Pregnancy is one of the most critical periods of human life, requiring massive changes in extremely complex physiological circuits. Interferences in these circuits can have adverse effects across generations. Hence, understanding these changes is key to preventing adverse effects and promoting a healthy life for children. Our study investigated HCC, a biomarker of HPA axis activity, with several covariates, including psychosocial stress measures (stress, anxiety, and depression) during the pre-pregnancy and pregnancy periods in a large sample of pregnant Peruvian women. Overall, we observed increased levels of HCC before and throughout pregnancy, peaking in the third trimester. Furthermore, we found that HCC was associated with pre-pregnancy BMI in all four prenatal periods, but time-specific associations were seen between HCC and gestational age at HCC collection, hair treatment, difficulty accessing basic foods, and symptoms of antenatal depression, after controlling for well-known confounders. We found no statistically significant associations between HCC and symptoms of anxiety or perceived stress neither before nor during pregnancy.
The mean HCC values observed in our sample were, on average, lower compared to other studies that investigated HCC during pregnancy, as shown in a recent systematic review of 56 studies by Marceau et al. 51. Nevertheless, the observed mean values in our sample ranging between 3.38 and 5.59 pg/mg, lie within most mean levels observed by Marceau et al. (2020). We are aware of only one study investigating HCC in a pregnant Peruvian sample 52 (not overlapping with samples in this study) 41,44,45,53,54. Interestingly, Dobernecker et al. 52 observed considerably higher HCC levels in 39 participants, which may be due to the small sample size used and the characteristics of the participants, given that more than 50% reported previous experiences of trauma, implicating a higher chronic cortisol secretion. Furthermore, we observed an increase in HCC across pregnancy, peaking in the third trimester. This increase in HCC across pregnancy was also found in previous studies, although not consistently. For example, Marceau et al. 51 did not find this increase in half of the reviewed studies, questioning this often-referenced assumption. Recently, this questioning was mitigated, as qualitatively more precise studies examining individual HCC trajectories 55 or more fine-grained time intervals 56 obtained HCC increases across pregnancy, although in a non-linear way, with interindividual differences and massive within-person variations. This non-linear cortisol increase is in accordance with established biological findings. Beginning with gestational week seven, cortisol secretion is increasingly stimulated by the temporary growth of the pituitary gland and by the placenta 57–61, due to an isolated excitatory influence of the placental cortisol-releasing hormone on cortisol secretion, leading to cortisol elevations up to five-fold in certain tissues 61–64.
For providing a methodological foundation for further investigations of HCC in pregnant samples, we investigated the bivariate influence of twenty-one pregnancy-related, sociodemographic, and hair-related covariates on HCC. The only covariates that showed a significant bivariate influence on HCC in at least two time points and in a consistent manner were maternal BMI, maternal education, difficulty accessing basic foods, and infant sex, which is partly consistent with previous studies 38–40,45,65. For instance, we showed a significant difference in prenatal HCC by infant sex, whereby women giving birth to a female infant had significantly higher HCC preconception and in the first trimester, compared to women giving birth to a male infant. The vast majority of previous studies did not find such an effect 33,38,39,44,61,66–73. However, Romero-Gonzalez et al.65 recently reported significant differences in prenatal HCC by infant sex. Similar to our findings, they found a higher first-trimester HCC in women carrying a female compared to a male baby 65. These findings indicate that prenatal experiences of stress may influence the survival of the fetus and the secondary sex ratio distribution in the population; however, further results from Romero-Gonzalez et al. 65 found no significant impact on infant sex by perceived stress.
The correlation observed between educational level and HCC is similarly inconsistent based on results from previous pregnancy studies. While some studies found a statistically significant influence of educational level on HCC 38–40,74,75, others found no such effect 61,68,76–78. For example, in a subsample of N = 62 pregnant women from Spain, HCC differed significantly regarding educational level across the three trimesters, with participants of higher education showing lower HCC in the first and second, but not in the third trimester 40. Our results were directionally and time-consistently related to the associations identified by Garcia-Leon et al. 40. Given the close relationship between educational attainment and income 79, it is possible that our finding of the correlation between education and HCC corresponds with the association identified between difficulty accessing basic foods and HCC in our study. This notion is supported by the fact that we found both variables, education and difficulty accessing basic foods, to be correlated, although this correlation was weak. We did not find other studies except our own 45,53 investigating difficulty accessing basic foods among pregnant women, which might be explained by the uniqueness of our LMIC sample, as most studies examining HCC among pregnant women have been conducted in high-income countries in North America and Europe 51 where including difficulty accessing basic foods might be less important.
