In recent studies, we demonstrated that C. elegans can serve as a valuable model organism for assessing the antinociceptive properties of bioactive compounds. Utilizing proteomics techniques, researchers have gained insights into valuable aspects such as differential expression and protein-protein interactions, facilitating the investigation of underlying biological pathways [16, 21–25]. In this study, our initial objective was to ascertain whether there existed any behavioral bias in C. elegans using our experimental setup. To test this, we conducted an evaluation of the mobility and bias of both wild-type (N2) and specific mutant nematodes, with and without exposure to AEA. The experiments were conducted at room temperature (≈ 22˚C), maintaining consistency across all quadrants. As illustrated in Fig. 1, our findings indicate the absence of any quadrant selection bias among all experimental groups of C. elegans, regardless of exposure to AEA (10 µM). The data reveal a uniform dispersion of nematodes throughout the Petri dish 30 minutes after initial placement at the center. Furthermore, exposure to AEA for sixty minutes did not induce significant alterations in nematode mobility or behavioral biases.
3.1 Evaluation of antinociceptive activity of AEA
We investigated the antinociceptive activity of AEA in this study in an attempt to elucidate the role of endocannabinoids in the nociceptive behavior of C. elegans. In Fig. 2, our data revealed that AEA (≥ 10 µM) hampers the nocifensive response of C. elegans to noxious heat following a 1-hour exposure period. AEA plays a crucial role in modulating pain perception in mammals, which is likely related to its ability to bind to vanilloid and cannabinoid receptors. AEA actions involve regulating neuronal activity and synaptic transmission pathways involved in pain signaling, contributing to the overall management of pain sensation. The results obtained highlights AEA play a significant role in modulating nociceptive behavior in C. elegans. This is coherent with AEA acting as a pain modulator in mammals.
To elucidate potential targets of AEA, we conducted experiments using specific C. elegans mutants (ocr-2, osm-9, npr-19, and npr-32). All tested mutants exhibited reduced sensitivity to noxious heat compared to the WT (N2) control, albeit remaining responsive. To identify targets, mutants were exposed to 10 µM of AEA for 60 minutes prior to conducting heat avoidance experiments. Results depicted in Fig. 3 indicate quantifiable antinociceptive effects of AEA in all mutants. While the data suggest AEA evoke antinociceptive effect on the ocr-2 mutant, thorough inspection does not support this assertion, precluding a conclusive determination of AEA targeting OCR-2 specifically. However, results from mutant exposure to AEA hint at redundancy in receptor involvement and potential compensatory mechanisms. Notably, all single mutants tested retained sensitivity to heat, albeit reduced compared to WT, indicating potential redundancy in receptor function. Indeed, double mutants (e.g., ocr-2/osm-9) have exhibited insensitivity to noxious heat [38]. It's worth noting inconclusive outcomes about targets were also obtained when testing vanilloids in previous studies [23, 25]. In C. elegans, thermal nociceptive neurons express heat-sensitive TRPV channels, primarily OCR-2 and OSM-9, with more supporting data for OCR-2 as the receptor channel targeted by vanilloids [21, 22].
3.2 Proteomic and bioinformatic investigations
Anandamide showed antinociceptive activity in C. elegans but data derived from specific mutants may suggest compensatory effects from the vanilloid and cannabinoid system, respectively. The vanilloid and cannabinoid systems are closely related to each other [39]. Thus, we used mass spectrometry-based proteomics and network biology to decipher the pathways activated by AEA. Label-free proteomics was performed on C. elegans exposed to AEA (25 µM) for 1 h. The volcano plots in Fig. 4 show several DEPs (≥ 2-fold) in response to the AEA treatment. Tables S1 (supplementary file) contain the log2 fold changes and a p-values for all DEPs identified. Enrichment analysis of Reactome pathways and Gene Ontology Biological Process database in Fig. 5 revealed that the upregulated DEPs are connected to pathways and biological processes strongly associated with the activation of the vanilloid system. Ion homeostasis (Reactome identifier R-CEL-5578775) is an essential pathway for maintaining the electrical properties of neurons, enabling them to generate and transmit signals, communicate with other neurons, and undergo adaptive changes in response to stimuli. Dysfunction in ion homeostasis can lead to neuronal excitability. Transient receptor potential vanilloid channels are versatile ion channels that play an important role in ion homeostasis, particularly through its ability to mediate the influx of calcium ions. It is well described that AEA can bind to and activate mammalian TRPV1 channels [40, 41]. The activation of the TRPV1 by AEA or other ligands triggers calcium influx and depolarization of nociceptive neurons. However, prolonged TRPV1 activation results in desensitization, wherein the channel becomes less responsive to subsequent stimuli. This desensitization led to a reduction in pain perception in mammals. The activation of vanilloid receptors by AEA is part of the broader role of endocannabinoids in modulating neuronal activity and neurotransmitter release. This is also coherent with biological processes such as monoatomic cation homeostasis (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0055080) and programmed cell death (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0012501). The maintenance of ion homeostasis, including monoatomic cation homeostasis, plays a crucial role in determining cell fate, and disruptions in these processes can contribute to programmed cell death [42]. In mammals, the increase in intracellular calcium, as a result of TRPV1 activation, can activate apoptotic pathways [43, 44]. It’s important to note that while there is evidence supporting a role for TRPV1 in cell death, the precise mechanisms, and conditions under which C. elegans vanilloid receptors contributes to apoptotic pathways remain to be defined. Interestingly, Resiniferatoxin-induced TRPV1 activation can lead to cell death but our recent study in C. elegans has not shown nematode apoptosis following Resiniferatoxin exposure [45]. The effects can vary depending on factors such as concentration and duration of exposure. Therefore, further studies are needed to fully understand the intricacies between C. elegans vanilloid receptors and apoptosis. Collectively, the strong enrichment of Ion homeostasis (Reactome identifier R-CEL-5578775), monoatomic cation homeostasis (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0055080) and programmed cell death (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0012501) suggest that AEA bind and activate C. elegans vanilloid receptors (e.g. OSM-9, OCR-2).
