Most studies on mothers of preterm infants have focused only on symptom prevalence. This study is the first to investigate dysfunctional psychological processes in a population of mothers of preterm infants in Africa. We hypothesized that anhedonia, brooding rumination, and worry would be the processes underlying symptoms in mothers after preterm delivery. Our findings can be summarized into three main points. First, the prevalence of PTS, anxiety, and depressive symptoms in Cameroonian mothers of preterm infants suggests that preterm birth may be associated with postpartum disorders. These results are consistent with previous studies [8, 12, 15, 46]. Second, the results reveled that psychological processes predict a large proportion of the variance in PTS, anxiety, and depressive symptoms in mothers after preterm delivery. In other words, anhedonia, brooding rumination and worry are significant factors that explain the onset and maintenance of symptoms in Cameroonian mothers of preterm infants. Third, the results show that psychological processes predict multiple symptoms simultaneously, supporting the transdiagnostic nature of dysfunctional psychological processes [19, 21, 28, 47].
4.1. Mothers’ symptoms a few days after preterm delivery
The prevalence of postnatal symptoms in this study was estimated at 27.4% for PTS symptoms, 63.2% for anxiety symptoms and 46.2% for depressive symptoms in mothers a few days after preterm delivery. The prevalence of PTS symptoms is similar to the prevalence of between 28% and 32.5% previously reported in studies conducted in Canada and Iran during the first 10 days after a preterm delivery [48, 49]. However, it is substantially lower than the 71.1% observed in a study conducted in the USA [7]. This discrepancy may be attributable to the fact that Shaw et al. (2014) examined all traumatic events associated with infants’ Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU) hospitalization rather than focusing solely on the traumatic event of preterm delivery. The prevalence of anxiety we found is consistent with the findings of previous studies, which reported that approximately half of mothers of preterm infants experience pathological levels of anxiety within the first two weeks after birth [7, 10, 11, 50]. As for depression, the prevalence found in this study is similar to the results of several studies assessing depressive symptoms within 2 weeks after preterm delivery [7, 10, 48], which reported a prevalence ranging from 35.6% to 43%. Furthermore, these data are in line with a systematic review of the literature that reported a prevalence of depression corresponding to 40% in mothers of preterm babies [12]. However, in the week after delivery, Trumello et al. [11] reported a depression prevalence of 68% for mothers whose children were born between 28 and 31 weeks and of 60% for mothers whose children were born between 32 and 36 weeks of pregnancy. The higher proportions may be attributed to the Italian version’s 8/9 cut-off point, which is lower than the usual cut-off point of 9/10 or above recommended by the authors of the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS) [51].
The respective prevalence of PTS, anxiety and depressive symptoms is higher than those in community samples of postpartum mothers [52–57]. This finding suggests that preterm birth is a stressful event that increases the risk of postpartum disorders in mothers [3, 8, 9, 46, 58, 59].
Few previous studies provide data comparing the prevalence of anxiety and depression in mothers following preterm birth, and those results are inconsistent. In our study, the predominance of anxiety over depression is supported by the fact that mothers of preterm newborns report being alert and worrying as the main manifestations during the first days after delivery. These results are in line with two studies assessing anxiety and depression in the first two weeks after preterm delivery [7, 10]. Trumello et al. [11] found equivalent prevalence in the first week postpartum, which is inconsistent with this study. However, those authors used a cut-off point of 8/9 for the EPDS, which is lower than the standard cut-off point of 10. This may have contributed to an increase in the rate of depression, making it similar to that of anxiety. In sum, Cameroonian mothers of preterm infants report PTS, anxiety, and depression, with a higher prevalence for anxiety symptoms.
4.2. Psychological processes underlying symptoms
For anhedonia, our findings indicate that a deficit in consummatory pleasure has a transdiagnostic effect, which contributes to the severity of both anxiety and depressive symptoms. This effect on depressive symptoms is in accordance with the findings of Wu et al.’s [60] study, in which depressed people showed a greater consummatory pleasure deficit than healthy individuals. According to Stanton et al. [33], the deficit in consummatory pleasure may be associated with a disruption of the physiological reward circuits due to the stress of the preterm birth. Our results suggest that anhedonia is a target for intervention to improve both anxiety and depressive symptoms simultaneously. Behavioral activation, mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, and mental imagery therapy are potential treatments to improve anhedonia. Indeed, in a randomized controlled trial conducted by Cernasov et al. [61], participants with anhedonia were assigned to receive either behavioral activation therapy or mindfulness-based cognitive therapy. A significant reduction in anhedonia was reported in both groups. Similarly, Webb et al. [62] found that, in adolescents, behavioral activation not only reduced anhedonia but also increased neuronal sensitivity to affectively salient stimuli, including those related to reward. Two studies have also demonstrated the effectiveness of mental imagery therapy in reducing anhedonia [63, 64]
Finally, this study found that reminiscence pleasure is a significant predictor of anxiety. This suggests that mothers with higher hedonic capacity in relation to past events are more likely to experience anxiety about the stressful situation of preterm birth than mothers with lower hedonic capacity. Based on the mothers’ discourse during clinical interviews, it can be hypothesized that these mothers are comparing their current situation, which is stressful due to the preterm birth, with their past situation, where they felt less stress. Nevertheless, further research may be required to better understand the relationship between reminiscence pleasure and anxiety in mothers who have experienced preterm delivery.
