In this study, we observed that the richness and composition of the oropharyngeal microbiota were significantly different between smokers and non-smokers before and after smoking cessation. Before smoking cessation, specific bacteria, including P. aeruginosa, P. melaninogenica, S. salivarius, A. defectiva, and Candidatus Nanosynbacter lyticus, were more significantly enriched in the experimental group compared with the control group. These bacteria were primarily concentrated in the phyla Actinobacteria, Bacteroidetes, Firmicutes, and Ascomycota before smoking cessation, whereas the phylum Proteobacteria was more abundant in the control group. After 30 days of smoking cessation, the most differential species were similar to those before smoking cessation. Comparisons before and after smoking cessation revealed significant changes in the family Actinomycetaceae and phylum Bacteroidetes; the most noticeable differences were observed in Prevotella intermedia in the phylum Bacteroidetes. This suggests that smoking cessation can reverse smoking-related changes in the oral microbiota. Furthermore, correlation analysis between microorganisms and microorganisms and clinical indicators revealed that the microbial population was unique among smokers. In addition to their association with smoking, synergistic and antagonistic relationships were observed among the microorganisms. Moreover, these microbial interactions were associated with changes in cotinine concentration, smoking duration, daily smoking quantity, and initial smoking age. Our study findings innovatively suggest the relationships among oral microorganisms and the association between microorganisms and smoking status.
Composition of the pharyngeal microecological communities in smokers
Cigarette smoke contains more than 7000 chemicals[11]. Smoking decreases commensal bacteria and increases the colonization of pathogenic bacteria in the oral cavity[17]. An early in vitro study based on cultivation methods has revealed that cigarette smoke strongly inhibits Neisseria growth; however, Streptococcus is less affected by cigarette smoke[18]. Comprehensive analysis of the oral bacteria using high-throughput 16S rRNA sequencing revealed that the abundance of Neisseria, Porphyromonas, and Gemella significantly decreased in smokers[19]. Furthermore, another study has demonstrated the enrichment of Capnocytophaga, Streptococcus, and Veillonella and reduction of Capnocytophaga, Fusobacterium, and Neisseria in the oral cavity of smokers[20]. In addition, a large-scale cohort study including 1204 individuals in the United States revealed an increase in the abundance of the genera Veillonella and Streptococcus but a decrease in Neisseria and Capnocytophaga in current smokers[14]. In addition, at the operational taxonomic unit (OTU) level, 249 OTUs were different between current and never-smokers. These differing taxa were primarily concentrated in the genera Streptococcus and Actinomyces; on the other hand, 57 OTUs in the genus Fusobacterium and the phylum Bacteroidetes were decreased in smokers[14]. The differences in the findings of these studies may be owing to 11 different oral partitions[21], each with distinct microbiota[22]. In a previous study, the bacterial composition of seven different surface samples in the oral cavity was evaluated; similar microbial communities were observed in the buccal mucosa, gingiva, and hard palate; however, different microbial communities were observed in the saliva, tongue, tonsils, throat, and above and below the gingiva[22]. Mohammad et al.[10] conducted 16S rRNA sequencing using oropharyngeal swab samples and reported that the oral microbiota composition is primarily represented by the phyla Firmicutes, Bacteroidetes, Actinobacteria, and Proteobacteria in smokers. Furthermore, they identified the genera Prevotella and Veillonella[10]. These findings are highly consistent with those of the present study; however, because the primary focus of the study was on the population in the Middle East, which exhibits obvious differences in ethnicity and dietary habits compared with our population, and different microbial gene sequencing methods were utilized, we observed variations in the classification at the microbial species level. We observed that Candidatus Nanosynbacter lyticus was enriched in smokers. This bacterium, originally known as TM7, has been recently discovered and is classified under the Candidate Phyla Radiation, along with the phyla Saccharibacteria and Absconditabacteria. TM7 is associated with different mucosal diseases, including vaginal infections, inflammatory bowel disease, halitosis, and periodontal diseases[23–25]. Furthermore, TM7 is prevalent in the oral cavity and exhibits a positive correlation with oral disease development[26]; in addition, it can modulate immune responses in humans[27].
