In this research, we evaluated the degree of sympathetic blockade induced by ELA by quantifying blood flow spectral parameters using PWD US. The aim was to determine the predictive value of these parameters for the onset of ERMF. To our knowledge, this is the first study to examine the link between blood flow spectral parameters and ERMF. We measured regional blood flow spectral parameters in the anterior and posterior tibial arteries, which indicate sympathetic nervous system activity. These vessels' superficial and consistent anatomical positioning facilitates longitudinal ultrasound scanning, allowing for precise and reliable measurements.
Our findings revealed significant differences in PSV and EDV between the febrile and afebrile groups at 10 and 15 minutes post-ELA, respectively (P < 0.01). Sympathetic nerves solely innervate the blood vessels in the human limbs. During ELA, the blockade of sympathetic nerve fibers precedes motor and sensory block as the local anesthetic permeates the epidural space. This blockade triggers a vasodilatory effect, influencing local blood flow velocity, a phenomenon detectable through the spectral parameters assessed by PWD US8,13. Previous research has employed the pulse perfusion index (PI) as an indicator for ERMF. Sun et al. found that individuals who developed a fever during labor exhibited significantly higher PI values commencing 10 minutes post-ELA, corroborating the time our study detected intergroup disparities9.
The thermoregulatory hypothesis posits that epidural labor analgesia (ELA) may interfere with maternal thermoregulation2. Typically, during pregnancy, there is an enhanced sympathetic activation, a characteristic feature in normotensive women, further augmented by increased vasodilatory sympathetic activity compared to the nonpregnant state14. Conditions such as preeclampsia are believed to arise from an imbalance between excessive sympathetic activation and the vasodilatory responses that are typical during pregnancy15,16. Consequently, preserving the equilibrium of the sympathetic nervous system is crucial throughout pregnancy. Labor and delivery are characterized by intense uterine contractions and considerable physical exertion, leading to elevated heat production5. In the case of fever, skin vasodilation during this period is mediated by sympathetic cholinergic fibers, facilitating 'active vasodilation' and thus promoting increased heat loss5,17,18. We hypothesize that ELA might disrupt this delicate balance by inducing a 'chemical blockade' of the sympathetic nervous system, thus compromising the enhanced cooling mechanisms that are critical during labor.
Our hypothesis suggests that variations in the degree of sympathetic blockade may be a pathogenic factor contributing to ERMF, prompting us to analyze the correlation between blood flow spectral parameters and the participant’s body temperature. Prior research has documented a progressive rise in body temperature during labor, culminating at the termination of the second stage9,19,20.We noted a similar gradual increase in blood flow spectral parameters following analgesia. Although our measurements were confined to a 30-minute post-analgesia window, and we cannot confirm these as peak values, the consistent analgesic level at 30 minutes indicates a relatively stable impact of the local anesthetic on sympathetic tone9. A positive correlation between PSV30, EDV30, and the peak body temperature during labor supports our initial hypothesis that a more pronounced sympathetic blockade intensifies the disturbance in autonomic function equilibrium and impedes heat dissipation, leading to a higher body temperature increase. Our findings highlight the potential involvement of the thermoregulatory hypothesis in ERMF development2.
It is imperative to note the considerable individual variability in the ATA and PTA's baseline blood flow spectral parameters. Focusing on the relative changes in these parameters pre- and post-analgesia is more informative than the absolute values alone. A significant strength of this study is incorporating the change of these parameters with the incidence of ERMF in an ROC analysis to determine the AUC. The results demonstrate that the ΔEDV has a superior predictive value compared to the ΔPSV. (AUC: ATA ΔPSV 0.701; ATA ΔEDV 0.733; PTA ΔPSV 0.687; PTA ΔEDV 0.713). The reason may be that EDV better reflects vascular compliance and distal vascular resistance, whereas PSV is mainly influenced by cardiac functional status and vascular anatomy, and therefore EDV is more representative of the degree of sympathetic blockade. While the predictive sensitivity of these indicators is not exceedingly high, it is crucial to recognize that ERMF development is multifactorial, and disturbances in thermoregulation from epidural analgesia are only a part of the pathophysiological narrative and do not fully account for it1,2,21. The data indicate that ΔPSV and ΔEDV in the ATA and PTA regions possess potential predictive merits for the occurrence of ERMF.
In clinical practice, direct measurement of SNA is not achievable; instead, we infer its activity through indirect methods. The previous study showed a PI with an AUC of 0.818 for ERMF prediction, higher than our study9. This variation may result from different anesthetic concentrations and doses used in the studies. Some participants were treated with ropivacaine at concentrations up to 0.15%. Lower concentrations of local anesthetics might lead to lesser sympathetic blockade than higher concentrations22,23. Although PI is convenient clinically, its reliability can be significantly affected by uterine contractions during labor24. Our study introduces a new predictor by utilizing changes in ultrasound spectral parameters (PSV, EDV), which could offer a more objective quantitative measure and minimize the influence of confounding factors.
The practical significance of this research is in defining critical values for the variability of blood flow spectral parameters. Maternal and fetal hyperthermia exposure is associated with adverse effects1. The likelihood of ERMF increases when the ΔPSV of ATA and PTA is above 43.35 and 39.96, respectively, and the ΔEDV of ATA and PTA is above 29.94 and 33.10, respectively. Our findings also confirm that the total and second stages of labor are longer in febrile women, which is consistent with prior studies25. Epidural analgesia, which blocks the sympathetic-motor nerve fibers, may reduce uterine contractility and extend labor. Prolonged labor and higher doses of local anesthetics are significant risk factors for maternal fever1,23. Clinicians should monitor such patients closely, maintain labor progress, or consider lower anesthetic concentrations when feasible20.
This study has its limitations. It was a prospective observational study with a small sample size, and single-center trials may not be as reliable as multicenter ones. The homogeneity of subjects also raises concerns about the applicability of these findings to parturients with conditions like gestational hypertension or gestational diabetes mellitus that could affect sympathetic nervous system. Future research should have an inclusive study population and pursue validation through more rigorous randomized controlled trials. Additionally, the anesthetic concentrations used were standard for our facility, and further studies are required to determine whether different concentrations affect the variability of these parameters.
In summary, the changes in regional blood flow spectral parameters post-epidural analgesia offer an indirect method to gauge the extent of sympathetic inhibition, which can predict the occurrence of ERMF. Notably, the changes in peak systolic velocity and end-diastolic velocity relative to the baseline, measured 30 minutes after ELA induction, emerged as the most predictive factors. These findings could enable clinicians to identify high-risk individuals more promptly, allowing for earlier interventions to enhance maternal and infant outcomes.