Other strongly enriched pathways are Translation (Reactome identifier R-CEL-72766) and its child term Mitochondrial translation elongation (Reactome identifier R-CEL-5389840). Vanilloid receptor activation can lead to the influx of calcium ions (Ca2+) into the cell. This calcium influx is a key event in the modulation of neurotransmitter synthesis and release as it has been shown for neuropeptides. Elevated intracellular calcium levels activate various intracellular signaling pathways including calcium-dependent enzymes and transcription factors. In mammals, TRPV1-mediated calcium influx can activate transcription factors, such as CREB (cAMP response element-binding protein) leading to the upregulation of genes encoding proneuropeptides or proteins involved in proneuropeptide biosynthesis. Neuropeptides act as neurotransmitters and are central to trigger nocifensive response in C. elegans [28, 46]. Consequently, the upregulation of translation associated pathways is intimately linked to the activation of the vanilloid receptors. Other pathways including protein localization to membrane (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0072657), cellular component assembly (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0022607), membrane organization (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0061024), and vesicle organization (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0016050) are also related to translation and protein synthesis, protein transport and exocytosis. ATP synthesis is vital for anabolism reaction. This could explain the significant enrichment of the biological process proton motive force-driven ATP synthesis (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0015986). Activation of vanilloid receptors can also trigger an influx of calcium ions resulting in a change in state or activity of neurons. This is coherent with the significant enrichment of the biological process response to abiotic stimulus (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0009628). The mechanistic target of rapamycin complex 1 (mTORC1) is a key cellular signaling complex that plays a central role in regulating various cellular processes, including protein synthesis, cell growth, metabolism, and autophagy. Another interesting enriched pathway is Amino acids regulate mTORC1 (Reactome identifier R-CEL-9639288). In mammals, mTORC1 has been shown to play a role in regulating synaptic plasticity, which is crucial for the processing of pain signals in the central nervous system [47, 48]. mTORC1 has been implicated in the molecular mechanisms underlying neuronal sensitization, contributing to the amplification of pain signals [49, 50]. Calcium influx through TRPV1, especially in the context of sensory neurons, impact mTORC1 signaling [51]. Studies suggested that targeting mTORC1 may provide a new avenue for developing therapeutic interventions to alleviate chronic pain [52]. It is a noteworthy observation that exposure to anandamide trigger mTORC1 associated pathway in C. elegans.
In mammals, the endocannabinoid system is involved in maintaining immune homeostasis, and endocannabinoids can influence the activity of immune cells. CB2 receptors, in particular, are expressed on immune cells, and their activation has been associated with anti-inflammatory effects [53]. AEA can activate CB2 receptors on immune cells, leading to the modulation of cytokine production and other immune responses [54]. There is some evidence to suggest that AEA may interact with TLR4, and their crosstalk could have implications for immune regulation and inflammatory responses [55–57]. Following C. elegans exposition to AEA, enrichment analysis of down-regulated DEPs revealed that the pathway Toll Like Receptor 4 (TLR4) Cascade (Reactome identifier R-CEL-166016) was significantly enriched. Activation of TLR4 initiates signaling cascades that lead to the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines and chemokines and it has been linked to the sensitization of nociceptive pathways [58]. AEA has shown to activate CB2 receptors leading to anti-inflammatory and immunomodulatory effects in mammals [54]. In C. elegans, this effect is most likely triggered by the interaction of AEA with NPR-19 or NPR-32, which are orthologs of cannabinoid receptors. Moreover, the activation of cannabinoid receptors leads to a reduction in cAMP levels. The inhibition of cAMP by cannabinoid receptors is associated with the modulation of neurotransmitter release, which explains the enrichment of the biological process adenylate cyclase-modulating G protein-coupled receptor signaling pathway (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0007188). Another interesting significantly enriched biological process is the positive regulation of the nervous system development (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0051962), which is related to the modulation of chemical synaptic transmission (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0050804). The positive regulation of synaptogenesis includes processes that promote the establishment of functional chemical synapses, and they are useful to trigger responses to noxious stimuli. Following AEA treatment, synaptogenesis is negatively modulated in C. elegans contributing to the antinociceptive effect observed. Conversely, the biological process translational initiation (Gene Ontology identifier GO:0006413) could be related to the regulation of neuropeptide synthesis. Neuropeptides are key chemical synapse players and function as neurotransmitters or neuromodulators. Therefore, AEA treatment likely inhibits neurotransmitters involved in typical pain response.