In bivariate and multivariable analyses, we found that pre-pregnancy BMI was the strongest predictor of HCC before and during pregnancy. This finding is in accordance with some 39,44,55,66,74,75,80,81 but not all 38,45,67,77,82,83 previous studies. To our knowledge, only two studies have investigated the association between HCC and maternal BMI across all three trimesters 40,74 with partly conflicting findings. While Bosquet Enlow et al. 74 found a significant positive correlation between BMI and HCC in the second but not in the first and third trimesters in a sample of n = 93 U.S.-American women, Garcia-Leon et al. 40 failed to find such an association in their Spanish sample of n = 62 women. As we investigated HCC in a pregnant sample three to ten-fold larger than in previous studies, our findings of an unbiased and consistent association between pre-pregnancy BMI and HCC in all four prenatal periods (i.e., from preconception to the third trimester), add to this existing evidence. An association between BMI and HCC is likely, as associations between measures of obesity and both, HPA-axis activity 84 and stress 85, are well established in non-pregnant samples.
From the different psychosocial stress measures considered in our study, maternal symptoms of antenatal depression was the only measure associated exclusively with first-trimester HCC after controlling for relevant covariates. While such findings have been reported in previous studies, evidence is still conflicting about the temporal aspect of this association. For instance, there have been studies that report a positive association of HCC with antenatal depression in every trimester of pregnancy 33,34, except for the pre-pregnancy period 41. However, an equal number of studies support a null association of antenatal depression with HCC in late pregnancy 35–37, or throughout pregnancy 41. Identifying an association of depression with HCC restricted to the first trimester is a plausible finding. One explanation for this finding is the fact that levels of HCC in early pregnancy are lower than in subsequent trimesters, where they tend to be more influenced by physiological factors, which implies that the associations between psychosocial stressors like depression and HCC are more likely to be detected in early versus in late pregnancy 86. This observation agrees with the concept of a “ceiling effect” for stressors measured in pregnancy, which suggests that their influence is only apparent when the physiological response measured is low to moderate 41. The fact that in our study we assessed antenatal depression at the time of the interview in early and mid-pregnancy and HCC from preconception to the third trimester, indicates that our results are less likely to be influenced by the time in which the stressor was measured and more related to the time in which the psychoendocrine association is interrogated.
Our study has different strengths. First, this is the largest study conducted to date assessing the correlates of HCC in the prenatal period, affording greater power to identify true associations with HCC compared to previous smaller studies. In addition, we were able to assess HCC from preconception through to the third trimester, which allowed us to better characterize HCC's relative response in relation to multiple factors acting during pregnancy. Lastly, we included a comprehensive list of sociodemographic, pregnancy-related, hair-related, and psychosocial covariates in the characterization of HCC correlates in pregnancy, and this helped us to confirm existing evidence and provide foundational evidence about the role of multiple stressors on relative changes in HCC during pregnancy.
Our study comes with some limitations. Despite our large sample size, not all individuals in our sample had longitudinal measures of HCC from preconception through to the third trimester, reason why comparisons of HCCs were only possible between consecutive time periods, where paired measures were available. Despite this limitation, groups of samples in our study with at least two consecutive measures of HCC in pregnancy (n from 60–1,022) were larger than the number of samples included in a recent study addressing longitudinal changes of HCC in pregnancy (n = 98) 41. The lack of a full longitudinal assessment of HCC in our study prevented us from interrogating individual patterns of HCC change across pregnancy, and from identifying interindividual trajectories of HCC change, and their association with multiple stressors measured in pregnancy. Future studies addressing this gap are required in larger samples from longitudinal pre-birth cohort studies. Lastly, our study included pregnant women from Perú, and the specific socioeconomic and cultural context of this population means that our findings may not be generalizable to other populations from different socioeconomic backgrounds.