Optical microscope
The size and morphology of Cat-MOx particles were witnessed via an optical microscope. The magnification was 200× and the scale length was 100 µm. Light micrographs of Cat-MOx particles are showed in Fig. 1. Cat-MOx particles were well dispersed, and no significant aggregations were observed.The particles had spherical shape in the size range from 20 to 80 µm. The particle size decreased with the increase of metal oxide content. Disintegration of some granules was observed, which was caused by the decomposition of oxalate precursors at high temperature.
Particle size distribution
The particle size distribution (PSD) profiles of spray-dried Cat-MOx catalysts with various metal oxide contents were measured and the results were showed in Fig. 2 and Table 1. The PDS profiles of Cat-MO20, Cat-MO30 and Cat-MO40 samples featured a wide particle size distribution in the range of 20–120 µm. Cat-MO50 and Cat-MO60 samples exhibited a less wide particle size distribution in the range of 20–80 µm. Unsupported Cat-MO100 sample had a particle size distribution in the range of 10–50 µm. These results indicated that higher metal oxide content led to narrower particle size distributions and smaller diameters.
Table 1
Particle size characteristics of catalysts with different metal oxide contents
Cat-MOx
|
MO20
|
MO30
|
MO40
|
MO50
|
MO60
|
MO70
|
MO100
|
D50/µm
|
51.61
|
46.84
|
42.70
|
38.41
|
38.11
|
40.04
|
24.87
|
The PSD profiles of Cat-PTVCrO catalyst and the colloidal silica support were presented in Fig. 3. Both the PSD profiles had a particle size distribution in the range of 50–300 µm. The introduction of metal oxides had no obvious effect on the particle size distribution due to the low loading of metal oxides over colloidal silica.
X-ray powder diffraction (XRD)
XRD characterization was performed to check the effect of metal oxide contents on the structure of Cat-MOx catalysts. The XRD patterns of Cat-MOx (x = 20–100) samples were shown in Fig. 4 for comparison. The broad peak around 2θ = 23° corresponded to the amorphous structure of SiO2 support. For the samples of 30 ≤ x ≤ 70, the XRD patterns agreed well with PDF#51 − 0031, which corresponded to monoclinic-CrVO4 [21], and no diffraction peaks of impurity could be observed. The intensities of XRD peaks gradually increased with the increase of x. It was also found that Cat-MO20 and Cat-MO100 samples were indexed to be dominant monoclinic-CrVO4 (PDF#51 − 0031) phase. For the Cat-MO20 sample, diffraction peaks for hexagonal-Cr2O3 (PDF#38-1479) phase were traced, suggested that in the low loading catalyst, the interaction between metal oxide specimen and the silica support could hinder the formation of CrVO4 phase and promote the formation of amorphous V5+ phase and Cr2O3 phase. On the high loading sample, however, the metal oxide species could easily be precipitated next to the silica surface and be aggregated together in the phase of monoclinic-CrVO4, due to the relatively weak interaction with the silica support. Compared with standard card of monoclinic-CrVO4, the XRD pattern of Cat-MO100 appeared weak miscellaneous peaks around 24.296°, 26.223°, 32.053°, 35.684°, 36.440° and 64.171°, which could be ascribed to orthorhombic-CrVO4 (PDF#38-1376). For the Cat-PTVCrO sample, the possible CrVO4 phase was not formed, and instead, only the phase of hexagonal-Cr2O3 appeared. Cat-PTVCrO was prepared via an incipient wetness impregnation method with a low vanadium-chromium loading. This result suggested that the supported vanadium-chromium oxide component was mostly in amorphous form.
Fourier transform-IR spectra (FT-IR)
FT-IR spectroscopy was used to verify the change in the skeletal structures of SiO2 resulting from loading the metal oxides. The FTIR spectra of Cat-MOx (x = 20, 50 and 60) samples were shown in Fig. 5. In the fingerprint region, there are one absorption band at 956 cm− 1 attributed to V5+=O bond stretching, two absorption bands at 869 and 548 cm− 1 assigned to V−O−V bending vibration and stretching vibration, and two bands at 1250 and 654 cm− 1 due to the vibrations of Cr-O-Cr and Cr-O. The band peaked at 1116 cm− 1 was related to the antisymmetric stretching vibration of Si-O-Si, suggesting that the skeletal structures of SiO2 was not damaged as the metal oxides were loaded.
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS)
The XPS analysis was carried out to elucidate the chemical states of V, Cr and O presented in the surface region of Cat-MOx (x = 20–100) samples. The survey XPS spectrum of the Cat-MO50 sample contained the Cr, V, O, Si, and C peaks (Fig. 6a). The C 1s peak was originated from the organic residues of the XPS instrument itself. The high-resolution Cr 2p spectrum (Fig. 6b) was resolved into two peaks located at 576.6 and 586.6 eV, assigning to the binding energies of Cr 2p 3/2 and Cr 2p 1/2 [25]. The V 2p spectrum (Fig. 6c) exhibits two peaks at 516.6 and 523.2 eV (V 2p1/2 and V 2p3/2) ascribed predominantly to V5+ oxidation state [26]. Additionally, the O 1s peak could be attributed to the oxygen bonds with Cr or V in the CrVO4 lattice.
