To the best of our knowledge, our study is the first to be conducted in a predominantly Caribbean population to provide a prevalence estimate of osteoarticular deformities, called ADH, in the Caribbean region. We report a high prevalence of ADH (77.8%) (95% CI: 68.7%- 86.8%) for a rather homogeneous population in rehabilitation care with a higher level of dependence.
Previous reports have described an ADH prevalence ranging from 24–88% in other populations. (9, 11) As such, the observed prevalence of 77.8% in our Caribbean study population is among the highest rates described thus far. In comparison to pioneering work(9), our patient inclusion modalities differ, as ADH diagnosis was carried out by a PM&R physician in direct collaboration with on-site physicians at each of the three participating LTCUs(9). This might have contributed to optimized ADH diagnosis due to greater expertise in identifying neuro-orthopedic deformities and a resulting greater prevalence of ADH.
Moreover, the level of patient dependence in our study was high, with an average GMP of 924 years compared with 854 years in mainland France(9), with a similar approximate mean age of 85 years. We also observed a significant statistical relationship between the level of dependence of the participating institutions and the risk of ADH onset: the greater the level of dependence was, the greater the risk of developing ADH (R²=0.998, p = 0.007). The late use of specialized institutions for patients with more comorbidities in the territory is consistent with this observation of a higher ADH incidence in comparison to the 25.6% prevalence found by Dehail and al.
ADH management suffers from a lack of knowledge by medical and paramedical teams, who also manifest a certain fatalism toward the condition: 3 out of 4 practitioners considered ADH irreversible with frequent therapeutic abstention(9). This was also observed among caregivers during the present research, with the latter being in total unawareness of ADH and its possible multidisciplinary management. We observe in the literature a lack of consensus on the use of the ADH term for identifying contracture and joint deformations in the dependent elderly population(26–28).
Hence, a minimal information campaign for caregivers in geriatric institutions is likely needed.(9, 10) Many caregivers still use the term “contracture” in elderly populations and seemingly ignore the comprehensive definition, with the resulting consequences being less recourse to a multidisciplinary therapeutic arsenal with a tailored collaborative approach by PM&R physicians, geriatrists and trained orthopedic surgeons with regard to the patient’s level of frailty.
We further observed a scarcity of paramedical staff in the three participating LTCUs, in line with the general situation in all public health care institutions on the island. In the rehabilitation field, we report one physiotherapist for more than one hundred patients and a quasisystematic absence of occupational therapists—far too few to allow for adequate prevention and therapeutic management in LTCUs. In this context of poor density of specialized personnel and care rationalization, interactions between patients and caregivers limit themselves to the conduct of routine activities, which is counterproductive to the development of patient autonomy.(21, 22) It has been proven that the absence of stimulation does not allow the maintenance of functional skills or accelerate the loss of autonomy in fragile and dependent patients.(26–30)
A notable strength of the present study is the exhaustive recruitment of all patients aged 75 years and older who were institutionalized in the three LTCUs of the island. However, the observational nature of the present study did not allow for the use of an ADH chronology. The observed high ADH prevalence in our Caribbean population must also be considered in light of the present study’s methodology (diagnosis by a PM&R physician) and the context of insularity. The geographical arrangement induced by the latter negatively impacts the healthcare system with regard to less equipment, a lower density of medical and paramedical staff resources and greater social deprivation. When combined, these different elements might induce more handicap.(10, 28)
Global healthcare based on the One Health concept can positively impact health strategies and provide more effective results by facilitating the implementation of cultural and societal specificities among nursing teams to prevent or reduce the impact of ADH through the use of personalized occupational strategies. Currently, the notion of "practicing care" in an institution must be replaced by "taking care" for elderly people: "care" before "cure"(21, 31).