Our initial search yielded 1088 titles. After removing duplicates, titles reporting exclusively on children older than five years, review papers and studies that focused on diagnosis remained with 35 studies. Twenty-three (23) of those studies were removed after full article screening because they were focused on diagnosis or did not describe the processes, materials and outcomes that were used in the treatment process. Twelve studies met the search criteria (Fig. 1).
Twelve peer reviewed articles met our inclusion criteria (table 1). The studies in these articles were from five different countries: Ghana (41.7%), Ivory Coast (16.7%), Niger (8.3%), Sudan (8.3%) and Zimbabwe (16.7%). The lowest age of the children reported in the studies was 1 month old and the highest age reported was 93 months. Ten of the studies reported on the use of the praziquantel (PZQ) tablet, 1 study reported on the use of PZQ syrup and one study reported on the use of both the PZQ tablet and the PZQ syrup.
Process
All the studies followed the same treatment sequence: enrolment of children into the program; clinical examination; diagnosis; weight and height measurements; treatment and the monitoring of side effects. Enrolment involved acquiring consent from parents and recording all the children that participated in the study. The enrolled children were subjected to clinical examination to make sure that the children were safe to treat. Based on the clinical examinations the children who were considered safe for treatment were those who: were generally well(Amin, Swar et al. 2012, Coulibaly, N'Gbesso et al. 2012, Navaratnam, Sousa-Figueiredo et al. 2012, Sousa-Figueiredo, Betson et al. 2012, Garba, Lamine et al. 2013, Wami, Nausch et al. 2016); had had no recent illness(Wami, Nausch et al. 2016) ; were not suffering from or receiving treatment for tuberculosis (TB)(Wami, Nausch et al. 2016) ; did not have malaria(Navaratnam, Sousa-Figueiredo et al. 2012); had not undergone a major surgical procedure(Wami, Nausch et al. 2016); were not suffering from a fever(Namwanje, Kabatereine et al. 2011, Wami, Nausch et al. 2016) and did not have a history of adverse drug reactions(Namwanje, Kabatereine et al. 2011). The appropriate interventions were provided to the enrolled children who were illegible for PZQ treatment on the basis of ill health.
Diagnosis of schistosomiasis was done in all the studies to determine baseline prevalence and intensity in the children before treatment. Weight and height(Sousa-Figueiredo, Pleasant et al. 2010, Sousa-Figueiredo, Betson et al. 2012, Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2017) measurements were then done to determine the required dose of PZQ to treat children. Administration of PZQ included feeding the children to reduce side effects(Nalugwa, Nuwaha et al. 2015) and to increase the assimilation of PZQ(Sousa-Figueiredo, Betson et al. 2012, Garba, Lamine et al. 2013); making the PZQ palatable for the children by breaking or crushing the tablet and mixing it with a sweeter; and feeding the tablets to the children. After orally taking in the tablet, the children were monitored for side-effects. The most immediate side effect that was observed for was vomiting the tablet within the first 20–60minutes(Mutapi, Rujeni et al. 2011, Coulibaly, N'Gbesso et al. 2012), in which case the tablet was re-administered to the children. Other side-effects were recorded and appropriate treatment was provided to the children.
Using the processes carried out in the 12 clinical studies to treat schistosomiasis in children aged five years and below, we designed a treatment process that can be used to implement a schistosomiasis mass drug administration (MDA) program for this age group (Fig. 2). In the MDA treatment process diagnosis of schistosomiasis could be done only on a sample of the children before the clinical examination is done.
Structure
The materials that were used to treat schistosomiasis in children under five years old in the studies are listed in table 2. In the same table we have proposed materials that could be used in a schistosomiasis MDA program for children under five years old in resource limited settings. Registers were used to enroll children into the clinical studies. For a schistosomiasis control MDA program for children under five we recommend electronic registers that are embedded in electronic tablets. The Kato-Katz and schistosomiasis urine filtration kits(Garba, Barkiré et al. 2010, Mutapi, Rujeni et al. 2011, Amin, Swar et al. 2012, Coulibaly, N'Gbesso et al. 2012, Nalugwa, Nuwaha et al. 2015, Wami, Nausch et al. 2016, Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2017, Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2018) were the most used materials to diagnose Schistosomiasis mansoni and Schistosomiasis haematobium respectively in the studies. The stools and urine for diagnosis were collected in specimen containers(Namwanje, Kabatereine et al. 2011). Serological tests: Point-of-care circulating cathodic antigen (POC-CCA)(Sousa-Figueiredo, Pleasant et al. 2010, Coulibaly, N'Gbesso et al. 2012, Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2017); soluble egg antigen enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay SEA-ELISA(Sousa-Figueiredo, Pleasant et al. 2010); microalbumin reagent strips(Wami, Nausch et al. 2016) and urinalysis dip sticks(Wami, Nausch et al. 2016) were also used to test for schistosomiasis in the children. Questionnaires were also used for diagnosis(Sousa-Figueiredo, Pleasant et al. 2010, Mutapi, Rujeni et al. 2011, Amin, Swar et al. 2012, Sousa-Figueiredo, Betson et al. 2012, Garba, Lamine et al. 2013, Wami, Nausch et al. 2016, Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2017, Mduluza and Mutapi 2017, Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2018). We recommend the use of questionnaires and urine dipsticks for the diagnosis of urinary schistosomiasis and the POC-CCA for the diagnosis of intestinal schistosomiasis on the field for use in schistosomiasis control MDA programs for children aged under five years. Questionnaires and the child health booklet(Garba, Lamine et al. 2013) were used for clinical assessments. We also recommend that both be used for clinical assessments in the schistosomiasis control MDA programs for children aged under five years old and below years old. Some the studies that we reviewed reported using weight scales, while others used stadiometers (Sousa-Figueiredo, Pleasant et al. 2010, Amin, Swar et al. 2012) and one used dose poles(Sousa-Figueiredo, Pleasant et al. 2010) to obtain the anthropometric measurement that were used to calculate the dose amount of PZQ. We recommend the use of the dose pole and/or tape measures to make these measurements in schistosomiasis control MDA programs for young children.