In this study, we also observed the presence of fungi and viruses in the oral microbiota of smokers. The top 10 fungi in all three groups were M. restricta, M. globosa, P. oryzae, S. cerevisiae, A. sydowii, C. sphaerospermum, P. striiformis, M. Japan, A. laibachii, and C. albicans. Among them, the relative abundance of M.globosa and C. albicans was higher in smokers than in non-smokers; however, the difference was not statistically significant. In a survey of the fungal communities in mouthwash samples from 20 healthy individuals, 74 cultivable and 11 uncultivable fungal genera were identified. The dominant genera included Candida, Aspergillus, Penicillium, Saccharomyces, Fusarium, Fusobacterium, and Cryptococcus[28]. This was the first study to analyze the “baseline mycobiome” in healthy individuals. Our study results were similar to some extent to the results of this study; however, whether the identified genera represent the colonization of fungal nutritional forms remains unclear at present. In addition, the fungal reproduction cycle is relatively long, and significant changes may not occur in the short term. Analysis of the relative abundance of viruses revealed that herpesviruses are the predominant virus type in the oral cavity; however, the observed viruses did not exhibit significant differences in the three groups. In many recent studies, next-generation sequencing techniques have been applied to reveal the oral virome in humans under different conditions, including in healthy individuals, those with prolonged antibiotic use, and individuals with oral viromes associated with periodontal diseases[29–31]. The oral virome in healthy individuals includes eukaryotic viruses and bacteriophages, with similarities to the oral bacterial community; the viral community remains stable over time[32, 33]. The most common eukaryotic virus families in the oral cavity are Herpesviridae, Papillomaviridae, and Anelloviridae; they can exist asymptomatically in healthy individuals[31]. A study has demonstrated a relationship between herpesviruses and periodontal disease[34]; however, the effect of viruses on oral diseases remains unknown. In the present study, oral herpesviruses were not significantly different in the three groups; this may be owing to limitations in sample type and quantity. Therefore, in future studies, the sample size should be increased or other oral samples should be used for analysis.
Possible mechanisms by which smoking affects the pharyngeal microecology
Smoking primarily affects the structure of the oral microbiota by increasing salivary acidity, depleting oxygen in the oral cavity, exerting antibiotic effects, and affecting bacterial surface adhesion. Smokers exhibit low salivary acidity, significantly decreasing Neisseria abundance; on the other hand, acid-resistant Streptococcus and Rothia can flourish in smokers. Furthermore, aerobic metabolic pathways (including the tricarboxylic acid cycle and oxidative phosphorylation) were downregulated in the oral microbiota of smokers, whereas glycolysis and other anaerobic carbohydrate metabolism pathways significantly increase[14]. This finding further confirms that smoking establishes favorable conditions for the growth of obligate or facultative anaerobic bacteria but detrimental conditions for the survival of obligate aerobic bacteria. In the present study, we observed that the abundance of Streptococcus, Prevotella, Veillonella, and Gemella increases in smokers. These genera comprise facultative or obligate anaerobic bacteria; the factors mentioned above partially explain their enrichment in the smoking environment. Furthermore, cigarette smoke promotes biofilm formation by Streptococcus and Staphylococcus aureus, making them more prone to mucosal adhesion[35]. Therefore, this makes smokers more susceptible to respiratory infections and dental caries[9, 36].
The oral mucosa functions as a first-line defense against pathogen invasion; however, smoking compromises the oral mucosa, disrupts the integrity of the oral epithelium[37, 38], increases the autophagy and apoptosis of epithelial cells[39, 40], and decreases β-defensin production by oral epithelial cells[41–44]. Furthermore, smoking inhibits the phagocytic capacity of neutrophils in the oral cavity as well as their ability to generate superoxide, while also decreasing the release of LL-37, an antimicrobial peptide vital for pathogen clearance[45–47]. Simultaneously, smoking interferes with the ability of oral macrophages to recognize, engulf, and present pathogenic antigens[48, 49], thereby affecting DC cell count and inhibiting their maturation and differentiation as well as their ability to present antigens to reactive T cells [50–56]. Moreover, smoking interferes with natural killer cell cytotoxicity by decreasing interferon-γ and tumor necrosis factor-α secretion[57–59]. Finally, studies have revealed that IgA and IgG levels are significantly decreased in the oral cavity of smokers[60–62]. Therefore, smoking establishes a more favorable oral ecosystem for pathogenic bacteria and indirectly inhibits local defense functions, finally increasing the risk of oral diseases and other systemic diseases in smokers.
