Over the last 20 years, MIST for preterm infants with RDS has emerged as a less invasive mode for SRT. Evidence supporting its use continues to be inconclusive regarding improved long-term outcomes, nonetheless, it seems to be a promising technique given it is less invasive. In our study, we used a modified MIST technique, utilizing a thin nasogastric tube during spontaneous breathing with nCPAP or NIPPV and demonstrated its feasibility.
In the last decade, several strategies for SRT have been proposed, with the purpose of minimizing intubation and delivering surfactant in a less invasive manner, while maintaining the patient on nCPAP. We decided to introduce modified MIST technique, similar to the study presented by Tomar et al in preterm infants between 24 weeks to 33 + 6 weeks of gestational age (16). There have been different specific catheters developed to administer surfactant such as LISAcath® (17) (Chiesi Farmaceutici SpA, Parma, Italy), Surfcath® (Vygon, Ecouen, France) or Neocath® (14).These catheters are not currently available or might not be affordable in low resource settings, like ours. Although the ideal type of catheter for this procedure is still controversial, our study demonstrated the feasibility of utilizing a thin NGT (4-6Fr) with adequate training.
Figure 1 shows the learning curve in the adoption of this new technique in our NICU. After adequate training for all medical personnel in our Unit, MIST was universally adopted as the preferred technique for SRT.
There have been several studies published that show the benefits of MIST. In the Avoid Mechanical Ventilation Trial, Gopel et al reported a shorter duration of mechanical ventilation in patients who received SRT via thin catheter vs standard group (which were intubated patients), although they did not find a difference between groups in rates of death or BPD (19). Kanmaz et al showed a successful reduction in BPD rates with the Take Care technique (10.3%) compared with the InSurE method (20.2%), lesser need for mechanical ventilation in the first 72 hours of life and lower duration of respiratory support (11). The meta-analysis by Rigo et al showed a decrease in invasive mechanical ventilation within 72 hours of birth, pneumothorax and CPAP failure, as well as a decrease in rates of BPD at 36 weeks or combined outcome of BPD and/or mortality (20). Also, the pneumothorax rate showed a trend towards reduction (RR = 0.61 [0.37–1.02]. Similar results were found by Aldana-Aguirre et al in their meta-analysis, as well as a decreased need for invasive mechanical ventilation anytime during the NICU stay (21). In the meta-analysis presented by Lau et al, MIST was associated with a decrease in the need for mechanical ventilation within 72 hours of birth, with a shorter duration of mechanical ventilation and days on oxygen therapy, as well as a decrease in BPD incidence rates (22).
The meta-analysis by Abdel-Latif et al reports a significant decrease in risk of BPD and death, a decrease in the need for intubation within 72 hours of birth and a decrease in the incidence of complications such as pneumothorax, intraventricular hemorrhage as well as a decrease in mortality, in the group who received SRT with a thin catheter vs administration through an endotracheal tube (14).
In our study, given the small number of patients we could not demonstrate an impact on the incidence of BPD, need for mechanical ventilation or mortality (Table 2). We did not find any differences in respiratory outcomes such as days of oxygen therapy, duration of invasive mechanical ventilation or length of hospital stay (Table 3). Our findings suggest that the modified MIST technique is not inferior to the usual InSurE technique. One of the strengths of our study is that we demonstrated the feasibility of the modified MIST technique for RDS treatment in a low-middle income setting.
Important negative factors in our population, are the limited use of antenatal steroids and poor prenatal care. More than half of our VLBW infants, in both the InSurE and the MIST group, did not receive or received an incomplete course of antenatal steroids.This could be a factor influencing the need for invasive mechanical ventilation (regardless of the mode of surfactant replacement therapy). According to Janssen et al, independently associated risk factors for MIST failure were extreme prematurity (GA less than 28 weeks), absence of antenatal corticosteroids, low surfactant dose and elevated C reactive protein levels (23).
It is well known that the absence of antenatal corticosteroids is strongly associated with RDS development and that the response to exogenous surfactant therapy is enhanced by antenatal steroid exposure (6) This probably explains the higher need for surfactant therapy compared to other published studies.
For the MIST procedure, we maintained our infants on spontaneous breathing with nCPAP at all times. We did not use premedication such as sedoanalgesia because of the risk of suppression of spontaneous breathing. We utilized 20% sucrose and swaddling as non-pharmacological measures to diminish pain and discomfort. According to a European survey, 52% of neonatologists do not use premedication when administering MIST or LISA (24). We consider spontaneous breathing as a very important factor for adequate surfactant distribution.
An important limitation of our study is that we are comparing a retrospective and prospective cohort (of InSurE technique and MIST technique respectively). Although the demographic characteristics are similar, and therefore the groups are comparable, there might be differences in management given the different time points, and possible changes in management in our NICU. Another limitation is the small number of patients included. Although there have been several published articles comparing MIST vs InSurE, we believe this is an important contribution, given that there is scarce data in Latin America. Another limitation is the limited generalizability of this study given the low use of antenatal steroids in both cohorts, although this might be the case in other low- or middle-income countries.