Bread and juice(Mutapi, Rujeni et al. 2011, Navaratnam, Sousa-Figueiredo et al. 2012, Sousa-Figueiredo, Betson et al. 2012, Nalugwa, Nuwaha et al. 2015, Wami, Nausch et al. 2016, Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2017), millet wafer(Garba, Lamine et al. 2013) and porridge(Garba, Lamine et al. 2013) were the food items that were used in the studies we reviewed. PZQ tablets were crushed with spoons(Mutapi, Rujeni et al. 2011) or pestle and mortar(Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2017, Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2018) to make them small enough for the children to take in. The studies used honey and sugar(Amin, Swar et al. 2012), juice and syrup flavored water as sweeteners(Mutapi, Rujeni et al. 2011, Navaratnam, Sousa-Figueiredo et al. 2012, Sousa-Figueiredo, Betson et al. 2012, Nalugwa, Nuwaha et al. 2015, Wami, Nausch et al. 2016, Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2017) to mask the bitter taste of PZQ. We recommend that children aged five years old and below should be fed with bread and juice or instant porridge during schistosomiasis control MDA programs for this age group. We recommend the use of tablets that were crushed with a pestle and mortar and juice as the sweetener for use in these MDA programs.
Some of the studies reported using schools(Mutapi, Rujeni et al. 2011, Namwanje, Kabatereine et al. 2011, Wami, Nausch et al. 2016), early childhood development (ECD) centers(Wami, Nausch et al. 2016), healthcare centers(Navaratnam, Sousa-Figueiredo et al. 2012), clinics(Sousa-Figueiredo, Pleasant et al. 2010) and churches(Navaratnam, Sousa-Figueiredo et al. 2012) as sites where the children were recruited. The schools were used as treatment centers in studies that involved comparisons between children that were aged five years old and below (of pre –school aged children (PSAC)) and school aged children (SAC)(Wami, Nausch et al. 2016). The ECD centers that are reported on in the studies were attached to the schools were the SAC participants were found(Wami, Nausch et al. 2016). We recommend the use of schools and clinics as treatment centers for schistosomiasis control MDA programs for children aged five years old and below.
The human resources that took part in the clinical aspects of the studies were from a variety of healthcare professions. These medical staff included pediatricians(Namwanje, Kabatereine et al. 2011), medical doctors(Garba, Lamine et al. 2013), nurses(Mutapi, Rujeni et al. 2011) and laboratory technicians(Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2017, Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2018). Some studies did not specify the professions of the clinical human resources only indicating that medical staff, clinicians or health officers were part of the study. One study stated the involvement of community leaders and community drug distributors(Sousa-Figueiredo, Pleasant et al. 2010) as part of their human resources. We recommend nurses to be the human healthcare professionals that implement the schistosomiasis control MDA programs for children aged five years old and below.
Challenges
Some of the studies reported the use of the current WHO approved 600mg PZQ dose tablet formulation as a challenge when treating schistosomiasis in children aged five years old and below, especially when implementing a large scale treatment program(Davis and Schul 1993, Nalugwa, Nuwaha et al. 2015, Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2017). They recommended that a variation of this formulation with three partitions that make it possible to split the tablet into four pieces of 150mg each should be used when treating schistosomiasis in children aged five years old and below so as to ensure the use of the correct PZQ to treat schistosomiasis in these children(Sousa-Figueiredo, Pleasant et al. 2010). The studies proposed that a pediatric formulation should be developed and that the PZQ pediatric formulations could be an orally dispensable tablet(Coulibaly, Panic et al. 2017) or a PZQ syrup(Garba, Lamine et al. 2013).