Early-life fungal colonizers uniquely modulate microbiome ecology in a model of diet-induced obesity
We developed a gnotobiotic diet-induced obesity model to interrogate the causal impact of three core human gut mycobiome species on host metabolic health in both male and female mice. Germ-free C57Bl/6J mice were inoculated with the Oligo-Mouse-Microbiota (Oligo-MM12) bacterial consortium33 alone or in combination with C. albicans (B + C), R. mucilaginosa (B + R) or M. restricta (B + M) twice at the commencement of breeding (Fig. 1A). Dams were kept on a standard mouse diet (SD) during breeding and gestation. While it has been established that the Oligo-MM12 bacterial consortium is heritable33, whether vertical transmission occurs for the three fungal species in gnotobiotic mice had not been previously determined. Therefore, fungal cultures were also applied to the dams’ nipple and abdominal area twice during the first week following birth to promote early-life transfer of these fungal species to the offspring (F1). F1 mice were then weaned onto a standard (SD) or high-fat-high-sucrose (HFHS) mouse diet until 12 weeks of age to model the development of childhood obesity. This model allowed us to explore the consequences of exposure to individual fungal species during development.
We carried out fungal culture and rDNA detection to determine if each species was able to stably colonize gnotobiotic F1 mice. Independently of sex, both C. albicans and R. mucilaginosa were able to stably colonize the mice with no difference in fecal fungal growth between the two species when mice consumed either diet. Intriguingly, there was a reduction in viable C. albicans and R. mucilaginosa in mice fed HFHS (diet p < 0.0001; Fig. 1B). M. restricta could not be recovered from fecal samples at 6–7 weeks of age, indicating transient early-life exposure. Similarly, amplification of internal transcribed spacer region (ITS) in fecal DNA was only detected in B + C and B + R samples at 12 weeks, with a strong inhibitory effect of HFHS diet on fungal growth in both sexes (diet p < 0.0001; Fig. 1C-D). While C. albicans is a known pathobiont that can result in disseminated infection26, we did not detect it’s growth in the blood, liver, or kidneys on either diet, indicating that fungal growth was restricted to the gut. These data show that early-life exposure to C. albicans and R. mucilaginosa resulted in long-term establishment in the gut of gnotobiotic mice, while this only occurred transiently for M. restricta.
We then explored the effect of early-life exposure to fungi on the bacterial community. At weaning, before the dietary challenge, we found that exposure to an individual fungal species altered the bacterial community composition early in life. Specifically, both C. albicans and R. mucilaginosa induced significant shifts in beta-diversity, as measured by the Bray-Curtis Dissimilarity Index, relative to mice exposed to bacteria (B) only (Fig. 1E & Table S1). These effects were independent of sex (Table S1). While fungal colonization did not result in changes to alpha-diversity, as measured by the Shannon index (Figure S1A), it did result in several shifts of bacterial relative abundance. Specifically, C. albicans colonization was associated with an increased relative abundance of Turicimonas muris YL45 and decreased Limosilactobacillus reuteri I49, whereas R. mucilaginosa was associated with increased Bifidobacterium animalis YL2 and decreased Flavonifractor plautii YL31 and L. reuteri I49 (Fig. 1F & Figure S1B). Despite the absence of statistical significance in beta-diversity, M. restricta was associated with decreased relative abundance of Acutalibacter muris KB18 (Fig. 1F & Figure S1B). These findings indicate that early-life fungal exposure has cross-kingdom consequences for microbiome establishment in a species-specific manner.
We also evaluated the bacterial gut microbiome at the conclusion of the diet challenge at 12 weeks of age. Aligned with previous studies34–36, diet strongly influenced bacterial beta-diversity (Fig. 1G), as well as exposure to all three fungi during early life. Again, the strongest effects were induced by C. albicans and R. mucilaginosa (Fig. 1G & Table S2). A sex effect was detected in B + C mice and approached significance in B + R and B + M mice (Table S2). On SD, no alterations in alpha-diversity were observed (Figure S1C), though all three fungal species influenced the relative abundance of several bacterial strains. C. albicans colonization resulted in an increased abundance of B. animalis YL2, and decreased A. muris KB18, Blautia pseudococcoides YL58 and L. reuteri I49 (Fig. 1H & Figure S1D). Similarly, R. mucilaginosa was associated with an increased abundance of B. animalis YL2 and Enterococcus faecalis KB1, and decreased A. muris KB18 and L. reuteri I49, and (Fig. 1H & Figure S1D). Meanwhile, M. restricta was associated with decreased abundance of Clostridium innocuum I46 and increased E. faecalis KB1 (Fig. 1H & Figure S1D).
