1. Data sources
The data was obtained from the 2018 China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study (CHARLS), a high-quality study aimed at analyzing the current situation of ageing in China and promoting the development of ageing issues, with questionnaires and face-to-face interviews with middle-aged and older people aged 45 and above and their families in a multi-stage sample of 150 counties and 450 communities or villages in 28 provinces across China. [18]The survey included a wide range of information on personal information, economy, health and so on, and the survey method was multi-stage sampling, with PPS sampling at both the county/district and village sampling stages. The data was released on 23 September 2020, which includes the latest nationally representative survey data on middle-aged and elderly people with cognitive impairment in China. Therefore, we chose the data from the CHARLS 2018.
2. Study population
This study was conducted on older adults aged 55 years and older from CHARLS 2018. Data from the modules " Demographic Backgrounds", "Health Status and Functioning" and "Cognition and Depression" were selected for this study.
In the part of “Demographic Backgrounds”, gender, age, address, the highest level of education and marital status were considered. It should be noted that age was classified as 55–64,65–74,75 and above. Address included village or city/town. The highest level of education included “No formal education (illiterate)”, “Elementary school or did not finish primary school”, “Middle school and above”. Meanwhile, marital status marital status was divided into “married” and “others”. Secondly, in the “Health Status and Functioning” part, smoking and drinking status, Sleep duration, nap, activities were selected. Sleep duration was classified as insufficient, normal, or excessive according to the criteria of < 7h, 7 ~ 9h, and > 9h.[19] In addition, We calculated and used the MMSE scores from the "Cognition and Depression" module. 921 patients were diagnosed with cognitive impairment, and 684 valid samples were finally obtained by deleting samples with missing information on important variables.
Participants were excluded if they met any of the following criteria:(1) aged below 55 years, (2) did not finish the Minimum Mental State Examination (MMSE), (3) did not meet a diagnosis of cognitive impairment (4) incomplete information on EQ-5D-3L. (Fig. 1)
3. MMSE
The Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) is a widely used cognitive function assessment tool, and is known for its high degree of reliability and validity when used by general population or Chinese population.[20, 21] In this study, the MMSE was used to assess the cognitive function of older adults, measuring orientation, memory, attention, computation, and language. Higher scores indicate better cognitive function. In addition, MMSE thresholds consisted of 17 (illiterate participants), 20 (participants with elementary school or did not finish it), and 24 (participants with Middle school and above) based on the previous studies.[22, 23] Meanwhile, cognitive impairment was defined as those whose MMSE score was below the set threshold according to the level of education.
4. EQ-5D-3L
Recently, the 3-level version of the EuroQoL Five Dimensions Questionnaire (EQ-5D-3L) has been widely used to measure HRQoL and showed good reliability and validity in Chinese population.[24, 25]
The EQ-5D-3L questionnaire consists of five dimensions, including “Mobility”, “Self-Care”, “Usual Activities”, “Pain or Discomfort”, and “Anxiety or Depression”. Each dimension consists of three levels: “have no problems/be not,” “have some/moderate problems,” “have extremely problems/unable to.”[24, 26] Based on the meanings of the five dimensions, the corresponding questions were selected in the two modules of the CHARLS questionnaire, namely "Health Status and Functioning" and "Cognition and Depression". The correspondence between the questions of the CHARLS questionnaire and the dimensions of the EQ-5D-3L selected for this study is shown in the Table 1.
Based on a value set, we can convert EQ-5D states to health utility value, which was calculated using the utility value integral system constructed according to the preferences of the Chinese population. The calculation formula is: Health utility value = 1 - the sum of the corresponding level coefficients of each dimension.[25] Table 2. shows the coefficients of different levels for each dimension. Notably, the answer options for the questions in the CHARLS questionnaire are based on four items: no difficulty, can still be completed autonomously if there is difficulty, difficulty requires help from others, and cannot be completed. We combined the second and third options corresponding to the second level in the EQ-5D-3L "have some/moderate problems ". The worst-case state of any problem in each dimension (“have extremely problems/unable to.”> “have some/moderate problems,” > “have no problems/be not,”) is the final state for this dimension.
