3.1 Synthesis and characterization
Solid-state 13C and 29Si NMR, XRD, SEM and XPS provided evidence of the formation and structure of AgPc, Pc-Ormosil and the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites. 13C and 29Si CP-MAS NMR spectra were obtained for the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites, as shown in Fig. 2. 13C NMR peaks were observed for AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10 at 10.6 (C-1), 20.8 (C-2), 36.5 (C-3), 45.9 (C-6 and C-7) and 50.5 ppm (C-4 and C-5), which corresponded to the characteristic peaks of [Si–(CH2)3NH(CH2)2NH(CH2)2NH] groups on Ormosil. In addition, the peaks at 141.4 (C-8 and C-9), 125.4 (C-10 and C-11), 133.1 (C-12 and C-13), 151.2 (C-14 and C-15) and 168.5 ppm (C-16 and C-17) corresponded to the characteristic peaks of AgPc– functional groups of AgPc-Ormosil. The 13C NMR peaks of the Pc-Ormosil composite partially overlapped (C-3, C-4,5 and C-6,7), and the chemical shift (δ) was weakened by the incorporation of AgNPs (40.1 shift to 36.5 ppm and 48.7 shift to 45.9 ppm). This result was due to dipolar interactions between 13C nuclei and the paramagnetic Ag, which provided efficient NMR relaxation sinks [8]. This result was very important because it proves that AgNPs formation on the amine groups of aminosilane, which produced chelation or adsorption on the surface of aminosilane (CH2NH…Ag). Also, the peaks of AgPc-Ormosil/Ag were of mixed AgPc and Pc-Ormosil functional groups, and that at 151.2 ppm (C-14 and C-15) corresponded to the characteristic peaks of N–Ag–N functional groups on AgPc. The 29Si NMR peaks of the Ormosil network units were observed at − 57.8 (T2), − 68.1 (T3), − 90.0 (Q2), − 101.3 (Q3) and − 110.8 (Q4) ppm. T2, T3, Q2, Q3 and Q4 denote R–Si(OSi)2(OH), R–Si(OSi)3, Si(OSi)2(OH)2, Si(OSi)3(OH) and Si(OSi)4, respectively. The structural characterizations of the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites were in agreement with the Pc-Ormosil composite expected in light of the 29Si NMR spectra. However, the intensity ratios of Q4/Q3 and T3/T2 of the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10 composite (Q4/Q3 = 2.12; T3/T2 = 8.48) were larger than those of Pc-Ormosil (Q4/Q3 = 1.84; T3/T2 = 4.51). These results indicated that the AgNPs were coordinated with silica network units (Si–OH…Ag) at Q3 and T2, and the intensity ratios of Q4 and T3 were therefore enhanced [8].
Figure 3 shows the XRD diffraction peaks of AgPc, Pc-Ormosil and the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites. The peaks obtained for AgPc showed the presence of a sharp and well-resolved diffraction peak, which confirmed its crystalline behavior. The diffraction peaks at 2θ values of 27.9°, 29.6° and 32.3° were due to the crystalline phases of Pc. The 2θ values at 38.1°, 44.2°, 64.4° and 77.3° were indexed as the (111), (200), (220) and (311) faces, respectively, which was consistent with the bulk face-centered cubic Ag single crystal. Observations revealed that the diffraction peak with a d value of 2.37 Å corresponding to a 38.1° angle (2θ) was more prominent. The peak has been indexed in terms of the tetragonal AgPc lattice [19], which indicated that the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites contained Ag and AgPc simultaneously.
3.2 Morphology and structure characterization
SEM images were obtained to evaluate the surface morphology and size distribution of the AgNPs deposited in AgPc and AgPc-Ormosil/Ag. The SEM image of AgPc showed the formation of long nanowires, and the lengths of these nanostructures were measured to be 80–300 nm (Fig. 4a). SEM images of the Pc-Ormosil composites show uniform morphology, with the condensation reaction between the Ormosil chains and the Pc crystals forming a cross-linked polymerization (Fig. 4b). The AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites consisted of non-agglomerated, uniformly distributed AgNPs in the Pc and Ormosil matrix (Fig. 4c and d). The AgNPs in the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-2.5 composite is mainly concentrated in the Pc matrix, forming spherical AgPc that are uniformly distributed in the Ormosil structure and are in the range of 100–300 nm in size (Fig. 4c). SEM analysis also confirmed that the spherical AgPc and AgNPs were uniformly distributed in the Ormosil structure to form the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10 composite, and significantly showed that the spherical AgPc size increases to 200–500 nm (Fig. 4d). The differences of Ag particles in the SEM images of AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-2.5 and AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10 composites were compared. It was found that according to the content of AgNO3 in Pc-Ormosil composites, AgNPs preferentially reacted with Pc to form AgPc-Ormosil composite, and more AgNO3 content reacted with Pc-Ormosil to form AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composite. AgNPs are evenly distributed in the Pc and Ormosil matrices. This behavior could be attributed to the actions of N–Ag–N of Pc and –CH2NH…Ag of Ormosil as a surface modifier that inhibits Ag particle growth and prevents aggregation.