Bacterial compositional changes were also detected in mice fed HFHS. Alpha-diversity remained unchanged between B only and B + C or B + R, though was increased in B + M mice on HFHS (Figure S1C). In all groups, there was a significant effect of diet on alpha-diversity with an overall reduction with HFHS-fed mice (B + C: p = 0.020, B + R: p = 0.007, B + M: p < 0.001; Figure S1C). C. albicans influenced the greatest number of bacterial strains with an increase in B. animalis YL2 and Enterocloster clostridioforme YL32 and a decrease in A. muris KB18, B. pseudococcoides YL58, E. faecalis KB1, F. plautii YL31 and T. muris YL45 (Fig. 1I & Figure S1D). R. mucilaginosa colonized mice displayed increased B. animalis YL2 and decreased E. faecalis KB1, while M. restricta was associated with increased C. innocuum I46 and E. faecalis KB1, and decreased Akkermansia muciniphila YL44 (Fig. 1I & Figure S1D). Altogether, exposure to a single fungal species early in life had long-term consequences for the bacterial community composition and its response to a diet high in fat and sucrose. These cross-kingdom alterations may provide an avenue for fungi to influence host metabolism.
Early-life fungal colonization has long-lasting consequences for the metabolic output of the gut microbiome in a diet-specific manner
Given the alterations to the gut microbiome observed on both diets with early-life fungal exposure, we explored whether there were also functional alterations with fecal untargeted metabolomics. Similar to the alterations in bacterial community structure, the overall fecal metabolome was strongly influenced by diet (Fig. 2A & Table S3). Significant metabolome shifts were also found with early-life fungal exposure in B + C and B + R, but not B + M mice (Fig. 2A & Table S3). In line with this, the concentrations of specific metabolites were significantly shifted in B + C and B + R relative to B-only mice. C. albicans colonization resulted in the greatest number of significantly altered metabolites, with 8 increased and 6 decreased metabolites on SD, and 6 increased and 1 decreased metabolite on HFHS (Fig. 2B-E & Table S4). Several of these metabolites have been previously associated with C. albicans, including being produced (cystathionine, hypotaurine, arabitol), consumed (glutamine), degraded (urate) or simply associated with its presence37–42, highlighting its capacity to contribute to the fecal metabolome. Some metabolites also displayed significant fold change with R. mucilaginosa colonization on SD only, where there were 5 increased and 4 decreased metabolites, including mannitol and glucose, which are known to be consumed by this yeast43 (Fig. 2F-G & Table S4). There were no significantly altered metabolites in B + M mice on either diet. As this was a DIO model, we were also interested in the total lipid content remaining in the feces. There were no differences in fecal lipid concentration between B only and B + C or B + M mice on either diet (Figure S2A-B). We did, however, find an increase in fecal lipid concentration in B + R mice on both diets (Figure S2C). These data indicate that fungal colonization had a persistent and substantial impact on the fecal metabolome, including luminal nutrient content in mice.
To gain a better understanding of the functional consequences of fungal-induced alterations to the bacterial community, we constructed a community metabolic model by integrating the datasets from 16S rRNA sequencing and metabolomics. We used Model-based Integration of MIMOSA2 (Metabolite Observations and Species Abundances Version 2), which infers putative metabolites governed by the microbiome and the species that contribute to the experimental variation in metabolite levels44. Given our gnotobiotic approach, we created a custom AGORA (Access to Global Online Research in Agriculture) database from the whole genome sequences of the Oligo-MM12 strains to assess the metabolic output of the exact strains present in the consortium.