3.3 Thermal proteome profiling for unbiased identification of AEA targets
To identify the principal targets of AEA, we employed a TPP approach with a ligand concentration range (TTP-CCR) [30, 59]. The choice of a 60˚C temperature challenge for the TPP-CCR experiments was based on the determination of the protein’s melting temperature (Tm) established in a previous study [21]. As shown in Fig. 6A, we detected 757 proteins in the soluble fraction following the thermal challenge at 60˚C. Further analysis of this dataset, allowed us to identify 46 targets with fold-change ≥ 2 and adjusted p-value ≤ 0.01 as shown in Fig. 6B. As exhibited in the heat map, protein concentrations in the soluble fraction increases significantly with ligand concentration. Remarkably, in C. elegans, cannabinoid receptor orthologs NPR-32 and, to a lesser degree, NPR-19 emerge as primary targets of AEA. Moreover, vanilloid receptor ortholog OCR-2 is also targeted by AEA but with most likely less affinity based on the increase in solubility observed following AEA exposure. Interestingly, OCR-2 was the primary target of capsaicin, a well known ligand of the mammalian TRPV1 [21, 22].
Another top target is LEC-2 (G5EGB1). This protein is an ortholog of mammalian galectins. Galectins, a class of proteins implicated in various biological processes, including pain modulation, exhibit potential roles in pain perception and processing [60, 61]. Research suggests galectins may influence pain pathways, offering insights into novel therapeutic targets[62] for managing pain conditions through modulation of galectin activity or expression levels. Investigating the potential crosstalk between AEA signaling and galectin function could unveil novel insights into pain modulation mechanisms and therapeutic avenues. Another interesting top target is CPR-4 (P43508), a Cathepsin B-like cysteine proteinase. Cathepsin B, a lysosomal protease, has been implicated in various pain conditions due to its involvement in neuronal inflammation and neuropathic pain mechanisms [63]. Cathepsin B's role extends beyond pain to include inflammation modulation, as it participates in cytokine processing and activation, implicating it as a potential target for anti-inflammatory interventions [64, 65]. Cathepsin B may interact with endocannabinoids like AEA, potentially influencing their metabolism and signaling pathways. Another top target is PGRN-1 (Q9U362), a C. elegans progranulin ortholog. Progranulin, a multifunctional growth factor, exhibits potential implications in pain modulation, with studies linking its deficiency to heightened pain sensitivity [66, 67]. Investigations into progranulin's mechanisms suggest its involvement in neuroinflammation[68] and nociceptive signaling pathways, highlighting its promising role as a therapeutic target for managing pain disorders. Progranulin might intersect with anandamide for its regulatory role in various processes associated with pain and inflammation. Research exploring the potential interplay between progranulin and anandamide signaling pathways could provide novel insights into their mutual regulatory mechanisms and associated physiological implications. Additionally. we were also intrigued by the presence of TTR-15 (Q22288), a Transthyretin-like protein in the list of AEA targets. Transthyretin, a carrier protein primarily transporting thyroid hormones and retinol-binding proteins, may play a role in pain and inflammation modulation. Intriguingly, we have showed a link between transthyretin and pain [69, 70]. However, there isn't a well-established association between transthyretin and anandamide or the endocannabinoid system. Additionally, as disclosed in Table 1, several small and large ribosomal proteins were identified as top targets. Protein-protein interaction network analyses performed with STRING (V.12.0) (Fig. 7) revealed there is an important cluster regrouping several proteins from GTP hydrolysis and joining of the 60S ribosomal subunit (Reactome identifier R-CEL-72706) including specifically small and large ribosomal proteins, essential to protein synthesis. This metabolic pathway may have an impact on nociceptive and inflammation pathways through its involvement in cellular signaling cascades [71–73]. Moreover, small and large ribosomal proteins play important roles in cytokine/chemokine production [74, 75]. Exploring the potential interplay between AEA and small and large ribosomal proteins could reveal novel regulatory mechanisms.