The XRD patterns of the as-obtained samples were shown in Fig. 1. As shown in XRD pattern, when the molar ration of Mg content at 250 mol%, the primary phase was (Ta0.25Hf0.25Ti0.25Nb0.25)Si2 and the impurities, including HfO2 and Nb, were also detected. Theoretically, the formation of HfO2 phase may lack of reducing agent, i.e., Mg powders (melting point ~ 848K) because of the severe volatilization at such high temperature. To future address this issue, the molar ration of Mg content increased to 350 mol% and 400 mol%; the XRD patterns were also shown in Fig. 1. Unexpected, the HfO2 still existed in the as-obtained powders and led to increase the Nb phase with increase the molar ration of Mg. Thus, the Mg content is not a major factor affecting the purity of HES powders.
SEM images of the as-obtained HES nanopowders shown that they were all composed of many nanoparticles in the range of several nanometers to hundreds of nanometers (Fig. 2). Figure 2b shows the EDS maps of four main transition metal elements in the as-synthesized powders at micrometer scale. Obviously, the distribution of elements is highly uniform without any aggregation or segregation. This indicates that the as-synthesized HES powders have highly compositional uniformity at microscale.
Figure 3a presents a typical TEM image of the as-obtained HES nanopowders. It obviously indicates that HES nanopowders consist of numerous individual nanoparticles. Figure 3b shows a typical high-resolution transmission electron microscopy image (HRTEM). It clearly exhibits a periodic lattice structure with a set of fringes with the d-space of 0.409 nm, corresponding to the {100} plane of HES phase, which is in good agreement with the calculation value (0.414 nm) from XRD pattern. Meanwhile, it should be noted that there is an amorphous layer with the thickness of 2–4 nm coated on surface, which may be due to the presence of amorphous SiO2. The selected area electron diffraction (SAED) pattern along with zone axis of [] indicates that the as-synthesized powders possess a single hexagonal structure. In addition, the average particle size of HES was confirmed to ~ 55 nm according to 50 individual nanoparticles (Fig. 4). The scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) image and the corresponding EDS elemental maps (Fig. 4) of the as-synthesized HES nanopowders demonstrate that the distribution of three metal elements and Si element is basically uniform except Ti element aggregation at nanoscale.
Figure 5 demonstrates the possible formation mechanism of the as-synthesized HES powders via molten salt-assisted magnesium thermal reduction. It is generally accepted that the mixed salts firstly melted into the liquid during heat process (Fig. 5a). After that, four metal oxides, SiO2 and Mg gradually dissolved into the mixed molten salts (Fig. 5b) by the following reactions: 8

During this process, Mg gradually dissociated to mobile cations (Mg2+) and delocalized electrons (e−) in NaCl/KCl molten salts according to Eq. 1. Meanwhile, four metal oxides and SiO2 also dissolved in NaCl/KCl molten salts to produce mobile cations and anions. It has been reported that the molten salt synthesis method involves two mechanisms, including template formation and dissolution-precipitation. According to the similarity-intermiscibility theory,15 it is considered that SiO2 is an atomic crystal; while the bond between four metal oxides and NaCl/KCl is mainly ionic. The solubility of SiO2 in NaCl/KCl molten salts is much less than that of four metal oxides.16 In this content, four transition metal cations would move to silicon ion surface and capture free electrons around it to generate HES molecules in molten salt according to Eq. 4 (Fig. 5c). Thus, it can be deduced that the formation mechanism in this work is mainly template formation mechanism. As the reaction proceeded, when the concentration of the generated HES molecules in molten salt medium reached the supersaturation condition, they could precipitate from the molten salt to nucleate and grow. Finally, numerous HES nanoparticles are obtained after removing the remnant reactants (Fig. 5d).