Through this analysis, we found that each fungal species induced alterations in bacteria-governed metabolites on either diet. In B + C mice, uracil concentrations on SD and succinate on HFHS were significantly correlated with community metabolic potential, with eight of the OligoMM12 contributing to the variance, including strains whose relative abundances were shifted in B + C mice (A. muris KB18, L. reuteri I49 and B. pseudococcoides YL58 on SD, T. muris YL45 on HFHS; Fig. 1H-I & Figure S2D). This suggests that differential levels of uracil and succinate occurred via C. albicans-induced shifts to the bacterial microbiome. In B + M mice, succinate concentration on SD and uracil concentration in HFHS were significantly correlated with community metabolic potential, with seven OligoMM12 taxa contributing to the variance in the levels of these metabolites (Figure S2E). In this case, exposure to M. restricta was related to shifts in the relative abundance of C. innocuum I46 and E. faecalis KB1 (Fig. 1H-I). Lastly, in B + R mice, xanthine and hypoxanthine concentrations on SD and fumarate and taurine concentrations on HFHS were significantly correlated with community metabolic potential (Figure S2F). Coinciding with their contributions to the variance of these metabolites, R. mucilaginosa colonization shifted the relative abundance of L. reuteri I49 on SD and E. faecalis KB1 on both diets (Fig. 1H-I), also suggesting this fungal species indirectly influenced the microbiome’s metabolic output via changes in bacterial species abundance and/or metabolism. In combination with our ecological analysis via 16S rRNA sequencing, community-metabolic modeling highlights interkingdom interactions as driving forces of the composition and functional output of the gut microbiome.
Early-life fungal colonizers modulate diet-induced obesity and metabolic disease development
We next evaluated whether early-life fungal exposure was causally involved in host energy metabolism and the metabolic response to the HFHS diet. For this, we carried out an extensive assessment of metabolic health, which included measurements of body and tissue weight, body composition, adipocyte size, glycemic response to oral glucose, blood lipids and metabolic hormones.
Given the known effect of sex on metabolic measurements and diet-induced obesity45, we designed this study to identify sex-driven effects on metabolism. To achieve this, we employed a Three-way ANOVA model, that included sex, diet and colonization as independent variables, except when no significant sex-related effects were observed. Area under the curve (AUC) for body weight from 3–12 weeks was significantly lower in B + C mice compared to the B only group on both diets in males and on HFHS in females (Fig. 3A-B). Male B + C mice had lower body weight at every week compared to the B only group regardless of diet, while females had lower body weight at weeks 4, 5 and 9 on SD diet, and lower weight at all time points on HFHS (Fig. 3A-B). In contrast, we detected higher body weight in female SD-fed mice exposed to M. restricta at weeks 10–12 (Fig. 3B). R. mucilaginosa did not drive changes in body weight in either sex. We identified reciprocal findings in body composition, measured by time-domain nuclear magnetic resonance (TD-NMR). On SD, C. albicans resulted in lower fat mass, while R. mucilaginosa and M. restricta resulted in higher adiposity compared to the B only group (Fig. 3C). Higher adiposity in B + M mice on SD was consistent with greater weight of the peri-gonadal fat pad (primary visceral fat pad in rodents46) in both sexes compared to B only, and a higher proportion of large adipocytes (> 70um diameter) in this depot (Fig. 3D-G). Expansion of visceral adiposity, along with adipocyte hypertrophy are determinants of metabolic health28, highlighting the ability of core fungal species to differentially regulate host energy storage in a consequential manner for metabolic disease development.
In obesogenic diet conditions (HFHS), mice colonized with C. albicans failed to gain body fat mass and peri-gonadal fat pad weight (Fig. 3C-E). Instead, these mice displayed a higher lean mass percentage compared to mice harbouring bacteria alone (Figure S3A-B). This resistance to DIO in mice colonized with C. albicans was also accompanied by histological changes in WAT. Compared to bacteria-only mice, B + C mice displayed a lower proportion of large adipocytes (> 70um diameter) and a greater percentage of small and medium size adipocytes on either diet, suggesting reduced lipid storage in this depot, which expands in response to DIO47 (Fig. 3F-G). In addition, C. albicans colonization resulted in lower liver, kidney and heart weight on HFHS in both sexes (Figure S3C-H), as well as lower kidney and heart weight in males on SD conditions (Figure S3E & S3G). Increased weight of these organs has been characterized as markers of metabolic disease development48–50, further supporting that C. albicans promoted systemic resistance to DIO. Importantly, we did not detect differences in energy intake driven by fungal colonization on either diet, except for an increase in B + C mice at 9 weeks on HFHS (Figure S3I-J). This indicates that the stark changes in body and tissue weight, and adiposity, were not a result of changes in energy intake and occurred in both normal and obesogenic diet conditions.