XPS studies performed on Pc or Ormosil previously loaded with Ag+ ions indicated that the complexing main sites were the amines and the secondary alcohol functional groups, as the N atom-pyrrole, –NH–, –NH2 and –OH groups have a pair of electrons that can add themselves to a cation by a coordinated covalent bond or chemical affinity [19, 20]. The attraction of the electron pair by the atom nucleus is stronger in oxygen, but nitrogen has a greater tendency to donate its pair of electrons to a metal ion to form a complex through a coordinated covalent bond. Figure 5 shows typical XPS spectra of AgPc, Pc-Ormosil and the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites. Before Ag induction, for Pc-Ormosil, there were two peaks in the N1s spectra at binding energies (BEs) of approximately 398.1 (N2) and 400.0 eV (N3). These peaks were attributed to the N atoms in the Pc and –NH– groups of Ormosil, respectively. For AgPc, there were two peaks in the N1s spectra at BEs of approximately 398.9 (N1) and 398.1 eV (N2). It is worth noting that a AgPc molecule has two inequivalent nitrogen sites: 2 nitrogen atoms (N1) are connected to the central Ag atom to form a complex bond, while the other 6 nitrogen atoms are linked to iminic carbon (N2; –C = N–C–).
After Ag induction, for AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-2.5, the N1s spectra showed a broad feature, which was fitted to three peaks at BEs of approximately 398.9 (N1), 398.1 (N2) and 400.0 eV (N3). When the Ag amount increased, for AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10, there were two peaks assigned to N1 and N2 species, and a disappearance in the N3 peak was observed compared with AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-2.5. This result indicated that Ag interacted with the –NH– groups of the Ormosil to form an Ag…NH– complex (similar N1 species). Therefore, the N3 peak disappeared, and the N1 peak intensity increased for AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10. In the case of AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-2.5, the N1s spectra consisted of the N1, N2 and N3 species. Most likely, the small amount of Ag atoms more strongly reacts with these pyrrolic N atoms (–NH–) in Pc, which is connected with a stronger charge transfer.
The XPS signal for the Ag3d spectra of the AgPc composite consisted of two peaks at 374.7 and 368.8 eV, which were associated with Ag3d3/2 and Ag3d5/2 BEs, respectively. For the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-2.5 composite, the corresponding Ag3d sites were similar to those in AgPc (Ag1 species). This result indicated that AgNPs preferentially react with Pc from AgPc. With an increasing Ag amount, AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-5 and AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10, the Ag3d5/2 main peak is broader than that for AgPc and AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-2.5. In the case of the present data of AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10, we analyzed the peak of Ag3d5/2 by three components: Ag1 species at 368.8 eV, Ag2 species at 368.2 eV and Ag3 species at 367.1 eV. These peaks were attributed to the Ag atoms interacting with Pc (Ag1), Ag interacting with the –NH– groups of the Ormosil Ag…NH– complex (Ag2) and free Ag atoms in Ormosil (Ag3). These results confirmed that N1s and Ag3d XPS have the same resolution as SEM.
3.3 Antibacterial effects
Inductively coupled plasma‒optical emission spectrometry (ICP‒OES) was used to measure the absorption intensity of a specific silver ion concentration, and a calibration curve was obtained by plotting the intensity of the absorption line as a function of the silver ion concentration of the corresponding standard solution (Fig. 6 insert), which was then used to quantitatively estimate the silver ion release from various samples. Figure 6 shows the Ag+ release concentration vs. time of the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites (5.0 mg) in 1 L of nitric acid in aqueous solution. At the initial time, the Ag+ release concentration increased significantly, the Ag+ release began to decrease at 48–60 h, and the release increased with the increase of the AgNPs content in the sample. Since AgNPs are finer and more uniformly dispersed (morphologically) in the composites, possibly due to reduced agglomeration, the water molecules entering the sample interact with more of the AgNPs surface, allowing AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10 to release more Ag+ ions.
