci co-colonized with other serotypes. Although NT pneumococci are infrequent causes of invasive disease in young children, they are associated with a variety of mucosal diseases and may serve as an essential reservoir for antimicrobial resistance genes.[32].
The NP carriage rate and serotype distribution vary by geography and are altered by the implementation of PCVs and socioeconomic status. We recruited healthy children from 4 different regions in Hainan Province. Haikou, the provincial capital with a higher economic level than other regions, had the majority of children vaccinated with PCV13. Consequently, the lowest PCV13 serotype coverage rates were also observed in Haikou. Although the overall carriage rates remained stable or relatively moderately declined after the introduction of PCVs in several studies[33–35], lower carriage rates were found in children vaccinated with PCV13 in our study. This could be attributed to higher economic levels and better living conditions, which reduce the likelihood of pneumococcal carriage.
Several expected epidemiologic factors showed associations with pneumococcal carriage. Consistent with previous findings[25,34,36], factors such as age, daycae attendance, presence of siblings, residing in a rural area and having a lower socioeconomic status were significantly associated with higher rates of pneumococcal colonization. Previous studies have reported that breastfeeding was associated with lower rates of pneumococcal colonization[37,38]. Considering that the majority of Chinese children are weaned between 1 and 2 years old, and that breastfeeding has minimal impact on pneumococcal colonization in children over 2 years old, only children under 2 years old were included in the bivariate analysis. However, in our study, breastfeeding showed no relationship to colonization. Antibiotic therapy, previously associated with reduced odds of pneumococcal colonization[34], showed no such association in our study. After adjustment for multiple factors, only 5 factors remained statistically significant. Consistent with several previous studies[34,36], having siblings and daycae attendance were identified as risk factors for carriage. This is likely due to the transmission of pneumococci between children within the same family and kindergarten through close contact. Studies conducted in the UK suggested that reduced-dose schedules have been shown to be immunogenic and have little impact on IPD or pneumococcal community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) cases[39,40]. However, 2 primary doses of the PCVs received in the first year of life have a weak effect on colonization. In line with this study, we found that completion of 3-4 doses of PCV13 was associated with a lower likelihood of NP carriage[41]. Several factors could explain this observation. First, echoing previous findings, high IgG concentrations are required to reduce and prevent NP carriage[42]. After the infant series (3 doses of PCV13) and the toddler dose (4 doses of PCV13), children obtained high IgG concentrations, contributing to the clearance of NP-carriage and prevention of new colonization. In addition, since PCV13 was not widely used in China, non-vaccine serotypes replacement was less obvious than that in other countries with high PCV13 vaccination coverage[43].
Our study has several limitations. First, our investigation was a single-center study confined to Hainan Province; thus, the findings might not represent the overall NP carriage trends in China. Conducting a multicenter investigation of NP carriage and serotype distribution is essential to provide important epidemiological baseline data for assessing the impact of PCVs on NP carriage, especially prior to the introduction of PCV13 into national immunization. Second, carriage patterns also varied with seasonality. Our investigation took place over a 1-month period in each region, and some vaccine serotypes were not found or were uncommon in our study; these serotypes are common causes of IPD. Therefore, the NP carriage patterns may not accurately predict the distribution of specific serotypes causing severe disease in the local area.