Given the overt signs of altered metabolic states driven by early-life fungal exposures, we further explored metabolic outcomes. To evaluate the effect of fungal colonization on glucose metabolism, we performed an oral-glucose tolerance test (OGTT) at 12 weeks of age. In both sexes and in HFHS diet conditions, colonization with R. mucilaginosa resulted in elevated blood glucose levels (BGL) at several time points, including 30 and 60 minutes in males, as well as baseline, 60 and 120 minutes in females (Fig. 4A-B). Meanwhile, B + M mice fed SD displayed higher BGL at 60 minutes in both sexes along with 90 minutes in males (Fig. 4A-B). In contrast, B + C mice consuming HFHS displayed lower BGL at 60 and 90 minutes in both sexes, along with 120 minutes in females (Fig. 4A-B). While the effect of fungal colonization was not reflected in total glucose area under the curve (AUC) measurements, alterations at individual time points suggest that intestinal fungi can influence host glucose control.
Measurement of metabolic hormones and metabolically relevant cytokines revealed endocrine alterations consistent with the above findings. Similar to changes in adiposity, levels of the satiety hormone, leptin, were elevated in B + M mice on both diets compared to B only, and lower in B + C mice fed HFHS, independently of sex (Figure S4A). The hunger-stimulating hormone, ghrelin, was also higher in B + M mice on both diets in males and in HFHS fed females (Figure S4B-C), along with interleukin (IL)-6 in male mice fed SD and glucagon-like peptide 1 (GLP-1) in HFHS fed mice, independently of sex (Figure S4D-F). GLP-1 was also higher in B + R mice fed HFHS compared to B only (Figure S4F). Fungal colonization did not influence the concentrations of monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1), glucagon or peptide tyrosine tyrosine (PYY) (Figures S4G-K). These results suggest that fungal-induced metabolic changes occur at least in part through modulation of the host endocrine system.
Fungal colonization also impacted systemic lipid profiles. Male B + C mice displayed lower plasma triglycerides on both diets and both sexes had lower total cholesterol when fed HFHS, reflective of their lean phenotype and resistance to DIO (Fig. 4C-F). In contrast, B + R mice displayed higher triglycerides in females, LDL cholesterol in males fed HFHS and in females on both diets, alongside lower HDL cholesterol in females fed HFHS (Fig. 4C-H & Figure S4L-M). We also found that B + R mice on HFHS displayed enhanced hepatic lipid accumulation in both sexes compared to B only (Fig. 4I-K). These alterations in systemic lipid profiles and hepatic lipid accumulation induced by R. mucilaginosa colonization are indicative of dyslipidemia and metabolic disease. Interestingly, both B + C and B + M female mice displayed lower hepatic lipid droplets, despite showing different metabolic phenotypes (Fig. 4J-K). Altogether, we show that each of these core human mycobiome species distinctly modulate several aspects of host metabolism and metabolic disease development under normal and obesogenic dietary conditions.
Fungal colonizers modulate the visceral adipose tissue immune landscape
Immune cell populations in adipose tissue are critical regulators of tissue function with implications for metabolic health51. Therefore, we evaluated the impact of early-life exposure to these three fungal species on the visceral WAT immune landscape. Among the different fat depots, visceral WAT has the greatest inflammatory potential and has been studied extensively in the context of microbiome-mediated alterations to adipose tissue immunity 28,52. We carried out a comprehensive assessment of 27 myeloid and lymphoid immune cell populations in peri-gonadal fat tissue and in the spleen at 12 weeks of age (Figure S5 & Table S5). Comparing the immune landscape of WAT to that of the spleen allowed us to discern immune changes specific to this depot from systemic ones. This analysis yielded numerous significant changes in WAT immune cell populations that varied according to fungal colonization, diet and sex.
