Patient characteristics are shown in Table 1. The median interval from the start of treatment to the last follow-up time was 7.6 years. Most of NGGCT histology was mixed subtype at 21 of 26 patients, followed by teratoma in 3 of 26 patients, and choriocarcinoma in 2 of 26 patients.
NGGCT
All the patients in this group were diagnosed by tissue pathology. Eleven of 24 patients (46%) got a biopsy, while 13 of 24 patients (54%) got subtotal tumor removal (STR). Median B-HCG level in NGGCT was 37.56 IU/L (0.56-583.20) in serum and 35.63 IU/L (29.64 – 103.4) in the CSF. For AFP, the median value was 35.05 ng/ml (3.82-198.38) in serum and 2.34 ng/ml (0.5-14.22) in the CSF. Metastasis disease had been found in 3 of 24 patients (13%) on MR imaging and/or on CSF cytology. They received chemotherapy followed by CSI to 36Gy. 20 of 24 patients with NGGCT received chemotherapy (83%) including 25% of BEP, 42% of ICE, and 17% of Carboplatin combined with etoposide, Twenty-two of 24 patients received RT (consisting of 50% CSI, 12% WBRT, 32% WVRT, and 6% involved-filed). Two patients who did not receive radiotherapy because one patient lost to follow-up and other patient developed lung fibrosis after chemotherapy. Two patients experienced an interruption in their RT regimen, each receiving a radiation dose below 18Gy. Both patients passed away due to pneumonia before they could complete the course of radiotherapy.
In NGGCT patients, the 5-year and 10-year EFS were 73.33%±9.3% and 61.11%±11.1%. The 5-year and 10-year OS were 75%±10.8% and 67.5% ±12.1%. In RT alone, the 5-year and 10-year EFS and OS were 100% and 100%. In Chemo-RT arm, the 5-year and 10-year EFS were 67.57%±10.88% and 54.05%±12.20%. The 5-year and 10-year OS were 68.44%±10.79% and 68.44%±10.79%. Three of the 9 deaths were related to disease recurrence. One patient who had a multifocal mixed germ cell tumor combined germinoma and immature teratoma received CMT with a stable response. Then, a patient got radiotherapy for 9 sessions, he passed away due to serious pneumonia. Another patient who mixed germ cell tumor with spinal metastasis and paraplegia at presentation received CMT then CSI to 36Gy passed away after 5 months of completing a radiotherapy course because of UTI with sepsis. Three of them had experienced severe sepsis. No documentation was available on the other one.
Five and 10-year OS were 100% and 100% for WBRT, 100% and 75% in CSI plus CMT , 33% and 0% WVRT alone , 66.67%, 66.67% WVRT+CMT. In WBRT plus CMT and focal tumor bed RT plus CMT showed no patients alive at 5-and 10-year. When we compare in terms of OS of CMT and site of RT factors, there were no statistically significant parameter different between OS (P= 0.21) as shown in Figure 1. The pattern of failure was in-field RT 2 of 3 patients. One of 3 patients developed diffuse leptomeningeal involvement and local recurrence at the pineal area as shown in Table2. Another individual developed out-field drop metastases at T5-6 spinal region after WVRT only 6 months. Acute toxicities were reported in Figure 2. Grade 3 toxicity was found in patients who received CMT plus RT more than RT alone in terms of anemia (10%) and thrombocytopenia (5%). Radiotherapy treatment interruption in combined Chemo-RT was found 31.6% (6/19) and 0% in RT alone.
For subgroup patients with elevated tumor markers, there are sixteen patients who received CMT+RT. The 5-year and 10-year EFS were 66.67%±13.93% and 66.67%±13.93%. The 5-year and 10-year OS were 71.38%±12.18% and 71.38%±12.18%. Only one patient received radiotherapy alone because of poor performance status. He underwent WBRT 34Gy in 17 fractions alone. Despite the challenging circumstances, the patient managed to survive for 13 years after completing the radiotherapy course. He passed away due to severe sepsis at the primary hospital.
Germinoma
Fifty-three of 60 patients underwent surgeries, whereas 7 of 60 patients were diagnosed by radiologic finding and tumor marker level. Forty-seven of the 60 patients had biopsies, and 6 had subtotal resections (STR). The median B-HCG was 1.91 IU/L (0.20-17.6) in serum and 22.46 IU/L (2.90-81.70) in CSF. For AFP, the median value was 1.47 ng/ml (0.79-2.59) in serum, and 0.5 ng/ml (0.5 -0.7) in the CSF, respectively. Thirty-six patients (60%) received chemotherapy which is composed of BEP (32%), carboplatin plus etoposide (18%), and cisplatin plus etoposide (32%). Fifty-nine patients (98%) received radiotherapy treatment (consisting of 62% WVRT, 26% CSI, and 12% WBRT). One patient did not proceed with radiotherapy because condition continued to worsen after completing four cycles of BEP treatment then passed away because of obstructive hydrocephalus caused by disease progression at the left basal ganglion. Three of the 60 patients had found radiographic spinal metastases and positive CSF cytology. All three metastases’ patients received combined CSI and chemotherapy.
In germinoma patients, EFS were 82.7%±5% at 5 years and 72%±6.7% at 10 years. 5-year and 10-year OS were 89.30%±4.1% and 77.19%±6.23%, respectively. In RT alone, the 5-year and 10-year EFS were 95.83%±4.08% and 76.87%±9.16%. The 5-year and 10-year OS were 95.83%±4.08% and 86.40%±7.35%. Whereas in Chemo-RT, the 5-year and 10-year EFS were 73.33%±7.69% and 69.63%±9.54%. The 5-year and 10-year OS were 85.10%±6.19% and 69.63%±9.54%. Of the 15 deaths, 6 were related to disease, 1 was related to complications of treatment, 4 were from severe infection, 4 were due to unrelated causes (2 from heart disease, 1 from meningitis, and 1 from OSA-related sequence). Five and 10-year OS were 100% and 100% for WBRT plus CMT and CSI alone, 87.5% and 87.5% in CSI plus CMT , 93% and 87% WVRT alone, 100% and 75% for WBRT alone, 85% and 62% WVRT+CMT. As shown in Table2. The local pattern of failure was in-field RT 3 of 5 patients. To Compare in terms overall survival of pure germinoma patients based on the RT site and CMT, no statistically significant differences in parameters were observed for OS (P=0.41). Corresponding with EFS and OS, hazard ratio of patients who received combined CMT and RT compared to RT alone were 1.61(P=0.308), and 2.74 (P = 0.141) in Table 3. After adjusting by age > 18, primary site, metastasis, type of surgery, field of radiotherapy, gender, serum beta-HCG, serum AFP, the HR for EFS and OS were 2.49(P=0.095), and 2.55 (P = 0.237).
The acute toxicity was found to be lower than that of the non-germinoma group, mainly due to a smaller number of patients who underwent craniospinal irradiation (CSI). The rate of grade 2 and 3 toxicities in terms of anemia, neutropenia, thrombocytopenia, and renal toxicity was observed in patients who received both RT and CMT compared to those who received RT alone, as depicted in Figure 2. Radiotherapy treatment interruption in Chemo-RT was found 17.6% (6/34) and 21.7% (5/23) in radiotherapy alone.