It is noteworthy that a complex and dynamic ecological relationship is formed between the host and the fungi and bacteria in the oral cavity. Smoking may lead to an increase in certain microbial communities, such as specific bacterial populations, thereby suppressing the long-term colonization of fungal communities through competition and interaction mechanisms. The interaction between fungi and commensal bacteria involves physical binding, communication through signaling molecules, and metabolic exchange during the co-adaptation process in the multiple oral micro-environmental niche[63]. In addition, alterations in the host environment are essential in shaping the composition of the oral fungal microbiota and in the development of fungal diseases[64]. However, studies of changes in oral fungal communities in immunosuppressed populations are still limited.
Effects of smoking cessation on the pharyngeal microecology
Smoking cessation is a vital approach to prevent premature morbidity, disability, and death; furthermore, it is the most direct and effective approach to restore microecology. A study involving African Americans revealed that the effects of smoking on the structure of the oral microbiota were recovered after smoking cessation[65]. In addition, using nested polymerase chain reaction and flow cytometry to analyze the common subgingival microbial community structure 12 months after smoking cessation revealed that the abundance of periodontal disease-associated pathogens significantly decreased, whereas that of health-related microorganisms was re-enriched[66]. Simultaneously, previous studies have suggested that the oral microecological structure of never- and previous smokers is basically similar; however, at the OTU level, only 17 different OTUs were identified; therefore, smoking may have altered the oral microecology, with irreversible changes in some taxa[14]. However, studies on smoking cessation and oral microecological changes are limited, and the duration of smoking cessation and oral microecological changes was at least 12 months; as a result, the effects of short-term smoking cessation on the microecology have not been studied. For the first time, in our 30-day short-term smoking cessation study, we observed that after smoking cessation, there were rapid changes in the smoking-associated dominant bacteria Prevococcus melanotica and the phylum Actinobacteria. Previous studies have revealed a definite relationship between Prevotella nigrescens production and the occurrence of halitosis and periodontal diseases[67]. Simultaneously, this species was observed to be involved in the oral nitrate reduction reaction, which is impossible in mammalian cells. Under anaerobic conditions, mammalian cells use nitrate as the terminal respiratory electron receptor to produce nitrite; the conversion of nitrite to carcinogenic nitrosamines and the proinflammatory factor nitric oxide exerts a toxic effect[68, 69]. Furthermore, the enrichment of oral P. nigrescens may be associated with the occurrence of intestinal and lung cancers. Finally, Actinomycetes can affect oral health and lead to halitosis in smokers by producing hydrogen sulfide[70].
Smoking-related clinical indicators may affect the microecological structure
In this study, we also observed a weak correlation between microorganisms and concentration changes of cotinine, a metabolic end product of nicotine; however, the implications remain unclear. Finally, when analyzing the association between microorganisms and smoking-related clinical indicators, we observed that oral desulfurococci and smoking years were negatively correlated. Oral desulfurococci can adapt to the oral environment in humans by losing some biosynthetic and metabolic capabilities, thereby significantly decreasing environmental sensing and signal transduction abilities. Furthermore, they can spontaneously lose the gene responsible for synthesizing methylmercury, a potent neurotoxin. However, transcriptomics and proteomics analyses revealed that this bacterium can trigger inflammatory responses in oral epithelial cells; this suggests that it plays a role in periodontal diseases[71]. Our study findings suggest a negative correlation between Desulfobulbus and smoking duration, implying that this change confers some positive implications on oral health. However, the exact meaning remains unclear and requires additional experimental validation.
This study has some limitations. The experimental research lacked a sufficient observation period; for oral microecological research, smoking cessation should be analyzed for at least 12 months. In a study on the effect of smoking cessation on the intestinal flora, the relationship with changes in the intestinal flora change was explored; the researchers observed that the relative abundance of Bacteroidetes and Firmicutes changed after 12 weeks[72]. Therefore, the findings deserve our reference that appropriately extending the observation period may be necessary in future studies. Finally, some selective bias was observed in this study.