The antimicrobial effects of Pc-Ormosil and AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites against Gram-bacteria were measured by inhibition zone test, MIC, MBC and plate-counting method. Figure 7 and Table 1 detail the bacterial inhibition and antimicrobial ring size of the composites. After 24 h of incubation, the inhibitory region (12.96–19.28 mm) of AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composite was significantly greater than that of Pc-Ormosil (10.66–14.55 mm), and the antibacterial performance was greatly improved by increasing the Ag content of the composite. AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites exhibited significant inhibitory effects on Gram-bacteria, especially Staphylococcus aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. The MIC and MBC values of the composites against Gram-bacteria are shown in Table 2. The MIC/MBC values of Pc-Ormosil, AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-2.5, AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-5 and AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10 against bacteria were 11.0/>11.0, 1.10/1.10, 0.11/0.11 and 0.011/0.011, respectively, indicating that the ability of composites to inhibit bacterial growth was in the order AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10 > AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-5 > AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-2.5 > Pc-Ormosil. AgNPs are closely related to antimicrobial ability, which depends on the AgNPs content in Pc-Ormosil. Compared with the results of our previous literature [7, 8, 22], the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites exhibit better antimicrobial properties than Ormosil(NR4+Cl−)/Ag, Ormosil/POM, and Ormosil(NR4+Cl−)/POM. These results may be due to the relatively small and uniform distribution of AgNPs in the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites. Pc-Ormosil samples also showed certain antimicrobial properties, which were attributed to the antimicrobial efficacy of the amine groups in Ormosil and the photosensitizing ability of Pc [8, 14].
Table 1
Zone of inhibition (mm) against bacteria of the Pc-Ormosil and the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites.
Bacteria | S. aureus | B. subtilis | P. aeruginosa | E. coli |
Blank | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Pc-Ormosil | 12.39 | 14.55 | 12.90 | 10.66 |
AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-2.5 | 16.39 | 15.06 | 16.56 | 12.96 |
AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-5 | 18.22 | 16.44 | 17.78 | 14.26 |
AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10 | 19.28 | 17.56 | 18.38 | 16.58 |
Table 2 The MIC and MBC values of the Pc-Ormosil and the AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites on bacteria. |
Bacteria | S. aureus | B. subtilis | P. aeruginosa | E. coli | | Minimum inhibitory concentration (mg/mL) | Pc-Ormosil | 11.0 | 11.0 | 11.0 | 11.0 | AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-2.5 | 1.10 | 1.10 | 1.10 | 1.10 | AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-5 | 0.11 | 0.11 | 0.11 | 0.11 | AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10 | 0.011 | 0.011 | 0.011 | 0.011 | | Minimum bactericidal concentration (mg/mL) | Pc-Ormosil | > 11.0 | > 11.0 | > 11.0 | > 11.0 | AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-2.5 | 1.10 | 1.10 | 1.10 | 1.10 | AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-5 | 0.11 | 0.11 | 0.11 | 0.11 | AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10 | 0.011 | 0.011 | 0.011 | 0.011 | |
Figure 8 shows the number of bacterial colonies grown on the MH plate as a function of the amount of AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10 composite and the time of inoculation, when approximately 3.02–3.13×105 CFU/mL S. aureus are applied to the plate. Bacterial colonies grown on plates containing more than 10 mg of AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10 particles were significantly reduced, and gram-positive S. aureus bacterial colonies were completely killed when treated with 40 mg of AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10. In addition, bacterial growth was monitored in MH medium supplemented with 3.02–3.13×105 CFU/mL S. aureus cells and 11 mg/mL AgPc-Ormosil/Ag-10 at different inoculation durations. Figure 8b shows that the gram-positive S. aureus bacterial colonies were completely killed 8 h after inoculation, with a 100% reduction rate of bacteria after 8–48 h of inoculation. As the high CFU levels applied in this study are rarely found in real-life systems, it appears that these AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites could possess an excellent biocidal effect and are effective in reducing bacterial growth, possibly due to the uniform and fine distribution of AgNPs on the surface of Pc-Ormosil. The mechanism of action of Ag+ inhibition in bacteria may be that DNA loses its ability to replicate and cellular proteins lose their activity after Ag + action [23]. In addition, studies have shown that Ag+, catalyzed by neo-oxygen catalytic oxidation, react with bacterial cell membranes, leading to cell death [24]. The high antimicrobial efficiency of these AgPc-Ormosil/Ag composites may be explained by the high density of AgPc groups and long alkyl chains of ATS in Ormosil matrix.