The age of onset of HSD10 disease can range from newborn to early childhood. The most severely affected patients were males (hemizygous), while heterozygous females were generally asymptomatic or had only mild symptoms. HSD10 disease is characterized by progressive neurodegeneration and includes intellectual disability, language defects, bradykinesia, ataxia, epilepsy, visual and auditory disorders, hypotonia, cardiomyopathy and metabolic disorders. There are four clinical types of HELLP syndrome: the neonatal, infantile, juvenile and atypical/asymptomatic [1]. The most common type is the infantile form. The clinical features of our patient included intellectual disability, metabolic acidosis, hyperlactatemia, hypoglycemia, cholestatic hepatitis and myocardial enzyme levels; slightly elevated 2M3HBA levels; and early death. Whole-exome sequencing of the proband and his parents revealed a novel de novo heterozygous variant, c.59C > T (p.S20L), of the HSD17B10 gene. Combined with the highly characteristic clinical phenotype and molecular genetic analyses, HSD10 MD (neonatal form) was a likely diagnosis.
Hepatic involvement is a common feature of early-onset mitochondrial disease[17]. Genetically confirmed mitochondrial disease was observed in 17% of children who presented with acute liver failure before the age of 2 years [18, 19]. The main organ manifestation of HSD10 disease is the central nervous system. The liver and kidneys are not usually affected by the infantile form [1]. Few patients with the neonatal form of HSD10 MD have been reported to date (Table 2). Two patients with the neonatal form had hepatic dysfunction [8, 10]. Chatfield et al.[8] reported that infants had hepatomegaly. The histological features of the patients included micro- and macrovesicular steatohepatitis, disrupted mitochondrial architecture with a strongly increased number of mitochondria and abnormal cristae structure. Mitochondrial respiration and assembly are disrupted in HSD10 disease. Our patient also had hepatic dysfunction. Genetic tests did not reveal any other variants that were potentially causative of mitochondrial disease or liver disease. Thus, the incidence of hepatic dysfunction in neonates is relatively high (50%). Patients with hepatic dysfunction and metabolic derangement should be vigilant against HSD10 disease during the neonatal period.
Table 2
Genotypes and phenotypes summary in neonatal form of HSD10 MD
| Mutation | Sex | Onset age | Clinical feature | Brain MRI | Family history | Present status (age) |
Patient 1 (this report) | c.59C > T(p.S20L) | M | 2d | development retardation, metabolic acidosis, hyperlactatemia, hypoglycemia, Cholestatic hepatitis, elevated myocardial enzyme. | NA | Normal parents | Dead (3m) |
Patient 2[17] | c.740A > G (p.N247S) | M | 1d | Metabolic acidosis, hypoglycemia, hypotonia, cyanosis, cardiomegalia, hyperlactatemia and hyperlactaturia | NA | sister is patient ,Normal mother | Dead (2 m) |
Patient 3[10] | c.677G > A (p.R226Q) | M | 1 d | Developmental regression, metabolic acidosis, hypoglycemia, anemia, hyperamoniemia, thrombopenia, cuagulopathy, hepatic dysfunction, myoclonus, seizures, hypertrophic miocardiopathy | Isquemic lesions in nucleus | Normal mother | Dead (7 m) |
Patient 4[7] | c.257A > G(p.D86G) | M | NA | Neurological development, progressive hypertrophic cardiomyopathy | NA | NA | Dead (7 m) |
Patient 5[8] | c.740A > G(p.N247S) | M | 1d | mildly encephalopathic, hyperlactatemia, hyperlactaturia, hyperammonemia, feeding difficulties, PDA(patent ductus arteriosus), anemia, thrombocytopenia,, elevated transaminases, cuagulopathy | restricted diffusion in the perirolandic white matter | NA | Dead (6 m) |
Patient 6[18] | c.677G > A(p.Arg226Gln) | M | 1d | Polypnea, moan, hypoglycemia, hyperlactatemia, psychomotor retardation | a slightly deeper sulci in the cerebral hemisphere | NA | abandoned the treatment |
NA: not available |
The 17β-HSD10 protein is encoded by the HSD17B10 gene, which maps to chromosome Xp11.2 and consists of 6 exons. In total, 16 different missense variants and a splicing mutation are reported to cause HSD10 MD [4, 11, 20–24]. The mutation c.388C > T (p.R130C) is the most frequent variant [12]. At present, the reported mutation types in neonatal patients include c.740A > G (p.N247S), c.677G > A (p.R226Q) and c.257A > G (p.D86G). This study also revealed a new mutation that causes neonatal-type HSD10 disease. Protein structural analysis revealed that these mutations may impact local secondary structure and molecular function. The mutated amino acid D86 was found in a clinically severely affected child and caused severe disruption of mitochondrial morphology. The amino acid Q165 was observed in a clinically mildly affected child but with completely deficient MHBD enzyme activity[7]. The amino acids N247[8], S20, and R226 are close to the amino acid D86 and away from the amino acid Q165. These mutations may increase the likelihood of causing mitochondrial dysfunction, which can lead to disease. Furthermore, we classified the missense variant c.59C > T as a likely pathogenic candidate causing this proband’s clinical manifestations for the following reasons. First, this variant is not listed in the HGMD, PubMed, ClinVar or other databases or the related literature. Second, the clinical features of the patient were consistent with those of patients with the neonatal form of HSD10 MD. Third, the ACMG variant classification guidelines classify patients as "class 2 - possibly pathogenic". Molecular dynamic simulation and protein structural analysis revealed that the mutation may disrupt the conformational stability of the protein.
This study has several limitations. Brain MRI was not performed. Studies to determine the effect of the mutation on protein expression were not performed. Due to the early death of our patient, functional verification was not carried out. The same mutation can lead to different clinical manifestations. Due to the small number of cases reported thus far, additional evidence for a clear genotype–phenotype correlation is needed.
There is no effective therapy for HSD10 MD. Cardiac failure, Kussmaul breathing, and multiple-organ dysfunction may be induced by mild infection[8]. Our patient had an upper respiratory tract infection before death. Therefore, rapid intervention in patients with acute infection is highly important.
In conclusion, HSD10 MD (neonatal form) can lead to hepatic dysfunction. Our results add evidence that the de novo variant c.59C > T (p.S20L) suggests HSD10 MD (neonatal form) in this 2-month and 12-day-old patient, broadening the spectrum of HSD17B10-related disease.