This study showed that brooding rumination contributed to the severity of PTS symptoms, but not anxiety or depressive symptoms. These findings support previous research indicating that a reduction in rumination following an intervention is associated with a decrease in PTS symptoms but not in anxiety and depressive symptoms [65]. The significant predictive effect of brooding on PTS symptoms is also consistent with the findings of a systematic review that confirmed the predictive effect of brooding rumination on PTSD [20]. In our study, we assume that thoughts about preterm birth may act as mediators for the generation and maintenance of PTS symptoms caused by rumination. These thoughts likely include the fact that preterm birth is known to be a major cause of illness and death in newborns [35, 66]. According to the study by Schaich et al. [67], training in concrete, experiential thinking could be beneficial in countering the negative effects of rumination on PTS symptoms. This would allow mothers to address specific negative thoughts about preterm birth with factual information about their current situation and that of their baby.
Our findings indicate that worry is a contributing factor to the severity of PTS, anxiety, and depressive symptoms, which is in line with the results of previous research [22, 68–70]. These findings also support the transdiagnostic nature of worry reported by the mother during the perinatal period [25]. Hong [71] has shown that worry can affect the severity of anxiety and depressive symptoms, which may be mediated by the perception that coping efforts to deal with the identified stressful event are not effective. An intervention should address worry, which is a transdiagnostic dysfunctional process common to PTS, anxiety, and depressive symptoms among mothers of preterm infants. Once again, behavioral activation and mental imagery are also potential interventions [72–74].
4.3. Limitations
This study has several limitations that may affect the quality of the results and their interpretation. First, it should be noted that in this study the HADS-A subscale, the CP subscale, and the AAT subscale showed insufficient internal consistency. This may explain why our results did not replicate some of the findings of previous studies. The subscales’ low internal consistency suggests that certain items were not understood by Cameroonian French-speaking people in the same way as French speakers in France, with whom the scale was translated and validated. For example, the item Je peux rester tranquillement assise à ne rien faire et me sentir décontractée (I can sit at ease and feel relaxed) of the HADS-A subscale may be culturally interpreted as indicating laziness rather than an absence of anxiety. In other words, because of nuances in local word meanings, some items do not assess the behaviors they are supposed to. This explanation highlights the need to translate and validate local versions of these scales.
It will also be interesting in future research to set up a control group with mothers of full-term babies. This will allow us to assess the real impact of preterm birth in terms of prevalence and severity of symptoms. It would enable any differences observed between the two groups to be more accurately attributed to prematurity or full term. Finally, the sample size in this study is not large and therefore limits the generalizability of the results.
4.4. Conclusion
Despite its limitations, this study reveals the psychological distress experienced by mothers of preterm infants in Cameroon during the first 10 days after delivery. It also points to the presence of psychological vulnerability associated with dysfunctional psychological processes in mothers. Given the early involvement of mothers in the care of their preterm newborns, it can be concluded that poor mental health is also a significant threat to the survival and well-being of preterm newborns. Numerous studies have shown that postnatal psychological problems in the mother can have a deleterious impact on the quality of maternal care. The more anxious and depressed mothers are, the more their interactions with their babies are affected [75]. In addition, compared with mothers of full-term babies, mothers of preterm babies have more difficulty breastfeeding and stop breastfeeding earlier [76].
Health professionals should therefore pay particular attention to the early identification of PTS, anxiety, and depressive symptoms after a preterm delivery, and medium- and long-term follow-up seems necessary. Early interventions should also help prevent babies from developing complications due to their mothers’ mental health problems [3, 8, 12]: complications related to the quality of maternal care [77, 78] and the quality of the mother-infant relationship [13].
Interventions targeting brooding and worrying and promoting consummatory pleasure may help to reduce symptoms and improve mothers’ well-being after a preterm birth. Behavioral activation has beneficial effects on anhedonia, rumination and worry [61, 62, 65, 72, 79]. It seems to be a relevant option to offer to mothers of preterm infants. Future studies could focus on designing and testing a form of behavioral activation therapy adapted to the needs and specific characteristics of the population of mothers of preterm infants.