Table 2
The level of each dimension and its coefficient in the EQ-5D-3L. [1]
Dimension
|
Level
|
Coefficient
|
Mobility
|
have no problems/be not
|
0.0000
|
|
have some/moderate problems
|
0.0766
|
|
have extremely problems/unable to
|
0.2688
|
Self-Care
|
have no problems/be not
|
0.0000
|
|
have some/moderate problems
|
0.0441
|
|
have extremely problems/unable to
|
0.2912
|
Usual Activities
|
have no problems/be not
|
0.0000
|
|
have some/moderate problems
|
0.0370
|
|
have extremely problems/unable to
|
0.0538
|
Pain or Discomfort
|
have no problems/be not
|
0.0000
|
|
have some/moderate problems
|
0.0274
|
|
have extremely problems/unable to
|
0.0409
|
Anxiety or Depression
|
have no problems/be not
|
0.0000
|
|
have some/moderate problems
|
0.0359
|
|
have extremely problems/unable to
|
0.1771
|
5. Statistical analysis
We applied SPSS 26.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, US) for statistical analysis. Firstly, we tested all the health utility values of elderly patients with cognitive impairment by Kolmogorov-Smirnov method. It indicated that the health utility values did not conform to normal distribution, thus Median (P25, P75) was used to statistically describe it. Univariate analyses were performed by Mann-Whitney test or Kruskal-Wallis test.
Additionally, Since the health utility value as a dependent variable has a limited range of values and has a strong ceiling effect[27], in other words, it’s a restricted dependent variable with the characteristic of being intercepted. In order to deal with this situation, we conducted regression analyses using the Tobit regression model [28] to analyze the influencing factors of health-related quality of life. To solve the error caused by the ceiling effect, we assumed that an elderly cognitively impaired patient with a health utility value of 1 has a true value greater than or equal to 1. We used \({Y}_{i}\) to denote the utility value of a particular individual \(i\) computed by the scale, and \({Y}_{i}^{*}\) to denote the actual utility value of the individual \(i\), thus the Tobit model can be expressed as:
We used the Tobit regression model with Stata MP 17.0 (StataCorp LLC, Texas, US), \(\alpha\)=0.05. In all the results, p < 0.05 was used as the criterion for statistically significant differences.
Table 1
The Correspondence between CHARLS Questionnaire Questions and EQ-5D-3L Dimensions.
Serial number
|
Dimension
|
Code of questions
|
The content of questions
|
1
|
Mobility
|
DB002
|
Do you have difficulty with walking 1 km?
|
2
|
|
DB003
|
Do you have difficulty with walking 100 meters?
|
3
|
|
DB004
|
Do you have difficulty with getting up from a chair after sitting for a long period?
|
4
|
|
DB006
|
Do you have difficulty with stooping, kneeling, or crouching?
|
5
|
Self-Care
|
DB010
|
Because of health and memory problems, do you have any difficulty with dressing?
|
6
|
|
DB011
|
Because of health and memory problems, do you have any difficulty with bathing or showering?
|
7
|
|
DB012
|
Because of health and memory problems, do you have any difficulty with eating, such as cutting up your food?
|
8
|
|
DB013
|
Do you have any difficulty with getting into or out of bed?
|
9
|
|
DB014
|
Because of health and memory problems, do you have any difficulties with using the toilet, including getting up and down?
|
10
|
Usual Activities
|
DB016
|
Because of health and memory problems, do you have any difficulties with doing household chores?
|
11
|
|
DB017
|
Because of health and memory problems, do you have any difficulties with preparing hot meals?
|
12
|
|
DB018
|
Because of health and memory problems, do you have any difficulties with shopping for groceries
|
13
|
|
DB019
|
Because of health and memory problems, do you have any difficulties with managing your money, such as paying your bills, keeping track of expenses, or managing assets?
|
14
|
Pain or Discomfort
|
DA041_W4
|
Are you often troubled with any body pains?
|
15
|
Anxiety or Depression
|
DC009
|
I was bothered by things that don’t usually bother me
|
16
|
|
DC010
|
I had trouble keeping my mind on what I was doing
|
17
|
|
DC011
|
I felt depressed
|
18
|
|
DC014
|
I felt fearful
|
Table 2
The level of each dimension and its coefficient in the EQ-5D-3L. [25]
Dimension
|
Level
|
Coefficient
|
Mobility
|
have no problems/be not
|
0.0000
|
|
have some/moderate problems
|
0.0766
|
|
have extremely problems/unable to
|
0.2688
|
Self-Care
|
have no problems/be not
|
0.0000
|
|
have some/moderate problems
|
0.0441
|
|
have extremely problems/unable to
|
0.2912
|
Usual Activities
|
have no problems/be not
|
0.0000
|
|
have some/moderate problems
|
0.0370
|
|
have extremely problems/unable to
|
0.0538
|
Pain or Discomfort
|
have no problems/be not
|
0.0000
|
|
have some/moderate problems
|
0.0274
|
|
have extremely problems/unable to
|
0.0409
|
Anxiety or Depression
|
have no problems/be not
|
0.0000
|
|
have some/moderate problems
|
0.0359
|
|
have extremely problems/unable to
|
0.1771
|