The high-resolution XPS spectra of the Cr and V + O regions were presented in Figs. 7a and 7b, respectively. The detailed results were summarized in Table 1. The binding energies (BE) of Cr 2p, V 2p and O 1s showed no appreciable differences when the metal oxide content was raised from 20–100%. The results suggested that oxidation states of Cr and V remained constant. Meanwhile, the surface atomic Cr/V ratios were close to 1:1, which was the nominal value of Cr/V molar ratio in CrVO4, suggesting a well dispersion of metal oxides on the surface of catalysts.
Table 2
XPS results of the Cat-MOx (x = 20–100) samples
MO content
|
20%
|
30%
|
40%
|
50%
|
60%
|
70%
|
100%
|
Sample
|
MO20
|
MO30
|
MO40
|
MO50
|
MO60
|
MO70
|
MO100
|
V 2p3/2
|
517.4
|
517.1
|
517.2
|
516.6
|
516.9
|
516.9
|
516.9
|
V 2p1/2
|
523.1
|
524.1
|
524.4
|
523.2
|
524.1
|
524.2
|
524.1
|
O 1s
|
533.0
|
532.7
|
532.8
|
532.8
|
532.5
|
532.7
|
532.7
|
Cr 2p3/2
|
577.3
|
577.0
|
577.2
|
576.6
|
576.9
|
576.9
|
576.7
|
Cr 2p1/2
|
587.0
|
586.5
|
586.8
|
586.6
|
586.4
|
586.3
|
586.5
|
Ratio of Cr/V
|
0.96:1
|
1:1
|
0.90:1
|
1.14:1
|
1:1
|
1.20:1
|
2.13:1
|
BET surface area
BET gas sorptometry measurement was used to investigate the surface areas and the porosity nature of Cat-MOx samples. The N2 adsorption-desorption isotherms for the Cat-MOx (x = 20, 50, 60, 100) samples were presented in Fig. 8. The data of BET surface areas, the average pore volumes and sizes were given in Table 3. The N2 adsorption-desorption isotherms for Cat-MOx samples displayed a type-IV hysteresis loop, characteristic of micro/mesoporous materials [27]. As can be seen in Table 3, the surface area of the unsupported catalyst (Cat-MO100) was 18.123 m2g− 1 and the pore volume was 0.079 cm3 g− 1, which were much lower than those of the supported Cat-MOx (x = 20, 50, 60) samples. The surface area and pore volume of the supported catalyst increased firstly, reached the highest values of 73.574 m2g− 1 and 0.267 cm3 g− 1 at x = 0.50, and then decreased with increasing CrVO4 loading from x = 20 to 60. However, the pore size was increased continuously from 8.324 to 11.075 nm, as could be seen in Table 3. The loaded CrVO4 species could plug the pore mouth, resulting in those pores inaccessible for N2 adsorption and consequently a decrease in the surface area and pore volume. Moreover, some larger pores were formed on the higher loading Cat-MOx sample, due probably to the generation of large volume gas products during thermal decomposition of the oxalate precursor at high temperature. Thus, the contents of SiO2 support and oxalate precursor jointly determined the surface area and porosity of Cat-MOx sample.
Table 3
Pore structure parameters of Cat-MOx catalyst
Sample
|
Specific surface (m2g− 1)
|
Pore volume (cm3g− 1)
|
Pore size
(nm)
|
Cat-MO20
|
66.893
|
0.244
|
8.324
|
Cat-MO50
|
73.574
|
0.267
|
10.383
|
Cat-MO60
|
50.612
|
0.214
|
11.075
|
Cat-MO100
|
18.123
|
0.079
|
9.437
|
H2-TPR spectroscopy
The H2-TPR profiles of Cat-MOx (x = 20–100) samples are shown in Fig. 9. Pure Cat-MO100 showed one H2 consumption peak at ∼442 °C, which corresponded to the reduction of V5+ to V3+. The additional SiO2 support significantly modified the reduction profiles and causes a shift in the main reduction peak to higher temperatures, which was certainly due to the interaction between the metal oxides and the SiO2 support.
Catalyst activity
Activities of Cat-MOx catalysts were investigated for the vapor phase ammoxidation of p-chlorotoluene (PCT) to p-chlorobenzonitrile (PCBN). All the reaction conditions including reaction temperature, n(NH3)/n(PCT), n(air)/n(PCT), and loading of metal oxides were assessed in the ammoxidation of PCT over Cat-MO60 catalyst. The influence of reaction temperature on the activity, selectivity and yield behavior of Cat-MO60 catalysts is shown in Fig. 10a. It was observed that the conversion of PCT increased from 98.5% to almost 100% upon a temperature increase from 380 ◦C to 420 ◦C. The selectivity and yield of PCBN were increased initially and then remained constant upon an increase in the temperature. The maximum selectivity and yield of PCBN observed at 410 ◦C were 87.61% and 87.38%, respectively. The selectivity and yield of PCBN decreased at the reaction temperature higher than 410◦C due to the thermal decomposition or deep oxidation of PCBN.
