In this prospective study, we investigated the effects of naturalistic guided psychedelic group sessions on OA’s well-being by leveraging an opportunity sample of 62 participants aged 60 years or older attending self-initiated psychedelic ceremonies or retreats. Analyses revealed clinically meaningful improvements in well-being in OA at two and four weeks following a psychedelic group session, in line with prior naturalistic studies in YA (Kettner et al., 2021; Mason et al., 2019; Ruffell et al., 2021; Uthaug et al., 2021). Interestingly, this was the case despite lower acute subjective effects scores in the OA sample, indicating that differential salutogenic mechanisms may be at play in this age group. This exploratory hypothesis was partially confirmed through regression and correlational analyses showing a primacy of relational mechanisms, as opposed to classic intrasubjective psychedelic effects in OA attending psychedelic group sessions.
Among baseline and demographic variables predicting well-being increases in OA, only the presence of a psychiatric diagnosis showed significant effects. This finding was stable also when controlling for expectation effects, a hypothesized confounder in psychedelic trials (Muthukumaraswamy et al., 2021) and is in line with the transdiagnostic utility of psychedelic treatments for a number of mental health disorders (Brennan & Belser, 2022; Kelly et al., 2021; Kočárová et al., 2021), including major depression, alcohol-use disorder, and anorexia nervosa. Indeed, resilience to expectancy is consistent with recent research that failed to support its influence in driving therapeutic response to psilocybin therapy for depression (Szigeti et al., 2024), implying a substantive direct therapeutic action. Outside regulated clinical trial settings, the structured, user-reviewed services offered by retreat centres might have particular appeal to OA when compared to individual use (e.g., at-home). OA may have less access to or tend to avoid the acquisition of scheduled substances over the black market, may have greater psychological needs for safety, structure and social contact (Albert & Duffy, 2012), and the economical means to afford the often high financial cost of psychedelic retreats or ceremonies.
Crucially, clinically relevant improvements in mental health in OA were indistinguishable from those found in a sample of YA, matched to account for several demographic factors including higher OA well-being at baseline, a common finding in the literature (Carstensen et al., 2003). For example, elevated baseline well-being levels in OA are in accordance with representative population level studies showing that in wealthy English-speaking countries, happiness and hedonic experiences are lowest around ages 45-54 and tend to increase with age, following an inverted U-shape (Steptoe et al., 2015, Blanchflower, 2021). The observed return of well-being levels to baseline at the six-months follow-up time point in OA is in contrast with prior studies showing long-term mental health improvements following psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy (reviewed in Aday, Mitzkovitz, et al., 2020). Two prior naturalistic studies in YA have also found sustained two-year increases in protective psychological traits such as resilience and mindfulness (Mans et al., 2021), or nature relatedness (Kettner et al., 2019), although, similar to the present study, affective measures of well-being have thus far been shown to remain increased only at nominal, non-significant levels (Mans et al., 2021). The conditions under which psychedelic-induced salutogenesis remains stable therefore remains a critical unanswered question, considering that in clinical studies, improvements appear to remain significant for months to years following treatment (Agin-Liebes et al., 2020; Carhart-Harris et al., 2018; Gukasyan & Nayak, 2021; Johnson et al., 2017).
Our study revealed differential acute psychedelic effects and salutogenic mechanisms in OA when compared to YA. This is of clinical importance, since current models of psychedelic function propose that the acute psychedelic effects are key mediators of mental health improvements (Griffiths et al., 2008; Griffiths et al., 2006; Ko et al., 2022; Majić et al., 2015; Roseman et al., 2018). In contrast to prior controlled research reporting challenging experiences to be negatively correlated with age (Ko et al., 2023; Kopra et al., 2022; Studerus et al., 2012), the OA group in the present sample showed lower acute effects scores on all metrics except for challenging experiences. One potential reason for this apparent discrepancy may be the overall younger age (means ranging from 27-36) and lack of participants aged 60 or above in the abovementioned controlled studies. It is thus possible that the intensity of challenging experiences under psychedelics peaks among the younger distribution of YA and remains stable after a certain age, pointing to population diversity as a key strength of naturalistic studies such as this one.
Nonetheless, the absence of any significant correlations between acute psychedelic effects and long-term changes in OA contradicts previous work showing that the quality of the acute experience constitutes a key predictor of psychedelic-induced changes in well-being (Haijen et al., 2018; Kangaslampi, 2020, 2023; Kettner et al., 2021; Peill et al., 2022; Roseman et al., 2019; Roseman et al., 2018). In contrast, only the experience of Communitas rated in reference to the entire retreat – not just the psychedelic session – was associated with well-being changes in OA. This finding suggests that OA might benefit from psychedelics for different reasons than YA, greater relevance being given to the experience of togetherness and social bonds that can occur in group settings than to the individual, intrapersonal experience. The witnessing of other participants’ vulnerability and the resulting emotional intimacy generated through sharing rounds before and after dosing sessions might be particularly impactful to OA, for whom social contact, especially with nonfamily members, is known to decrease (Sander et al., 2017). Indeed, from the present data it is unclear to what extent the consumption of the psychedelic substance itself would have even been necessary for OA to experience the detected psychological benefits. Future research should thus further explore the details of psychotherapeutic and group activities taking place at psychedelic retreats, and their psychological benefits for participants, as well as the validity of instruments assessing the overall experience in OA. Conceivably, the psychedelic session itself could be seen as a non-essential part, primarily providing the context for an intimate and intergenerational group-based intervention with the potential to tackle the negative emotional and cognitive health consequences of social isolation in the elderly (Krzeczkowska et al., 2021; Murayama et al., 2015).
Further, the present findings of reduced acute psychedelic effects and increased importance of social connections may relate to the consolidation of “emotional landscapes” in OA (Carstensen et al., 2003). Our findings are in line with Carstensen’s (et al., 1999) Socioemotional Selectivity Theory posing that OA optimize emotional experiences to prioritize meaningful social connections and foster positive experiences and emotional satisfaction. Intriguingly, reduced acute psychedelic effects in OA may mechanistically also relate to age-dependent reductions in cortical serotonin receptor density, which is most pronounced for the 2A receptor (Karrer et al., 2019), the primary target of psychedelics (Madsen et al., 2019; Vollenweider et al., 1998).
Several limitations need to be considered when interpreting our findings. Most importantly, the context of psychedelic use in the present sample was limited to ceremony and retreat settings, raising the question whether well-being improvements, attenuated acute psychedelic effects, and greater importance of psychosocial mechanisms detected in the current sample would also occur in other naturalistic or controlled psychotherapeutic settings. Replications in larger and more representative samples will therefore be crucial to further explore the effects of psychedelic on the elderly outside psychedelic ceremony and retreat settings, and in samples less biased towards white, highly educated participants. Controlled laboratory studies administering psychedelics to OA will potentially be able to clarify the role of acute psychedelic effects in environments that do not provide the psychosocial group benefits present at psychedelic retreats. Additional limitations include the inaccurate qualitative assessment of psychedelic dose, as well as possible co-use of other substances - common in naturalistic samples (Kuc et al., 2021; Zeifman et al., 2023) - which was not controlled for in the present study. Furthermore, the potential of systematic biases through attrition effects constitutes another limitation related to the remote nature of this survey study, although prior research has shown that attrition in prospective psychedelic surveys follows similar patterns as in other fields (Hübner et al., 2021).