Similar to the potent ability of C. albicans to modulate host immunity at distal sites, such as the lungs26, C. albicans colonization resulted in drastic changes to the visceral WAT innate and adaptive immune landscape, compared to mice harboring bacteria only. Under SD diet conditions, B + C mice displayed higher numbers of γδT cells, innate lymphoid cell (ILC) 1, ILC3, intermediate macrophages (CD206lo/intLy6C+MHCII+), conventional dendritic cell (cDC) 1, CX3CR1+ DCs and neutrophils in both sexes compared to B only (Fig. 5A & Table S6-7). In males only, B + C mice displayed higher Th1, Th17, CD8+ T cells, B cells, NK cells, total CD64+ cells including CX3CR1+ macrophages, vascular-associated macrophages (VAM) type 1 and 2 (CD206hiMHCII−Tim4int and Tim4hi, respectively) and preVAM (CD206lo/intLy6C−MHCII+CD11c-) (Fig. 5A & Table S6-7). Except for changes in Th1, Th17 and ILC3 in both sexes, and γδT cells cDC1 and neutrophils in females, most of the shifts in WAT immune cell populations were not identified in the spleens of mice colonized with C. albicans (Figure S6A & Table S8-9), indicating that the broad and drastic effect on WAT immunity is not solely a result of systemic immune changes. These changes are also not a result of C. albicans infection or translocation from the gut since we could not detect the growth of this yeast in internal organs or blood.
Both R. mucilaginosa and M. restricta similarly influenced the populations of immune cells in WAT on a SD, although their effects were not as pronounced as those observed with C. albicans. In females, B + R mice displayed higher ILC2, CD11c+ macrophages, preVAM, VAM2 and eosinophils, with a parallel enrichment in the spleen for ILC2 only (Fig. 5A, Figure S6A & Table S6-9). In B + M mice, there were fewer ILC2 and eosinophils in both sexes, fewer Tregs and CD8+ T cells in males only, and fewer B cells in females only compared to B only (Fig. 5A & Table S6-7). Importantly, none of these changes in population dynamics were mirrored in the spleen (Figure S6A & Table S8-9), indicating that fungal colonizers can uniquely modulate the immune landscape within WAT, particularly under SD conditions, which carries significant implications for metabolic outcomes.
We next examined how fungi influenced this same immune landscape under obesogenic conditions. As observed in normal diet conditions, C. albicans elicited the most potent immune modulation in WAT. B + C mice displayed more cDC1 and neutrophils in both sexes, Th17, CD8+ T cells, B cells, γδT cells, ILC1, ILC2, VAM1 and eosinophils in males only, and lower CD9+ macrophages in females only (Figure S7A & Table S10-11). We also observed alterations to Th17 and ILC1 in the spleen (Figure S6B & Table S12-13), suggesting that mice fed HFHS experience systemic immune changes that may also impact WAT. Fewer populations were modulated in B + R mice, including higher ILC2, ILC3, VAM1 and VAM2 in males only, with no parallel shifts in the spleen (Figure S6B, Figure S7A & Table S10-13). Lastly, B + M mice displayed lower Th17 in both sexes (also seen in the spleen for males), and lower Th1 and ILC3 in females (Figure S6B, Figure S7A & Table S10-13). Together, this extensive evaluation of WAT immunity indicates that early-life fungal colonization can uniquely and causally modulate the immune landscape of this important fat depot in both standard and obesogenic diet conditions, with differential effects driven by sex.
Systems-level integration show fungal associations with microbiome, metabolic and immune changes
To gain insights into the complex connections between the biological processes measured in our study, we carried out an integrative analysis based on Spearman correlations between microbial, metabolic and immune datasets. This type of unsupervised analysis can highlight interrelationships between the involved biomolecules and their functions53. Notably, we found that colonization with C. albicans displayed most of the detected significant correlations in mice fed SD (Fig. 5B). This analysis revealed significant negative correlations between C. albicans colonization and fat mass and leptin, reflective of the lean phenotype. We also observed significant integration between C. albicans colonization and γδT cells, Th17 and CX3CR1 + DCs (Fig. 5B), in line with the increased type 17 inflammation in the WAT of these mice. Meanwhile, R. mucilaginosa colonization was positively correlated with the relative abundance of B. animalis YL2, contrasting with mice colonized with only bacteria, and negatively correlated with A. muris KB18 (Fig. 5B). On HFHS, C. albicans colonization maintained a negative correlation with fat mass and leptin, along with body weight at 12 weeks (Figure S7B). Overall, these findings suggest that C. albicans influences both metabolic programming and the inflammatory tone of WAT, which may regulate host energy storage. On the other hand, R. mucilaginosa may elicit its effects on host metabolism through its relationship with the ecology of the bacterial microbiome.