As shown in Fig. 10b, the molar ratio of n(NH3)/n(PCT) had a highly pronounced promotional effect on the ammoxidation of PCT. As the n(NH3)/n(PCT) ratio was increased from 1 to 3, the conversion of PCT was observed to increase initially and then reached maximum at around 99.5%. The selectivity and yield of PCBN had the same trend. On the surface of Cat-MO60 catalyst, increasing the NH3 content led to an increase of M = NH species, which were formed via the condensation reaction between terminal M = O with NH3 along with the loss of water [28]. Further increase in the NH3 content led to a reduction of the O2 supply and a decrease in the yield and selectivity.
The evolution of the catalytic behavior as a function of the ratio of n(air)/n(PCT) in the range of 11–21 was shown in Fig. 10c. The conversion of PCT kept constant with increasing the ratio of n(air)/n(PCT), while the selectivity and yield of PCBN increased firstly to a maximum at 15 and then decreased. Obviously, high ratio of n(air)/n(PCT) was benefit from the recovery of lattice oxygen. However, excess oxygen content might lead to the deep oxidation of PCBN.
The effect of reaction load over Cat-MO60 catalyst bed was studied and the results are shown in Fig. 10d. With an increase in the reaction load, the conversion of PCT slightly decreased due to a reduction in contact time between the reactant and active sites. Lower reaction load prolonged the contact time, leading to somewhat lower yield and selectivity due to the deep oxidation of PCBN over the catalyst. The best yield and selectivity were obtained at a reaction load of 0.13 g/gCat·h.
As discussed above, the optimal reaction conditions could be determined as follows: T = 410 oC, PCT:NH3:Air = 1:3:15; reaction load = 0.13 g/gCat·h. The activity of VCat-MOx catalysts for the ammoxidation of PCT was evaluated. During the ammoxidation of PCT over these catalysts, PCBN was the desired product and other possible by products, such as benzonitrile, chlorobenzene and toluene, were not detected. The variation in the catalytic activity was observed with change in the CrVO4 loading in the catalysts and the results are depicted in Fig. 11. The VCat-MO20 catalyst exhibited only 57.14% conversion of PCT and 43.55% yield of PCBN. When the metal oxides loading increased up to 60 wt%, the conversion of PCT and the yield of PCBN increased up to 99.62% and 86.52%, respectively. However, for VCat-MO100 catalyst, which contains no SiO2 support, the conversion of PCT and the yield of PCBN were with levels of 98.62% and 78.30%, respectively.
Since silica support showed no catalytic activity under the same experimental conditions, the performance measured should be merely attributed to the supported CrVO4 species. Generally, VCat-MO100 showed lower activity than the supported catalyst. The inner CrVO4 species was not accessible in the bulk phase of CrVO4. If the CrVO4 phase was dispersed on the support with high surface area, more active species exposed and the number of available reactive sites increased. On the contrary, in high level of SiO2 supported samples, CrVO4 species could be heavily embedded, leading to a decrease of the catalytic activity. Notice in Fig. 11 that the VCat-MO60 catalyst showed the highest PCT conversion and PCBN yield in comparison with the other supported or pure catalysts.
The performance of Cat-PTVCrO catalyst was also tested in the same conditions for comparison and the results were depicted in Fig. 12. Although the conversion of PCT was close to 100%, both the selectivity and yield of PCBN were obviously below than those obtained over VCat-MO60 catalyst. Furthermore, the reaction load was quite low. All these results suggested that the spray drying technique showed significant advantages in preparing ammoxidation catalysts.
In addition, the catalytic behavior of the Cat-MO60 catalyst was also investigated in the ammoxidation reaction of toluene and other chloro-substituted toluenes such as m-chlorotoluene (MCT) and o-chlorotoluene (OCT), and the results were depicted in Fig. 13. The present catalyst exhibited equally excellent catalytic ability in these reactions. Meanwhile, the position of Cl-substituent had an obvious influence on the catalytic activity of ammoxidation reaction. The Cl-substituent had a weak electron-withdrawing effect. Meanwhile, the Cl-substituent in para position had almost no steric hindrance in activating the methyl group. For PCT the process got the highest conversion of PCT and yield of PCBN, but the selectivity was slightly lower than that for toluene due to the deep oxidation of PCBN at high temperature. OCT had the electronic similarity with PCT but more steric hindrance, leading to obviously lower activity. Due to the serious electron-withdrawing effect of Cl-substituent in the meta position, the ammoxidation process exhibited the lowest conversion of MCT and the lowest yield and selectivity of MCBN. These results were consisted with that reported previously [29, 30].